Maqbool Khan @ Maqbool Kha v. State Of Punjab And Others
! ! "
# "$%$ & ' % ( "$
$) $
!"#$%&!"!$ '"
" $ +
",&%"- !.*-/ '" ) ! ! ", ",")" &!
0.**,,,. % (, $,&!$!.*-/ '"" $) $ ,12, "!$ '""() $ ) ! ! $ '! * % * " & / ! 451 ", ,, )"6!
0'"%$!
0' ,17* *82,4,1985% * "& / ! $212.
.79: ;$ / ! 274 ** * " <" 0!$ " * !/ & ! .! 6 0.!$ "!/ &&0";= $"< *"* "* * 28,8,1911 )$$ * 6 "
* . && 0" / -!/ !
0 $
/!
0 ) ! ! " * $%$ % )"/ *!
0$ "!$!
" '"> $!$'/>)">!$ * *8,?,1911;
@%"
2<, "! ''/ $' )" $ /$ " " $) ,1!, , />)!
*0 * !
% $ ! 0!
$ ) ! ! "$ //%$ *.
= " !
! =$ 0 * ">""!0 =$$ > !A *% 856 "$0 =! !
%!, ," $) ,2 * 6= " $$ *=! '!- /!*"
% '=!/4" 0!"$ * !$$ , 6= " !-!
0 %$ '& 6 -!'" $ B6 "$6 C!
0"> "
0=! " "
'>!! $, 88,4,1985 "%$ **0 > !$" "
= *$ 0=! "/!*"
$ ) !
!0 , % 81,87 !"
!0" !, , )" $ ) ! ! "/> *! *"'
"> * $> =$) *, " * "> *0")) *=! "*% =!/ " 0 $= " "C */ $= " "
, " ' "
" =6'"> $) "!
0 -!/ '> "/6/ ' "
%$ *,& * - "6 !
0 "%$ *,& 0=! "%$ = )/ '//%$ *) "$ $'"$C!
0% !
/!* .
*!$% / ) $ 0=! !$" " $ " *%$!
0 > *%"" *=! "%$ *, =$ *0 * C 0/ ! 0!
$ - $!*//%$ *, !
- $ !0 ! />> / * * />) ! ' $> .
/ =$)" $ *, / /%$! ' "!.//%$ * =$/ -!/ * *$
/ *% * "& / ! $47?.212.274 .274.
79: '" 6 ""!0"%$!>)"!$ > 6 "!%" -!* ! $"* "
* *28,8,1911, //%$ * ) ! ! "/ 0 * $> 6'!!
0
)) '" "
*& $$! $%" &&0" * $> !$ ) *!
0*(%*!/ ! , %"!
0 ) /6' )) .0*$ $ )" -! * =! !
"- ! ' " $) / $. )" ! $ " * !
/>)">!$ ** /!* * %"6 / , ) ! ! "))"/ * !$ %" 6=6 )" $ ) ! ! '"%$!
0' */ $ %
)"/ *!
0$"!$!
0 " '"> $!$' />)">!$ ""!- * = )" ! $, D "
*/% $ '" ) ! ! "$%>! $ )"$ /% !
' ) ! ! "!$ !
0% %$ ' )"/ $$' %" , $%>! $ %0 ) ! ! "$" *6 / -!/ *6 %"
'/>) (%"!$*!/ ! .= - ".*%"!
0 ) /6' ))
'" !$ "!/ %" . && 0". )" ! $ - ""!- * />)">!$ *" $) $,1 *2* $ = )"$ /% ) ! ! " 6 >" , %$. * $%$ % )"/ *!
0$ 0=! (%*0> */ -!/ ! "* "* *28,8,1911)$$ *6 "
*.&&0">6C!
*6 %$ *, D "
*/% $ '" ) ! ! "$$" ! *%) % /%*0> ' !$%" ! *$
!"# $ %
& ' !
(
$
#
) ' !
(
$
! D "
*/% $ '"" $) $,1 *2$$%))" * /
! $' "
*/% $ '" ) ! ! ".= " $. "
*& /% $ $))$ * $> , !$%" -!* "* "* *28,95,1911*!" / * )" ! $ )) " '" E% 60!$ " '"" /"*! 0 !"$ > $.$ /
* * '" %" . * E% 6 0!$ " =$ $ *!" / * $ *! $" )" , )%"$% / $> . "
*.&& 0"$$ "" )" * *B,81,1911 !$%" ,F! " )" $ $$
@ * ) /)! $'$ > '" $) $,1.
-! 0"! -!. " $) ,2 !
% * //%$ *E) ! ! "
" /"* * 15,9B,1911, $!$' $ > $.
"
*.&&0"$/ /%* *!
" )" />)">!$ '' / * = )" ! $ !$ -% "!6. =! % 6 !
*%/ > .
/ "/! ")" $$%" ,
!$$> ! * //%$ *=$ * /" *)"/!> *''
* "!
!$/$ , - "* "
*/% $ '" )" ! $.) "%$ * " /"* * " )" $ 6 "
*.&&0", " ) "%$'$ % "6)"-!$! ' 451", ,,=%* $= !0%" >6>C $%/"* "$.$>6 / $$"6 0!- '' / 6"* "% * " !$* " )" - %$ ' )"/ $$ ' 6%" " "=!$ $ /%" *$'(%$ !/ ,& / ! 219", ,, !$ %6" - '"/ $!* " ! .=!/)" $/"! $ )"/ *%" '"
/>)% *!
0 ' ''
/ $ % * " *!
* , G &%)" > %" !
$ % *
& '
%
+,
!
"
#
"
$
!
%&'
(# )*
$
+
&,&, -., ,",
%&'# (# )*
,
!
# (+( $,-.(/$0123.(4 *5$*55 + 67 (8$19( ------ ).
'/ (# )*
# 0
1 1
"
!
#
%&'# (# )*
#
+
%' #
"
'/# (# )*2
! 0
3452
645
6 457
6845#
9
: )!
0!
-! = %" '''
/ $ 0 *6/>>! * * '/ )" ! $- >!/6$ * !"*!$)% . / % ! '/"!>!
)"$ /% ! =%* '% ! @ "/!$ , G &%)" > %" !
%> "'/$ $!
/%*!
0/
*
!(
(00# 1 2
) '
(
% $ 0"'= *6 !$%" !
% //$ '
&,&, -., ,0, *
!" - * =! )")$! ! !
-- *!
)" $ /$ *$ * =, " ' ". G &%)" > %" !
Gian Singh /State of Punjab and another $19(71(
'%" "* =! !$$% * "! "=$ *6 &%)" > %" '"%$! ' !
State of Haryana /Bhajan Lal4
$199$
:,
":8' (%*0> " *$$% * "+
;$
3
0
<=
'/ #
>645
45
#
0
<=
#
"
0
?
"
(
#
+
&,&, -., ,,
" 6
0
@
0
"
# 0
"
!
0
#
0
4 5
0
:
))6!
0 =$ *6 G &%)" > %" !
) " '(%*0> $ * !$!0%" .! !$))"
= )" ! $-
" *!
/>)">!$ . / % ! ' )"/ *!
0$=%* > " 6 %$ ')"/ $$' %" *6=!
0 *// ) !
0 )"6 "' ) ! ! "$6%$!
0 =%* $ /%"!
0 *$'
(%$ !/ .=!/!$)"!>"!6 ( / ' 0!$ %" / !
0% * "
& / ! 451", ,, $" $% . !$%" '!
*$ /$ !
*$%" 6'$ =! !
>! *)"> "$$ *6(%*!/!)" / * $ * / .
,17* *82,4,1985% * "& / ! $212.274 .79: ;$ / !
274 ** * " <" 0!$ " * !/ & ! .! 6 0.!$ "!/ &&0";= $"< *"* "* *28,8,1911)$$ *6 "
. && 0" / -!/ !
0 ) ! ! " * $%$ %
)"/ *!
0$"!$!
0 " '">" %$ *% ) ! ! " $!$'
/>)">!$ * *8,?,1911;
@%"
2<, )) ) *!
0 '" "
*)) %" =%* % > !/6$ *$!
'"%/ %%$, * $$ $6 )" ! $$" >!
% *6 ">$ */ *! ! $' />)">!$ * !"$ > $" /"* * '" %" =,
! ! $ *$= *, "!$ '" "# ;!
%/C6 F "$) C!
0E" $ *+ $E F " )" + $E