← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/221/2011dismissed

Commissioner Of Income Tax-I v. M/S Jain Uday Fabries Pvt. Ltd

2024-07-16Mr. Justice Sanjeev Prakash Sharma,Mr. Justice Jagmohan Bansal4 pages

-  

            

 !"#$ 

% &&""



'(

*+ # ,

-&'

"

 &

   

    !    

    

&(  ( . /0 12! ( 1)

4 (25544  ( .0)( ! 3.!(2( 3  666666   ! "

 #$%



27(  (3/)3   2 554(22

 (5

3 (3(33 ) 89:;2 < =

! > 9( 2(?2 @; 7 2

(/ 12 7A  )  2

<.3 554   )  2 2 + <<

(!")32  !B2. 32 (3(33C 3 (32

1 (<5402

< 2()( 3 < 27

 2 (  7A    )   (3 140!  2 

1   (  5

3  (3( <540 12

< 33:

 ( 22()( 3 <<A ( 33  

)5 !88!8!:C 2<<

( < ==(

5B( )  32(3(2 . 32 (3( 33  >:   2  

  5(((3    554  7(  2   <  =

5544 ( 7) 4 3. 3  (3(33  !(3(5

3702

- B 3 32(3(2 B )5243 (4 3 

        

 9:; C:243 122(3(5

3702  )43 7  37(( 20 4B  "( 3  )

4  (  2  5544  (. )  )7<   2  2  + <<

(B2 45

1(3()  2 )12  2.3 (32 5

(3( (< 4 33B 702 < 32 )12 2.=< 32  (  35 3 40B 4 )7< 3227A

) B( .(5(3)37(2+ <<

( 3!2((!2

(3(5

3)  2 B 4  33 . )(2(!  B (1)32

2(3 3 32(3( =(

1  5B(

 122  B(((  : "( 3)

4(2

!2B.(! )55( 2(3( )22((3 37A ) 237 5(3)37(2

1 (B223 35 3 405

3 4(3(<A 1(

33  

2()(   D2.()440

3(32 )7<

 35() 32(3(

5

370.( ) )2(   ! <   37.D 32  4402

1  ( 43 A  2(5402 

 3 23 2)(( 3405

32(3( 27 2

 2  3(3(B

244 13)  2 7(2+ <<

(!B2 (< 332<(2

1 (

3(2(540 2((3B

5(3)37(2+ <<

(B24  322  2 (3(

 440 3227A ) 237 5(3)3 3 2A3  (<  B  A3(<2

B2 2234 7 

B(37)2 (540B 

3(3D4 22

1 ()5 (< 32

&- =< 32 ( 2A 1 

3(  442((37A  )  32 <333  

)54<)  !88!8!:C 2  ()<   ! 

7  322 23 554 32 < 3(2223

 3)33 4 1  E) (0B2 2 

 4((2 1 4)  5

12

< (3( 8

2<<

( < =B2 4=(

15B( ) 3(    /)( 3   B)437  434A 2 (3(2 5(. 332(2 2 4) 22 < ((  2= 2  5(/)3 2 ( 2(. ) 2B  3  



(0( (( ) 2.7 4 33B



    9 )5(; ) 3(

9 ;

2(3(

1 ( )127(.

3 ((  9 ;

 5(/)3  42 ( 2(. )  -2  2   3  

 (!  2((!  (E) (3    7    3 

7 (.3702 5=)(!.(04

(. ) 

E) 2(3( 2

1 (

7(3 5(/)3 2 ( 2(. )

2) ! B. B (5

74(2 4)  3 

< !<(40 7) 2<<

(3 1(B 22. B353702 !

 71() 32432(3( ((  2(((2 7) 3(<2 5(.

4B 32(3( 7 3 40B2 2. BA 702

 )

 74 4B  D 32

554B2 4(40 1 2(  3/)31< (232 4) 22. BA 702 

7  37 (( D4  32233  

2.7 <37 3 25(.

4B702  3!2((!3  3 0( ( (( 1B 22

'- B44( 3(3(2

B2 2 7 3  ( ! )7   4 E)   4B 7  37(E) (37=< 3702 )(. 2( !B(   3(=<

12(3(2

2)4402(

((( 2((! ((  B(( 3 C & 1< 44 554   !  0!4  3 3            !                ( ) '

 

D22( 5A 1*( 3

, * D22(5(74

, *