Mukesh Thapar v. State Of Punjab And Another







 
 

 






!"#"




  

    

 



 $
 %&'
"

( '
( ''

&
****    

 

!

" #   



 () *
+ -.
"

$%&

    # '()  

*  +  

    " (-(. $ +&   / ,       (0 %- (-%1 $2  0&  !#    #3

#3   # 45+ -(6 (- -'

(-%.$2 %& # .-67.(.7.(07.('$#%0)7%0859 3  &" , 3#   

" : #

 "      #

$2 1&  $(&

;

#3     

* 3 <,"

   33, 3*"

*  3 3  

#3

!

 

 -0 %- (-%1 3*,   

, # 

3#   !   3# *  !

#* 3#   #  #5 3*%) (-%0  3%*


 =  # 9 

    

  9>>.'110>(-(0  *  #   3* ,/ ,45+ (6 (- -'

(-%.

- 2 -      #

  ! 

  #" # 



#%60>59!3 ,  

#3 !

 $0&

+# $'&

? ,"

  

":@  ## #  3  + % 



" #  3

# 3  + (!# 

#  $1&

;

 #3    + (    3    %) (-(0 $2  >1&"    

# 3*3!   + (   #  

 45  /       #

!

 $6&

=

3

#3 

 $)&

3*"9  # 33   # #

 ! 

  # #  

#,  #%60>59#  *9   

# 3   3  ! 

3 #   9 A   !#.
/ /-
)0
1 )/
2)3)
)
) /24
540+0
(/)/
6
)47) )
)
) /241  !.
/ /-
)0
184

02)
8+9)4
540+0
(/)/
6
)47) )
)
) /241.  # 3*!  3 #   #     !

!"  #  

#%60>59 33  

#3 !

- 3 - $8&

  9>   #   9    #  3
 

        

 
       

 ! 33 

>  

                     

  !"#$ 

                         %   

    

  % % &   %         '"( %                %    

)         % 

    

            "        



    

  *!"#$ 

        !    

  % '"( +   , -.,-

      



 *!"#$ !

 # 

 / %

 0     '   %) 

   )   $%-&

  3 3

2

#  ,!3 ! !  # !

 !



#  

 

    # *

 ,  3"  !



 # 

#%60>59  33  

##  $%%&

5 !     # 3  ,  #

 # 





 #

,

, !#   3#  # 33 9>>.'110>(-(0

3   #    # !   #   

 3         #*  3

," ! 

 3

- 4 -    "   3

 !3  

 * #, 

#%60>59" #  $%(&

## ,3*"

  33!     (0 %- (-%1 $2  0&  !#    #3

#3     #  45 + -(6   (- -'

(-%. $2  %&   # .-67.(.7.(07.(' $# %0)7%08 59  3   &"

, 3# 

": #

 "  #

$2 1&")   *   .% (-(0 11  :() *
+ -;

+ ,

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No