← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/455/2016dismissed

Aman Singh v. Haryana Power Generation Corp Ltd & ANR

2019-11-14Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi15 pages

  

  !"#"$"%""

""$ " & '

& ()'

$ **+ 



, "-.*/ ** 01 23 *4*5*-* 4 & '

 6

.1-.*/.** ** 01 23 *4*5*-* 4 &7'

, 

& ()'

$*8 ** 01 23 *4*5*-* 4 &'

6 

& ()'

9:*.** ** 01 23 *4*5*-* 4

 & '

6

& ()'

.1*:1-" ** 01 23 *4*5*-* 4 &'

6

& ()'

9.*/ ** 01 23 *4*5*-* 4 &;'

6;

& ()'

.*:1-.- ** 01 23 *4*5*-* 4 &6'

,;

 0*9282/* ** 01 23 *4*5*-* 4

 &,'

,; 

& ()'

: * ** 01 23 *4*5*-* 4 &

'

,;;

& ()'

"<:1- 1 ** 01 23 *4*5*-* 4 &

'

,;6

& ()'

9*.*/ ** 01 23 *4*5*-* 4 &

'





& ()'

:189*.*/ ** 01 23 *4*5*-* 4

& 7'



6

& ()'

:-*.*/ ** 01 23 *4*5*-* 4 & '



7

& ()'

."0*3* ** 01 23 *4*5*-* 4 & '



6,

& ()'

:*58.- ** 01 23 *4*5*-* 4 & '



, 

 .-.*/)8*< ** 01 23 *4*5*-* 4

 & ;'

 

 #*-8$=* ** 01 23 *4*5*-* 4 & 6'



7

& ()' ). 14 ** 01 23 *4*5*-* 4 & ,'





& ()'

"*8:1- 14 ** 01 23 *4*5*-* 4 &

'



 

& ()'

-< 14 ** 01 23 *4*5*-* 4

 &

'



,

;

!/*.*/ ** 01 23 *4*5*-* 4 &

'

 6,6

;

9*.*/ ** 01 23 *4*5*-* 4 

     

  

  ! 

"

%



 & '



"  

$

()' "*+"*+"*+" *+,"*-,"*-,"*-,,"*-,+ "****"**"*+"*+-" *-*"**"*-*"*

()' -"*, & # . / 



"  

$

()' *"**"*

*" *% 0





"  

$

()' +"*

+-+"*,% >>>  

 !"

 1!

22  

 

"

, / 3

 /

3

"



 

2 45

"

 

"

6  #5#

"

   "

 /

3

.

"2()'"*  7 3

 

/

3

/!

%

53   

 

"#2

(

8

(

88#

  

"0 !

/5    



95



%

/ 

3

:

   (

3! 

 3!  3

  #2

    /

 "



5   /

3

! 

 ! ## /   #

"

;



;< 5

 ;

;< 5

;

 

  #

%    5#     /!  2

  # !   " 

#

%

95

 2#! 

/ #2

# "   

%  3!  ! 5 / 3

2 /

"

#2

3 #

 <

   

  7 / ""

()'"*  

5    

##

5

;

 !

-+*

  0 !

 ; 

!  1  

 

 0 !

  

 (#

 =

   

 

 #2  

 5

 ;

8   

 

 ;

 

  

 ;< 5

;

 *-+-**-**,

*,*** # 

 !>   

 /  3     

3!"  5 



 #2  

 5

  ;

    **,-++   0 

 "5 #2



;

 +*--



;< 5

;

    -*** 

   

 ;< 5

  ;

  

***,

3  

"#2

"#

 

+ 

5     #  #$%

 # &

'

 #( # ) # '

#$ #  #$*##$$+!   , 

#)-

 # )# '

#$ # 2

3$% 

$ (% &>

; ,*-+* $% 2

;8 *-+- &>

6

)? *-,- 2

; **-**, 2

;$)?(% *+-+ 2

;; *,*** 2

;$: 35 % +*-+ 2

;8 **,-++ 2

; +*--  2

@;'

***,  = 5

"

% 35

  



"

5"    5 (



/ 

"0 !

"#2

 (

8

(

88#

"

;< 5

 

;< 5

 ;

 (

88

;< 5

 ;

(

8#

  " 3

"

#2

  (

8 

  (

88 #

    

   52   /!

3

3/

" 



!  

   " 

#2

/

 /  <

   

  52 



! 

 = 5

"

"5

35

  /

"#2

 <

   

  52 /  <

 

%



 



 

  =   5

  "    #

%  "5    35

#2

" 

  /

" 

 /

5## " 352

 #  

 5#  9532

*#

/! (

1 "

(5

()' "*

 

./ 0

#$)1#



- $

<5 % 

  5

"

%

"  #2

" 

  / 

 #2

%  

 "

2 /

"

#2

. #

3



 9532

"0 A/  5# 2 (5 "

.  1#

0  

#$%*./1#

  2333 4"

  256

 

 (

3!(



      

3!  

3        

 3

#2

# "      2?   (

3!(

/ 2 



95

  

3!

  "



!

#5#"

? # ! 45

  

3!95

 , = 5

"  

"



2"

%

 3   #2

 /

3

 

  /

" 

   

5 

/  

/!  

= 5

"

  

 

"5

  

/

" 

/ 

(

8

(

88#

"

!

= 5

"  

"5

 /

"#2

(

8

(

88#

/!3

3/

" 



 3!3

 

 = 5

"

. #

3



 "

 #2

3

 

   3!3



2   



/!  

/!#

3 # .

3 

**,$

<5 %   1!      

  **,  $

<5  %    

 "

* #2

" 



;

/

3 

 #2

 #

"

;< 5

 ;

;< 5

 ;

 /



 



 

   **

5#  

"



  

  / "  3

"#2

"

;< 5

 ;

;< 5

 ;



(

8#

 + 

%   

3    

**, $

<5 %/!

3

  35

53

 

"#2



;

/ 

3 



"  

  

 

"#2

" 

  52



;

 

"#2

"#

%

#

"5  #2



;< 5

 ;

;< 5

 ;

 /



/5  "

/



    <

       

   52  

  .

3  

#2   #

     /



    "  

  "

/

  /



"2 

#

%

 



 

  

 "

/

 65  

/ 

 / ""

#

%

 

**,$

<5 %



3

/

"2 

/

 /

2



 <

 /

  <

   

  52 

%  /

3



  3 - = 5

"  

#

 #!

/ "

 

  

  #!  !"

 

()'

 "*

/  5""

" 

3 

/ /5   3  "   

 * 8    5

"

 3

53   

/ 

    #

  !45

" 

 

"

(5

/

/  3!

<

 

 2#!   /

" 



/ 





 2

. 22

/!



/  

/!

5#  

 

"

5    #

 

2"

%

 #2

" 



 /  <

 

    #

 "  

 ;

  

 ;< 5

  ;

 

;< 5

  ;

     /

 "   

 

 

!   

9532

"

(5

./ 

 +  *7"  :

  #

  

 

3

5 



 /

"

#2

 <

   



3  2

.  ( 

3 2

. 

 2

"   2#!  >  

. 

/  

 53

2 

 /

3#

5 /!

% 3

 

/ 

/!

% >    #2

  <

   



/

 "   

 

 



 

  

  #2



;

/  



5/

 

"

#2

"

%3

 "

%   3  <

  65       #2

 "    

   52  

 

;< 5

  ;

 

  ;< 5

  ;

    /  2# !





   "   3

 

/

3

/!

#

%

95

# 

/ 3 #2



;< 5

 ;

;< 5

 ;

# "   

$ %/!  3!3

3  /

" 

 

 "

 ! 3

 "

%

 3   #2

3



5/

!"5



"#2

"  



"2 

# 

"#

%  = 5

"

% 35

53

/

"#2

 /



"2  52 /5

   "

/

 

9! 

.

3  #2 #

  /



"2 2



2"

%"

3#2

 ""  "2  



3

2  5/

  7 

2"#2

3

""

/

 

"" 

# 

 7 #

%   

#5

3

 /

"

#2

 <

   

 !



 >    3#2

 <

   

 !



2 

/ 3

%8 /

 "

!#2

%" 3 

.45

"3

"

  /

 " 

  #2

 

  8   "

52

"



  5 "

! 

 !    

  !

  * 

 

   

    /

 "

#2

 





"

/

5

 /



"2   2#! /!  

  !

 3  " 

   . #  "

 /

35  <

 /

"#2

#

%

 

"

/

'"

5 

/ "5

 



3  "

/

"2  2#!  53  /

"#2

   !/





  <

   3!  

 7  " 

#

%# ! 

 3 #2



;< 5

;

;< 5

 ;





"

/

!  35

 "

/

     "2  



3  /

"#2

  " 

 ! 



/ 

 "

 52

 "

#



  "

 #

 # ! "

$ %



   /

"#2

 

3

2 /

"#2

% 8

!

3

 



/!  2

/

"#2

 3

 

 3



! 

>  

%  "  

/

"#2

5  / 3

 

/! 

!  "   

 

2  /

 

 /  # !   /!   2 

%   /

3



2 /

 

%

# !

/

"#2

 3!3

 

  52  5 / 



/5

/



!

5/  <

   2

  = 5

"

%"5 35

 

**,$

<5 %

/

/

2





"



/ 3

/!

(5  8 "

/!   

**,$ <5 %

/

3 2#53 /!

%

%   3



!  

    

   52  

 / 3

 #2

    #

 "



;



5/

 

"#2

"

#

%:

 3

 "

%

#2

 3!  3     

   52  

 /    

  /! 

2#53   

#2

 

"

5" 

 /



/! 2#53  65  #

%

 3 

 

/

 

   

**,$

<5 %  /

<

       

   52   5

3 

 

2  /!  3

#2

 #

"

;



;< 5

 ;

 ;< 5

  ;

/!

! "  

 /



 82#53      

  **, 

  !  

3  # 95      

 !

 2#! 

33  

 

  3 

2  , = 5

"

% 35

%

 2 .

3 #

   !

*/5  /

"2  

 !



"

3"

 + 2!#

#

%2    



/!

/

3

   3

!?

 2

. 



22

/!3

3#2

 

  /

"



  !

   

"!

3  2

. 

5

!"



/ 

2 



 !   3

"/

%1

<

 

 2#! 

 

! 5 

 #

# "

  / 



  /  <

    8



25

# #

3

 3

!

2# 2

/  -  "

 52

 "  

35

2  5

"3

"/

% 45

" 

  52

 #  "  #2

 #

"

;

 

 ;< 5

  ;

 

  ;< 5

  ;

 

#2

 

"

5" 

 !



/!  

 :

5

! 



 =-? @

, &".)". .'

  !

$