High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3871/2012allowed

Rachna Monga v. National Insurance Company Ltd. And ORS.

2019-07-23Mr. Justice Satpal14 pages

! "

#$% && '( ) (*+& ,$( #&

#$% && '( ) (*+& ,$( #& -

.(+(/%$ && '( %$(/%$$( #&

((0 ($( && '( %$(/%$$( #& 1

2(3$40 ($( && '( %$(/%$$( #& $% &'

( ('(''

(#4$/$!5

($&&

((& 6- !6- "6 1

( /7$!5

($&&6- !6- "6 1

((&

(#4$'(+!5

($ (+& $&&

'(''

) 7$4 %+$&

!6- !

6- "6 1

$ 35 && + (+ + & (% +(5$9$$:& -

7$ +&$533 $((*+ 7(3 !/($( (( ((;$7(3 ;5++9(

$53 3 $ 9( $

%5$$%%$(5( (%$

( $ (+& 59(

&3 $( 7(3 6- " 6 1

$5 3 3 $ + ($+ +&9(3 $7(3 $ (/%$4/%$ 59(

$ 3 3 $&&< .(+(/%$ ($+ +& 4 ( 3

(3 $+$+(5$!9$$: & -

=( ( (4 $($$ + $(&(& (/ 11 $( '$:%+& $ 4/%$!

(/%$ 4 (

(3 .(+(/%$ +(5$ ($%%(5% $

% 5$! 7( : 3(% (%( 2#>"?

" ! 3

(& ,( 7(3 $ $( 9 +

(3 ( %%$&( $!$( (!$+ 9($ 6@ $9(+&*(3 ( %%$&( $9 6@) ( +& 9

($(%$(5($+ &3 (+ $9((5($%( $$&((3 $ (&<(5( : ,( ($&&(% $(5( (%$ $53

($ (+& $%( $$(5% &((3 $(&<(5(9 :295(!$

% $(7(3 3 $(&( 1 3+ 3 $ ( 7(3 & ( (( - &3 $* (,( 3+$&& ((( - # *.*9 ((&(5$$(5( $

% 5$9$%5(5%7$&&<9( %$ &(($(%(5% $(5(+ %$( /%$7$(5% $(5( $

%5$&(5 3% !$( (!&( $&& 3 $9(3 9 )(5$%$!$* (5(( - 1

(&&( $(5(9( 59$( ($(% +!$(5% $3 $(5( $

%5$$(5+!3 ($ (7(3 3 59&(5$ (( &(5$(5(( (+$#7;

#&( (+$( 7(3 $ (& 9 ( #5 &( ((

- 1( ( > (%($&&

! $( ( && ( (& 57$5$(5% $53 5 ( $(5(3 $7;

2( 7$ %(5 $ &&>9( $ $ 7(3 +( (5( +3 $ ((; (&(559%53 $ (( &(5 $ 5 (+ & 3 ++% $ (( (+$7;

7$((9&( $+ 9$$5%( $(&( ( 5 (+ & !$ (( $5$3 3 3

B( 7$+( + $ 5 (+

& ( $(5%9 (C ( 3&(57$ + 3 ( (5:$ &(+ (3 $% $ +! $$ +$( ) &( $ +!$$(5($ (5%$+(5$ $$ (5 (&( 5$ 9 5 (+

" -D9$($+ +!$ ( (7' & 5 &

7$>(+3 (+ ! (! 9$(! ) $5 3(5! $ (+95 (+

- 7$($3 %(($&( $&& % +$7(3 3 $ (%(%5

(+ & 9 (C (3B+3 % ( (&( (+ $ ( *+ 7(3 7$ + 9$$&& (((- #

*.*(((3(5$ (&$ *7/( (%5%&&( $(5( 9(%559$( ($(% + 9$3 5$ ((3(%$

(5(( (+$#7;

! $ :( $ + (% 7$(&($3 $ (9$&( $(+$E .

( $(!(&( 1 1$3(5

(+$(7(3 ?((/

/( .( $(&( 1 1(5$#F0$ *$!$(*(: (+$

#72(G.9 B+3 $ (+& #F$& &$$ C 9 ( " (+( ,'.(5 7$9( (27' &

) 9 3C % (9 9

" -)& 3 #F$9 $ + %$(/%$ . (/%$.$%(&$9

B $(%(#F& $$&$& $DB#H9 3 $

3($+&$%(&$

B$ (%( ,(7(3 $%( 3(5$$ 5(5%)+( (($$ C :& -

!$( (!&(5$$ (5+(5( $

%5$9$%5(5% )&($34$53 3 $ (+& $%%$(&($(( 3& (+ $( 0&%59$ ( +35! % $(7(3 (&$(5%$3 $(5(

%5$(5%$3 $(5( $

%5$$+ $&(535

3($ $(+ $ ( & &(5 *C !$ (+& 3+ $9( $(%$(5($+ +&&3 )(&$&& 3 $+!(

($+(% $$(7(3 $9(+%( +&$+$$(+&)$+( (%(%$ 4/%$ (/%$!(7(3 ! 3+!$((%$+ $9( (+

( &(& $ 3

( &($39(% && ) (& $ +( &(% +& $ 4 (>.(+(/%$! 3+$$&&

( @

3 29 " ($+ $ 9& ( %$I +&$39(9( +(5(!+%(+&$3

( ($ $($ ,( ($+<&&

($((% $ ( 7(3 $ (( $% $ $( 9 (3 ( %%$&( $$B 6@7$+ ($(+& ,( ($ (+& 9$(

%$ (% + ( 3 ( ( $ && 3+ $ C +&$39(3 $(7(3 9$$ (

($($+$$ %(%(%(3 ( %%((!$( (!$ 3 &$)!$ !&( $$ && 3 $+3+

2(( ($&($5&( $ 53((9$$(3 ,(7(3 $$$$((3 ( %% $&( 4 (>.(+(/%$93$$ + $$( $+9((%99$()

(&(% $99$($$ % (3 ( %% $3( (3 $(7(3 &( $((!$95(!

(5$9(&(%!9$$9$ 5 (

$C 7(&(% 3 5 $(

( 3 $3 &(! % (3 ( %%$&( $4 (?$3 $ 5((,( ($ (+&

3& 5(($9$(&(%9$ 5 ( ($C 0&%59$ ( +35!$

%( (3 $(7(3 !$$(9(3 ( %%$B 6@$&( $4 (! )$$$+($(+

# 7$(& $4/%$$ +( 5$!9$$:& -

$($ %%(5% 7( :3(%(%(2#>"?

" (53 (& 7$>4/%$9+ " ( $+ $)& &3 $+$ (

+&%$I !4/%$$&&+3#&( 9% (*+& ()

($(+$$9 9(:%9(:$&3%( 3 $ ($+3%9 $5( 6!?>&(+$

( (+&%$ /(/( *( DB+ 4/%$ ((!9$$$9$$$($B+($!

,(7(3 $+ $ -!?> 9$( ($9% :3 (($(5+) +( (($$$+&$I $ &+3(&(!$( (!4 $+

$9$( ($++ +9%53 : 3 (( )+ $!$ ! 1!?>&(+$ -!?>&(+$)59 $% $2;3 / &(+* ( $ *+,-*.-/01*-2345*-6',4,+37 831/0/ 1*-*6(3+9,*-7+931/ ! ,8,."!(

(&(&$( -@ -?>

(!$ 9 " ($+ !9$$:+ $ -?>&(+$7$+!$!($99 +$(! +(((+(3($( $)&&( $$(5(( $+$ $+9( 5%%$($$+9(& &$ 7$( (!59 $% 93 $2;3/ &(+ * (

"#*#*5

!&( 9$( ?($ 3&&!$(3 ((%+ $ 361?> -> && %+ &(

1(+ $4 %+ $2;3/ &(+* (

!"#$ ! & $ +

!"!1?>61 B

7$+( 6!?>$ (

(B& ) (+ $4 %+ $2;3/ &(+* ( *:4*3-31*.

-/01*-2345*-6',4,+37831/0/*-0 *4.,*/90910 *4*-7 +931 ! ,8,. - " $ * ( # (91, *43-31*.-/01*-23 45*-6',4,+37831/0/3*-+;*01*-7+931/) && +$( $(-!?> ( + *+ (! $ ! +&

"!1?> ( > , & 61B

!"!1?> , ( + -!?> , 6!?> (B& 6!?> +*.

"!1?> 7$+ +&( 9($&&! !$ (+$+ 35 &&(($( 6@&( +$ $+ (+$ % $&(J &&(+ + +&+%+ $3$+( B3 $(7(3 ( $ 7(3 (&+( 3 (+ +&+ $+$ (

!" 7$(& $ (/%$!$

+(5$!9$$:& -

$ ($%%(5% 7( :3(%(%(2#>"?

(53 (& 7$< (/%$9+

" ($+ $)& &3 $ +$ (+&%$I ! (/%$99(:% 3 (( 9 + /( /( *( DB+

(/%$((!9$$$9$$$($ B+($! ",(7(3 $+ $ -!?>9$( ($9% $ :3 (( $(5+)+( (($$$+& $I !$( (!4 $+9$( ( 9%(3 :3 (( )+ $!$ !

1!?>&(+$)59 $% $ 2;3 / &(+* ($ 1*-*6(3+9, &(!(

(&(&$( -@ -?>

(!$ 9 " ($+ !9$$:+ $ -?>&(+$)59 $% 93 $2;3 / &(+* ( &(!6@ $3 (%$

$93$(!$(3 ((%+ $3 - ?> ->- && %+ &(

1!(+ $4 %+ $2;3/ &(+* (

!"#$ !& $+"! !

?>- B

7$+ ( 6!?>$ (

(B& ) (+ $4 %+ $2;3/ &(+* ( *:4*3-31*.

-/01*-2345*-6',4,+37831/0/*-0 *4.,*/90910 *4*-7

+931 ! ,8,. - " $ * ( # (91, *43-31*.-/01*-23 45*-6',4,+37831/0/3*-+;*01*-7+931/)&&&( $ ( -!?> ( + *+ (! $ ! +&

?> ( > , & - B

"! !

?> , ( + -!?> , 6!?> (B& 6!?> +*. "!

?> 7$+ +&( 9($&&! !$ (+$+ 35 &&(($( 6@&( +$ $+ (+$ % $&(J &&(+ + +&+%+ $3$+( B3 $(7(3 ( $ 7(3 (&+( 3 (+ +&+ $+$ (

! 7$&&<.(+(/%$+

(4 ( $C !9$$5$+9$&(+3

@.F-()$9(/%$!.( (2 &(+ ( / (%( ! .K)/! #$: %( & $ ( B+ $&.(+(/%$3 $=(!9 $ .(+(9!

A @&(+ 3 $4 ( 9$ ((&( 9$ (( 9$

+(+((E .F- &(5 $ + ( 3 $ =( DB.F-?)& 3 .F-$$+$ ( 5 $(C ($& $(&(5 ($( $(.F6(K J(K &!.( (!&(+ ( / (%( !*!, $ $.(+(/%$9+ *!, $ -

(9$$ 4 ( ($&4 ( 2(+ ((+

7$ + 9 % +

$(%

7$( (!+>.(+(/%$9 %+

$ ( (%( &(+ $(%

$$(%( 9(&(53 .F67$3!

9$$ $ +& ($ (+ !9( &(53 .F6!9$

($($$3 &(+ ( : +&(5 &( $(((5$

3 $ &&<.(+(/%$ @2 35(( $ ( $(9$ (5$2 & & + (5$+ $()$ !9 +3 &$ (7(3 $59(+& ( (%7$(5((&(5$+ $ 4 ( C $&&$3&

(+$((!3 ( ($&&)$ ( +!(4 B&$+

$4 (>+36!-?>&(+$!++ +9%

:3 (($/ 2( $+ $9

6!6 ?>&(+$&&-@(+

(&(&59 $% " ($+

+ &( $3&& &($% 93 $2;3/ &(+* ( %

& '

( )

* '

$ !++ !," !$&&

(+ 1! !"1<% L6-B ?

I-?

B ?

B 6-B

B M*+& ( + !1!

1?>9(+ B&9(3 $(7(3 +7$&&

($( + !!?> (&

!?>9(3 $(7(3 + 6!!?>9( 3 $ (7(3 + +

!!?> +((%&(&( &$ 7$ && + !?> (&

-?> 6!?> ( (&( $(% -?> 0&%59 $ $$&&9 (C ( !$$ !!?>$(% 7$&&!$ !+&

( > ,

(+ 1! !"1<% .

(% !!?> , + 6!!?> , +((%&(& !!?> $(% !!?> /& !?> 7(&( 6!?> B& !1!

1?> +*.

")!)#<%

- + +&( 9($&&$ (+$+ 35&&$3 ($( 6@&( +$$+

(+$ % $&( F$ $ 35 + $ +

+&!6- !6- "6 1

(9 ',/*,..

! "

07:3 ( F$$(&:%?(

N? F$$((&(3