High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4735/2016dismissed

Block Education Officer, Panipat District Panipat And Others v. Sh. Karambir And Others

2016-03-11Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain4 pages

! "!#$%$&'()#*

! "!#$%$&'()#*+ + + +

,#-".# $&

$#!)+&$/ &"& *!) ! $ $&!)% 0!)%.% 1*)$2)34$)1$&5*&"& *!) !%/&"!& % (' (' (' (' 6 7(111 6 7(111 6 7(111 6 7(111 )!%!& '

)!%!& '

()2(--"+ )8& 99999 99999 99999 99999 1 + 1 + 1 + 1 + ! $ $&!)*% $,!" *$%/! $ $&.&"!)) $#,!

*!&% $ . $& &"$%!!-$&5:)$ $& *!& .)!

!) $))$ ) ;.%*$&5 *! :)" " !"

<&&!=.)!>? !%/&"!& *")$%!"&&".% )$,"$%/. ! 48 %!)@$&5 "!3&" & $#! #*,,!&5$&5 *$% !)3$& $& *!%$""$%/. !)$%!"48 *!/! $ $&!):%)! !))!" ) "A."$# $& *! &".% )$, )$4.&,>#.3>74.) .) + &$/ 48 *!//)/)$ !@!)&3!& *!#%! )!%/&"!& +$&4)$!

+:% * *!

*"4!!&//$& !"%*:-$"):$ * *!/! $ $&!)%&" *" :)-!" % %.#* )3 B 1!)@$#!% )!%/&"!& *"4!!& !)3$& !"48 *!

/! $ $&!)% :$ *. #3/,8$&5 :$ * *! 3&" )8

/)@$%$&% &".% )$, $%/. !%# +B <6# 6 )%*) ! $ $&!)%$& *!$):)$ !&% !3!& @!))!" * )!%/&"!& :%//$& !"%".%! *:-$")% /!) *! $)!# )+1#*,".# $&+)8&3!3" !"

+,, *!/)$&#$/,%:!)!"$)!# !" !&%.)! *! % ! 8&"%!#.)$ 8 ,,".%! &"#3/. !)%$&% ,,!"$& *!%#*,&#%!+*:-$"):%/% !"$& *!1#*,+ *!&, !)& !))&5!3!& %:!)!)"!)!" 4!3"! )3 !=$% $&5 %

!&%C(,$C1:!!/!)% ) %*$ >:$%! &$5* ". 8 //$& 3!& )!%/&"!& :% 3"!$& & $,,!5,3&&!) *!)!,!@& $3!+ !@ :%:)-$&5 % !&>#.3>*:-$") $& @!)&3!& $5* 1#*,+ 1"*/.)&)!5.,)4%$%&"*:-$"),,:&#!%*" ,)!"8 4!!& /$" *! )!5.,) !& 3A.)8 :% :)-$&5%/) > $3!1:!!/!)$& *!%$"1#*,%/!) *!,! !)" !"

+&)!;.$)!3!& :% *!)!

&8".%! *:-$")$&@!)&3!& )$3)81#*, & *!/,!"$&5% *!/) $!%+ ,,:$&5$%%.!% :!)! )3!"48 *!&".% )$,)$4.&,>#.3>74.).) '> D *! *!) *! !)3$& $& 1!)@$#!%

:)-3& 1*)$ 2)34$)1$&5*$%,!5, &"

@,$" & %+ :*$#*)!,$!

+ *!:)-3& $%!& $ ,!"E

!,$!

F ) $!% ,!" *!$) !@$"!&#! $& %.//) *!$) )!%/!# $@!/,!%

*! &".% )$, )$4.&,>#.3>74.) .) @$"! $3/.5&!":)"" !"

)"!)!")!$&% !3!& )!%/&"!& :$ *#& $&.$ 8 %!)@$#!&" G4#-> :5!% )3 *! " ! "!3&" & $#!+ $! B !&#!+ *!/)!%!& /! $ $&48 *!/! $ $&!)%>(&5!3!& *@!*!)",!)&!"1 !#.&%!,&"*@!5&! *).5* *!)!#)"@$,4,!& *! $,!#)!

.,,8 & *!/)!%!& #%!+"3$ !",8+)!%/&"!& *":)-!"%*:-$")$& *!/)!3$%!% @!)&3!& $5* 1#*, )3 B *.%+ )!%/&"!& *":)-!" )3)! *& "8%$& 8!)/)!#!"$&5 *!" ! *$% !)3$& $&:!@!)+ *!

%!)@$#!% )!%/&"!& :!)!"$%/!&%!":$ *:$ *.

#3/,8$&5:$ * *!3&" )8/)@$%$&% 1!# $&

*!# &#%!+ *!/! $ $&!)%:!)! *!/$&$& * )!%/&"!& *"4!!&//$& !"$&#& )@!& $& *!

,! !) " !"

$%%.!" 48 *! $)!# )+ 1#*, ".# $&+)8&+ *!/! $ $&!)%#.,"*@!)! )!&#*!" )!%/&"!& !) #3/,8$&5 :$ * *! 3&" )8 /)@$%$&% 1!# $&

*!# ()!@!)+(*"

% !"$&*$%#)%%>!=3$& $& * *!:)-:*$#*:% 4!$&5"&!48)!%/&"!& :%% $,,$&!=$% !&#!$& *! 1#*,& *!%!#$)#.3% &#!%+ *!&".% )$,)$4.&,>#.3> 74.) .) )$5* ,8 )"!)!" *! )!$&% !3!&

)!%/&"!&

& *! # % &" #$)#.3% &#!% *! /)!%!& #%!+ & 5).&" ) $& !) !)!&#! 48 *$% .) :*$,!

!=!)#$%$&5A.)$%"$# $&.&"!)) $#,!

*!&% $ . $& &"$+$%3"!.

$%3$%%!" <1 ?

<1 ?

()#*+ ()#*+ ()#*+ ()#*+ 3*@$)