Dharamjit Singh v. Presiding Officer Ind Tribunal & ORS
!"#"$% &
!"#"$% &
!"#"$% &
!"#"$% &
'
)*" +"$,'
'
)*" +"$,'
'
)*" +"$,'
'
)*" +"$,'
" "$ ( " "$ ( " "$ ( " "$ ( - (#.# - (#.# - (#.# - (#.# ( #"/"$,
"! (0$/.# ("
1("2.$ 10 $/'
( $/ ' (# ( #"/"$,
"! (0$/.# ("
1("2.$ 10 $/'
( $/ ' (# ( #"/"$,
"! (0$/.# ("
1("2.$ 10 $/'
( $/ ' (# ( #"/"$,
"! (0$/.# ("
1("2.$ 10 $/'
( $/ ' (# #3$/ $ # #3$/ $ # #3$/ $ # #3$/ $ # 4% 4% 4% 4% 564+ 564+ 564+ 564+
7 ' ' ( 3( (# ' 1!
13 3 (#) 82
119 / # ' *./,) $ :
7 2 ( (( / ' 3( (#($ :
7 ' ' ( ' *./,) $ #'.1/2 ( 3( /"$ '
", # :
( # $ % 4# ";8 +'
() 0/;!
( ' 3 " "$ ( 4('.9 $6. '( 0/;!
(( #3$/ $ # $/ <<< * $ '("0=( * $ '("0=( * $ '("0=( * $ '("0=(
"/ ;" +"2 $0 > !. "; "( ! (0 .$* +!' /.1 / # #6 $/ ; 13) $ $/"$ $! (3( "$0 '
$/", (''
#2 $ "1 /"$.( / 8' # ) "# ? $ $( !(/ $ ' "$# $ 9(" 3 " "$0 ' 3 " "$ ( '
@. # "$ / ' (/ (/ /
3 ## /28( #3$/ $ =$$ >.( A 7 ("
! # ' !
( '
' 3 " "$ (9
33"$ / ' 13 ( "$ ' )$ ' .,.# 0 "#
33"$ ) $ 9 #) / 28( #3$/ $ A , (0 .$* 2 + 6 $/ ; 13) $ $/ "$ $! (3( "$0 $/'
( '"1 9(?"$, ##.!'03 " "$ (9 #"$ (;" 9 /
( ' 3# ("; ($
28( #3$/ $ $/ #( !(." / ("; ( *"$ / /("; ($
' 3 " "$ ('
#2 $3 "/)$ '18# (8 BCA "#
11 , / '
' 3 " "$ ( ( ' 3.(3# 33"$ "$,'")
("; (0 '
# 2("2 / ( #3$/ $ . #) )"#A .$/ (# $/"$,2 9 $ ' 3 " "$ ( $/( #3$/ $ 0 '"## (;"! #'
/2 $ ()"$ /$ D ( $!
# (/ ( / $ E ' 6 2.( .( 3 ## /
(/ $
28 '1/"$, '
' 3 " "$ ( "# $ $ " 1 / ( ( A"$# ) $ "# $ " 1 / $18 ( '
!)3 $# "$ 1"$, ,,(" ; /28 ' (/ (0 (/ '
2.( .( / /
0 ' 3 " "$ ('
"1 / '
3( # $ 3 " "$ ($ /!.$# 1 ( ' 3 " "$ (!$ $/ / '
' 3 " "$ ('
#2 $9($,18 ()"$ /' 6 2.(.( '
) / .("##. #09'"!'( /# 119#%A ' ' ( ' 331"!
$
11#9" '"$/ "$" "$
' 59(?) $5.C# =#7 ' ! :
' ' ( ' ( #3$/ $
11#9" '"$/ "$" "$ ' $/.# (8.C# =*7 ' ! : ' ' ( ' ( 9 #( 1 "$#'"3 ) # ( $/ # (;
$ 2 9 $ ' 3 ( " #: D ' ' ( ' # (;"! # ' 9(?) $ 9 ( "11 , 118 ()"$ /: # 9'
( 1"
'
9(?) $ $ " 1 / :G
' 6 2.(.( ,"; $ "$/"$,"$( #3 ! "##. # "$
;.( ' 9(?) $$#
( #"##. D"# !$! ($ /0" 9 , "$# ' 9(?) $ ( ' ( #$ '
'
3 " "$ (=9(?) $7/"/$ .1 "11 ' !$/" "$# D/ 8# 9(? $/ ' # ) "#$ ( 1 ! /"$ ' ; ( ,"# ( 9 ' 1/ '
3 " "$ ( "# $ " 1 / ( !)3 $# "$ 6 ($ / !.$# 1 ( ' 3 " "$ ( .( ' ( #.2)" / '
' 9
33"$ / 13 ("$ ' )$ ' .,.# 0 # (;"!
' 3 " "$ ( 13 ("# ? $"$ !$#"/ ( "$0' 9"11
.1 "11 ' !$/" "$ D/ 8#' 6 2.(.( '
"1 / !$#"/ ( ' # (;"! ( $/ ( /28 ' 3 " "$ ( 13 ( .( ' ( (,. / '
( #3$/ $ #'
; $ /"#3. /( 1 "$, /"#!'
(, $ ' 3# 13 ( #9 11 ("; (28 '
3 " "$ ( ' $18!$ $ "$"# '
' 3 " "$ (9 #$
33"$ / 28 ' !)3 $ . '(" 80 $ ) 180 > !. ";
"( ! (0 ' ( ( 03 " "$ ("#$ $ " 1 / ( A"$# ) $ 9" '2 !?9 , # ( !$ ( 0 1 ($ / !.$# 1 ( ' ( #3$/ $ # #.2)" / '
3 " "$ (9 #$ 33"$ / ("; (28 ( #3$/ $ A , (' !)3 $ . '(" 8
33"$ ' 3 " "$ ( ' 3# ("; ( "# > !. ";
"( ! ( 9 .( ' ( !$ $/ / '
3 " "$ ( '
# $ !)31 / D / 8# "$ ' /("; ( 3# # # !1 ") '
()"$ "$"#"11 , 1 $/ $ " 1 ) $ 2 !?9 , # (/1 ($ /!.$# 1 ( ' 3 ( " # (.# / ' ( !(/# "# ;"/ $ '
3 " "$ ('
9(? / 13 ( # 9 11 ("; ( $
! 0 $ '
, ) $ 9" $ ##0 $ ) 180'
$*" +"$,'0'
//.! / ;"/ $! 2 ( ' 6 2.(.( # "$, '
3 " "$ ('
/"#!'
(, //. " # ' 3# ("; (' ( ( 0 ' # (;"! # ( $/ ( /28 ' 3 " "$ ( 13 ( $/ ("; ("# ? $"$ !$#"/ ( "$' 3 " "$ ( .1 "11# ' !$/" "$ D/ 8# 9(?"$,' 6 2.(.( 9'"1 3 ##"$, (/"$( #3 !
"##. # 09 #(/ ( /"$
;.( ' 9(?) $$18 "$( #3 ! "##. D"#!$! ($ /0" 9 #( * ! / ;"$,( , (/ ' ;"/ $! ' 4 , ) $ 9" $ ##0 $ ) 180 '
$*" +"$,' = 7 ( / 9" ' 9(" $ ) $ "$3 0" "# ;"/ $ '
3 " "$ ('
#9(? /
$//"#!'
(, / ' /. " # ' 3# 13 ( $/ ("; ('
$18'.(/1 ,( $ ( 1"
' 3 " "$ ("# '
' 9 #$
33"$ / 28 ' )3 $ . '(" 80 $ ) 180 > !. ";
"( ! (' , ('
33"$ / ' 3 " "$ ( 13 ( #9 11 ("; ((",' 18(9($,18($$A!)31"
$!
$/.# ("
1 "#3. #! 0 ()"$ "$(/ ("#' 1/ 2 2 /
$/ (// /
=$$ >.( A 7"#)/"
" / '
> $ '
3 " "$ ("# $ " 1 / ( A"$# ) $ 9" '&H !?9 , # " "$# $/#/"#3# / "$ 2; ()# 8 0 8 0 8 0 8 0 =7 =7 =7 =7 ?
$!'