High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7545/2013disposed of

Naveen Kumar v. Presiding Officer And Others

2023-12-08Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger8 pages

" !

#$%$&

!%'( &(+#,#)$ -.

%/(($ 012%3 ......

('#'#)$(3 4(3,1, 3(,#&#$6 **#+(37 $&1,'3#%8 3#91$%8+12:%9)13 )13'7 #,%3 )'5(3,

......

(,;)$&($', < :

= =

3(,($'

=%'$%2 =#$657 &/)+%'(

=.0.

4(32%7 &/)+%'(

%;;8#+%$';('#'#)$(3.

3%/(($ 5%$&(3 )>%87 &&#'#)$%8 ..

%3>%$% 3(,;)$&($', ).

. . =

5#, %$ %;;8#+%'#)$ *#8(& 1$&(3

3(%& 3&(3

18(

3(,')3%'#)$ 2%#$

)'#+( %;;8#+%'#)$.

3%/(($ 5%$&(3 )>%87 &&#'#)$%8 ..

%3>%$% %++(;', $)'#+( 9(5%8* 3(,;)$&($', ).

,192#', 5( $) )9@(+'#)$ #* %;;8#+%'#)$ 3(,')3%'#)$ 2%#$

%88)?(&.

/#(?

%*)3(,%#& ,192#,,#)$7 %;;8#+%'#)$ %88)?(& 2%#$ 3(,')3(& #', )3#6#$%8 $129(3 ;),#'#)$ ,%2( '%A($ 9)%3& ')&%> #',(8* 5(%3#$6.

;;8#+%'#)$ %++)3&#$68> &#,;),(& )*.

('#'#)$(3

%/(($ 012%3 *#8(& 1$&(3 3'#+8(, )$,'#'1'#)$ $&#% #,,1%$+( $%'13( +(3'#)3%3# B1%,5#$6 ?%3& &%'(&

$$(C13( 7 ;%,,(& $&1,'3#%8 3#91$%8+12:%9)13 )13'7 #,%3

5(3(#$%*'(3 3(*(33(& <'5( 3#91$%8<7 ?5(3(9> 63%$'(& +)2;($,%'#)$

7 #$,'(%& 3(#$,'%'(2($'.

13'5(3 ;3%>(3 2%&( &#3(+'#$6 3(,;)$&($', 3(#$,'%'( 5#, ;3(/#)1, ?)3A;),'

+)$'#$1#'> ,(3/#+( *188 9%+A ?%6(, %8)$6?#'5 %88 +)$,(B1($'#%8 9($(*#',.

3#(*8>7 3%#,(& %$ #$&1,'3#%8 &#,;1'( ,(3/#$6 &(2%$& $)'#+( 1$&(3 $&1,'3#%8 !#,;1'(, +'7

5(3(#$%*'(3 3(*(33(& < +'< 1;)$ *%#813( +)$+#8#%'#)$ ;3)+((&#$6,7 &#,;1'( 3(*(33(& 1$&(3

%&@1&#+%'#)$.

+8%#2(& 5( %;;)#$'(&($6%6(& (8&%3 (**(+'

*3)2

. .

5( ?)3A(& ,1+5 198#+ (%8'5 =19 !#/#,#)$ ).

!#/#,#)$ ).

7 5#?%$#

3($%2(& 198#+ (%8'5 =19 !#/#,#)$7 %?%$# 05(3% '#88

(931%3>7 '5($

198#+ (%8'5 =19 !#/#,#)$ ).

5#?%$# '#88

(931%3>7 (3'%#$ %88(6%'#)$, 5%3%,,2($'

?(3( 2%&( %6%#$,'

=19 !#/#,#)$%8 **#+(3 ,'%'#$6 5( &(8#9(3%'(8> '3%$,*(33(& 198#+

(%8'5 =19 !#/#,#)$ %'

:)5%317 ?5#+5 A2, %?%> ?5(3( @)#$(&.

,'%'(& +%1,( 5#, '3%$,*(3 *3)2 5#?%$# :)5%31 )$8> +)2;(8 5#2 8(%/( ,(3/#+(, %'

5#, )?$.

+8%#2(& 5( 2%3A(& %9,($'

&(,;#'( 9(#$6 &1'> 5( ;%#& ?%6(, )$8> ;(3#)& *3)2 =(;'(29(37

)/(29(37

?%6(, ;(3#)& %3+57 ;3#87 161,'

!(+(29(37

?(3( ?#'55(8&.

,'%'(& *3)2

. 7 %88)?(& 3(,12( 5#, &1'#(,

'5(3(%*'(37 ,(3/#+(, ?(3( '(32#$%'(&.

+8%#2(& +)$'#$1)1,8> ?)3A(& *3)2

. .

. . 3(,;)$&($'!(;%3'2($'

*%88, ?#'5#$ %29#'

<#$&1,'3>< ;(3

+'.

+8%#2(& '5(3( 3(8%'#)$,5#;

(2;8)>(((2;8)>(3 9('?(($ ;('#'#)$(3 3(,;)$&($'

!(;%3'2($'.

,'%'(& @1$#)3, 5%/( 3('%#$(& ,(3/#+( %*'(3 %88(6(& &%'( '(32#$%'#)$ ,(3/#+(, ;('#'#)$(3.

?%,7 '5(3(*)3(7 ,'%'(& '(32#$%'#)$ ,(3/#+(, /#)8%'#)$ ;3)/#,#)$, =(+'#)$,

%2)1$', 1$*%#3 8%9)13 ;3%+'#+(.

,'%'(& ;),'

?)3A %,,#6$(& ;(32%$($'

$%'13( ,%2( ,'#88 (C#,'($+(7 5)?(/(37 3(,;)$&($'!(;%3'2($'

'(32(& +%,1%8 ?)3A(3.

++)3&#$68>7 #'

;3%>(& ($'#'8(& 3(#$,'%'(2($'

+)$'#$1#'> ,(3/#+( *188 9%+A ?%6(, %88 +)$,(B1($'#%8 9($(*#',.

%;;(%3, %$%6(2($'

&#& *#8( #', ?3#''($ ,'%'(2($'

&(,;#'( );;)3'1$#'#(, '5(3(*)3( #', &(*($+( ,'31+A )**7 /#&( )3&(3 &%'(& . . - 9(8)?.

;)$ +)$,#&(3#$6 2%'(3#%8(/#&($+( 3(+)3&7 3('13$(& *)88)?#$6 *#$&#$6,

! " # $ %& '

( ++)3&#$68>7 63%$'(& *)88)?#$6 3(8#(* )* ( + " + , "+

" "+

# $ %( -+ *$,.

+ / .

%*)3(2($'#)$(& +#3+12,'%$+(,7 *#8(& 9(*)3( '5#, %6%#$,'

#2;16$(& ?%3& &%'(&

$$(C13( .

5%/( 5(%3& 8(%3$(& +)1$,(8 3(,;(+'#/( ;%3'#(, 5%/( ;(31,(& ;%;(39))A '5(#3 %98( %,,#,'%$+(.

)$+(&(&8>7 %*)3(,%#& ?%3& &%'(&

$$(C13( #2;16$(& 3(,;)$&($'!(;%3'2($'.

*'(3 %361#$6 ,)2( '#2(7 8(%3$(& +)1$,(8 +)$*#$(, 5#, ;3%>(3 )$8> 3(6%3& ($5%$+(2($'

+)2;($,%'#)$ %?%3&(& ,192#''#$6 +)2;($,%'#)$ %?%3&(& 8)?(3 ,#&(.

$ )'5(3 5%$&7 8(%3$(& ='%'( +)1$,(8 %;;(%3#$6 3(,;)$&($', ).

);;),(& ;3%>(3 ($5%$+(2($'

+)2;($,%'#)$ ,192#''#$6 %?%3&(& +)2;($,%'#)$ @1,'#*#(& %++)3&#$68>7 ;3%>(3

&#,2#,,%8 2%&(.

)$<98( =1;3(2( 0#12 3 + 0+ + ,

= 7 5(8& 1$&(3 )4

, +

5 " + .

. . " 6 , + +

7 " ,

+ +

, " # $% 4 + +( ,8+ " +

+ "

-+ *

"+ * + "+4 +

+ 9+ +

# $%4 + +( ," ,

# +

" , + #:# ; "<",= #88,!+

, ++ + " +

8+ + , +

4 + + , " , , + " + >/

( ? ,*- "8 3 + @ # 7

=1;3(2( %,(,

7 %9)/(,'%'(& /#(?

%**#32(&.

5(8& 3(#$,'%'(2($'

318(7 #'

&(;($&, 1;)$ /%3#)1, +#3+12,'%$+(,7 8#A( $%'13( ?)3A7 2%$$(3 2('5)& %;;)#$'2($'7 8($6'5 ,(3/#+( ('+.

/#(?

3%'#) @1&62($',7

3(*(33(& %9)/(7 63%$'

+)2;($,%'#)$ #$,'(%& 3(#$,'%'(2($'

;3);(3 3(2(&>.

)$<98( ;(C ;8('5)3% +%,(, &#3(+'(& +)2;($,%'#)$ 8#(1 3(#$,'%'(2($'.

(*(3($+( +%$ 9( 2%&( A "1 ,@- + :B#88$'$, #*" A 1 +% !

4 +:B$#88'$, @(" ( ;+ :B #88=

%A#$6 $)'( *%+'

%;;)#$'(& (8&%3 3(,;)$&($'!(;%3'2($'

5(8& ?)3A(& 3(,;)$&($'!(;%3'2($'

*3)2

,(3/#+(, 5%& '(32#$%'(& /#)8%'#)$ ;3)/#,#)$,

+'7 +)1;8(& *%+'

3(,;)$&($'!(;%3'2($'

8%#& %$> +5%88($6( %*)3(,%#& ?%3& &%'(&

$$(C13( %8,) +)$,#&(3#$6 8#'#6%'#$6 3(,;)$&($'!(;%3'2($'

,#$+( D '5(3(*)3(7 %2 +)$,#&(3(& );#$#)$ +)2;($,%'#)$ %?%3&(& 8)?(3 ,#&(.

++)3&#$68>7 +)$,#&(3#$6 ')'%8#'> +#3+12,'%$+(,7 2> +)$,#&(3(& /#(?7 #$'(3(,'

@1,'#+( ?)18& 9( 2('

#* +)2;($,%'#)$ %?%3&(& ($5%$+(& *3)2

7 7 .

(,;)$&($'!(;%3'2($'

&#3(+'(& ;%>

($5%$+(& %2)1$'

+)2;($,%'#)$

%*'(3 %&@1,'#$6

7 7 #* %83(%&> ;%#&7 ?#'5#$ ;(3#)& '53(( 2)$'5, *3)2 &%'( 3(+(#;';3)&1+'#)$ +(3'#*#(& +);> '5#, )3&(3.

$)$;%>2($'

%*)3(,%#& %2)1$'

?#'5#$ ,'#;18%'(& ;(3#)&7

,5%88 9( ($'#'8(& +8%#2 ,#2;8( #$'(3(,'

3%'( E ;(3 %$$12 '#88 '#2( ,1+5 ;%>2($'

2%&(.

&#,;),(& %*)3(,'%'(& '(32,.

;($&#$6 %;;8#+%'#)$ ,7 #* %$>7 ,5%88 ,'%$& +8),(&.

,@A, 5('5(3 ,;(%A#$63(%,)$(&

"(,

) 5('5(3 3(;)3'%98( "(,

)