High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3845/2012dismissed

New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Shimla Devi And ORS.

2015-07-28Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan5 pages

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA

AT CHANDIGARH and Cross Objections No.168-CII of 2014 (O&M) Date of decision: 28.07.2015 New India Assurance Co. Ltd.

3.. Appellant versus Shimla Devi and others 33Respondents

CORAM:

Hon'ble Mr.Justice Kuldip Singh

"! #" $

Kuldip Singh, J.

%" &'("")* $+,- .

" / 0 '/ * " 1+2 00

," /"'&" + $ .

/ ''"" 34'5 '" " !" 6")!"'"*' 4"""&"!

( 0" '/ 8"'" 34'5

'" $"'"&'" 6"8(" "& '/'("

0(6"8( " :((4"&"% "& &"" #2 +2 2-911 &"&!

"7 '/(& $-..2 0("',

..+ + $.6"8( "&&("6 " !

;"< ' "'"&"(4 / %( "&" / 6 " ( ( (4"& " 7!

" 6"8(""&"&' & &(";"< ' 46"8 (''

& ( // /" %'" *'

4 ( / " -

..+ "&

!" =, ( / "

'/'"'" :(

"? '/ " " (" '((4"&" % "&&"" #2 +2 2-911 0("' " ( " (" 7" '/ : " "" '/ '/ ("'6"8 8"" " " '/ ( "' / 0 '/("" '/'/ (" % ( "&"""""

"/ % & " ( 4 )' "&("&" ('2 "

& % ''""("" '/'/ (" 0(" " "/"""'"

'" '/("" '/( " /'" "&/'" ,++$1,2((

@ '" (( %" '/&" "("" "4"&''" 0 " /& &" )"'& ' " '/"(""'/ '/ ('/2! " 0

& " "'6"8(" :('"'"'6 "( (4"&" 0 & ( " %(""& '

& &( "( ""&""&"' & "'"6 "(""&( '/ ;" < ' " ( " %"'"A'";"< ' 3 "3 ;"< ' "' !"'"" !

"'/ "'&&6 "" : "B "(/ 4 :" 6" 8 ( " % (" ( A'"" %" '( (" %' !

"" ((4"& " :(" '( &6"8( " " '/!

"( "&/ (4"&"""'/"(/(""& '

& %"" ;" %""&'

& &"6"

8 " '" "/ / (

' 3 (" %(4 '/( ""/ 0 "& " '/ ( "&/ " / '" !B '" ''"" 4/ '""' '(&"

$-..2""&& =/ 4-.@'"" '""'

'(&'

"" '(" %""&"/"' 8 2 & """'("(" :(" / "' ( "&/ 4 '""'

'(&A""&"/ ..+ 8 & ""/(( <"&" "("("'(" ("( ""'/'"( "0"""(/ "' :(0" ''""( "'(' ( '''"" ( -

..+" "C" !'""&/( 0 "( &"& " " "'" "/( A 28.07.2015 (Kuldip Singh) "

Judge