High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/25610/2017dismissed

Punjab Unaided Technical Institutions Association And Others v. State Of Punjab And Others

2018-12-21Mr. Justice Tejinder Singh Dhindsa21 pages

!"# #$%&%'(

)

(* + , , ,

"# $%

% ! #

% !

$ &! ' & !

!(# !

)* +++++ , ,

, &

& / 0 01 #

&.&

& 2 '

3 .'

4 '

1 45689 '

" &/ 61

# ;

& !

# & #6<5=4567. & ' #!

: #

.& 6> 2'

.& # # '

#, :

? '?

' #

# ! !"

# !$ !"

#%""&' !"

# (#!"

# !

%#!"

"#!"

!#!"

#%""&'

)#!"

##!"

# -

67574567 / *1 & & &! 4 & * !

' &

;

; ' & :

! # ;

- 9 * &#

4*574567 #

6<584567

4 &#

465745676<584567

- 6

3 .'

# & &

6<584567

- # '

& #

67574567/ *1

# ;

& &

# '' &

& .!

& # &

# '

&' &

# & !

, & # @ !'

58584567

:" )=45** 4567

" ! )A528 4564/ 81

; # ' @0

" !.&/!0!'!"//!.%"!12#.3&"!'4"/#.&0& 22'4%!3'$%2 .

#$/'%$!243$!"%'!'4"/#.&

--,-) :

5 6<584567*6584567 !

# !

' &

: *6584567 #

& 3

@ &" -"B)6A*=84567 !6!&"/!''7%'##.%'722#7#&,$%#"80&,"!"# !6!&"/!'!'4 "/#.&

42664567 & C & @ & "

58584567 / 8&# 1#

# '

- ' 3

6766456=/ 461

# '

4566456=

- !

67574567/ *1

' & #

6<584567 &

6766456=/ 461

' ,&

4567 4568

& &

( %

' ( !

' $

= 7 !

& 4567 4568

6<584567 # !

# , 4<584567

# &

# & 6<584567

$ ! - &

*5654568

' " +

6!893:!./!;3.!'4.&<&,"!"# !.8!'!

!'4!'"/#.&

3 !

456= 4567

#' @0

" !.&/!0!'!"/ /!.%"!12#.3&"&3=.! #

& "

. !

6< & '

; # &

/ 61 # &

& ) "

/)"1 ) #$

# ,

& D "

" & "

& # ' '

& & &# ### &! &

! #

& # & !

4 &

'6<&4567

# #

;

# &

)" 6<584567 &

58584567/ 81

*6584567

& E

& ' ' & # ' & !.&/!0!'!"//!.%"!12#.3&"&3=.! # 6<&'

" '

6<&

& ! ' & '

'; &

' 9 36!.!2> 3'6!1 #$/'%$!2 '%0#.&%"8?3'6!1% '%0#.&%"8 !"%!2! # & :

# !

! 6<584567 :

!.&/!0!'!"//!.%"!12#.3&"&3=.!1

" #

# # &

* *, ***- *.-' /, ' 12 % 3

0 *, !

*, * *,

- . 2 2 )" 3 ! . 2 2

" 3 4 . 2 2 !" 3 4

2+)" 3 56+72

/72 2 2 )"

4 +2.*

% ' 4 + 2 8+-9+ # & '

'6& !'

) &! & '

'6<& # #

565*4567

'%!

& /

- 1

- #

' &

; ' & : !

& '

# !

' "

" & 4567 4568/ 61

& # 6<5=4567

3 " 3

# #

& & ' ) "

/)"1 ) #$ #

&D D" & & # ' '

& & & # ### &! &

! # 6?* !

# ,

, &

& # /### &! 1 & # #

& ! '

, & & # & & #

/### &! 1

# %!

)

9 %!

565*4567

& =#.'"% %$!"%'4!"#4

"/#.#A#.#"1#"A.3'4& $#'".!2%B#4$3'&#22%'718"/# !.4/#&#$'4$3'&#22%'7A!&" 1#0#.18

!'4"/#!4:%&&%'$'&#C3#'"""/%&A!&"1# !22A#43=" "/ 328 /#.#!

"#."/#4%.#$"!4:%&&%'&!""/# $22#7#2#0#2A#.#"1#!22A#4 .0!$!'"&#!"&!'4"/# !.4A!&" %&&3#'#$#&&!.8%'&".3$"%'&""/#%'&"%"3"%'&'

%'"/%& .#7!.4 /#=.$#&& '2%'#.#7%&".!"%' &3$/&#!"&A!&"1# $:=2#"#418 "/ 373&"18!22:#!'&

67574567/ *1

&! 4

& &

# #

6 .

62 2 + / , 2 +:

2 + 6 + !

2 ; ! 6 2 + 2 62

6662 .

6 ) <= 2 2 = ( .

- 7 - 6 + % .

62 !

3!"

# .* < < + < 4 - !" !"

! 2 % !"

# &

565*4567

# #

67574567 / *1

- # '

& #

6<584567

# ;

& &

# ''

! 4 & #

' ! &

, & & ! 4

& # & !

, & # ' &

6 #

565*4567 #

) & ' #

/ 61

565*4567

6<584567

; #

" #

58584567/

:" )=45**4567

/ " ! )A52845641# '

' : & "

*6584567H !.&/!0!'!"//!.%"!12#.3&"&3=.!> :" # ' & #

' , &

' # # &

F/3&A#!==.0#"/#&#!4:%&&%'4!"#&!'44#$2!.#%"" 1# "/# 2!A A/%$/ &/!22 1# &".%$"28 !4/#.#4 " 18 !22 $'$#.'#4 !'4 ''# "/# !3"/.%"%#& &/!22 /!0# "/# =A#..63.%&4%$"%'"0!.8"/#&#4!"#& !4:%&&%'

#."!%'"8%'"/%& %#24%&13'4"&#.0#"/##'4& !%.> ".!'&=!.#'"!'4634%$%3&:#"/4 7.!'" !4:%&&%'

!'4 $::#'$#:#'" "/# "#$/'%$!2 $3.&#& '8 0!.%!"%'%&13'4"!40#.&#28!

#$""/#:!%'"#'!'$# /%7/#.&"!'4!.4& #43$!"%'!'4&8&"#:%$!'4=.=#.

$:=2#"%' $3.&#&D & & # &

> " # #

$%&'# ( # )*

+ ,

- .

: " 58584567

# &

)=45**4567

" ! )A5284564

& "

0 1 23 +24 &

. )=45**4567 " ! )A5284564 #'!.&/!0!'!"//!.%"!12#.3&"

- &3=.!>

, & : ' 6<584567 ' &

& '! &

: &

& ; ' : 65I4 & & ' #

' : :

". .: &

' : '

& #

6<584567#& , & )=45**4567 :"

& *684567 3

# !

" # &

& )=2*A*4567 )=2*A74567&# )=45** 4567 " ! )A5284564 #

58584567 8

66584562

&# )274562

! )A5284564

& &

4562 456< :

*6584562 ', &

' 545=4562 #'

$ & &

4*584567

:"#

&# )78*564567

" ! )A5284564 # ' # :

*6584567

9 ' '

4*584567

:" #

>5 # 0

# 0

1 23 +24 "

# # # . # , )78*564567 " ! )A528 4564

# ! &

' # .: # & & '

, &

@' C, - ). @#

# &

.: #&' &

& CJ( # # @'

' & &

! & B '

& !

? '

:", & & E

" ! )A5284564 &

58584567/

# &

: " !.&/!0!'!"/ /!.%"!12# .3&"&3=.!

' &6< & #

& !

& ' #

# & "

626

" !

# !

# ;

' & !

' & C & @ &" !6!&"/!''7%'##.%'722#7#&,$%#"8&3=.!, !

58584567/ 81

:" #

# !

' *6584567 #

& E

& C &

: ?

" ,

:" #

58584567/ 81 ' "

585845679

& C & @ &"# &

& E &

' *6584567

& : ! &

& E"/#.$3.&#&D

& !

E"/#.$3.&#&D # '

# !.&/!0!'!"/ /!.%"!12#.3&"&3=.!># E"/#.$3.&#&D#

' !

#, '

& C & @ &"

6766456=/ 461 '

& !

! , 6< &456= ,

& !

# #

6*5A4567 !

# # &

F&+ 2 +

2 ? 2 22.* %"$!"

5@2 A

& ; '

& & # ,

# # &

'(%

'? !

' # & :

& !

. # !

& &!

'%" '

# ' : " !.&/!0!'!"//!.%"!12#.3&"&3=.!,

# !

' & & ?

& '

$ ! - &

6!8 93:!./!;3.*&$!&#&3=.!> #'

6<58456= !

& /3..

1 - .&

& -

- " - $ '

! &

# "

& C &

& ; '

# &

' 3 - ,

)

! &

! E ' &

; ?$$?).9 ?

1 ,

& , $ ! - 6!893:!./!;3.*&$!&#&3=.!

>2+7

+ 2 6 2 +

2 .

2+ B2 /2 B 2 + :2;7 7 B 7 2 6 6 +22 C

: 62 6 2 7 2 6 7 6 6 2 :7 7

;

+ 2 + 7 2A

& ?

# & : ! &

*6584567

67584567/ 6=1 # # ; ' $

$ :

*6584567 @#

6<584567

2/ '1

64584567 &' & '

" &

- , <

6 5A 4=<?

68584567

& -,

2/"'1#

<455 #

6<584567

# 3

<455 # 6 4 & # !

455 : ' # <5

: ' #

# !

' & &

# "

& ' !

? & # !

' ! :

7 ' 7 % ''&

!C"$C!"

##$

)-$-!"

# ( $ % $

(-$-!"

# ! "#

%-$-!"

# !'C%&' ! "#

# "

%-$-!"

#%&'C#&' )!

%-$-!"

##&'C "&'

%-$-!"

# "&'C

&' %!

%-$-!"

&'C !&' $)

& 3

' # #

&& !

& ? !

6<584567

& # !,

? & D D " & # &&

) "

/)"1#

&'& E %!

' "

&' )"

& D D " &...,

' 7

& ?

# !

" ' # )

! & ,

: /1 ' !

' "

5<644567 #

:# ' ; ' !

' #

58584567/ 81#

# 3 , # #

4<5<4568

: &485<4568#

# ;

' " 4=664568 # & # & 5=644568

6<584567

#' :"

#! &

# ; ' !

# B

, ,

#$#:1#. >

) 6 B , &?

> ?) B

> ?)