High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4805/2016dismissed

Sunpati And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2022-08-31The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Arun Palli11 pages

CWP No. 4805 of 2016 -1-

"#$%&

#'#( "#$& )'#*+,-+#",.

' ),+, + 1+#++#",.

#, 2$ 342 ) 0)5 6 ) 342 )

#,$7 2 +"+!6"!(+, 6 ,.

2 #8' 2-,,+96 ""9 "!(+, # +96 + 1+#+ :-,. 2 )+' +;. 2+<6 , "!(+, # +9 + 1+#+6 +#" 25'.+9"

*52+#(.+#"+ #,

-#,+#, * ,-,-# .+ ;

# -9 " (9+-=-#< ,.+, ,.

+(>'--,-# * (

"-#<(+ - "',!-"

#,--(+,-#-'

"'#"

) (,-#? ,.

4+#" (>'--,-# (,6 % "+, " &

% +#" %

(,-!

91@99:

";1,.

+:+ ""+, " % 6,.

;1+(>'- -#< 9+#" +*';9-(*' * 6#+= 91 ,.

#,+#"',-9-A+,-# 9+#"+ -"

#,-+97('=7(== (-+9+ + ) (, &76' '< +=@ >'+ ,.

9+#" ,.

* (=* - " -# 5.+ + BB B B +' -#< & 8+#+9 %=+ 9+ -,'+, " :-,.-# ,.

,+, 0-99+< +, *' -6 .-9?-, -(,' '< +=@.+9+* "-#!- :,.

* !--# ) (,-# CD ,.

-<., , +- =* #+,-# +#" +#*+ #(1 -# 4+#" (>'--,-#

.+;-9-,+,-# +#"

,,9 #, (, &C . ,6E,.

&FD

CWP No. 4805 of 2016 -2- :-#<,,.

(#, !

1 '*, "+ <+ ",.

-#, ,+,-# * !--#) (,-#CD,.

&69-8 =+#1,.

: -, ,-,-#6,.

* (

"-#<-#,.

-#,+#,* ,-,-#:

8 *,-#+;

1+#( +:+-,-#<,.

(--#,.

)'* ' ,.

(#, !

1:+-#+991 *', +, , ;1 ,.

#,-,',-# #(. ,.

)'* ' , -#

! #'9,-=+, *+ +< +*.:.-(.- * "'( ".

-#;

9:$7 "# $ % & '

('( & ) % &

& % & % *+ %

%& % * & )- ) )) %% .& , & - % & + &,

& & '

('-(% & % * & % / % - * 0)"1 & '(- )

-"1 "1 0 % &2 &, & '(% & % * 3

&) & % %% &

& % & + % - 3&

- )+ & - 3+ &

- + % &

- + -

3 0 .

4 4 %

& '(% & % * & %&

& 0&2&%5 & '( & - ) & 6 % ,

-%& '

)( % %& % &2 & % & % /

- &

&&& ) % & % * & - , & * % &2 & %

/ -% %

+ & *% & &-, 75 %&

' & (

% &2

&, & % 5 ) &

6 % ,%% +&

& % * - 8 )8 % %& % &2

& % & % /

CWP No. 4805 of 2016 -39 & - &

& * '

(% & %

/ + & &2

& '( 5 5 %&

& 0- , &

- , & * '

( ))% &&

) , %& % , &

+ & & &2 &,

& '(% & % * ! 0 & '(% & % * - % & '( % & '

('-( : 0 % 3, & % / &

& '( - ),%2 ; <&) - 3, & !% & % / +

& '(% & % *+&

- 3 & '( / 0 % & '( ,% % &,

&- & % & 3

% % -% & % *& %&+ &,%

&2 , ) &&

0 % - & %

-& -.& &

% %

& '(% & % * , ) & % & 2 , % && &, % &2 &

&, , %%& % & % *+ + 5- & &&

) ) 2 , % % 3, &,

% %&

% & &2 1 & '=+#"';,+#( ,.

-#, ,+,-#) (,-#CD (, & ;1 ,.

)'* ' , - ,.+, ,.

- , +#" =, (#"-,-# ,

8 9+*-#< - ,.+, ;,. ,.

(#,-#< #(- * !-"

" - +;',,.

*.1-(+9* -#+#",.

*+1= #,(=* #+,-#+ ,;

'9-99 "6= +#-#<,.

;16- -,.

(#"-,-#-#,+,-- "6,.

:'9";

#9+*-#<+ +,.

;9-<+,-#,=+8 ,.

*+1= #,-#9- '

CWP No. 4805 of 2016 -4- ,.

9+#" +(>'- " - (#( # "6 -, .+ ;

# (9+ -- " ,.+, '(. ;9-<+,-# , *+1 - (=*9 ;1 , #"

-#< ,.

(=* #+,-# :.-(. :'9" = +# ,.+, ,.

(=* #+,-# +='#, :+ =+"

+!+-9+;9 , ,.

9+#":# +#"-.

.+#,+(( *, ",.

+= 6-,:-99#,;

+!+-9+;9 ,.

9+#" :# , (9+-= ,.+, ,.

(=* #+,-# .+ #, ;

# *+-" )-=-9+ 916 ,.

: " G"

*-,H .+ ;

# -#, " , = +# "

*-,-#< :-,. ,.

4 ,.

+' 1 ,.

#( ' , +:-#< *+#(.#+=+ .+ ;

# (#-"

" , ;

+ !+9-" * ,+8-#< *.1-(+9 * -# +#" #( ,.

9+#" ,+#" !

" -# ,.

),+, 6 ,.

- # "-!

,-#<* !-"

"'#"

) (,-#CD,.

)'* ' ,.+' ,.

(9+ -- ",.+,,.

-" :.-(.+#1-#, -= "

:+ -# * +,-#6 :-99 ;

I(9'"

" :.-9 (=*',-#< ,.

<+* * -" -!

+ )-=-9+ 916-,.+;

#(9+ -- ",.+,) (,-#CD,.

(, &" #,<-!

- ,+# :(+'

+(,-#,>'

,-#,.

9 <+9-,1 (#(9'"

"* (

"-#<9+#"+(>'--,-#+-,+**9- ,#91,. (+ :.

-#,.

* (

"-#<:

#"-#<#,.

"+, # ( #, ,.

& * ,.

(+ *', ,.;1,.

6,.

1+ :# ,.

9+#" = +' -#< & 8+#+9 % =+ 9+ (=* - " -# 5-99+ BB B B -,'+, "-#,.

,+, + , *' -6 .-9?-, -(,' '< += +-"9+#":++(>'- ";1,.

#= #,+ 1+#+;1-'-#< #,--(+,-#"+, " &

% +#"%

%'#"

) (,-#? ,.

(>'--,-#(,6 %99:

";1+:+ ""+, " % ,.

*';9-( *' * #+= 916 "

#,+#"',-9-A+,-#9+#"+ -"

#,-+97 ('=7(== (-+9 + + ) (, &76 ' '< += , - ,.

(+ ,.

,.+,"

*-, .+!-#<+##'#( ",.

+:+ "# % 6,.

#,.+!

+-9 ",,+8 ,.

* -#,.

9+#"-#>'

,-#+#"

CWP No. 4805 of 2016 -5-

#,.

+='#,(=* #+,-#.+# -,.

;

#*+-"# "

*-, "-#

#( ' ,.

6,.

+(>'--,-#* (

"-#<>'+,.

9+#" -#>'

,-#,+#"9+* "-#!- :) (,-#CD,.

(#, + 2 #8' 2-,,+96 9 + # " ('# 9 +** + -#< ,.

#, ),+, 6 ';=-,, " ,.+, ,.

-#,+#, * ,-,-# "

, ;

"-=- "-#!- :,.

9+:9+-"":#;1,.

)'* ' ,-#,.

(+ #" #, ',. -,1 C'* +D + ## ,.

(#,-#< #(- ( -;

"-#) (,-#CD,.

&+ '9-99 ".

- ,+#" =, >'- #, (9+-=-#<9+*-#<+(>'--,-#* (

"-#<- , * !

,.+, ,.

9+#" :# - -# * -# ,.

9+#" -# >'

,-#6 :.-(.,.

.+!

+-9 ",* !

+,.

* -#,.

9+#"-# >'

,-#:+,+8 #;1,.

),+, ;1 ( "-#< +*+, A#+=(.+ % "+, " % 6 :.-(. .+ ;

# .

9" + + !+9-" ="

,+8-#< * -# #( '(.* -#-,+8 #6,.

9+#"!

,+;9', 91-# ),+, +#":. ,+-# =+-#-#,.

* -#,.

9+#"6 .

-+, *+ ' ,.

';=-,,.+,,.

;9-<+,-#,.

),+, , *+1,.

(=* #+,-#,+#""'91"-(.+ < "+,.

#,- (=* #+,-# +='#, :+ , #"

" +, ,.

,-= +##'#( #, +:+ " +#" :+ =+"

+!+-9+;9 , ,.

9+#":# + + ,.

9+#" -# >'

,-# - (#( # "6 ,.

* .+!

#, ( -!

",.

(=* #+,-# +='#,6 :.-(.,.

1+ +,9-;

,1, ( -!

6-#!- :,.

9+:9+-" ":#;1,.

)'* ' ,-##" #,',. -,1C'* +D6 ## ,.

(#,-#< #(- ( -;

"-#) (,-#CD,.

& + '9-99 " +#" # "

(9+ +,-# + <+ " 9+*-#< +(>'--,-# * (

"-#<(+#;

=+"

+!-#< .

+ " ,.

(,-!

+ <'= #,6 <-#< ,. '<. ,.

(,-!

*9 +"-#<+#"+;!

+99,.

I*-,-##" #,

CWP No. 4805 of 2016 -6- ',. -,1 C'* +D6 :

+ ,.

(#-"

" *-#-# ,.+, ,.

-#,+#, ,-,-#-9-+;9 ,;

"-=- " = ,.+## +# J * -# ,.

-#,+#, * ,-,-# .+!

(9+-= " , ;

-# ,.

*.1-(+9* -#,.

9+#"-#>'

,-# -,-!

(+ ,'*;1,.

-,.+, #,.'<.,.

+:+ ":+*+ "# % +#" 1 "-" #, =+8 (.+99 #< , ,.

+(>'--,-# * (

"-#< ;', ,.

*.1-(+9 * -# .+ #, ;

# ,+8 # = ,.

= # ,.- <+ "6 ,.

#,.+!

-9 ",.

: -,, #,+, #,';=-,,-#<,.+,* -# :+ ,+8 # ;1 " +:-#< *+#(.#+=+ -# ,.

= +*+, A#+=(.+ %"+, " % :.-(..+;

9"++!+9-"="

,+8-#< * -#,.

9+#") (,-#

(, %* !-"

,.+,+, ,+8-#< ,.

* -# ,.

9+#"6 -, !

, -# ,.

),+,

= +99

#('=; +#( .'6:

+ ,.

(#-"

"*-#-#,.+,,.

*.1-(+9 * -#,.

9+#"-#>'

,-#,+#""'91,+8 #+#"9+#"-!

"-# ),+, .

#( -# ,.- <+ " - =+"

, ,.

99:-#< *+ +< +*. =,.

K'"<= #,$7

! "

#$ % & !

( "

) !

$% * +) ,

( "- "

" ! "

$% ."

)

/ ."

! )

" &

)

) )

CWP No. 4805 of 2016 -7- 0&."

! !

( "

%%& +) )&

& % / + - 3,

& % 03,

& % * )

3, & % =

> &2 )

% 3, + 3,

& % < ,&3%

))&&2+ >

&%& &

- % %)& -&2 &

& )

" ") )

! .'6,.

*9 +,.

;

-#<-#*.1-(+9* -# 9+#"-#>'

,-#-:.991=-7(#( -!

"+#"-9-+;9 ,;

K (, "

" " # $ # % #, .+!

(+, < -(+991 *9 +"

" -# ,.

: -,, # ,+, #,,.+,,.

+='#,(=* #+,-# ,.

#,- +(>'- "9+#" :+=+"

+!+-9+;9 ,+99,.

9+#":# ,-,.

,+#",.

),+, ,.+, +='#,"'

,,.

-+!+-9+;9 "-;'

#,+#",.

+ +, 9-;

,1 , ( -!

+= 6 ,.- .: ,.+, ,.

(=* #+,-#+='#,:+"'91, #"

"6+#",.

;9-<+,-#,.

),+, , *+1 ,.

(=* #+,-# ,+#" "'91 "-(.+ < " .'6 (#" (#,-#< #(1 (9+-=-#<,.

9+*-#<+(>'--,-#* (

"-#<-+9 #,+!+-9+;9 ,,.

#,.- <+ "62 2-,,+9.++ ",.+, -#!- :,.

I*-,-#-##" #,',. -,1C'* +D,.

CWP No. 4805 of 2016 -8- ;9-<+,-# ,.

),+, , *+1 ,.

(=* #+,-# - "-(.+ < " - ,.

+='#,(=* #+,-#-, #"

":.-(..+;

#-#, ",= +# ,.+,,.

+='#,:+=+"

+!+-9+;9 ,,.

9+#":# +;

"-#

+ +&:.-(.- * "'( ".

-#;

9:$7 2*+ & !

' (

+ $ %

3 3

" 4

?) +& % -

) ) -&,% - ,

3 & & - % %

3, - "

" )

+ ++$! "

5 "

)

" ) "

+ %

)

) " )

+) !

* * +

6 "

7 8 "

) 8 " ,

+ $%)

?) + & ) , + -

& *+

& 6 "

7 8 " )

+ 9 !) ."

1 5

+ ,+, "+(,(9 + 91 +9,.+,,.

;

!+,-#=+"

-#+;!

"#,9 +!

+#1(* "';,,.+,,.

),+, .+"-(.+ < "-, ;9-<+,-# ,:+ " =+8-#< ,.

(=* #+,-# ,.

9+#" +(>'- "

6,.

(#, #,-#,.

,.+,#(=* #+,-#+='#, .+;

#*+-"-= -,9 +#",.'6-.

;1 K (, "

CWP No. 4805 of 2016 -9- ##% &'(&) &*+,#

)'* ' ,-##" #,',. -,1C'* +D.+ (9 + 91 ;

" ,.+, "

" 9+*-#< +(>'--,-# * (

"-#< '#"

) (,-#CD,.

&6;,.,.

(#"-,-#- *+1= #, (=* #+,-# +#" ,+8-#< * -# =', #, ;

'9-99 " - -

-,.

(#"-,-# - '9-99 "6 ,.

9+*-#< (+##, .+** # .

)'* ' ,.+;

",.+,,.

: "G H((' -#<-#) (,-# CD,.

&=',;

+"+G+#"B# H

!+#,*+ + =,.

K'"<= #,+ * "'( ".

-#;

9:$7 2- 8 " 5

$%) !

&")

)

! !

* +

" & ) "

( ") '

( " '

( ' ( ,,,, ,,,, ,,,, ,,,,

- :; 7 & <

- =##) 8

> "

) ,

(

" " " - !

@ '$ +%- !

)

" - ")3 3 3 33 3 - =, 4

3 3 3

$ %!

) " ! ! 3 - ) 3& ,

(

) 6-&9673 ) !

" 3 )33 3

-) ) "

) ! !

)

! !

- " " ,

7 )***

CWP No. 4805 of 2016 -10- $ %-) !)

)

3 3 ! "!

" "

& "

" - "

" " " " !

" ,7 )***5 $ 0% & ."

@ - "

A - " & "

( $ " % 0+ % % &2 &, )+ & '(%- - 3+ + & 3+ &

+ &2 &,

#,.

(+ +,.+#"+ 9 (, " =,.

*91-9 "6-,- !-"

#, ,.+, +, ,.

+:+ " :+ +##'#( " # % 6 ,.

*.1-(+9 * -# :+ ,+8 # ;1 ( "-#< +*+, A#+=(.+ % "+, " % +#",.

(=* #+,-#+='#,:+"'91, #"

")-#( ## ,.

(#"-,-# * ( -;

" -# ) (,-# CD ,.

(, & - '9-99 "6,.

6+-"* !--#(+##,;

9- "'*#;1,.

,(9+-=9+*-#<,.

+(>'--,-#* (

"-#<

& 2 #8' 2-,,+96 # ,.

, #<,. ,.

+(, *9 +"

" -# ,.

: -,, #,+, #,6.+!

#,91(#, #"

",.+,,.

),+, +(>'- ",.

9+#" ,.

*';9-(*' * 6#+= 91 "

#,+#"',-9-A+,-# 9+#"+ -"

#,-+97('=7(== (-+9+ + ) (, &76' '< +=.

9+#"-#>'

,-#-!

1='(.

#,-+9,+(.- ,.

*';9-(*' * +-, + (, ,.

#, +" + * ,.

9+1', *9+# .+!

(#-"

",.-*+ ,+ <'= #, +- ";1,.

#,+#":

+ -# (=*9 +<

#, :-,. ,.

+= + ,.- - +#-=* ,+#, +(, ,;

CWP No. 4805 of 2016 -11- *,-#=-#":.-9 "

+9-#<:-,.,.

(+ + --#<',,.

+(>'--,-# 9+#",+(.- ,.

*';9-(*' * +#"-,-,.

),+, B-,+',. -,1:.- -#,.

;

,*-,-#,"

(-"

+;',',-9-A+,-#,.

9+#"+(>'- "6+, -,.+!-#<;

"-#),+, 14.

+ >'

9 ,.

+;!

"-('-# +#" -# !- : 9+: '==+ -A " -# *+ + & & #" #, ',. -,1 C'* +D6 (--(+991+, .+!-#< ( "

",.+,-#,.

(+ +,.+#"6,.

*.1-(+9 * -#,.

9+#"-#>'

,-#.+!-#<;

#,+8 #6,.

;9-<+,-# *+1= #,(=* #+,-#"-(.+ < "+#"+9(#-"

-#<,.+,,.

9+#" -#>'

,-#-!

1='(.

#,-+9,+(.- ,.

*';9-(*' * 6:

.+!

# .

-,+,-# , .9" ,.+, -# ,.

-#,+#, (+ 6 ,.

),+, .+ '991 "-(.+ < "-,;9-<+,-#>'+;,.,.

(#,-#< #(- ((' -#<-# (,-# CD,.

&+#"-,;

-#<6,.

-#,+#,* ,-,-#-"-=- "

+!-#< "-=- " ,.

=+-# : -, * ,-,-#6 * #"-#< +**9-(+,-#6 - +#16+9=

,,.

+= +, ),+,'>'6-+#16,+#"!+(+, " C 0)5 D ) C

44D & #"K .

* +8-#<B +# " B .

* ,+;9 B