Ishwar Chand v. Suresh Kumar & ORS.
!"#
$$%% &"' '" (')" "
$ *"
"
+" ,,"!%-. " $$%%
"
# / 0%-. " "$ 1
/"%3- " $% '" (')"- 4(')" 5" , % , -%% +"$% , )-" 6!+ "- 7 %7 "-"('"'8 " 5"', ', ' %(')" 9 , !"# 1 )8 ,$ 534) ""."3 """ -:
;! "<=>$"
')
$" $% -." ?
- 3 $' 1 ' %(')" $
$ 1 =:=- @" 1 = ! )'
$% %) 6!- "('"'8 " ) %3" -
;" $"?
?- "" " ! -:
;$") A " !"4 , $1 =:= $% %! "', " $1 =:=!
53 $% %% "* / !
$% ! $% A $ !%3 "' $% ! .""1 =:?
:
='53 '
$%#))-6! "" "' $!"- ""$". !
" # $%&' & ' -()*+" $$%5%A $% " ""!
" '$"$"3-! " 1 "" 'B","A 1 '5% $ 1 ! ' $% A 1 $" ) $" $ -! ) -:
;A $% " %"." )'
! "<=> $"
')") 1 A 3 ".%,% '
"
7" "*"$"3'$ - ! !'%3".53 )A 1 "$%3
%) , )%5!
" '$"$"3%%, ,
$'" . % 1 ; :
" , $% -' %'$53 1
",') "%'$"$"3-' ) .C'", $% A %%,. " 1 ! "!
" " $ ' $"$"3- "" ! )$ % )A 1 5) %- "" $ 1 ." '$"$"3%%,%-'
' "D "$"
7 $% "C' ) "
%) ." $ $5' 3"' ' - 3!" " % '
5 ,$' -5 $$" % !" ) !" ) '5) 53 1 - 8 '$."'%,%54 ! "," %' $% % 'A) 5%3 , ' " $% 5" , ' 3!"$$53 "!
'")% , 'A'" ")" '! $"$"%3.%'" $'"$ #'"
)"-' % $"E5"'"3-: "" "
"! - "" %5% $3 " A 1 - ! $ $ % E5"'"3:-! !$' $ $53 "
? $% +"$% , ' $"3"
)% '
!" ) %53 1 - %"8'$."'%,%54 , ' 5 %53 $% %%' ! 1
)"- !" , !
"
$ $ 1 =: $% !%% 1 . "
"! A " - 8 5"') -! 5 " %!'%", !" , A 1 !F"+"$% , - " $% " ' $% A $!
53 ) :B
5'
",. 53 $% "!" ,A $% ! $% $" B ,$ $A $% . "
! $!
53 1 A $1 =:= $ $$". 3A $ $ 5" , 1 =:A 1 , $%
") '
$%#))-6! !
" )53) ","%
:A ! $% " "!
" " $ $ 1 =:- C' $3 , 3" ) " '! ) 5%A ', $% ".
: 5'!'%3"$% " ,' - . ", '$"$"353!3.%#'""$ ".'"
53 #'"%"
'59', #% )" $%! '53 ". '"
$$% "$% )%3+"$% , ' , ") ," -' $"3")% '
7 $% % "$% "." , %%, !" ) ! """ , .") $%
$% , $"-%%! ,'!" ")
@ "." ?
$1 =:=@" 1 ='! )'
$%%)6!!%' 53$% .'" ) %3" -
;G **
@ " "' $ C' !)$%
?
:
= "" $ B)$ ") $". +"3 H"5 # "% I. - G **
@ " 1 '5% $ 1 ! ' $% G **
?
@ " 1 %$3 " $
!
)'
, -:
;G **
:
@ ". ?
3 5 ") G **
@ "$% . %' % ) $" ' . "," % :
1 !
"' $G *
@ "$% . ' G *
= @ "$% . ) #'"! % '$$""' )"%") #'"G *
@ " ' %%'. "' 5! $% 1 G *
@ "' 5 $"$"%3.%'" $'"$ #'" 4'" G *
@ " ' % ".%' 1 %$%H;:#*#G *
%
/ $"!""C'$$"' % ".
" " , %"
'
%" $"- "% #'"'1 .'" $% -'1
.'" $% -'1 - =, - '1 .'" $% -'1 ? .'" $% -'1 : .'" $% -'1
, '% %3 '!"! " , ." . $ $1 =:= $% ! $" ) '" " 1 !"$3""" -:
; ! "< >$"
') 7 .4',) " ?
E% ,,,".53 4',) "- 1 % $$% #'""9',- ('"'8 "- ! ! , %"
% " 9',- ('"'8 " +!."- %"
% " 9',- ('"'8 ".4',) " =
) $$%'$ % , 4',) "$53 "% #'"! %)3 , " "") >>$"
')
/ ,! 4',) "$ #'"5%!- 1 % $" ",'%" $$% 5" #'"- ! ! ' "$ ;$% 1 .$$" "', '
%
. "%"
'
%" $"5, , "', ""
7 #'"5%! %, "') %3D , . 5"', %535 $" .'
)" $% ."
= 1 !
" $ 5 "4 7 "% #'" 5". " ?
IB * B' 53 +"$% , - " $% .'" 1 ' %(')"!'%3$". ) ""5" ") ""$ , " )'
$%"""% ,' %(')"5 $ $'" "'%3$".53*@ '" "# -# "- '
$%#)) E'" ")"") $"'%"," %= =:IB * ""IB *@;/ $% IB *@;$".53*@936%5 ) 3*@:+"$% , - "$% -)' $ C' ! "' 3" ", , $% ")#-6! ?
:
=-) , "53 $ C' ! "'! 3" 5 ,%'-! B)$") $". +"3 H"5
# "% I. - 7 ".% %"
'
%" 1 ! "," $ C' .%5 ' 7 C' 5 ! " $ $5% , , $% " $ " $ 5% , , )! ! $% . "
7 "% #'" % , ! ' """ ) 3*@ '" "(')"-# "-#- 5-! ) !
$1 =:= =:=" !
" $ $% $ 1 =:!
53+"$% , - " $% $ 1 =: !
" $ 1 -! !"%"
)9,)% )*% *@?9,)-#%"8-$'3 #)) " $". C'"3"$" '53 #7-('"'8 " 7 "%#'" """ ) 3 *@:+"$% , "%" $ $'! . ,)'
$% 1 =:= 3" - , )" $ ' )!'
8 "1 :
$"
". ' ""- 8 " 1 : !
" $ *'
45 @8 /" " ) 3@ - 5 , -# ')"
#%"8-H+&/1'5. -6!-! B) 53 5 ) + 5"', %$" , %"3
$ , = ?-
!"% .'" !"# -! $ '"3
"," 5"', )" )% +$".%"3 5%%IB IB @) (')"- '% - @, '") $") $ "
$") ",'%"%3 8 !, )'") $". " $!
$53 !"
# + $". "$ " ' 53 $") "," IB ? IB :
@? ) # -," #%"8 $ .%
: !" # $'" ' $"$"3 ") 9,)% )*% @ , )-') @""-6! $". "," % $!" "
3 IB :: IB :-"$.%3 @9,)% , . " 1 "%" 3!"!
" $
C' ' 8 "1 .","% :-!% !"# + ) *% 5)!
" $ C' 5 4',) " $ #.% ' 1 ; 3 ." $ $
C' !"# @ $%0'$ $ !"# $ $ C' ", ") 5,
, ' %(')" ."") $ ) @&*"8 $". "$IB :IB '53'
$%#)) $ ,% 53 1 !"# #$3 ""IB $% IB - '"3 )%5 "$IB $". "" @= ! (')"-+'7B#%"8-$". 'B"$ 5%%IB ?IB = , $"
"" :- $1 =:!" """) ) 9,)% , )*% ) !"# + $".$3) "," ","IB := IB == +'" " )'
$% ')5" $ ."
") =:=-" "=: ' 8 "1
@ " !" " ,%3 "$%% 53 '
%" $% 7 ,""53%"
"% #'"",. $"1 = 4',) -! ""3 "" "5 ,"$"''
"
!
"
#
$%
#
& '
( )
'
' $% #
#
*+
#
#
#
#
" ##
& '
)
'
,
!
"#
# *$-
,
!
& '
'
#
% #
& '
,
!
*$
* #
#
'
& '
,
!
'
.
*" #
*
#
'
/
01
!-
#
"
' #
2 '
%
# "
% !
#
) ,'
" 3 )
'"
!
),'
'
4
3
)
' *"
#
!
#
1
$
#
0
'
' %
% '
' -
"
'
' #
'
0
'
#
'
#
0
'"
%0
'
# #
#2"
' "
#
# #
-
#
#
/5
'
5
/ '
#
5
/ '
,67
,67 %
5
/ '
/ !
"4 !
2
) ,
" #
/58
#
- 5
"
#
' 7
- 5
#
5
/ '
"9-,
'
:
.
..: # # !
'
'
#
# #
? 9 ## ' !7%
# '
'
- 5
; #
'
'
#
'
- !67%
5
/ '
" 12
'
'
- -
' 7
'
# 7
1 $; ,
#
#
' $%
- #
) 1
- 5
"
9
#'
- 5
'
'7-
' 7
7
*$<!
2
#
) 6
2
- 5
,
2"
'
#2
23
'
- 5
3
'
#
: !
' $%3
#
' $% '-
'
#/59 "
# *
*$
# - #
3 !
!:"
' =%!
# # #
1
$" *" #
1 $$
#"
'
#
!
#
#
#
# #
# 5 3 #"
# '
7 E"$$%%#'"%"
%" 9',-('"'8 "! ,") ! ' ,,. 53 "%#'" 3" '$ ) " 4',) "$53 "%#'"!"")!
) " "") >>
@ ' '"" ,5 , "-
3" "! 7 4',) '"
") 3%%,%3" ")3 7 ,"" " %3 5 ")$"."""'%)$$" .
)35) " '" , $ 3 $$%-6%#)) "!$$ . $ '5) "$"% ,! $%
/' C' " "$"."" ,""53 #'"5%!
5. '535 $" 7 ." ,. 53 #'"5%!
55"' ' )
"
6"
'
% " $$%% """ 4',) %
$53#" / #'" 1
'$$" $"3" " )" 5"" 5""' /' 5. ' 53 $"- #'"5%! ."" '"" ,
7 " 3' ," ""3')" ,
7 4',) "$535 #'" 5%! " !%% " - 5 '$ $"$" $$"% $$" . "" "$" %!
7 "
%%,%3 " ")3 "
7 " $$%% #'"
"' " "") >> 7 ""%3
E , )" $" $$%- ) )!
,- /"4 ./# /##0 #$102#3& 4 #01 ./# /##2 !# #01