M/S Alcon Transformer Industries & Another v. Punjab State Power Corporation Limited & Others
CWP No. 25949 of 2017 1
! "#$#%&
'($)"%* %$*+ *%!,$ *# $- % . * // # #% *$ 0$
,%1 23 4 **5* #%6#+# !- . *$ / $5%! % $ '& 76'
38 ' '6 76'
3' 6
1 98,+ *'# ):
! " # $# % &'(
)(' *+
* , - $.
$/ , .0 # (#
0 $ 0
12/ 0$ # .
/0 % / " $ .
3 " ! 0$ 4/ "0 4//
%
/ $ .
5$ 6 / " $ " .
3/ " 7 ,
./ **
* /
CWP No. 25949 of 2017 2 $ # 0 / / / 7 . , 0 / . .
$/ . 0 / / / 7 .
.0$
$# /0 . .
7 0
0 " 0 2 / #
0 .
.8 / / $..
7 .
. 6 1* .
.
$ . '5$ ++ . . 0 .
90:
; $ . / ! 5 ++ .
$# / ./ / // * / $ / . $ 7 . # 0/ /
$ $ $.
# *-
* . /$ / / . 0 / - **<
/ // * $ 0/ 7 (! / $ 90 . ! = 5$ * . / /* *2
* .
; $0 5$ * # *+
*
CWP No. 25949 of 2017 3 /$ / / ' 3 0 7/ . ./ / / 7 $.
/ / .
/ . 0
". . 0 /
* . .
. 0 / .. 090 7 .
/ . $/ . !# . ,
* $ . 0 0 12 $ / .
$ / 12
8 ! " , 2.
*
* 0 $ $ %
0./ > 0 0 !
'
/ # *+
* . 0 % 1 /$ / / ' 0 7/ " . .
. 1*.
$ $ . / 12 7
?, 2@ / >
$
. ! .
/ 0 " .
/ / ,
CWP No. 25949 of 2017 4 7 /
$ 0
$ $ 0 $ % 0 . 7 0 /0 9
.
0 7 9
. / $. /.,/ 0,!
. . / 09$ /A
/ 0/ /
7! /
, 9
0 / ". ( B"/00$
.0 #
/ 09$/
0 $.
/ A / 0 /
7 > $ !A 9 / 0 $
! /
, 9
0 / C - 7 / !
! "
" # $ % $# // :
$ . $
// # 9 " / 0 0
.
, . 9
.
0 /
CWP No. 25949 of 2017 5 9 / 7.9
..
0/ 0
0
7 ! , 9
0 D / / ". / / /
// 0 $ .
0
7,!
&'
( ) * + ,?
*8@ !>%+ ?!!@.
$ 9
. /
# 0 $
/ $ /. $ 9
. 0 / 0 /
0 0 / . 7 0 , ( * 79
. /. ,/ 0 !
)),) *; %#% %!# < =>3>
,% ?% *% #% )6 !7$"
$ <$,5* = @!#$.' %!
);3 *#$$ %! *$ < = 3
0 . . % '#".#@ % ,22 * <%!# = 6 ! ; 3 *%
%! *$< =B3 > 09.///
. .
0 9
CWP No. 25949 of 2017 6
.
.
$.?!!
+ +( *@ B+ 6/ 0
.
$ /$ ?@0 # / 8 0(0 0 0 7 /0 9
. , /
. /
".
0 0 . 0 $ /
E ?0@ , .
. ,
, $. ,
0 0 0 " D / / .
/. $ 0
$ /
0!
E ?@ " / / $ / . $ $
# 0 $
0 /
/ . 0 ! .E ?@ ! #
0 .
,.E
CWP No. 25949 of 2017 7 ?@ " /
0 0
. $ $ 0!
/ / $0 .
D /
7!0 $ / , . 9
.
.
$ # ?
@' / 0 / /E . / 0 F $ 0 .
. FE ?
@ ' 0
" .0 # $
0
C
. . / ) 0 .
# $
$
. "/ /
/ $
0 / 0 .
/ ! 73
; > $!.
. 9
CWP No. 25949 of 2017 8
$ 0 $ G$ / $. C
= . 0 / 0 . 1.38 crores for the last three financial years, which was earlier 1.00 crore, was on account of any malafide action or to benefit any particular person. In such circumstances, the said condition cannot be held to be arbitrary or unreasonable falling within the domain of judicial review of this Court under Articles 226/227 of the Constitution of India. 8.
$
.0 $
. 9
! " / !# $ / / 0 / <1 98,+ *'# )= ,!@ ; +2 * :
<+#
)= C@$7 ,!@ ' $ $ '0 $