High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/25563/2017dismissed

Manoj Kumar v. State Of Haryana And ANR.

2022-02-03The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Arun Palli12 pages

! "#$#%&

%()*+ , - ##% , . ,$*$ / ,0 % %1 , - $2%! %$

, $ %&3 ',.#4, +/#%516!7"

6 ,1 2 ##% , ',%4*,'# 86!!8!7"

% , 86 ,0 % 9#1 ',/ *, :1'

56$$#$ %!7"

% , 8 ,0 % 6

,1 , $2%! %$ ;1

, $ #!2, $ %" #$: #%5, ",! !1,*517#! "% , %"#%5$#%" 1 2," !#%5$

, : #%5"%!*" !#%7#,* 8*,<

1 "%,7 ,$0 #%787 ! #% 1 + , 1 %! , 787 $ ,*%! 1

228#"

:#8#0 / "#%=;< #51 #,+2 %$ %!, %$2 , %"0 #%> %!"?*#$##%6 1 :#8# %! $ 8 + %"6 %1

"$ 1 "

$ 91 , #%1 ,!*%! ,$ "#% 1 > %!"?*#$##%" @A= 9 %%*%" ! %

# +, 1 % #7 0 ,$ 2,#, 1 "++ %" + % 1 " % = $ "% %! ! :0 1 2 ##% ,1 2$$ $$#% 1 8 %!#%?* $#%#$% 4 %:01 / 1*511 "+2 %$ #%1 $: %, " #7 !:01 2 ##% ,91#"11 #$, !0 ! 2$# :

"4 1 , , 6 1 8 2$#%5 "?*#$##% 2," !#%5$ 1 $ : % "8 #+ ! % 1 5,*%! %%3 4#%5 210$#"

8 2$$ $$#% 1 8 %! #% ?* $#%

1 "%,7 ,$0 ",22 ! *2 ,*%! #% ,2, #% / "#% =;< " 9 $2* , $:01 %$#*#% %"1 1 %B:8 /*2, + *, %!# #%1 "

1 , :08 0#%5!9%2,#%"#28 $ ,! "8 ,#%51

"?*#$##%! + !1 7 : %8 2$ !*%! ,$ "#%=;< " 1 2 C*,1 $!#$"*$$ !#%!

#8 881 $2 "$% " $$ ,0 %!, 8 7 %

, #% ,2, #%5 $ "#% =;< " 6 19 7 ,6 , 1 2*,2$ $ ! "#!#%51 + , 1 %!61 , , %" 1 "%"8*!#%52 , 5, 21$ 1 (*!5+ %9*8!: $*

#" , , 2,!*" !1 , #%: 89&3 D- !"

# $#$" %

" !"

! &' ! "(

) !"

! & " % ) % %%

!! *"

( " ) ! " ' "(

" "

# $#)$! "

! & "

! +

! ) & , % -. "

#$ ) % "

) -. -. , ! "/ "("

#$ ! "

! & 0

"% "

! !! "

" ! "

! ) 0"

)

%' " ) 0' "

) ' ! "

) ' ) 0

,* 1 1 !"

#$!

! & "

! "

" ,"/"!2 "

#$ " ) % "

3 ! (

)!"# %$ ! !" ! "/ "

! +

) "

""" % ! "

! & " ) ( "

& ! 4 "/ "

! +

) ! !

' "

& ! "

" ) ( 52 !"

#" $

! "/ "( " ! 2 % "

3 ! (!!

! & ) %6 ! !" ! "/ "

! "

! +

7 " ) "

& # $! "

! +

' "

"/ "

2 2 ! "

" , ) ( "

) ( "

& # $ 4 % % ! ""

%( !"!("

' " "

"/ "( "

#$! "

! & , "

#$! "

! & )

#$ !"

# $#)$ 8 , ! 0( "

! +

#$ ) %( ! / 9 :" % ) 0(

! "

! +

' ( "

#$! "

! &' " ) 0 "

+ , ! "

#$ ( !

! "(

") " ! "

0 "

! ! )! "

! &" !"'

"(! "/ (% ""

, !) "! )" )*"

#$! "

! & ( % "!"

/ ( !""

"( ! "/ "

"( ( !!" ! "

! &''

2)"

% % /

( ! ! 0( "(

! !"

"/ .

1 $*+ %! $*:$ %" 1 (*!5+ % "

% : $*++ ,#E ! #% 1

889#%5 + %% , , +, "8 ,#0 % 1 2,#%"#28 $ 8 #! !9% :0 1 %$#*#% %"1&3 ;

< % 881$ "

$ $91 , #%1 "?*#$##%2," $$1 !: %#%## ! :*1 ,!1 $%: % %%*%" !*%! ,$ "#% 1 " @A=6 % 1 !

"++ %" + % 1 " #

=6 1 , #$ % 8 2$ 2," !#%5$ %! 1 $ + 9#88 "%#%* 619 7 ,69#11 ,#! ,1 1 "+2 %$ #%1 $: ! ,+#% ! *%! , 1 2,7#$#%$ " 88 1$ "

$ $ 91 , #%1 ,!*%! ,$ "#% 1 " @A=1 $: %

%%*%" ! 2,#, "++ %" + % 1 " 6 1 2,7#$#%$ 1 " 9*8!1 7 %:

,#%5, 228#"

%!1 2," !#%5$9#88"%#%* #%, $2 " 1$ "

$ $6 $# 6 1 " @A=1 $%: %, 2 8 ! ;:< 1 9,!F,B*$ !#%: 9 %1 :11 "%#%5 %"# $ $ "#% =;< 1 " #$: , ! $-., $-.91#"1 + %$1 $ 48 2$#%5 1 "?*#$##%2," !#%5$:11 "%#%5 %"# $ +*$ : *8 #88 ! '

%#%5 1 , :06 1 # 1 2$$ $$#%1 !: % 4 %:*1 "+2 %$ #%9 $%, " #7 !6 1 , 9*8! : % 8 2$ /#+#8 ,806 # "+2 %$ #% 1 $ : %

"" 2 !:*1 2$$ $$#%1 $%: % 4 %61 , 9*8!: % 2$#%5#!"

&&#$! 3( ;"< $

, $ 1 $2 " "+2 %$ , 1 8 "?*#, ! #$ "%" ,% !6 1 %B:8 /*2, + *, %!# 1 $ "

5,#"

880 :$ ,7 !1 1 C2, $$#%2 #!#%1 + #%2 , $ "#%=;< 1 " ! $%#%"8*! ! 2$# "+2 %$ #%#% "*, 1 #$ , ?*#, ! : 2,7 ! #$ 1 1 "+2 %$

+*%9 $ %! , !91#"11 $: % C28 #% !#% &1 1 %! ,#%5 1 +*% 9*8! + % 1 1 +*% #$ + !

#8 :8 1 8 %!9% , %! 1 9*8! : !#$"1 ,5 1 :8#5 #% + 4 1 2 0+ % %! #% 1 7 % $*"1 2 ,$% "

%%: 2 % 8#E ! ,1 !

*8#%+ 4#%51 2 0+ %1#8 , ,,#%5 $ "#%$ ;<6 ;<6 = 1 " @A= "+2 ,#%5 1 + 9#1 1 2 , + ,# 2,7#$#%$ # $ "#%$

%!@ 1 " 61 %B:8 2 C*,1 $"8 ,# # ! 1 %80 "%$ ?* %" %%32 0+ % "+2 %$ #% #$ + 4 1 2 0+ % #% , $ $2 ,$ "#% = 1 " @A= 7 %61 %B:8 /*2, + *,1 *,1 ,"8 ,# # !1 %" 1

0+ % "+2 %$ #%1 $: %

, !G %! , !*%! ,$ "#%

;<61 "?*#,#%5 *1,#0"

%%: 2 % 8#E ! ,%%32 0+ %

$ 1 +*% 1 $ , + #% *%2 #! !* , *$ 8 "" 2 :0 1 %!9% , "8 ,# 0 # *,1 ,6 1 %B:8 /*2, + *, 1

*,1 , :$ ,7 ! 1 # 8 %!9% , 1 #8 ! 1 , , %" , 1#51 , "+2 %$ #% 1 "

%% "8 #+ 1 1 9 $ % 2 #! 1

+*% ;!< 1#8 , !#%51 2,7#$$ "#%: 2 , $ "#%=;< 1 " 61 %B:8 /*2, + *,1 $"8 ,# # !1 #%"

$ 6 1

, ,2 0+ %1 $: %+ ! :*%! 2$# !68# :#8#0 0 +*% 8%5 9#1 #% , $ $*:$#$ %! # % ! 2$# ! , + (,#0 18!#%5$ , #7 0 ,$,+, 6"+2 %$ #%*%! ,1 " 1 $ : 2 #! 1 8 %!9% ,$ $ % 1 !

%# #"

,8 "?*#$##%*%! ,$ "#%= 1 " @A= 5 ,!#%5 1 ! 2$#6 # 1 $ : % "8 ,# # ! #% 1 (*!5+ % 1 , 1 1#51 , "+2 %$ #% 8896 1 +% 0 $1*8!%1 7 : %! 2$# !9#11 > %!"?*#$##%88 ", ,#%1 , $*,0,#%1 *,9#1, $2 "+ (,#0 8 18!#%5$6+ %#%51 , :0# #9 $! 2$# !#% %0 1 1, +! $ 9#1 , $2 " + (,#0 18!#%5$6 1 1#51 , "+2 %$ #%9#88% 8896:*#% , $*%! ,$ "#% = 1 " @A=9*8!: 1 "%$ ?* %" ; < $ , 5 ,!$ 1 +! 4#%5 2$$ $$#%6 1 %B:8 /*2, + *, 1 ! "8 ,# # ! 1 !, 9#%5 #%?* $ , 2,G + +, %!*+ 9*8!+ %1 210$#"

82$$ $$#%1 $: % 4 %1 8 99#1 , 5 ,!7 $#%5 8 %!1 $%" #%: , # , !18!1

%" 1 2$$ $$#%1 $: % 4 %*%! ,$ "#% 1 " @A=61 8 %!7 $#%1 / %!1 , "

%%: %0!#7 $#%5, 2$#%5 ;

< 1#8 "+2*#%51 5 22 ,#! #7 0 ,$: 9 %1 !

,! %! "++ %" + % 1 " 6 %0 #% ,#+ ,! , $*:$#$#%5#$: C"8*! !91#"1+ %$1

, C"8*!#%51 #% ,#+,! ,61 2, 3, ?*#$# 5 22 ,#! 0 ,$#$%1 , 6 1 2,7#$#%$ $ "#%=;<"

%%: #%74 ! ;5< 1 %B:8 *, 1 *,1 , "8 ,# # ! 1 # 1 "?*#$##% %! 1 ! ,8# , : % "1 88 %5 ! %! 1 "?*#$##% 9 $ *21 8!6 91#"1 + %$ 1 2," !#%5 $! "%"8*! !6 1 *+:, 88 2, "#% $ "#%=;< 1 " "

%%: #%74 $# ! $%, 7#7 $ 8 %!#+ :

,, !"8 #+$ ;1< %2 ,

61 %B:8 *,1 $+ ! #"8 ,1 1 2,7#$#% $ "#%=;< 1 " #$+ %: #%74 !:01 : % #"# ,# $# 8 %!9% ,$919 , , ",! !$ 1 #+ #$$* %" %# #"

#% *%! , $ "#% = 1 " @A= %0 $*:$ ?* %2*,"1 $ ,618! ,,1 ,9#$ 6"

%%#%74 1 2,7#$#%$ $ "#%=;< 1 " = $2 ,1 "

$ 2* ,1:01 2 ##% ,61 #$"39% ,#%2$$ $$#% 1 8 %! "+2,#$ ! #% )1 $, % @ ;

< #$9 $#* ! #% .#88 5 E#, :

!6 1$#8 #$,#" *,*5, + 91 , *2% , $#! %# 8 1*$ 1 : %"%$,*" ! %!1 8 %!#$: #%5*#8#E ! ,!+ $#"2*,2$ $8$61 2 ##% ,1 $G@1$1 , #%)1 $, %$@ 6@AG6@AG6A G$#* !#% .#88 5 E#, :

!6 1$#8 #$,#" *,*5, + %! 1 7 $ ! 1 7 "%$,*" !1*$ $%1 8 %!#%?* $#%1 $ #!8 %!9 "?*#, !:01

/ ,0 % 7#! %# #"

#%$ !

! AA = AA@ #$$* ! *%! ,$ "#%= %!$ "#% 1 > %!"?*#$##%"6@A=6 889 !:0

,! !

, 1 2*:8#" 2*,2$ % + 806 ! 7 82+ % *#8#E #% 8 , $#! %# 86 ++ ,"# 8 %! %$#*#% 8 / ", *,*5, +#$1 "

$ 1 2 ##% ,1 ! $2# 1 7#%5 "?*#, !1 8 #%?* $#%61 / 1

#8 ! 4 2$$ $$#% 1 8 %!#88!

1 2 ##% ,#$#% "* 8210$#"

82$$ $$#% 1 8 %!#%?* $#%#$ *,1 , "% %! ! 1 1*51 1 2 ##% , 1 $ , " #7 ! 1 "+2 %$ +*%6 19 7 , $#%" 2$$ $$#% 1 8 %! 1 $ % : % 4 %6 1 , , 6 1

"?*#$##%2," !#%5$$1 88: ! "8 , !1 7 : %8 2$ !1 2 ##% ,#$ , !0! 2$#:

"41 "+2 %$ +*% , "%, 6 ', %4*, '# 86 8 ,% ! !!##% 8 !7"

% , 8 ,0 % ,#%5 ,1 / ,0 % $*:+#$1 1 "% %#% 1 2 ##% , : #%5 #% 1 2$$ $$#% 1 8 %! #% ?* $#% #$ :$8* 80

"#*$ $1 2$$ $$#% 1 8 %!9 4 % 1 #+ %%*%" + % ,!#$ 8 :0, ",!#%5 E% +"1 %=@!

$ + 1 $: %1 %! !7 ,1 : % #"# ,0! 2 ,+ %# /. 1

8$!, 9% %#% 1#$*,1 28 !#%5$+ ! #%1 2 ##%91 , #% 1*511 2 ##% ,1 $$ !1 7 #8 !:( "#%$*%! ,$ "#% 3 " @A=619 7 ,61 7 "1$ %%!#$"8$ 1 2*,$* %$*"1 #8#%5 :( "#%$*%! ,$ "#% 3 " @A=61 $#! %# 8 , A

$? ,!$"+2,#$ !#%)1 $, %@ +#%;

3=3 <6@AG;

3 <6AG6A G $ , 8 $ ! 1 , , 61 %#, :

$#$ 1 2, $ % 9,#2 ##%1 1 , $#! %# 81*$ 1 $: %"%$,*" !%1 8 %!#%?* $#% %!1*$8 %!: , 8 $ !65 $*,1 ,61 "% %!$1 1 "+2 %$ ,8 %!#%?* $#% $ !*80 %! , ! # 6 9 $ + ! #8 :8 1 2 ##% , %! 1 , 8

9% ,$

, $*"1 %! ,6 1 2 ##% , 1 8, !0 , " #7 ! 1 "+2 %$ +*% %! : $#! $ 1#$ 1 1 8$ , " #7 ! 1 +*% "+2 %$ $ %1 %" !:01 8 ,% ! , %" *,: 89 ,,#%5 1 "% %#% 1 2 ##% , 1 1 #$ , !0 ! 2$# :

"4 1 "+2 %$ #%6 ', '# 8 :0 28 "#%5 , 8# %" % !"# #$#%!&'#( )(*!"+(,-./-#;$*2, <"% %!$1 1 , #$%2,7#$#%! 2$#:

"4 "+2 %$ %!1*$6$*"1 % 7 ,+ %#$$#+280:

$ 8 $$ %!%:

"4 !:0

%08 91 , , 6#1#$"% %#%1 %% 1 "%#%5 %"# $+ %#% ! #% / "#% = ;< 1 " , *8 #88 ! $ 2$$ $$#% 1 8 $ %!$ !*80 4 % %! 1 :8#5 #% 1 / 2 0 1 "+2 %$ $ %!$!#$"1 ,5 !9#11 %! , $9 88 $2 0+ % "+2 %$ #%61 %" 6 1 2, $ %2 ##%+ ,#$!#$+#$$ 8

, 1 7#%5 2 ,*$ ! 1 28 !#%5$ :1 1 "% $#%5 2 ,# $ , ",!#%51 #,"% %#%$69 1 7 %1 $# #%"%"8*! 1 1 + , %!#$$?* , 80"7 , !:01 2,#%"#28 $8 #!!9%:01 %B:8 /*2, + *, %!# #% 1 "

$ %!, 7 82+ % *1,#0 ;$*2, < %!1 2, 0 , 1 2 ##% ,"8 #+#%58 2$#%5 "?*#$##%2," !#%5$! $ ,7 $ !#$+#$$ 8#%7# 9 1 889#%5, $%$&3

< 1*51 1 2 ##% , 1 $ "% %! ! 1 "* 8 210$#"

8 2$$ $$#% 1 8 %! #% ?* $#% #$ $#88 9#1 1#+ %! 1 1 "%$,*" !, $#! %# 81*$ $%1 8 %!#%?* $#%619 7 ,6 1 $ #! 7 ,+ %! $% #%!$*:$ %" #,$806#%7# 9 1

" 1 1 , $#! %# 8 "%$,*"#% + $*,#%5 A

$? 0 ,!$

8, !0 $ %!$ , 8 $ ! ,+ "?*#$##% 2," !#%5$ *%! , $ "#% 3 " @A= %! $ "%!806 #% 7# 9 1 #% ,2, #% F210$#"

82$$ $$#%B+ ! :01 %B:8 2 C

*, #% %!, 7 82+ % *1,#0 ;/*2, < 91 , #% 1 %B:8 *, 1 $ "

5,#"

880 1 8! 1 1 9,! 2$$ $$#% *$ ! #% 1 " @A= 1 $ $ + + %#%5 $ 1 210$#"

8 2$$ $$#%*$ !#%/ "#%=;< " 1 %1 / 7 ,%+ % "?*#, $1 8 %!!, 9$+ +, %!*+ 4#%5 2$$ $$#% 91#"1 #% 1 2, $ % "

$ #$ :0 , ",!#%5 E% +"1 %=@!

61 +*%$ 4#%5 1 210$#"

8 2$$ $$#% 1 8 %! %" 1 2$$ $$#% #$

4 %61 , #$ :$8* 7 $#%5 1 8 %!#%1 / 1 ,

, 7 %# 1 8 %!9% ,, #%$1 2$$ $$#% 1 8 %!61 #$ , $2 $$ ,6 %!$*"12$$ $$#% , $2 $$ , %*, $ ,1#$: % #

%! % : 1 1 9% , # / 1 , , 6 $ :$ ,7 !

:7 1 210$#"

82$$ $$#% 1 8 %!#%?* $#%$ %!$ 4 % :0 , ",!#%5 E% +"1 % =@ !

6 "%$ ?* %80 1 8 %! $ %!$ 7 $ ! #% 1 / , ,+ 88 %"*+:, %" $%7# 9 $ + 61 28 1 2 ##% , 1#+ : #%5 #% 210$#"

8 2$$ $$#% 1 8 %! #% ?* $#% #$ 1 , :0 , ( " ! %! "%$ ?* %80 % 1 "%!##%$ , ?*#, ! #%74 $ "#%=;< " , + #%$*% *8 #88 ! :< $

, $1 $2 " "+2 %$ #%#$"%" ,% !6 !+# !801 "+2 %$ +*% 8%5 9#1 1 +*% %1 %" ! "+2 %$ #% $ %!$ , " #7 ! :0 1 2 ##% , , #%

5, + % 9#1 1 "% %#% , $2%! %$ 1 1 , #$ % 2,7#$#% #% > %! "?*#$##% "6 @A= 91#"1 889$ ! 2$# :

"4 "+2 %$ +*%%" #1 8, !0: %, " #7 !

/#%" 61 !* 2$$ $$#% 1 8 %!$ %!$ 4 % %!1 "+2 %$ #%$ %!$!*80 %! , ! %!, " #7 !:01 2 ##% ,6 %% 1 "%#%5 %"# $2, $",#: !#%$ "#%=;< " , *8 #88 ! %! 1*$6 1 , #$ % 8 2$#%5 "?*#$##% 2," !#%5$#%1 "

$ 1 %! ', %4*, '# 8 % 1 $, %51 1

"$ 28 ! ! #% 1 9,# % $ + % 1 $7 1 + %80 "% %! ! 1 1 / "?*#, ! 1 8 , 1 2*:8#" 2*,2$ , *#8#E #% 8 , , $#! %# 86 "++ ,"# 8 #%$#*#% 8/ ", *,*5, + $2 ,1 28 %2, 2 , !*%! ,1 ,0 % ,:

% 7 82+ %*1,#0"6A1 2*:8#"2*,2$ #$ "1# 7 !:0 !, 9#%5G 22,7#%51 8 0*28 %$2 ,1 8 0*28 %2, 2 , ! ,1

"?*#$##%#%?* $#%61 8 %!#%?* $#%#$7 ,0+*"1 $$ %# 8 "1# 7 1 2*:8#" 2*,2$ %! #

"$ 1 28 %%#%5 %$ 28 + ,8 "

5,06%$28 @+ ,8 "

5,06%$28$ + ,8 "

5,06 + 9#! , ! 1 7 "%$#! , !1#$2 , ,5*+ %, #$ !:01 , $2%! %$

%!9 , #%"+28 5, + %9#11 $ + $1#$#$ %#+2, %

", : 4 2#%+#%!91#8 !

8#%59#11 "

$ ,#$#%5* 1 "?*#$##% %! "1# 7 1 2*:8#"2*,2$ %!##$1 $ G#$ *1,#091#$#%1 : $2$##%! "#! :**#8#E #% 1 8 "?*#, !6

, #1 7#%5 : %7 $ !#%/ @ $ $ ?* 8 1 :7 !#$"*$$#% %!#%7# 9 8 9$*++ ,#E !#% ,

!"##$#%!&'#()(*!"+(,;$*2, <6$2 "# #"

880

,1 7#%5 , ",! ! 1 #% 1 "

$ #% 1 %!6 1 210$#"

8 2$$ $$#% 1 8 %! #% ?* $#%1 7#%5: % 4 %61 :8#5 ,2 0+ % "+2 %$ #%$ %!$ !#$"1 ,5 ! 8$"%$#! ,#%51 1 8 %!#%?* $#%#$7 ,0+*"1 $$ %# 8 "1# 7 1 2*:8#"2*,2$ 69 1 7 %1 $# #%18!1 #%1 #%$ %

$ 61 $ 1 *880!#$"1 ,5 !#$:8#5 #%?* :11 "%#%5 %"# $ ""*,,#%5#%$ "#%=;< " %!#: #%5$61 2, $ %2 ##% + ,#$!#$+#$$ 8 %!1 %" 61 #%$ %2 ##%#$!#$+#$$ ! A 7#%5!#$+#$$ !1 + #%9,#2 ##%6 882 %!#%5 228#"

#%$6 # %0 8$+ $1 $ +

1 9,#2 ##%#$!#$+#$$ !/ *$?*# %0 $ %!$7 "

01022022 ( % 1 1 ,$2 4#%5G, $% !&

/ 1 1 , 2, :8 &