Subhash v. State Of Haryana And Others









 

 











!"
#$%$!&'
((
)  )



 ) 
*



 )




'
+ ,

(
)
-
)(


 (
....
 

 






 
Mr. P.C. Goyal, Addl. A.G., Haryana.

-
)(


 /
(
 ,  0




  
 

 
 
!" 
#$

#%
 
  

&
'

 
"&(



("
!
 

 



)

  
 



&'


 )

'
 "

 *

 





(" 




&

"
&



 

+" 

, 
"










-$-.$//$

0 
&

#1 )



 


 
"& )
 


) 




 #1 )
2  




"

 
 
 )
&

#1 )

-$$%%--%
"
 


2


& 




 

 )


3 )

 


 "

 *


-4-5$//.


 '# 6" 6


) 

)

$7-5$//.
 & 

 "

 *

 




 '# 6" 6


) 


) 
 
 8
 


5$-5$//.

"&(

"





 

" 

 )




 
"




$//.
  

&



!

)


 
 

 )



 

)

"

%#


9" 
1"

$/:4

$%-4%--:
 



 )


 


 " 

 

 

 

& 

9" 
 &" #")#,&"
+" 
'


 





"





 
 
 

&



)


"

 

;-<
&'
 
 )




)


$%-4%--:

  

-/$%%-$$


  



 
& 
#1 )
& 

2 
+" 

+=
>$5$;$

%-$%
&"

)

)

 

%--4%-$;


) 


  

"
&)
 

2




 
 



-5-5%-$7
"

#1 )

 "  *


 

 )




(" 
)

>'"
)
6
 
 
 ?
0)
 ?
&


0 
 ?
0(







 
 "

 *

#1 )





&


-$-;%-$7
 &

 )




 "

 *

 




(

"



 

&



$:-.%-$7
   

 


 
 
"

 *


$//.

$7-5$//.

)

 
 )



"






  &
 "




&
 

&

 "

 *
 


@" &

  


" 
&
)"

 )

 *
 

 
)


(" )


28& 

" )
+" 


)

    

 

 !"# $%&  '

 ( )*
*$*   +

  

& 

" 


 

                            

   

              



  !"   #           

 

   

      $   

 
   

     

 %&     $   

    

'

%()



   

%* 
#1 )
  


(

 )
 )



 "
+=#%/5//

%-$7

"
&



'
 "

 *


 

 



 *


$//.
A" B






&

+" 


 


#1 )









  
 

 "  *

 



)
 




 
"
&

+" 

,"- .' 

 

  .

( # 

 +



 

 
)
 )





 




  



  

'
"
)





 
+C+
>$477

%-$/
1" 





)


# 1 )


)" 
 
(

 )




$:-7%-$/
"

 

)


)


 





&
 
 """

& 





  
)

 


 


  

)

"
)





 

+" 

, 
"











" 
 )
(" )


+" 




(  
 

. *
 "

  .

( #   +






)
 
2
" 



#1 )


"


  





(" 

&
 *
&

#1 )


 
 


D
)

)

 E
2




&


"
   & 

@" 
@"

 

&

 *


$//.





(" 

&
 "

 *


&
!




&


  



"
& 
,&"
+" 

-/$%%-$$
  
"

 

@" 

&
'

 

#1 )



! "


 

 )





"



  & 
  

 "

 *
"



$//.
2










 
 # 




 

+
 





  

-/$%%-$$

&

9" 
 &" #")#,&"
+" 
'

"

 

;-
<

&'
 

"
 

 
&
" 






, 

+"



 )



 

&
)


)

&
 

 
&

#1 )

'
 
$:-7%-$/
2





 

 "

 *


 




 
"
&

+" 

,"- .'/ 0

 !





"






  &


 *


$//.
" "


 

&

+" 




 
 


 


3
9 "








 

 
& 

,&"
+" 
'
 



  

&



 "


"

 
 
;-<
&'
 





-$$-%-$;

"

 

$%-4%--:
2


 '


# 1 )

" "
$//$

1)&
$//$

F"
$//%

F"

$//%



) 
 
 

 

5$-$$//.




 '

%:-
 


 




"


  & 
  



 *


-4-5$//.

)

$7-5$//.
9


" 
"&)

 







 

&

#1 )



 

&
 )
&





) 

)
 
&
("



&"
"


 )



  & 
  
  &


 *


$//.

,
 >

 ")

&

&



 

 (" )

9

 

 
"



 



 " 

")

 
 & 


 


& 


""


) 
 )

 






 '


#1 )

" "
$//$

F"

$//%

 



 
""

 )
 


)



&



$%-4%--:

  




&

9" 
 &" #")#,&"
+" 

'

-/$%%-$$


)


#1 )G


  
 


  





 

-$$-%-$;

"

 

$%-4%--:
 
;-<
&'
 

9



 
  
 
&

# 1 )
&"
"

 

&
"
 )



)


$%-4%--:

)

 
 


  

-/$%%-$$

&

9" 
 &" #")#,&"
+" 

! 

" 
-(+% &                  #              

         .

+
/ '

       
      

 +01       % % (%02%00)     



                 !   %-

2
 
) "




 
  
 




&
 
 

)
 
"

 

;-<
&'
 
 )



)


$%-4%--:


 


&
 

  
&

# 1 )


  


"

 




;-<
&'
 


&
!

$%-4%--:


 

&
"
)  


  


 



 ')6



)

"

 




 

&'

 


!

;-<

  

&
 

"







)



$%-4%--:
9






#1 )




'

 ")


)


&
 )

$%-4%--:

 


 

"

 
&)
 


 
 






 )







#1 )

 

"

)

 
 

 
("




 
&


&

"
&

 
&
!


)
+) 
1
>
&

 "





 


 

&
 

 
"
9







  

&

#1 )
"


&
& 


)





)

 


)  


  

&

9" 
 &" #")#,&"
+" 



 ")

 







#1 )

 

!

&

 "  *


3
  








))
("

 *

 

,

"

&

&

#1 )


 

 
)




 



  



@"
&


 
&
)"
&

#1 )



" 
 

 
)


)


 
&
 





 

 
)
  

> 

)




&
 

)"

 


 


)


 "

 *

 



 

 
)

 
&




&
 

 )
 




.<


&

)"

"

 & 
)
&
 
 )

 

"
 





 





)
 AB

 
 
AB


 


-
)(







/
(



















 
1 



 !

  56 !7 

   56 !7