High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4124/2012disposed of

Murti Devi And ANR v. Sanjay Kumar And ORS

2015-12-09Mr. Justice A.K. Sikri11 pages

!"#$$"" % &'( ) *$ +

*" , " -

! . -

$$"" %

01 "#

& #1

2) 3 1

2 '

5# "" $ " 6( "# + " 6( -

!#$( 7 $$" # 8 $ 6( " !"# 2 "1 *8

GAURI SHANKER 2016.01.15 17:31 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document Chandigarh

9 2 "9 8 #$ *:1;+1 < 8 8 "# *# /"

" 2 5 # 6 1 *# /" 8 55 ""5 / $

# (" $"" # (" =>? = * "( 1 @ 6 5 5 =>*;

A @ 65 6( &'( ) C5 C5 # # # " 6@ $ # (" " 8 1 *# /" "" 8 @ # '

*# /" $ @ $ 8( 2 $$" 5 @@ ""5 ##$

8 8 - # *$ = ;+ 1 & :<+ - /" ! 8 5 /" & 78" 5 &'( ) 1 5 @ $ / " $

& ;; % " 1 ??

A ??B "#5 #$ #"( *# /"

5 "

+ 8 #"( &'( ) < ! $ $"( $$ $ - 8 $"( " 6( #1 ( # 8"" "# 5 @ ""5 6( "# 5 # " #" $ 8 5 "( 5 6 #( # # 2

@ *" , " -

!#$( " $ 8 $"( @5 $ "# ( 6' 8 5 #6"( $ - ""5 " "# 5 @ ""

8 $" E #$ $"5 $ 1 ""85 8 #

! "#$"

% & ' ()

' ' * +

+ ()

' +

()

- 7 $ " 8"" # (

!#5 "

5"5 5 5 @

6( &'( ) 1 8 " *# /"1 " "

"# # *:1;+1< 8 8 #$ $ = 8 5"( " - =+ 8 $ 6( -

!#$(1 1 # 8 5 75 55 6( 8 $ 6( " 2 "1 "# " -

!#$( " $ + 2 6# # 6( " " $ 6 $

. "

!#$( 6# 8 @"" 8 @ 6( 2 "

# 8 * +< $ # 1 8 ( ## # 85 6( > ( & = ;; > " 8 6 " # 1 1 < # " 6 # $ " E$1 8 " 2 " # <+

"(5

!" # $%

$"&'$() %*$'+,-,./0 .

1023,1 # " 6 $$" 5 5 $ 5 6( " " 1 5 6# # 6( " "

!#$(1 " "

"# 6# 8 8 @5 2 8 =, # >" -

! "1 =8 " 8 5 # *1 < $ # 1 8 1 " " 5 "(

5 # @"" 8 @ 6( 5 # * +< $ # >

6# # 6 8 "

$ $ " " $ 2 $ 5 5 " *# /" > 8 + ( 5 8 #

# $ "#1 $$# " " $( 8 E *1 F

6 $ #

5 5 $ >8 1 6 " 6 " 6( # $ # < 5 1 # * +< $ # 6( 2 " ""

;

" 8 " # 6 8 "

$ $ 5"(1 "(5

$ 4"$%) '" " 45 ' $6$%) '".+,-702 3/ # 8 5

$ $ ""8 E G 2 # " "

!#$( # 5 5 $ " 6 $$" - "89&8'

$%) '" " %$)$$%$) '+,-7.+0 .

10::,1 "" 7 >96" & $ # !

" ++ H "

( 6" $ $ & " % # " # 2 6" 6 $ $ & " % # 5

5 !

1 #"(1 & ## 2 #1 2 "@ ! ! "

"# # & ;; ??

2 !

# 8 !"

# 6" # 6 5

5 5 / $ 655 5 6( #$"(5 6" $ $ & " % # #( ( " # 6 2 # E $( $ E# D " %"

5 $( # "$" # E #"

E 2 # "$" #""( 6

" "

$( I " "

# "$" 1 @5 5 1 # 6 # "$" 6( J# I

" $( - & " % #1 !

#$"( 8 #$"E E # " $( # #$ "# #

& ;; - 6 5 "( & " % # "# "# $

$ #$ # 6"

5 K # K #6 $ 2

" $(1 2 " #

< 6 #

5 #K 6 # 8 $ " "5 E$ K # 6 $$" 8 5 H @ (

"8 $ 8 "" 5 # 8 8 & " % # - 1 "

8 8 A- 8 8 61 8 # $

""8

- $$" #$ #

& ;; ?? 8 5 ( 61 !"#

" "" " # !"

# 6" $ $ & " % 8 $ '

- 8 5 $

( 1

$ & ;; & ;+

8 "# #$ 6 #1 # # & & " 6'

$ !"

# ;

6" & " % # " 6 ""8

" 61 8 " 5 "# $$" # & ;; 8 5 6 ( 1 ( !"# 2 " @ 5 $"5 " & & " ??

2 !"# 2 " "" ""8 $ " $ & " % #

# #$

H " #@5 #

$ $1 2 " "" ""8 $ 5 $ 5# & " % #

- $ " "5 E$ 1 2 " "" "( ""8 $ 6 $ 5 $ +1 + + '

5# & " % # 6' 6 # 6( $ +?

2 6 $ $ # # ""

$$"( "" $5 # 8 6 $

B #" 8 6 @ 6( >96" & $ # !

$&1 $%) '" "

)$1$"&'$( ) %$%) '"+,-++,,+ - &$$1 $$%$' " !

;

$ 9&8' '8 $% ) '" .+,-30 : 7/< ""85 * # ) 9 6 " A2 #5 D "( # 2 >5 !

""85 $ )" ."&;'01 @ + # H #

" $ 5 $ 1 6 55

##K 6 6 5 D 6( 3 5 7 "8 9&8'

."&;'0 - 8 " # 6 8 5 $$ 6 ( 8 5 5 6 $ 1 8""

"8( 6 # $ 8 5 " ( 5 51 1 6 @B * 5 1 8 + ( 5 8 #

??1 65 6" "5"1 !

" "8 9&8'

"("."&;'01 8 6D "8 6( " "

!#$(

("."&;'0 2 1 # ? $$" 6( " 2 "

5 5 $ " - "5 6 >96" $E !

$&1 $%) '"("."&;'01 # # " "

!#$( 65 6 " 1 8 $ "

E$ # " 6 E G $$ # 8 1 # 6 8 $ 8 " " 2

#"( 8 5 @ $ 1 1 # * 1< ""8 " " " # " E$ # * * 1< 2 "# 1 8 6 6 $ $ 1 "

( 6 " " #$ 6( " 2 " 5

$ " 5"(1 " #$ # *?1:1;< * + # "( # G

$ $ < 8 $ " E$ E E ?

F * " " "

5 " "

( 8 F * 1

5 " E$ "

( 8 2 #$ *1+1< ?1:1; :1;+1< "

(

8 "" 6 $ "#1 $ D " 1 8 $ ( # $ $( '

5#1 "5 8 1 # ""

( L : G $ # # "5 $$" "" " * ""(1 6 $$" $ #$ 5 8 # 6 E