High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/247/2011dismissed

Commissioner Of Income Tax Ii v. M/S Vijay Bharat Cigarette Store

2015-05-27Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari,Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal4 pages

!" ##$$%% " &' ()*+ , "- ""."! %' /!

" 0"## $/" !"

#!$%&' "()* '*(+ ,- "

. #'-()* ' #!$%&' "()* '.** # & "1 (#, %!/&

"! " $$%% "# (#.#2#('0!/&

"! "$/"# 3333 *(+ ,- "

. #'-()* ' " " / " $$%% " 4' %%5-"$/"6 ""/ " 7$$ %8$ /'/. " "!<=:< " >" "68 " " , 9??@ ?A# $$%% " "/ " "" %%5-'4"

" %B'" % 5 " %1 C

! #$%&% '

( $%) '&5!"'4"

" %B'" % 5/" "

# 9# ?<#<<#9??@!"$/" %/""' "' D!?D!:;?) # <<#?9#9??A!""'5 $ /'/ "<@;7<8 " "# -

/$"/ $ $- '/

. "<@D /<@E " " /?;#?D#9??D / "'/ "<@;7;8 /<@D " " " =!9<!;@?) # ;# <;#?E#9??D! " $/" %/ " " 4& / " / "/ ?;#?D#9??D# 7$$ %8 / %" 5" /"

% " $/"6

- /- $ ," """"$ "#, // "/?9#?<#9?<9!###78"/" "'/ % '<D "$ "$ //!"$ "5""%/" & "

"""F<9G$ '"

$40 " "4

% '% "/" /"4 % " 640 " "/ , "

'"-$/#"5 %/" ""$ ," ""5

/ 5""$& . "@?7487&8 " " /"###78/%"/ / %%5 <!::!=:E) /%/"$/""4""%/"""

%% 9!<;!D<?) #"$"

"""" ""5 %/" ""$ " /

/"4 % "% "/ " "$&'

'"-, / '%/ % """4 % $"" "$ "$//#/

/ %", / "4 %%-/# @# " "! " ### 78 / " "/ $ /- '/ " " "/-" ""-

%/" 0 , B' / " / " "" " " $$ "&# 9A#?<#9?<?! " " 5

' 5 '/ $ " " $ '/ " "#, // "/<9#?;#9?<?!###$ / /"$ /-'/ " "####"

"// "/?;#?D#9??D // "/"-

"$$ " " ""#

A# ,"// "/;<#?<#9?<<$'-/"$" %!" 4' %"

/"// "/<9#?;#9?<?# :# 4-'"$ %%%$ /-&5 %/" "$ - "/$'-/"$" %# D# ;?#<9#9?<?! " / 5 $ / 4, " -

$''

"""// "/<9#?;#9?<?$ /'/ " 9:; " "#, // "/9@#?;#9?<<!"4' %"

/"/ &5 "// "/;<#?<#9?<<5 $'-/"$" %# 5"/ %!"// "/;<#?<#9?<<"

/"// "/<9#?;#9?<? $ /'/ " "#5 %"/ %!4, // "/ ?9#?<#9?<9###78 / %%5/"$/"6 ""/

" / "/ ?;#?D#9??D / " / ""

/ %",# "

/""/%,"4 %%-/4,"$/"# E# &5 "

" " " " / / "/ ?9#?<#9?<9 ""

%",! " 5'%/ , &" " 4 $4% " $ / , '" " $ %%%$ /-'/ " "#4& ""/ "/ ?9#?<#9?<9 - /- " & %/", " $ ," "" 4, " $/") & % ""

/ %",# =# $$%% "

/"$ /-'/ "9:; %,4, / /'$ /-5 5'%/4 " ," / % " 5" " /- / " / / "/ ?9#?<#9?<9 " ### 78 "

%/4,"$/" ""/ "/ "/?;#?D#9??D# 5'%/ 4 $4% "5 $ %%% $

" 4 %%5/

"" "/#

<?# B'" % 5!" !"%,/"!4'"

" "$"

# <<# %" !//# 0*(+ ,- "1 . #'-()* ' 0.** # & 1 ().'

> &/6 Whether to be referred to the reporter or not. Yes No