High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7436/2013allowed

Dharam Pal v. State Of Haryana Etc

2015-04-21Mr. Justice Hemant Gupta,Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan13 pages

# $% &'& ((% ) *++,( % & # # - )./0#12)32#0 )./0#12)##4))2 %&%+(

567 +7+8 9 ) :%%(7+8 7( %& !+, /47""9,5;(%&9

( %<%(7(7+% +,%%<',87"9,,"49) *+ === %(7(7+% !"9> &?%%+> ,%,,%( &%+(%+;% +, &?%%+7+&"7( *;+ 7+%!%+(7+5 7'&:7"& ( %"&(?'(@ *% &9 & 7"%,( 7&<%(7(7+'+,% (7;"%&

%+&(7('(7+

+,79 &%%67+8 ,7 %;(7+ ( ( % %&<+,%+(& ( ( 7+ ( % ;(& +, ;7 ;'!&(+;%& ( % ;&% 7& ,%( &%+(%+;% ?% ;!!'(%, ( "7 7!< 7&+!%+(

%? 7% ;(& %;&% %( (7+7(7""*957,%:',8!%+(,(%, BB <&&%,?*( %;' ( ,,7(7+"%&&7+&1',8%9+%<(9( <%(7(7+% >&;+57;(%,'+,% %;(7+&

7+;&%#

- - ,(%, BB %87&(% %, ( "7;% ((7+ , +%<(9 +, >& &%+(%+;%,('+,% 8 78 '&7!< 7&+!%+( *% &+ BB ( ?'( 9> %+( %<%(7(7+% >&+?7"7+( %&7,;&%9 "+8>7( 7&? ( % 7 !"7+8 ;!!7((%,!' ,% 75%!%!?% &

!7"*9> >% % %"(%,(( %< &%;'( 7C9 > &% <%( %<%(7(7+% >&;+57;(%, %<%(7(7+% +, 7&? ( % 7 !"7+8 >% %( 7%,7+ ;&%#@,(%, BB '+,% %;(7+ 9 %87&(% %,( "7;%((7+, +%<(9 ;!!7&&7+ !'"(7<"%!' ,% &$7,% :',8!%+(,(%, BB9( %<%(7(7+% +, 7&? ( % 7 !"7+8

>% % ;+57;(%, +, > ,%, ,%( &%+(%+;% ?* ( % ( 7" ;' ( $7,% :',8!%+( ,(%, BBBB@ ++%C' % -9 <&&%, ?* ( 7& ;' (9 ( !' ,% % % %+;%!,%?*( %( 7";' (>&+&>% %,7+

7 !(75%9 > % %&( %<<%" 7"%,?*( %<%(7(7+% +, 7&? ( % 7 !"7+8 >& ,7&!7&&%,9+,( %7 ,%( &%+(%+;%>&;+ 7 !%,

87+&(( %?5%&7,:',8!%+(9( %<%(7(7+% +, 7&? ( 7 !"7+8 7"%,<<%"?% %( %<%C' ( %)+.?"%'< %!% ' (957,%:',8!%+(,(%,@ BBB++%C' %- 9> 7"%(67+87+( ;+&7,% (7+( ;(( %<%(7(7+% >&;+57;(%,7+ <%;&%+, , ;!!7((%,!' ,% !%!?% & !7"* %< &%;'( 7C9'< %",( ,%( &%+(%+;% > ,%, ( ( %<%(7(7+% )>%5% 9 ( % ,%( &%+(%+;% > ,%,( 7&? ( % 7 !"7+8 >&;!!'(%,("7 %7!< 7&+!%+(9 ?%;'&% %>&+(+;;'&%,7+( % <%;&%

- - % % (% 9 ( % <%(7(7+% 7"%, !% ;* <%(7(7+ ?% % ( %&7,%+( +,7+ BBB %&7,!% ;*<%(7(7+ %!7+%,<%+,7+8 7+( %

7;% % %&7,%+( +,7 ?'( *% &+, !+( &+, >& %:%;(%,?*( % %&7,%+( +,757,% ,% ,(%, @ +( !%+> 7"%957,%:',8!%+(,(%,B ++%C' %- 9( %<%(7(7+% >&;D'7((%,?*( 7&;' (7+( % <%;&%(7&( %;&% %<%(7(7+% 7& ;(>&+%5% ? '8 ((( %+(7;% % %&7,%+( +,7%7( ?*( %:7"'( 7(7%& ?*( %((%45% +!%+(

%+( %,%( &%+(%+;% %<%(7(7+% >&87+8(?% %C%;'(%,7+( %!+( < 7"9 9 7"%,( %7+&(+(<%(7(7+'+,% (7;"%&

%+&(7('(7+ +,79< *7+8( (7+( ;(&+, ;7 ;'!&(+;%& %;&%&>%""&( %;

+8%,;7 ;'!&(+;%&( ( & ?%%+;D'7((%,7+( % <%;&%97(>7""?%'+:'&(+,'+ %&+?"%9+, 57"(75% 7& (9(%C%;'(%( %,%( &%+(%+;%(( 7& &(8%9+, 7&,%( &%+(%+;%?%;!!'(%,("7 %7!< 7&+!%+(

+( 7&<%(7(7+9( %<%(7(7+% 7&< *7+8 ;!!'((7+ 7& ,%( &%+(%+;%("7 %7!< 7&+!%+(9+( "">7+8 ' 8 '+,& - 7 % %7&+'+%C<"7+%,+,7+ ,7+(%,%"*+( %< (

7;% % %&7,%+( +,79> (6?'( *% & +, !+( &(,%;7,%( %!% ;*<%(7(7+ %<%(7(7+% '% (( 7&7+ ,7+(%,%"*7+,7&<&" %!% ;*<%(7(7+9 7& ,%( &%+(%+;%>&+(%C%;'(%, "+8(7!%9+,( '& &

- - %&'"(%,57"(7+ 7& ('+,% (7;"%& 9 9B+, %+&(7('(7+ +,7E 77 %<%(7(7+% ( '8 '( %!7+%,7+&"7( *;+ 7+%!%+( 7+5 7'&:7"&&7+;%( %,(% 7&;+57;(7++,&%+(%+;%?* %( 7";' ()% &&'

% %,"(,'%(<7+ '"&"7( * ;+ 7+%!%+( ( %"&(?'(@*% &9+,>&"757+8"+%7+ &'? '!+;+,7(7+&7+&!"" !E 777 ;('! %<%(7(7+% ?%7+8;D'7((%, <%;

8% ?*( 7&;' (57,%:',8!%+(,(%,B >&+(<'('< ?% %( % %&7,%+( +,7"+8>7( %!% ;*<%(7(7+

%<%(7(7+% '&9""( % %"%5+(!(% 7"&>% %+(<";%, ?% %( % %&7,%+( +,79> ;'", 5%8 %(?% 7+8 +( %7&&'% < ,+9& 7&;+57;(7+7+( % <%;&%>& %8 '+, '< ",7+8 7&,%( &%+(%+;%E+, 75 ( %:%;(7+ ( % !% ;* <%(7(7+ ( % <%(7(7+% >& ;+5%*%, ( 7& % ?*( % '<% 7+(%+,%+(9 %+( " 17"9 !?"957,%"%((% ,(%,@ ++%C' %- 9+,7( >& 7+ !%, ( ( + 9 ,%( &%+(%+;% ( <%(7(7+% >'",?%%C%;'(%, % % (% 9( %<%(7(7+% 7"%,( 7+&(+(<%(7(7+97+> %C%;'(7+ 7&,%( &%+(%+;%>& &(*%, 57,% 7+(% 7! ,% ,(%, >9 ( ( 7& ?%"(%,&(8%9%C%;'(7+ %,%( &%+(%+;% %<%(7(7+%

- - >'",?% "*'+:'&(+,'+ %&+?"%9+,57"(75% 7&

( +7(& %<"*9( %2+7+ +,7 &( 7%,(%C<"7+( %,%"*7+ ,7&<&" %!% ;*<%(7(7+ 7"%,?*( %<%(7(7+% +,%C%;'(7+ 7& ,%( &%+(%+;%+( 7& %8 ,9< 8 < &B(

% %<"* % %"%5+(9 > %,&'+,% -

! " #

# "

! " #

(

)

* &

# " "

+ *

! " #

# !

" /

" ,

0 11

/ "

" ,

( 11

- 2

0 31

" *

" +

- - ,

" # !

3 31

1 (1

0 3 " ,

" ,

1 (1

11 (1

5 ,

# !

! " #

/ # !

7 0

# !

/ 1

! "9 : 11

/ / ;

! "

9 : ! "9 :

10 1

! "#

1$ 1

! "9 :

! " #

# !

" ( (1

/ " " ,

-- *

(

! "#

" ,

"8 . /

" #%

! " #

< !

' $1

* $

! " #

" *

! "

10 $1

# !

' 1

/ " " ,

" #

$ 1

" * / " ,

3 (1 1

# !

= /

-@- 1 1 1 1 ,

* 4 /

/#%

" 11

! " #

3 1 1 13

# !

<' 1 3 #%

# !

" * / / /

/ "

" 10 1 31 3 #%

" / . /

* 1

= ! "#

/ "

# "

1$ 31 37 @ +( %> 7((%+&((%!%+( 7"%,+?% "

%((% ) *+9 7( &?%%+,!7((%,( '8 '(( %<% 7, (% 7&;+57;(7+?*( ( 7" ;' ( 57,% :',8!%+( ,(%, BB9 ( % <%(7(7+% %!7+%, 7+ &"7( *;+ 7+%!%+(7+5 7'&:7"&' ( % 97( &+(?%%+,7&<'(%,( %:',8!%+(,(%,B <&&%,?*( 7&;' (9;D'7((7+8( %<%(7(7+%

-B7+( % <%;&%9>&+(<";%,?% %( % %&7,%+( +,7"+8>7( !% ;*<%(7(7+ %<%(7(7+% B +( %"78 ( %&7, ;(&9>% 5%%C!7+%,( %7&&'% 7&%,7+( 7&<%(7(7+9+, 5%;+&7,% %,( %D'%&(7+&(> %( % + 7+ ,7+(%,%"* ?'( *% &+, !+( &7+,7&<&" %!% ;* <%(7(7+>&&'

7;7%+("*+, %&+?"*%C<"7+%, (% 87+8( '8 %&7,< 8 < & % %<"* 7"%, +?% "

%2+7+ +,79>% % %<7+7+( (7+( %< %&%+( ;&%9( %"+8+,7+ ,7+(%,%"*7+(67+8,%;7&7++( %!% ;*<%(7(7+

&+(?%%+&'

7;7%+("*+, %&+?"*%C<"7+%,+' <7+7+9( !% ;*<%(7(7+ &+(?%%+%C<%,7(7'&"*,%"(>7( ?*( %'( 7(7%&9 > % %&7( &(?%%C<%,7(%,(%5% *&(8% !( ;(&&((%,?5% +,( %&(+,(6%+?*( % %&<+,%+(&7+( %7 &%< (%> 7((%+&((%!%+(&97( 7&+(( %;&% % %&<+,%+(&(""( %,%"*7+,7&<&" !% ;*<%(7(7++,%C%;'(7+ ,%( &%+(%+;%7&(( 7?'(%,(( %<%(7(7+% ( &?%%+ %",7+5 7'&:',8!%+(& %'< %!%' (( '+,'% +, 7+ ,7+(% ,%"* 7+ ,7&<&" !% ;* <%(7(7+ 57"(%& (

( ,%( ;+57;(+( 7& %8 ,9 % % %+;%;+?%!,%( %"(%&(,%;7&7+ %'< %!%' (7+

'< %!%' (&%&9> % %7( & ?%%+ %",( (< "+8%,,%"*7+%C%;'(7+ &%+(%+;% ,%( & ,% '!+7&7+8%

%;(+,( 7& &( %;+&(7('(7+"7!<"7;(7+ ,%< 757+8

-- <% &+ 7&"7 %7++'+:'&(9'+ 7 +,'+ %&+?"%>*&&(

%+, ('+,% (7;"% %+&(7('(7+ (7;"%& 9B +, &'<<"%!%+(%;

( % +, 78 ((;!!'((7+ ,%( <%+"(*,'% ('+,'%+,7+ ,7+(%,%"*7+%C%;'(7+ !% ;*<%(7(7+7&&'?&(+(75% ( ;+57;(+,+(!% %"*< ;%,' " 78 ( %7+ ,7+(%,%"*7+,7&<&" %!% ;*<%(7(7+7+( < %&%+( ;&%9 > & ?%%+ ;'&%, ?* ( % '( 7(7%& >7( '( +* %&+?"%8 '+,97&?%*+,( %;+( " %<%(7(7+% %7+ ,7+(%9 '+ %&+?"%+,'+%C<"7+%,,%"*7&8 '+,9> ;+ % & 78 (+ ;+,%!+%, < 7&+% ( 8%( 7& ,%( &%+(%+;% ;!!'(%, ( "7 7!< 7&+!%+(9?*&%%67+8<< < 7(% %!%,*'+,% ( %"> %&%;+,8 '+,9+> %<%(7(7+% 7&< *7+8 +( %C%;'(7+8 7&,%( &%+(%+;%(( 7&&(8%+, ;!!'(7+8( %&!%("7 7!< 7&+!%+(7&( %'( 7(7%&,7,+(<";%( %!(% 7">7( %8 ,(

7&;D'7(("7+( % <%;&%9?% %( % %&7,%+( +,7 7& ;("& 57"(%& ( % '+,!%+(" 78 (& ( % <%(7(7+% ( & ?%%+ %", 7+

&'< ( ( > %+ !% ;* <%(7(7+ ;+,%!+%,< 7&+% 7&<";%,?% %( % %&7,%+( +,7 ( %45% + %((%97(7&7+;'!?%+(+( %< ( 7+7&( *;+;% +%,(<";%""

%!(% 7"&&';

&:',8!%+( %( 7";' (9)78 ' (+,( 7+"

;' (&>%""&+*( % %"%5+(!(% 7";++%;(%,>7( %;+57;(7+ ""(8%( % +,(+;%+,+(;"" ( %,;'!%+(&<7%;%!%"+(

-- < %&%+(;&%9,!7((%,"*9( %:',8!%+( ;D'7((" <%(7(7+% 7+( % <% ;&%9 <&&%, ?* ( 7& ;' ( + B 9 >& +( <";%, ?% % ( %&7,%+( +,7"+8>7( %!% ;*<%(7(7+ %&7,:',8!%+(!78

5% ,8 %(?% 7+8+( %,%;7&7+ %!% ;*<%(7(7+9< (7;'" "* 6%%<7+87+57%>( ;(( %)+.?"%'< %!%' (;!!'(%,( ,%( &%+(%+;% ? ( % %<%(7(7+% ("7 %7!< 7&+!%+(9> 7"%(67+8 7+(;+&7,% (7+( ;(( ( %>&+(7+5"5%,7+( % <%;&% ;( %<%(7(7+% >&;D'7((%,7+( % <%;&%;'", 5%?%%+;+&7,% %, %(7!% ,7&<&" 7&!% ;*<%(7(7++,+( %&!%+"8*9( %&7,%+( +,7;'", 5%;!!'(%,( %,%( &%+(%+;% %<%(7(7+% ("7 %7!< 7&+!%+( 7&< ;%,' "7""%8"7(*9> ;'", 5%8+%( % ( %!((% 9 &;'&%,&% 7'&< %:',7;%(( %<%(7(7+% +, 57"(%, 7& ((8%( 7&!% ;*<%(7(7+;+&7,% %,7+7(& (<% &<%;(75% 7 ,"*97+( %< %&%+(;&%9'+,7&<'(%,"*9( %<%(7(7+% & %!7+%,7+&"7( *;+ 7+%!

%+(7+&7+8"%%""7+5 7'&:7"&9 (% 7& ;+57;(7+7+( %!' ,% ;&%?*( %( 7";' (+ BB)% &&<%+( ?'(@*% &7+&"7( *;+ 7+%!%+(' 7+8( %<%+,%+;* 7&!% ;* <%(7(7+9+"*%C%;'(7+ 7&,%( &%+(%+;%>&&(*%,9?'(( '8 '(( &7, <% 7,9 % %!7+%, 7+ &"7( * ;+ 7+%!%+( ( & ?

&'< ( (7 %;+,%!+%,< 7&+% 7&6%<( 7+&"7( *;+ 7+%!%+(< 7 ( %:%;(7+ 7&!% ;*<%(7(7+9( (7(&%"

- - !'+(& ( 57"(7+ 7& '+,!%+(" 78 ( '+,% (7;"% +&(7('(7+9&&"7( *;+ 7+%!%+(< 7 (,7&<&" %!% ;*<%(7(7+ 7&'+> +(%,+,>'",!'+((&%< (%+,,,7(7+"<'+7& !%+(+( '( 7&%,?*">)%+;%9( 7&;' (;+%+(% (7+( %7+&(+(<%(7(7+'+,% (7;"%

%+&(7('(7+97+;&%7(7&%&(?"7& %,( '+,!%+("

( %;+,%!+%,< 7&+% &?%%+57"(%, ' 7+8 ( % ;' &% 8'!%+(&9 "% +%, ;'+&%" ( %&<+,%+(&,7,+( 7&%( % 8'!%+( !7+(7+?7"7(* %7+&(+(> 7( <%(7(7+)>%5% 97( &?%%+;+(%+,%,?*( %"% +%,((%;'+&%"( (7+ %7+&(+(;&%9&7+;%( %<%(7(7+% &;!!7((%,!' ,% 75%!%!?% & !7"* % <%57;(7!9> ,,%<&%,87+&( 7!9( %,%(

&%+(%+;%> ,%,( 7!& '",+(?%;!!'(%,("7 %7!< 7&+!%+(+ %8 '+, 7+ ,7+(%,%"*7+,7&<&" 7&!% ;*<%(7(7++,6%%<7+8

7!7+&"7( *;+ 7+%!%+(,' 7+8( %<%+,%+;* %!% ;*<%(7(7+ 7& ;+(%+(7+97+' <7+7+9;++(?%;;%<(%,( &?%%+ %",?*( '< %!%' (7+

&'< ( (> %+( % %7& '+,'%+,'+%C<"7+%,,%"*7+,7&<&" %!% ;*<%(7(7+97(>7""?% '+:'&(+,'+ %&+?"%(%C%;'(%( %,%( &%+(%+;%(( %?%"(%,&(8%9 7 %&<%;(75% %8 57(* &% 7'&+%&& %

%+;%9&"+8&( %,%"* >&+(;'&%,(( %7+&(+;% %;+,%!+%,< 7&+% +( %< %&%+( ;&%9,%"*7+,7&<&" %!% ;*<%(7(7+7& "*7+ ,7+(%9> 7& ?'( *% &+, !+( & %)+.?"%<%C' (&>%""&%"

7)78

- - ' (F

BB## 7!7+" @G+,, & )78 ' (F

BB ## 7!7+"

G 5%;!!'(%,,%( &%+(%+;%("7 %7!< 7&+!%+(7+ ;&%&9> % %( %,%"*>&%5%+"%&&( + (@*% &+,,7(7+(( "+87+ ,7+(%+,'+%C<"7+%,,%"*9( % % %( % ;7 ;'!&(+;%&9"76% &"7( *;+ 7+%!%+( %<%(7(7+% ?'( *% &+, !+( & ,' 7+8( %<%+,%+;* 7&!% ;*<%(7(7+9+,++-<";7+8 %!(% 7"

;(?% %( % %&7,%+( +,79> 7+' <7+7+!6%'(( %< %&%+( ;&%& 7(;&%> % %( 7&;' (97+%C% ;7&% 7(&<>% &'+,% (7;"%

( % +&(7('(7+9 !* ""> ( % > 7( <%(7(7+ & ,% 7+8 ( %C%;'(7+ ,%( &%+(%+;%>7""?% "*'+:'&(+,'+ %&+?"%9+, 57"(75% ( %;+,%!+%,< 7&+% ( % %&+& %; ,%,?5%9( %7+&(+(> 7(<%(7(7+7& "">%,9+,( %,%( &%+(%+;%> ,%,(( %<%(7(7+% 7&;!!'(%,( "7 %7!< 7&+!%+(17"'( 7(7%&?%7+ !%,;; ,7+8"* # $ %&'( " !") # $ +,: