High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4636/2016dismissed

Bindu Kaushal v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2016-08-17Mr. Justice Inderjit Singh9 pages

!"#!$%#& '(

$!$ (#(' !*#+# (%'

,'$- '($

'$'(.

/ ,"/#& 01'

23#('4 (% / "!& ''-%' #1 23#('

/ 5'(% 1 &61!*#+ '( .

! "#!$%#& 4#$ #-- (' +8 4#8

'3(

'3 (9'(#$5/3(

# 3( !' (4 0#$$!3% !-( :

%' #&$ 4 0' (%' #& # '#

9 :

; (

'# 1(%'-'( 4#$#-- (' +84#8

!*#+5'#&(%'

3'$#$/3( :

# $ 3'(%'$%' 3( <(%'

#+# #

= 2'

(8 5'#&(% 3 '3'$1 #

0( & '#--& # 9 $$ ( />/>6 -&9#3!

$'$ %'

-'( #--& (%'$#9'! '

?@!(## #--'# (%'('$(1 4% 3% 4#$ 3 !3('

%' -'( @!#&

' (%'

'A#9 #( # $'3!

#0%'

'# 1(%'-'( #--&

! '

?@!(#

#--& 4#$ !&8 4# ' +8 /1#<

((%'

'3( 5'#&(%'

3'$1!*#++!((%'

$#9'4#$ '3& ' 2 #('

(%'< ! (%#( (%'

3'$ ' +8(%'-'( 8##5'#&(%'-# (9'(3#( (+'(#0' (3$ #( #('

$(%'$!+*'3(9#(('

3%#&&'<' (%'

- '$'(4

(-'( B'# ' $'

3!$'& 3(' $(%#(%# (%'

3'$ ' +8(%'-'( 5'#&(%'-# (9'(15# 8##+'

#-- (9'( !*#++84#8 +''3$ ' 1(%'-'(

4!& %#2' !&

&&' (%'(%'

3 $ - '$3

+' ! '

?@!(# B'# ' $'

3!$'& (%'

3(' $(%#( '$- '(.'-# (9'(%#$ < #(' ! '

?@!(#($ &# &8$ (!#(' '9-&8''$1#9'&81

%# #( %!$%# # )

6# < # #$ $!3% (%' #3(

'$- '(.'-# (9'( ( < #( < ( (%' -'( +'

#( 81# + 81!

'#$#+&' $& #+&'(+'$'(#$ ' B'# $'

3!$'&#&$3(' $(%#((%'3( 2'

$8$ &# ((%'- '$'(3#$'

%#$#& '# 8+''$'((&' +8(% $!

(%'*! <9'( 3#$'

!"#$%&#$#' ( )$*$ + '&

14%'

1 %#$+''%'& (%#(- '2 !$ #&$'

8##62'

%#$(+'3!(' &# 2 '4%#$#&$+''(#0' #(%'

*! <9'( (&' #$!, -.

+'.

/ %&#$#' ( )$*$ + '& :

1 '3 '

%' 3#$' $@!# '&832'

' +8# '$# (4*! <9'($# $%' $'( (&' ! '

?@!(#$-'

(%''& < + (83

#1(%'3# #('$4%4'

' (39-&'('

2'8'# $ $'

3'1!(

4% 3%1(48'# $$%!& +' 9$(

3!&(# '## (% ''8'# $$'

$%!& +'

3!&(# '#$%'-'( %# ' $'

#& '#

9 :

; ( :

# 4#$ '& < +&' ! '

? @!(# B'# ' $'

3!$'&%#$#&$ '& ' !-(%'*! <9'( 5C+&'(%'

-'A!

(%'3#$' $+ $0$ %&

( +.$ :,

:1 $!-- % $3('( $ B'# ' 3!$'& '$- '(.(#('--$'$(%'$!+9 $$ $ 9# '+8&'# ' 3!$'& # 3(' $(%#(#$-'

9$ # 3 $ (%'#-- (9'(&'(('

1(%'-'( 4#$('( (&'

#8+''

- '2 !$$'

3' 8##1%'3'1(%' '@!'$(

< #( 4#$

<%(&8 '*'3(' +8< <# '#$'

< %'-'( %#$ 4 0' #$/'

3#&

99!

(8 5'#&(%'( '1 %#4# <# %$ 3':

14% 3% $#3#('< 8DD$(#( 1 4%'

'#$1$%' $

' (39-&'('$ A8'# $ #&$'

3#('< 8EC $(#( +'

<'& < +&' ! '

?@!(# # 9 $$ (6 3!

$' %'-'( 4#$- +#( #-'

(48'# $# 39-&'( - +#( -'

$ 9# #( 8 3$

< %'

( # 9 $$ 63!

$'%'-'( 4#$('& < +&' #$$%'%# ('2'39-&'(' %'

- +#( -'

B'# ' 3!$'& #&$$!+9 ($(%#(

( (&' #$$.1

+%& #$#' ( )$*$ +$

' '3 '

1 (4#$%'& +8(% !

((%#( 3#$'(%'-'( 4#$#-- (' +8(

95# 8### < 2'

'$%#-- (9'( !*#+14#$( ! '( (&' (#8 +''

(%'- '2 !$$'

8##<# $((%'

'$# '3 1B;

4#$

&' +8(%'-'( +!((%'

$#9'4#$#&$ $$' :

;B'# ' (#('3!$'&#&$$!+9 ($

(%#(' #2''("#!

14%4#$#-- (' #$,!

#&/'

3#&

#&$#--& $(6 # !#('3!

$'! '

?@!(## #--'# (%'

('$(

# 4#$-&#3' #(9'

(

'# $%'#--&

+!((%'$#9'4#$(< #(' (%'

!'(.

&& <(%'3 #&$'

3'! '

?@!(##33!( .< #( 1$%'

#-- #3%' (% $!

(+84#8

+!((%'$#9'

4#$ $$' ;

+8%& <(%#(3'(%'-'( '$(

&&(%'- '$3

+' '& < + (83

## '$(%#2' ('$'

1$%'%# &'<#&

<%((3&# 9 $$!#3' B'# ' 3!$'&

'$- '(.(#('#&$$!+9 ($(%#(*! <9'( 5C+&'(%'-'A!

$+ 0$ &2$&'3&!"$4 '& ' !-+8&'# ' 3!$'& (%'

-'( $(#--& 3#+&'0''- < 2 '4(%' #(' *

< (%'

-'( 5'# (%'# <!9'($# 2#3' +8&'# ' $'

3!$'&

#$4'&&#$&'# ' (#('3!$'&# %#2'#&$-'

!$' (%'

9-!<' # (%'

3!9'($#2# &#+&'(%'

&' 9 ((' &81(%'-'( 4#$#-- (' #$/3(

!*#++84#8 #$

#&&8$%'4#$#-- (' +84#8

'3(

'3 (9'(#$ 5/ 3(

( $ ( $-!(' (%#( (%'

-'( ' $'

# #&# '#

9 :

;( :

#-- (9'(+84#8 !*#+1(%'-'( $!+9 (('

##--& # 9 $$ (/>/>6 -&9#!

$'$! '

@!(## $%'@!#&

' (%'('$(+8$'3!

< -$ %'

'# $%'

#--& ! '

?@!(#9'#( /3( $+!((%' '@!'$( 4#$ '3& ' 2 #('

(%'< ! (%#(%'

#&# '# 8##3#(+'3$ ' %'$(#

; (%' '$- '(.(#(' $ (%#( #$ -'

9$ # 3 $ (%'

#-- (9'(&'(('

1(%'-'( 3#(+'< #(' #8+''

(#$ (4#$ 3&'# &89'( ' (%'#-- (9'(&'(('

(%#($%'4 &&(+'< 2'#8 +''

-#$($'

8###9'3( 2'

$84#$ (%'

' $.1

+&2$&'3&!"$4 4%'

1 (4#$+$'

2' #$ ! '

F(%'& <%( (%' '

< 2' (%',!&'$1 #--# '( (%#( (%' 62'

9'( '9-&8''$ # 62'

3'4!& 9'##'9-&8'' (%'62'

9'( !*#+ # $'

3' (%'62'

9'( !*#+!&'$$$-'3

3#&&8 $# (%'

$''

!$#& ,!&'&'#2'$9#'

!+( (%#((%'$#9' $#--& 3#+&'(!*#+62'

9'('9-&8''$ &84% 3%%#$+'' (%'

' (+' '# (%'3('A(

4% 3%-& 38 $( !3( $>&'(('

#(' ;

9#0'$ #--& 3#+&'(('A-# $(%'#--& 3#+ (8 (%',!&'$(&8 ((%'!*#+62'

9'(9-&8''$1+!(((%$''9-&8''$ 4%4'

# ''9-&8''$ #+ 8 3 - #(' ( 4% 3% $4%&&8 $!+$(#( #&&84' +8(%'62'

9'(#$ #--# '(

9-# #.; (%'$# &'(('

% $-& 38&'(('

(%'

'1 3#( +' 'A(' ' ( # '9-&8'' 4% 4#$ $(4% &'#'9-&8'' 8##/'

'&8+'3#!$'

%#$+''#-- (' ! '

(%'(#(!( 8,!&'$+8 4#8 ( 1 4% 3% 4!& < 2' &'<#& $#3( (8 ( $!3% #-- (9'(1+!((% $ '$('( (&'%'

((%'-#8- ('3( # (%'$'

3'+''

($4% 3%$%'%# '# ' 4% &'4 <

(%'(#(' 8##19 '$4%'(%'

#-- (9'(

#('

'A!

'.3&'# &8$-'3

'$(%'-#8$3#&'

#&$(# -#84% 3%-'( 4!& +''( (&' ( %'#-- (9'( 4#$#

'$%'#$ $#--# '(

9(%'&#!$'$ # (%'$#

#-- (9'( 4%'

- +#( -'

'$% 9'

3#& 3'

3#(' # 2'

3 !3(# #('3' '($4'

'(+'#<# '

'$% '( %#2 <#33'-(' (%'

1#$ 9# '(%'

3#(143&# 9(%'+''

- '2 !$$'

3'1

' +8%'

8##%' '& #3'-&#3'

!-(%'-& 38 '3 #(' ;

'A!

'.;+8 -#8- ('3( # (%'

+''

($ $ %'&- ((%'-'( #$(%'$#9' $(#--& 3#+&'(%'

3#$' 2 '4 (%'#+2'1

<9'

(%'- '$'(4

-'( 1(%'$#9'$(# $ $$' G %'# '$# '3 4#$3%#&&'<' +84#8

<B ;

+!((%'$#9'4#$#&$ $$' %' '&'2#(-

(%'*! <9'( $ '- !3' #$! '

B <&'H! <'%'& (%#((%'$' $( !3( $# '#'A-&##( (,!&' - 2 $+'&4,!&'+ (%'!*#+ '

3' ,!&'$ '

(%'

,!&' (%' $( !3( $ #('

;

'(%'('

9I62'

9'(D5'3'1 '& #3'4#$ -&#3' (%' '

(%'('

9I62'

9'(D#$< 2'

%#-('

(%'!*#+ &'

3'$,!&'$$-'

,!&' 1 (%'('

9I62'

9'(D9'#$(%'!*#+62'

9'( (%'

$( #( 2' '-# (9'( %'

'+81 (%' B <&' H! <'

33&! ' (%#( (%'& <%( (%' '

< 2' (%'!*#+ &'

3',!&'$162'

9'('9-&8''$# 62'

3'4!& 9'##'9-&8'' (%'62'

9'( !*#+ # $'

3' (%'62'

9'( !*#+ '$-'3( 2'&8,!&' (%' !*#+ & '

3' ,!&'$ $ #--& 3#+&' ( !*#+ 62'

9'( '9-&8''$ &8 %' $( !3( $ #('

;

'A-# (%'#--& 3#+ (8 (%',!&'(&8((%'

!*#+62'

9'('9-&8''+!(#&$(%$''9-&8''$14% 4'

# ''9-&8''$ #+ 84%'(%'

3 - #(' (1 4% 3% $4%&&8 $!+$(#( #&&84' +8(%'62'

9'(#$ 3&'#

9-# #; (%' $( !3( $% $&'(('

3#(+'

'A(' ' (#'9-&8''14%4#$'# #'9-&8'' (%'

(#(' 8##/'

'&8+'3#!$'1(%'#--'&&#(4#$#-- ! '

(#(!( 8,!&'$+84#8 4!& ('( (&'%'

(-#8- ('3( # $'

3'+''

($ (%'$'

(%' (#(' 5# 8## / '2'

1 (%'

#-- (9'( 3&'# &8

3#(' ((+'#

'$%#-- (9'(14% 3%%#2 < +''#33'-(' +8(%'#--'&&#(1$%'3!& ((! # ! # 3&# 9 (%' +''

( %'

- '2 !$ $'

3' (%' (#('

5# 8## B'# ' 3!$'& (%'#--'&&#(%#$(+''#+&'( '9$( #('#$(%4(%'+''

&'(('

#(' ;

3!& +'#2# &' +8(%'#--'&&#(@!#%'

'# $'

(%'(#(' 8## ' # !&& #< ''9'( 4 (% (%' '#$ < (%'

B'# ' <&'H! <'(%#((%'+''

-#$($'

3'#$-'

(%'

&'(('

#(' ;

3#(+'#2# &' +8(%'#--'&&#(1 4%4#$'# $'

< 8## 33

<&81(%'

' $9'

(%'#--'#&# (%'$#9'

$ $$' G (%'- '$'(3#$'(%'$(#(!( 8 !&'$<2'

<(%'$'

3'$

# 'F%'!*#+ &/'

3#&'

3'$&#$$.,!&'$1 : G%'

' (#$D(%',!&'$1: G

'3(#-- (9'(%#$ +'' '

' ! '

,!&' F(%',!&'$1: G14% 3%9'#$(%#(# #-- (9'(9# '(%'

$'(%#+8- 9( +8( #-'

$ #& '# 8 (%'$'

3' 62'

9'( # #62'

9'( (#(' !+ !&'3 '

'$D62'

9'(D14% 3%9'#$(%'62'

9'(

!*#+ (%''-# (9'( 5'#&(%# #9 &8'& ',!&'- 2 '$ 9'(% #-- (9'(1#33

<(4% 3%1#&&#-- (9'($((%'$'

$%#&&+'9# '+8

'3(#-- (9'(1- 2 ' (%#((%'62'

9'(9#8

&& #8 2#3#38 +8 4#8 ( #8 -'

$ #& '# 8 $'

62'

9'( # #(#('62'

9'(,!&'- 2 '$-'

- +#( (48'# $

'3(#-- (''( $3&'#

9(%'# '$#

!&'$(%#((%'#-- (9'( #&(%!<%+84#8 ( $#

'$%

'3(#-- (9'(#$ $#--# '(

9(%'#-- (9'(&'(('

!$#& (%'# '$# F,!&'$1: G3&'# &8$%4$(%#( 62'

9'( '9-&8'' # 62'

9'( $'

3' 9'#$ '9-&8''

62'

9'( !*#+# $'

3' (%'62'

9'( !*#+!&'$$ $-'3

3#&&8$# (%'

$',!&' $#--& 3#+&'(!*#+62'

'9-&8''$ &8# $

' ( +' '# (%'3('A( 4% 3% -& 38> $( !3( $>&'(('

#(' ;

9#0'$ (#--& 3#+&'('A-# $

: (%'#--& 3#+ (8 (%',!&'(&8((%'!*#+62'

9'('9-&8''$ +!(((%$''9-&8''$4%4'

# ''9-&8''$ #+ 8 3 - #('

(4% 3% $4%&&8 $!+$(#( #&&84' +8(%'62'

9'(#

-& 38&'(('

1(%'

'13#(+''A(' ' (#'9-&8''4%4#$'#

#'9-&8'' 8## 3'(%'-'( 4#$4 <

(#(' 8### (%'

'# $%'4#$#-- (' +84#8

(#(' !*#+# #$$!3% ( '$('( (&'%'

((%'+''

-#$( $'

3' (#(' 5# 8## / '2'

1 ( 4#$ $-'3

3#&&8 ' (%'#-- (9'(&'(('

(%#((%'#-- (9'(

4#$#

'$%'# +'3#!$' (%#( '#$(%'- +#( -'

4#$#&$

(48'# $2'

'$%9'

3#&'A#9 #( # 2'

3 !3(# #('3' '($4'

'<(3 !3(' %'-'( %'

$'& #33'-(' (%'('

9$ # 3 $ (%' #-- (9'( &'(('

' %'

3'$ 33

<&81(%'-'( $('( (&' #8+''

-#$( #& $'

8### #$$!3%$%'4#$( $$!' +'

<3( 8(('

9$# 3 $ (%'#-- (9'(&'(('

<&81(%'

' $9'

(%'$!+9 $$ $9# '+8 &'# ' $'

3!$'& # (%'-'( +'

< '2 #8 9'

$%'

'+8 $$'

3 4 -*# %'(%'

$-'#0 <> '#$'

J'$ %'(%'

'- (#+&'

J'$