High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7398/2013dismissed

Pb Aided Colleges Retired Employees Association & ANR v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2015-02-12Mr. Justice S.S. Saron,Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul17 pages

"#$%%&&' (%)*&+,-(

( .(" / "#$,-(

0--( *((&&**()+$&&1%-#"%')2

$(((%- *(((2 30--(-#"%')-"&%$(*(%-'2

( 4(/+ &5/(%651- 4(-(#,4(.#+7")(-"%-(+5%65 (-*( 4( /#15%%&%6(&5 "#$ 4(-"*%(-5%65((*%8 4(//''"5%65((*%

- (%( -&& %* - ()% 1( * 1&&-1(*5)%--(%(5-&&''-

"#$ (6&+4'%&%% "#$6()%%&&'5

(+/-)5 889:

*&;5

"#$ 9

3;:(-(<-=;16(5(-&+((5-( >()-()%1(* - *( ((% )*&+ - 6()%% (6&+4'%&&' "#$-))$( -*(?((%%"('-*(% 88@

- ' "*(" - (6 % - ))$(5 1- (651('"&%"%(-*(6- 6(+&%(- (*6 6( - &&' 1( &% - ))$( - *(?1(-))$(-($"(+ "%/-) -/ "#$% "#$&%&&':/"(+ /(6 )*&+; 5 8@A - % %& 1- "(+ (6%1-(6%-)*&+&&+5-/ 6() ("&% /-) &&% <(??%=

8@8 1

8@B '(' 8!C (??% ' && - * D'

8@@ - &% &&' - ))$( - *(? -6#%(

8@@ - ((% )*&+ () ?6() &&' 1( *(' -(% 1- - 6() )> *(6 ( - *(+ $ &" *(6& ($"(+ (6% "% /-) :( -( <-

/-)=;5-6()1)'D*%"("*8!C -)*&+=-(-

)*-)"'("+1$' *%$+-4')-(%*(6&&'E" "-(-((%)*&+5-/6()()%-) ('(-?")?

()("+F F )&+ &" ($"(+ (6% "% 1 6% ("&( %%

889.%"-("&(5-*1(%(%$'(%&+ --'5$"?-'1&&&"-($"(+

(6% "%

8895-/6()("&%-)&&% < (6&+ 4'% &% % "#$ 6() %% &&'5

(+ /-)5 889= :( -( <- /-)=; - % -)51---$(*&%$+-

)+ $ )% -( - "#$ &% &&' % :/"(+/(6)))5)*&+;:)%);5 888 1% 9 A 888/8?%8?(%6%-(% )*1(% - / 6() '( *(+ $ "- ()%%)+$*(($%%&>*&5- *(6-()*&%1-)+$%-() - (% *(65 - / 6() - ()% "#$ (6&+ 4'% 'G% &% %% &&' :

% ($"(+

(6% "%; "&5

/"- "&-6$(*&%6% %%

:D"( ?

;5 1- "#$ (6&+ 4'%

'G% &% %% &&' :

% ($"(+ (6%

"%; *& "&5

1(*()"&'% -1()&%$+-/*&/((+5*() '-(%"5 "#$5$-&(*% ,35-$ *%"--/-)-''&$(+%&&)*&+ "%(-)*&+)%%&&'1($&-%1-%(1-( ($"(+ (6% "% (() & *% " - - (()'-&"((F)*&+%%&&'&(%+9 +( % !B +( 6() )*&+H -((5 -+ ( &(%+ #+'$1%%&+((6*%"- (%( 6% "%" % "($& & &$& - / D-E"(5 1 %(% D*% &1 *"$& (H -((5-1%(*&-*-)1-((*6 )(5*%"--/-)1)*&)%5 1&+("&%-%%&&'%*%

)"- (*" "% (% ( '(' * - )*&+ (6&+ 4'% &&' ( - 4') - 6() %% &&'

*%(-/-)(-)*&+%%D(-*-((5 -+(&'$&(+*(+$"%(- 4( /+ & 5 &(% ( "& (*(' - *(?5-6-)&+ ('"% -- -$ % 1-((*6"&&+-(%(*%$+-"(()) )'6-/-)+'1-((*65 - I'&"( - &+ "% - #"%') - "(5 1-- *()$&-"'--/I'&"(-'*&(+*1(&'&5 $"- *1("&&+ #"%') -"( (&"*- #"%')-=$&/"*()"((*(%/)&%", -(.7/-+)/"%(,-(:

;B/@3@4(-"(-( (&%"* ($-/'- . / "#$ , -(

:3; I 3835 1-($+ / 8 - "#$ -+ # 5 88A %&% 1- ((*6() @

1% 4( "%&5&(%"&(*('-*( 0 ! 3

A5-('"%--&"($&D(- *1(5 -((5 "$& & ('"% - -( ( "& )> - $# , 1-& (%"' - && - / I'&"()"--/I'&"(-$)%$&6-- *('(*(+$&"($"(+ (6% "% /-)-$D(%$+-)*&+(-((5- E"$"% I(% "& ( - *( (( () (%( *%$+6--"(

0 @3A

3 &% < (*& (%( /'- "& , -( . / "#$ , -(= %&' 1-- () --) (-(*&

"&---$(6%"%(

JKKI(% %%& %6 (&5 "#$ "$) -- "&((*&%5-( /-)6'" - )( $ '6 "- )*& 6("( "'- $ *(#%$+&(%%%&%6(&5 "#$&(%+ % $65 1+ $> - +(

5 - "( 1% " )%)"%('-(*%(-*-)- 1 $6 )*&+ $" - "%(>' 1 '6 $+ - 6() - - (+ * 1"&% $ > 1- -( )- - -) 1 "'- $ )*&)% 6% (%

"&5

16(5 ()% $+ $" - *%+ - * 1-( && - ("& -6 $ -&&'%%1-("&-6$(*&%-1"&% ) - - '6() ' 1+ % $> " () - "%(>' 1-- -% '6 () ) ) - "( ( ()- /-)01"&%&&>*" -&&-1(*5( 9 3

5)1'6 &(%%%&%6(&5 "#$51-1%%" - )( D*&( - *$&+ *' - **& -)()% 889"%(1--*-%$)%**&$& -(*(6&+%%&&'-"'-5&)6)- -6 *%5 1- ) 1 )%5 6 %+ - % 1 >---(-%((%()(6%-> -(

5-+&)*0--(*(1"&%$ &%*"%(-*-)(%(* &'-(0(((%1--"()-

/-)1--1()"&%1+$>-+( 889% -)(1%(''%$+-6()(&&-+(- (")5 1 ( '6' & **("+ - (*% %&$(-"%()-"(-D%-(' $"-)*&) 889/-)-&1-&>' %1"&%$1&&%6%-E"-"%(>'5 1--1('6%-)*1---%$))%(&(5 $" - *(%' 1( % $" -( "%(>'

( - (5 1 & (%( *(& *( - /((+5 *()%"1&&/((+ -D% -('5*6%>$+-%L

5 -((5 - )*"'% &'& 1 (%"% - / I'&"(

H *% $+ - &'&"( % %

3-&'G - -( -%5 4( #1 (& "* 6 $- #"%')-"((*(%/'-,-(./ "#$, -(

I$"( % %"(& B985 1-( - &) ( -'-( &*+-$("&(%% 3 @ 8!@'6$+- #"%') - "( % - =$& /"*() "( 1 1-%(1 $+ ' "#$ +/&-(5 A%&>'-E"& () - *+?& - "( - "*-&% - 6&%+ % &'&+ - )-1-((*6&('"%-I'&"( D( *&(+ *1( - - #"(% &1 1- ((*6(*&-)()%6%-& $"(% - / D-E"( / - &'& - D( - *&(+ *1( % - )*"'% &'&5 -((5 - -&&' "-)1"%$&&1 0-6-(%&(%"&(-*(%%)( -*($"-1(*--(&'&51--(% "%( J

.I 4

. 4 II/5 / //45 889:

I;5

"#$ 9

3; *(6%(-(*&- "#$ (6&+4'%&% % "#$6()%%&&'5 (+$/-)5

889%(-)(%-(1- 0 /5 - (( "$& (" :;5 "#$ ("&%-(%/-)()%$+-/6()6% ))9F !?B@?

%%- B-)$(5 889H

@ 0 /5-%/-)1%)%-6) (1-()- *(&5 H 0 / "%( - (% /-)5 && - )*&+ :-' % ?-'; - )*&+) &% &&' 1- 1( 6(% "%( 8!C '(??% -) 1( )% &'$& ( '( *(+ $ &" - ($"(+ (6% "%/-)"$#-D(* -("'--((*64''))H 0 /((%--(%*-6 $D(%$+-)*&+(H 0 /-(")5D*% &1 *"$& ( 6% "%" % "($& & &$&-/D-E"( % $+- I'&"(-/ "#$- /D+?-(%(- *"$&%&&1

; - )+ $ &&% - "#$ (6&+ 4'% &%% "#$6()%%&&'5 (+ /-)5 889:

*&;5

; -&& $ %)% -6 ) ( % 1- ()- %+*(&5

; % 1- () - *(&5 5 - "#$

(6&+ 4'% &% % "#$ 6() %% &&'5 (+ $ /-)5 889 ("&% 6% )) 9F !?B@?

%% - B- )$(5 8895 -&&$%-&&&1+$%)%-6$(*&% :

;1-%'+-'%+("5("& (-(&1(-)$'(%+(%((% + "(5 ($"&5 && - )*&+ - &% &&' :-' % ?-'; 6(% "%( 8!C '(??% -) -&& $ &% + *(+ $"%(-/-)(*&%"%("$?: ;L /"$?:

;/ (*&- "#$ (6&+4'% &% % "#$ 6() %% &&'5 (+ /-)5 889 &1+ $ %)% -6 $ (*&%5 1-( "$? /:

;/ )*&-1-%'+-'% +("5("&5(-(&1(-)$'(%+(%(

(%+"(5($"&5&&-)*&+-&%&&' :-' % ?-'; 6(% "%( 8!C '(??% -) -&& $&%+*(+$"%(-/-)(*&% &&-#"%')%F((%(-"(('6 - /-) - /-) - $ (*&% $+ /"5 - 6(+ "% - #"%') >>% %1 "&&+' - #"%')5$">>'%1-"%-#"%')-/-) &-((5-#"%')-=$&/"*()"(7/-+) /"%(,-(=:"*(;(((%$+4(-&*-('") (%%&4(%&--&"($&D(*1(- "(55-&%"%( J39/ "#$,-(."(%&/'-,-(: 8B ;

/A@ 5-"(-&%-1-*1(D(%$%- %$+%-%*"(**1($+)"&( *(''&')'&5&&%&"($&D( *1(-$)$%1-(-("$#(- %%(()-(1---*1(("%5'"%%$+ D("%(51--('%($%$"((&6- (")0--"%*1(&"%D( *1($+%("%-(*()1--- *1(6%5-$)$%(-(-*1(- $D(%$%(-%%' 3@-&+$-&%$+-"(--%()& %%6&6+E"$%()&%- *(&'&"("-5-"((%&)% ")*-*("&(&'&"(*("&( &1-&'&"()***("&()5- )61--)*&&%((&&+((&6 --( -%5-&'&"(&>)*5-E")6% ((6&&-((51--(""&(5 -"5&1+E"*1(-&'&"(-" 46 - &'&"( 1-& ' " E"& J4& ( )6 $% - *5 % *()$&

"''*(&)(+)*-()&%L- &'&"(5$%+5$"%-6'*%&1( D("*"(* ->%J(((% )&L">1 -&%&'&M/ 7#*(+, (. / (5 8!3 / 3@!H / -5 /& D (5 "#(, (.#4&&I)%,(5 8@@/

@8H7 '(# , ( . / %-( (%- , (5 8B! / !!

H0&(

54-(-(,(. # -& , (5 3/

99H%/7(&,(. *&

(6&I$(57(&/ , (5:

8;B/A9N DDD DDD 934%4- ->. %:

8@B; /! 5 6?"%' - - "( %(% )&( " % -&% --&'&"("&&#"%')'6' ('-+*(+%&(6#"%') -&%')* D6&%$"*(%%$+(6&%""1-(- "& ( &'& " ((*6&+ &(% $+ &'&"(5 - #"%') %5 "& (6(% $+ **& ( (61 ('' &'& (%( "&&+ - #"%') )* "( 1"&% )" (-' "* - #"%& *1( %&'&*()$&1--)%-("& -)%)""%$+"(6-"'-5-)%'" )+)"-$#-('-)$%%#"%') "&%$>1+$+-&'&"(%(&+)&(61 - $ ((% 7 />( ( . 6> )) 4&-+ )):

889;

/A B 9A J9B K - &'&"( $+ $( %&(5 1-" +-')(5%(&+6(("&5(6((6((%#"%& % 16( 5 D( - *&(+ *1( ((%"*$+(& A!% A9-"5 (%( #"%& % 6 $+ ' 6&% &1 "%)&&+&('(-''-%1--"- %$%L :.%4#"&--. 0)=* (* I%:

8;B/A3 5/**A9!?995*(9B; 9!61-$65-&1-"$"))(%- - #"%& *(") )* "( $ "&&%$+-&'&"(D(&'&6*1((+

( 1-6(-&'&"(5(%((6&%-&15 (()-%D'*((-#"%') -$ 1-- ( "(+ *(6 -% $ %&(% "&( 6( % ""&L -)#"%')51-&%('-(&6 $# , 5-"(-&%--/) $#, **%% - && %)$& % - (" - $ *%5$"$"%(&)%*"(*(('-%5 1--*(6&%-)1--%-)>'-&1%- D%"('+-6&51--"'-()%+-"($(6% "%( J99-/) $#% **%%-&& %)$&%-("-$*%5$" $"%(&)%*"(*('-% 1-- *(6&%-)1--%-)>'-&15%- D % "('+ - 6&5 1-- "'- ()%+ - /) $#% )+$(&6%"1- - $#6 + '6 " *% $+ - &'&"( )+ *(6% ( - ( 1-- %"% - &'&"( - "J (-*"(*%*-('-$#%*"(*(- 5 K - "( &> - /) $# % -(L:)*-"**&%;:.

%76&**(7(-&7-" ./4%(%7(& 89 / B % 1( I%.

8; 9/9!85/*9B95 *(@8; 9@ 4#"& -- . 0)= * (*(I%:

8;B/A3 5-"(-&%"%( :/* A!85*(A ; JA - *(* 1-- $ "&&% " () - ()% #"%') - &-"'- - /) $#% %-&&&%') - *("&( $ )% - & $ ( ("' - *(6 % -(5 - ) $ (((% ( "%(%' - $>'("%5 - % (%-)-"'-$()%%$+ -

" - /) $# % & $ &>%D(&%(**('-(" - &'&"( %F( - $# "'- $ -6% $+ )-*("&(((#"%''($& -&)%$+"-L:)*-%%%; 9B-"561-$65-/) $#% +)*&&"-(((1---) $("'-%$&>%(**('-("- &'&"((%"-$#"'-$-6%$+) - *("&( ( 6 ( #"%'' - ($& - &)%$+"-L -((56+-"((5$"% (%( - &'&"( 6%$&5 - $' 1- &'&6 )*6()-(%#"%')(&%"*-&(% "&(-*(H1%%+)%"(>%1 +*(6-/"-"%*"%&1--/I'&"( -'-*&(+*1(&1-"$#*(+$ -((5--)()%D(-D"6*1(-5 "&%$1-%(11-((*6 (&(5 "&& - - "( 0 B!

A 88@ &% </%- /'- , -( .

88BD)%-6(- "#$/*& (")-( 5 88B- "&&-D)%-#"%') (-64&& I%,-(.(-("'-4"*&+,-(: 898; / B3H

& (%-% ('6% . 4"*& ))(5 -)%$% :

89A; / 9 BH -"$-1( /'- , -( . % , -(:

88A;9/@@H-/(+,-(.-7(&?*

()(=/+I)% 883:

;/ 3!%%&")") ./7(& 889/ A3 1-&%--6()"&% -6 -'% - 6(+ $ - #"%') "%( *&(+ *1(

&'&%"&%-6*(6%%&'&*&()(-%-** $ **% ' - - -&% - - )*"'% &'& 6&6 (& A , 9 - " - - $(6% "%( JKKK- *1( - I'&"( 6&%' &1 &"%'-&1(%(6(&(#"%&%$+ ()6'5&('%"(&G'-&'&$-#"%') 1&& ('G% 16(5 % - #"%& ("+5 - 1))"$1--)*-I'&"(% )"$1- (?-"&- 1&&('G%&1-D(&'&6*1(5 -/$+ )(%&(5 1-"+-' )(%(&+ 6(?("&5(6(6(?(%#"%&%-E"&&( %( (-6 4&& I% % -( . (- ("'- 4"*&+ % -( :

898; / B35 " - D)% - 6( "#( )* D $+ 4"*&:.&%;5 893 #'--&&'- )* - I'&"( - 6&%' &1 "&&+ - - #"%') - /"*() "( & (%-% ('6% . 4"*& ))(5 -)%$%5 :

89A; / 9 B5-/"*()"(-&% J-I'&"(--*1(6(-"$#)( %)*)>6&%&15+) )> "- 6&% &1 % )> **&$& ((*6&+$%6*(- 6&%+ 6&%' &1 %*% "* 1--( - I'&"( * - )* 1-- &) 6( - "$#?)( % 1--( )>' - 6&% ()6 - % 1-- - "( -% "%-D'&1%)>%E"*(6 -6&%'&1(6&%)*-DL -"$-1( /'- % -( . % % -(:

88A;9/@@5-/"*()"(%(%-6&%+ -&4&I1:)%); (%%5

8B9-*D"("*-&%-)%)%$(6%

J (&)%/I'&"(-6*&(+*1( &'& - "$# 1- -( &% -+ &'& - % "$# *(*6&+ 1&& ((*6&+ - - &'&"( &(&+ D*(% - *"(*( (%" - &'& ( )% D' &'& ((*6&+5-"$#-&'&6)* % - D( $' 6& + - *(6 - "5 "- *1( $ E"% DDD DDDL % &")") :"*(;5 (((% $+ - "&& -/%-/'-=:/"*(;%$+-6- /'-=:"*(;5-=$&/"*()"(-&%"%( J!

"(5-%-%D%-)%&('- &1 6&% & )*1(% '6 ((*6&'&1-%)'%(1-() *("&(%-I'&"(-'--(( -D(%"+())*()$&*()$&D5$"-D ( &6+ -"&% 1( "- -(( % - I'&"( )* (6( - 6&% D 6&%' "- D ( ()6' - 6&% $ ( (6(+ () - "$# ( (%(-(6(+()-/"&)* (-&'&"(-&11-((*6% "-(G'&6+%&&-D-$5 )>-)*&6+&&%%(6(+-D )%6&%51-%'-%&($+-"((- %('6((6(+-( M8N--(%-("-("'-&&-% - "( - - &'&"( %(&+ 6(("& - %()>%($%'$"-*1( )>-%6$+()6'-$1-- - % 1 (%(%5 1- - &1 - "%-&'&"()"-6)*%- )L -=$&/"*()"(.

(%(/'-%,-( .

/!BB5--&%-&&1' J33-&'&6*1()>&11-((*61&& ('% & 1&& &% - -"'- - &'&"( - *1(6("(O#"%')(""(*#"%&*1(5$"5-5 "$# - )* )> &15 *1( ()6 - $ 1--&%-"(O%-&'&"(-*1( &11-((*6$"-*1(-'#"%') "(&1-(((*6&+(*(*6&+-" &(&+%-&)&'&6*1(%#"%&*1( (-"*-&%6(%$+--(-&1)%$+- &'&"( -6 () - "& *(6 /"$)-6&$)%$-&-*(-$+ '&11-((*65-&'&"(-*1(

>1+6%('--"('%--('-(% ("& " 1( )%)" $ > 1+ $+ ' &1 1- ((*6 - -( -%5 1 %% $-& - (*%? / - - *1( - &'&"(&11-((*6&"%-*1( >1+6%('-&"%'-1--)+$(%$+" 1( 3A 6(+ 6(' &'&"( * - ('- )> ((*6 &'& - *1( )> &1 &"% *1( '6((*6(/"I1:@-%;*' 3B@%((*6"-&&1'1(%P" %)% $ ((*6 1-- > 1+ ( )*( + 6% ('- E"(% "%( D' &15 ( ( 1 $&'5 ( )* 1 %"+5 ( - 1 %$&+ (* ((%(&(%+*P"%&(+ :

3- %; 7 +(5 "(1(-5 *'B!@5 - - 1(% O((*6O1-"%1-(())+):; 'D'(H(:;(?*'"**5&%% )*&%(H(:;'("%('-%()%H( :6; ' *(%"( 0(% % -( () % .&3@*'

!%O((*6O(((6&1P 1-- > 1+ ( )*( 6% ( ("% ('- E"(% "%( D' &1 ((6 &1 > 1+ ( )*( 6% ('- E"(% "%( D' &15 ( ( 1 $&'5 )* 1 %"+5 ( - 1 %$&+5 (* ((%(&(%+*L -6-/'-=:"*(;%(%- #"%') % &")") = :"*(; &&1% 4#"& -- . 4'' ((5 %-( (%- 0)= ?*(6

(*( I)%

/ 3 A3 - "( -&% - - I'&"( %(&+ 6(("& - % ( )> %( $%'5$"-*1()>-%6$+()6'-$ 1-- - % 1 (%(% 1- - &1 -

" *(6%% - - &'&"( )" -6 )* % - )%('-&'&-5-"($(6%"%( J 3$(*("&-(%(&%&'&- 1"&%-1--&'&"(-)%%6"(%&>- *+&()--'-(E"&$"-6%-*+& - * -&% $+ -(F4(F4( + 1+ &&"(-(-&%-%'(%51---'-( E"& ( 4( - "- -( 1"&% " 1(>1--*+&%)$&-*1"&%'+ D(()(-'-(E"&('-*+&4( "E"&1--1(--'-(*4( - - (%(% 6 - *&+ (" %%

3@ 8!@ %

8@85 1-- 5 1( - $ 6(" #"%')&"%'/ "#$.7(*&/'--:

8@!;A /@A -((5-$('(%%)(%&($+ - &'&"( %(&+ 6(("&'5 (6' ( 6((%' #"%& %-%$+-/&'&"(%%&+1- )*-(6+-&&'-)* &'&"( () "- &1 % "( () + 6 ($(((%() -((+>$('*(+ - *+ & && - ")$ -&%' ) * 1-" '(' + -'-( *+ ( -'-( E"& - - (+ L

( - ( ((%% -( (* D( - &'&6*1(51----(%('%651 %-'("%)%"-&&'-(%)(- ( - - ((*6&+ (*&% - < (6&+ 4'% &% % "#$6()%%&&'5 (+/-)5 889= ($- /'-= :/"*(;5 / 8 - "#$

-+ # 5 88A 1 %&% 1- ((*6 ()

-%5/ %&1--%4 '/(*--"("%-%451-- "(+*(61(5$"&&%$+((*6%&

@ / 8-%5-"("%-((*6&'& *($+%-&'&6)*5$"$%-6& (& A%"%-((*6+($((+5-)$ (">%11"%--)%)"&&+&1"&&+ *%%4%"%()6&&%/(*- /"- #"%') - - 5 1-( % 4 (&" *% 1- )#(+ F3(% ))$( ' - /(*-5 1 "'-$$("'-$>$+6("((*6)%)0%- "-#"%')*(6%-('")(% 61 - $6 %"5 1 % - - (*& -

(6&+ 4'% &% % "#$ 6() %% &&'5

(+/-)5 889$+-)*"'%"$% $"&(6(-" E"&+51%%+)(-*($"- *-)(%)% :4

;

! : I. 4; .)&

$%&

'()&

#7")(/./ "#$,-(

0 !

#-7")(,-(./ "#$, -( 3 0 @

3 7"&%*/'-,-(./ "#$, -( A 0

A ?6()%% (6&&'5 -')*&+ ./ "#$ ,-( ! 0

A -*("'(',-&'+ )*&+:

'%;./

"#$,-( 9 0 ! 3

A E$&/'--),-(./

"#$,-(