High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4007/2012disposed of

Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Kamla Devi And ORS.

2019-07-19Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh7 pages

!"#

$% "!!

!" #$ %

"

& '%

(

)*! +#$ '

,

- ', #$ " . /

" ./.123

$% "!!&/ '0 - ,'' " ' $

4!

3

"

5& '

-5!

'#

', ' / # 6 -5!

'60 ,5& " !

$*! +

)!! 5&7

$!'

8"'

1 1 .

1

$5 '5& '

"

& ( /

6

"

&60, .123 3 '5&* '

" 9!

$*! +

12 35& )!7

'

'(()*'((+,-(.- !

'

"

&,!' '& ! !$$ " !5 44!'& $'

4

"'&

!#

"

& ' $$&4 ! "

& " '

'& # 8 .

!

'

"

&,!' -5!

' '! 4"

' "!,4 $'

"'& " .

" .3

"

& " .3 '%

"

$ !

"'

,5& 5' 4$'

"'&% 4! , : ! 4$'5 4. ;

2<3 " 45 -5!

4" &5'4 !""'& 4"

!'

$ 4'

"

!#

"

& "$

""!

& 8 & $ , 4 $ '& , !

4'&#

"

& ' $ 4 $& ! "

& " '

% # 4!

"

&$ !" ! '' 4!" !""'&" '$

!

8 =>

- " 5 ' , " $ +'

'&# $ 4 $' " 45 -5!

5 !"$ --5!

' !.3# ! ! " # $ %

& % & ' %% ( ) *+, --5!

'# "

3 # ' " .3 " .

$ 8 5 4

!

'" 5 -5!

',4 ! !"

$ 4' " . % !!

#-5!

' 5!

, $ " . 3 $# "!,4 $'

"'&5, !

! %

4 "

& "! 5'&#$

! 4$' " 45 -5!

'-

"

&"'

"& '4 =>

" '"=>

3-''

# '' 4! 5&$

, 4$', 4$' ' 4

" &5'4 !""'& 4"

!'

$ 4' "5& $

" $'

!# & 4

""!

&8

&$ # 5 $,

" 4 $ 4' ' "5&, $ '

, ""'&$' "!5'"'

!'

'&# 4 -5!

' !.3

! % $,

5$# ! $'

"'& ! 4 $! !- 5 4# 4 -5!

' !.3

, $! %

"

&

! '''

&#%

"

'' $4& $& ! "

& " '

$, , ! 5 # '

"

'& '',

+/0,-(.0 --5!

?# 2## '!

'&

2#: ! "

'>"

:3 !'"'

( " &

?##: -

"

'

2#: ( !

#: (

#: -"' '

'& $*! + , #:!

*! / @0- >

> "

# , 5>

"! ! => @:

=> @:A > !

& ?

1--5!

'' 5& 4 4 >! ,' 4 - 8 4 '

> !

& 1 ' 5& , 5! " # #?:#

# #?:"

!- , 5 1 ?# , 1 1

1# #, '

& 4 ! -'

''5 ' !!""BC !'"' ""'

- ""' " '5&,,# ,

!4 5'! "

'

>" ,!' 5 : !# ' " &

?##2222/ 2#3#3: # #?> 2D ?#

# :/C

0E 2#32#12 2:/ :! 00 ;

$

' # '

'' 5 '

#/ # ' !# 2# 9!

'

!

'>" 0# '4 )!4 7 65' +!"!

! "#$ % &"

& ' %

! "# $ %& $, 5$# '" ?##2222:

' !

#2 #2222: / ?##2222 E ?# 2#0# "

5', B2C"

! " ''

'F $, , ! 5 # '

?

"

'& '',

+/',-(.0 --5!

1### '!

C 5'&B #2

#2#: " C 5'&

! 4

##: -

"

!!>" 2#: .!

2#:

4

2#: '>"

3##: !

' ""''

,!' -5!

'

'', '5! !

3##:, '

$ '! '5''"!

"$ 3##3 : !#

'! #3 :/3##3 3##0 '',

!

'>" $ G8 / @30# )! ! C 5'&7,!'" )!

" , '8! 45 85 - ' $ ,4 $

)!- 8 4 '! !5&+ 7 &

# > 4 !, 4# $ 3#:" - )!, 4 5 8 32 & ' ! 4'&# !!"",!'5BC

!'"' 2!# !!' !

5'& '!'

#3 #: / ?#??#: 3# >

> 2 D

#??#:/C 00-'

''5 ' ##: , ' ' - 8 4 $ ! C

5'&#,!' $

!4!' - $ '! $

3#:"

5&

""'& 4!'"' 2#'

2##: $

" '', 5& -5!

' "

! 4#

"

!!>" # !

! #2#: " 5'&

2#:

4,!'5 )!! " '',!

, $, 5$# '" #?#3 : /#3 #D ##D ##D2#D2#D2##D3##3

!

#?#3 :/ #?#3 1##0#"

5', B2C "

! " '' 'F =>" ! 2#:# 4

' !

'' 5 $ >"

! 4 ''5"

5' '

'

''5 ', , ! 2#: ,

2#: >"& & 4 4 # '"

'& '',

1

$% "!!2 34

A5

@" 8 4: H:. @" 5' H:.