High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/5653/2015dismissed

Amarjit Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS.

2018-04-17Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath5 pages

!"#

$%& &'()(*+

$%& &'()(*+, , , , -

. /$01(%(*23 &%(%(*&0 4) %$%& 5*1$6$*7%3&0) &)8*7&*%) "+9 :" "+9 :" "+9 :" "+9 :";;" ;;" ;;" ;;" 0&)&*%+ "050(*7&03$0/$<7='$%&<

0%3&8&%(%(*&0 "0(%%$<<5*1$6 ;;"< ;;"< ;;"< ;;"< 3& 8&%(%(*&0 3$) 80$>&7 0 %3& ())5$*'& $ ?0(% (* %3& *$%50& '&0%(0$0( 0@5$)3(*2%3&07&0 %3&AA&'%07$%&7

$*7 %3&//())(*&0<$A$*73$0 (=()(*<$A$*73$07$%&7

-6> ?3('3 =$A5& %3& 808&0%> (* @5&)%(* 3$) 6&&* 7&%&0/(*&7 $) <

< < B$*7%3&8&%(%(*&03$)6&&*7(0&'%&7%7&8)(%-<. <

B $) 7& ('(&*% )%$/8 75%> $A*2 ?(%3 (*%&0&)% C D 8$ %3&0&* (& < <. B$*7(*%%$A <

< B *60(& <3$0$*1(%(*23)B"(AE3$(*23$)&*&0$A?&0 %%0*&> 3() 60%3&0 $0$/1(% (*23 )B "(AE3$ (*23< &F&'5%&7 $ )$A& 7&&7(* %3&8&%(%(*&0 0$)5/ -<

B(*0&)8&'% $* $0&$ /&$)50(*2 $'0& - E$*$A $*7 G /$0A$ )(%5$%&7 $% 4(AA$2& (73(850< &3)(A $*7 ()%0('% $A$*73$0 < =(7& =$)(E$ . 7$%&7 .

$0$/1(% (*23 )B "(AE3$ (*23 /$7& $ '/8A$(*%%%3& //())(*&0<

$A$*73$0 (=()(*< $A$*73$0 %3$% 3() 60%3&0 3$0$*1(% (*23 )B "(AE3$ (*23 3$) )A7 3() $'0& . /$0A$) A$*7 )(%5$%&7 $% =(AA$2& (73(850< &3)(A$*7 ()%0('%$A$*73$06>?$> %?)$A&7&&7)(* /$01(% (*23$*7 $A6(0(*23%%3&&F%&*% $*$0&$/&$)50(*2

E$*$AG/$0A$ &$'3 0$)$A&'*)(7&0$%(* -<

B(*&$'3'$)&*%3&6$)() 3() 8?&0 $%%0*&>?3('3?$)$A0&$7>'$*'&AA&76>%3$%%(/&&3$)$AA&2&7 %3$%$*$20&&/&*%3$7&$0A(&06&&*/$7&6>3(/$)?&AA$)6>3()60%3&0 3$0$*1(% (*23 ?(%3 $A6(0 (*23 0 %3& )$A& %3() A$*7 $% %3& 0$%& G <

B 8&0 $'0& (* ?3('3 - <

B ?&0& 0&'&(=&7 65% %3& )$(7 $20&&/&*% ?$) )56)&@5&*%A> '$*'&AA&7 * $''5*% **8$>/&*% 6$A$*'& 80('& & 3$) 50%3&0 $AA&2&7 %3$% 6%3 %3& )$A& 7&&7) 3$=& 6&&* 5*7&0=$A5&7$*7%3&%$%&&F'3&@5&03$)6&&*85%%$A))

B 6> &=$)(* )%$/8 75%> $*7 0&2()%0$%(* '3$02&) & 0&'//&*7&7 (*(%($%(* 80'&&7(*2)5*7&0&'%(*-, %3&*7($*%$/8'%<.GG 0)30%I%3&'%9J3&56&2()%0$0<$A$*73$0K0& &00&7%3&)$A&7&&7 . 7$%&7 .

% %3& 77(%(*$A &85%> //())(*&0< $A$*73$0<&F&0'()(*2%3&8?&0) %3&AA&'%0<$A$*73$0<5*7&0%3&'%<

0(*(%($%(*280'&&7(*2)5*7&0&'%(*-, %3&'%3523<%3&)$A& 7&&7?$)&F&'5%&7*.

65%%3&$'%(*?$)(*(%($%&7$ %&0L>&$0(* %&0/) )5/%58?&0)&F&0'()&75*7&0&'%(*-, # %3&'%6>%3& AA&'%03&AA&'%0=(7&3()(/852*&707&07$%&7

7(0&'%&7 %3&8&%(%(*&0%7&8)(%%3&%%$A$/5*% <

< B$*7%3&0&$ %&0%3& $88&$A (A&76>%3&8&%(%(*&06& 0&%3&//())(*&0<$A$*73$0 (=()(*< $A$*73$0?$)7()/())&7*

:&$0*&7 '5*)&A 0 %3& 8&%(%(*&0 3$) )56/(%%&7 %3$% %3& 80'&&7(*2) '5A7 *% 3$=& 6&&* (*(%($%&7 $ %&0 L >&$0 0/ %3& 7$%& 0&2()%0$%(* )$A&7&&765%)(*'&%3&$'%(*3$)6&&*%$E&*5*7&0&'%(* -, # %3&'%(*?3('3%3&8&0(7 A(/(%$%(*()80=(7&7$) >&$0)< %3&0& 0&< %3& $'%(* %$E&* 6> %3& AA&'%0< ?3(A& &F&0'()(*2 )5 /%5 8?&0)<'$**%6&@5&)%(*&7

50(*2 %3& 8&*7&*'> %3& ?0(% 8&%(%(*< %3& 8&%(%(*&0 $A)

(A&7 " ,

. % 8A$'& * 0&'07 1572/&*% 0&*7&0&7 6> %3& (=(A572& 0 (=()(*#<$A$*73$07$%&7,

,3&)$(77&'()(*() 8&0%$(*(*2%%3&)5(% (A&76>$0$/1(%(*23 $(*))B"(AE3$(*2360%3&0 3$0$*1(%(*23)B"(AE3$(*23<?3?$)%3&8$0%*&0$*73$))A7%3& A$*7(*@5&)%(*(* %3&8&%(%(*&03&0&(*<?3?$)$A)$00$>&7$) 0&)8*7&*% (*%3&)5(%$*7(*?3('3$0$/1(%(*23)B"(AE3$(*23 3$) $A) )523% 7&'A$0$%(* %3$% %3& )$A& 7&&7 7$%&7 ,

6&$0(*2 4$)(E$5/6&0 .7$%&7.

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

- '%5$AA><%3&8&%(%(*&0<?3()%3&850'3$)&0 %3&808&0%>(* @5&)%(*<?$)$880&3&*)(=&%3$%%3&)5(% (A&76>$0$/1(%(*23)B"(AE3$ (*23 07&'A$0$%(*'3$AA&*2(*2%3&)$A&7&&77$%&7.

/$>*%6& 7&'0&&7*%3&205*7 0$57&%'$*7%3&8&%(%(*&0/$>*%3$=&%8$> %3& $/5*% 'A$(/&7 6> %3& 0&)8*7&*%) 6> ?$> %3& (/852*&7 07&0 3&0& 0&< %3& 8&%(%(*&0 %30523 3() '5*)&A< /&)3 30(< /$7& %3& )%$%&/&*%6& 0&%3&AA&'%0<?3('30&$7$)5*7&0+ M%$%&7%3$%(*%3&80&)&*%'$)&%3&'*'&0*&7 )$A&7&&7()'3$AA&*2&7(*%3&'$)&%(%A&7$) $0$/1(%(*23=)3$0$*1(%(*236& 0&%3& 50% =%$0 (*23 $07$0< 77A (=(A 572&0 (=$A$*73$0$*7*6&3$A 61&'%0 5*7&0%$E&) %3$% (* '$)& %3& '$)& 8&*7(*2 (* %3& '(=(A '50% () 7()/())&7 %3& 61&'%0)3$AA8$>%3&&*%(0&75&)'A$(/&76> %3&=&0*/&*%N (*'&< %3& )5(% (A&7 6> $0$/1(% (*23 )B "(AE3$ (*23 $2$(*)%3$0$*1(%(*23)B"(AE3$(*23 =&*7&&#3$)6&&*7()/())&76> %3&(=(A50%*,

,<%3&0& 0&<%3&8&%(%(*&0()A($6A&%8$>%3&75&) $)5*7&0%$E&*6& 0&%3&AA&'%0$*7'$**%%50*$05*7%'3$AA&*2&%3& 07&0)8$))&76>%3&AA&'%0$*7//())(*&00&)8&'%(=&A> :&$0*&7'5*)&A 0%3&8&%(%(*&03$)%3523%0(&7%7()?* %3&)%$%&/&*% 3()'5*)&A65%(%()%A$%&(*%3&7$>%7()?*%3&)$/& 6&'$5)& ( %3& )%$%&/&*% ?$) *% /$7& 6> %3& '5*)&A * 3() 6&3$A < 3& )35A73$=&/=&7%3&)$(750%6& 0&?3/%3&)%$%&/&*%?$)/$7&6>

%3&'5*)&A*3()6&3$A <?33$76&&*%305235%$)E(*2%3&50%*%% 80'&&7?(%3%3&/$%%&0%(AA%3&'(=(A)5(%()7&'(7&76&'$5)&%3&8&%(%(*&0 ?$)$ 0$(7%3$%3&/$>*%A)&(*%3&'(=(A)5(%$*7%3&A$*7(*@5&)%(* 850'3$)&7 6> 3(/ /$> *% 0&=&0% 6$'E % $0$/1(% (*23< ?3('3 ?$) $AA&2&7A>)A76>3()60%3&03$0$*1(%(*23$)3()$%%0*&>3&8&%(%(*&0 %35) '$**% 6& $AA?&7 % %$E& $ )/&0)$5A% % '3$AA&*2& %3& (/852*&7 07&0)(*%3&?$E& %3&)%$%&/&*%/$7&6>3()'5*)&A*3()6&3$A $*7 3&*'&<7*% (*7$*>/&0(%(*%3()8&%(%(* 0%3&8508)& (*%&0 &0&*'&

()/())&7 ;;"# ;;"# ;;"# ;;"# , , , , -

. 3&%3&0)8&$E(*2B0&$)*&7 +

&)B 3&%3&0&80%$6A& +

&)B