High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/26/2017dismissed

Khem Singh v. Food Corporation Of India And ORS

2017-07-19Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mr. Justice Arun Monga11 pages

#$%&'(!)* !"

+,-./,

0%'%

12#1#*+,#1(#.#1#*!

##+,#-4#5#*6 ,7,%

%21%

!"#$% !&'"%$$(!")*

!"#$% %$(!")*

%& 8

#-1./,*1$#* ,2

8 .'-*1$#* %21% !9

8 + ./#*1$#* %21 :

;;;;; %$(!

,#%1,2%624(</, =#1#(6>'%1$,%''1$%

", %'1#2#(/%%'#$#6,#'$# @'#%,/,11#19

!"A=' 3! B*16,$,,% $,$#41,#%4>$1 ,/'1,# ,2#1%% #$$' %#- 6#% #/ %,* 6, # ', 2#( %%'/ -#1#-'%1$/,$#%21%$%1,141 ,2,-#1/#,#18#<#4/,6% 4114(2/,#$#41*6,#',2#(%%'#$ 6,#'2,4(%#/,%21%#6#1,

$#$6<,411

#-1 ./,* #1 $'% 2%/ , 2%'4-1*,#,2*6,%#$#$#16</ 6,, 12#1#A%,C DB#1,.##/$% %$!))),#/,#=2$,1*#221,3 166,-#/6,,@'11$'-% %21

#131%8#<##1,-#1/#,* * #%2/*#1/13/#%,#,#112 ,316#% %%'1 9 !!

#1 , #% 1# %'4-%% , 41 6#%

,2/1#,416#% !!

,2 1='3F$#/,1#%#-',1*- #1#%-(12%A8B#1#/#%,8#<#*1

G!E)E":G9H,#%4#$#1,2#1 #/#% 1 41 ,-#1/#,* 1 -

G!E)E":GE"*,#%4#$#1 ', %'4-1 ,# , 2 #% %'4-1 # #1#%2$2#(-

#/6,$-#- ,8##/A#$B*6,,#1',4#1-,%%%#

1 '1--%% (,%*,2#%'2#11 ,%=2$,%,%21% @'-'%,/ $-#='6#%#%$-216,*%%$*$-#=' #$<61/-#/6,$-2'#$-*2#1%%#$$' %#-#14##$%,6#%#%##$,1*#%=' 3E #%%'4-1,#,26#%%'2%1$ , $ 1#1 E !!

A=' 39B - , $ , %21%*6,4(,6#%-1,#,41%,#-%

+ #%,#./,*/>./,#1+,-./,6$1#1, 2'2%#I#,41%*%$$#1%$2#$%6'1* 6,$,6@'14$#1 16,#,' ,6/1%$2#$%#%$1,=' 39B&3 A 75#$$'%'4-1#B 75#$$'%'4-1 6B #%2# $,#/%J: )) ?

#%2# $,#/%J!

E:!

#4'2#1J

")!

#4'2#1J":

/%%2J!

! E

/%%2J!

! E

, 2 1'( 21 , #-1 $ 1 2( 1#1 :

A=' 3:B $%/ # #1# 1#1 !!

#/6,2#1%%#$$'%#-A=' ',%'4-1,#,$-#='6#%%1#%,6#% $,#//%%2#%6#%2#1,$*,%#-$- #='6#%1 ,$#%21%%'/,#$#$#-, ,#1$$'#,26,/#1,2#1%% #$$'%#-*6,*11#1H !!

A=' 3"B*#% $#1,%#- 6*1-2'/11=' 3! *,41 ,26#%>$1,2-%,#,2#1%%#$$' %#-%'4-14(,26#%'14#1 ,$,$# 41%'4-14(,28#<#6#%#%>$1*6,#% ,#,,411,#14'14$,$#( 11%'22,#-%-#1,6 2#1$,#/,#-11*,%'4-1,#, %1$%##%,/%%2#1,$$'1(, $#% #4' #1 #%2# $,#/%* 6,$, 6#% %'4%@'( $$1 ,$,$#41,26#%>$14(21/

, 6/'/#,,411%#%,%#-#$$-2#14($- #='6#%%'$@'-$1%1 ,#$ %21%

#19%1%$-#(4(</,1%$2#$% 2#1%%#$$'%#-,,2%%#1*,'%*'/1 ,%',#,-2'/11%#44%3#%1

$#* 8 .'- * #1 $'% 2%/ %21% !9%'4-1,# $#'%#$#$$'1, 2$,#/,-2'/11 #$*,2(, 2#$$-2#14(##1#*,#%$#11(4#1-1,# ,#2#1%%%#-'2#111,-1/#, 1#1

*,6#%%--%#<#%%-=2%%6$'1 '1,,#1C#4'2#1$,#/%D%#1-/,%#-'1 C#%2# $,#/%D , %#- 6#% $$1 4( ,% ,#1 $$'#9 "

6*#,-%'4-/,1 ,',1#1 )

*,$$12#1%%%#-6#% '2#11 #$*,2,#1'2#11612#1%% %#-%,%#-#$#(#*1,-1/#,#1 ,,', ,%1%#-,#141, $$-#= ,$$2#1%%#$$'%#-6#% -#1#(@'14'2#116,,$-#=2#-4( ,1

'/,$'%,,#/*,,#%1# 2* * #3,411$#/%1$'-%4 '2#11#%6#%1#1) !!

64(,$, $- #= $* #1 "A9B (<# ,#6#* +%, #/#* 5'1,##%</-#,6/2%&3 C

" #

% # % % #!# # & %2%,#-1@'%%*,$-#= $*11#1!!

*,#%/,6/#%6%&3

,, ., +,- ./, %1, 75$$'6, $-#= 12#-#% 1#

'%# , $- #= 2#- ## % 1 ,# ., +,- ./, .? ., #1 ./, ,#% 1 ,% ' $- , %%%%-# !93!: 1#1

)

!9 %1 '$-,#%41 4( ., +,- ./, %%%%-# !93!:

,, ., +,- ./, ,#% %1 # %'4-/ 6 75 #$$' %#- #1 % 2-1 , 2% $* '1 -$%# %%1'$- 1 4( ., +,- ./, %%%%- # !93!:

, @'% #% %'4-/6 75#$$'

,,%#1 75#$$'% #16,'%%#- 2#- ,,#(2%$#,# - ,# 75 #$$' %#- #$# (# 1 2'2% #1 % 2-1 '1 #( #$ #22$##6

*#%2,$-#=$* !) !,%%'$,2%

1',4'%%%,%#/'-*,,#%1 ,/#$1* *-#1'24(,1*6,, ,#1'1#<,##-#'%,1%$$#1$#%% '14$$''* 12#1#%6,%/, 1%@'#( ,- 6,' // #( $ #% , #1 4(

/ , $1* 1#6 , # ,% ' #'% '1#</%*=#$11$'-% #/%3!* #1E* *221=3 6#1/5B* 1#</#$$2#$-%#1$1% $/1#1221=3A#-#1%

,#2%,#-11$'-%'2#114(, 2#1,'%&3 C!

' % ## !% ' ! ' ( ) * ## + #% ' %

#% ( , % * % *

% #( % '. ## , % % ! #!% , '! # ## % !# #% # / #!# #

$ #% 1# # # % ! !

( #% ## ! / # ## !

2'3& *,'%*'/1,%'1%-%%#,62

4'#*8

#-1./,4(/ ##/#2,%!

!9,>'1/-114(,K4.'2-'./01 .2/3.

3 4 /5/ '

2.. .

)

50 7.

3/(+89#:-$1,#6,>$/, 1%*,%#'('$#(%@'1/#%% $#4

%'22-14(%,#%%#1',,#,%'4-%%,#% $-#='6#%%%#-/1$$-# ,%'4>$$/1

,#,#1,#1$'%,2#%*#22#%1, 2#24<*>'1/-$1#%6#%,$1%21'$14'% #1>'1$#,#-1% '2*,/#$, 2$#41$#1#1#44>$1 1%# 6, , #- >'1$# 6* * $> #1/ , '1#<//4(,2#16,-#*=#$1#4* %'/,4(, 12#1#-,$,$-#=* #%,#,2,#1%'4-1,$$2#1%% #$$'%#- ,$-2#%$,#,2#1%%#$$' %#-% %'4-1 # #1 %'4%@'( %,6% -#< 1$ 6#1%,$,#/%,#4'#%6#%#%2# ,# %'4-12#1%%#$$'%#-*#%2#$,#/%,# 4%,64: *)) ?3*6,#%,%'4%@'*!

$11 #-',#%412$1 .-#(*,#%#-*#4'$,#/% ,#4%,6#%

*")*!

!?3#1,%'4%@'#"*:

*9H ?3

,##%-#(*,#$-#%,#,#-12#1%% #$$'%#-%'###$,2,#4%$,#/ %'4-1,%1', $-#=2#-*,'%*, -#2114(,26#%'14$$-#</ ,-/4 ,61%*,2%1$,#/, #$6,'1#<//6,%'4-/,1$'-% A%'2#B

,%1%2',#1$11$'1'./01

; .2/3 /<./ 8/56.9(4',1/%#4#%1'2,#$% #$,$#% ,%#1$#%*,$/1*,%'4-%% , $-* 2 %% %#- 6#% # %%# @'-* 6,#%,2%$#%*%,6%*,*,%#-$#$- ,%$'#1,2

,K4.'2-' .. 3. =6 //. .

3 4 /5/

0 ./>

.?.7.

3/( %,# +:(6,(/'2,>'1/-11!.@3/0. 3.4 /5/ #. //..

3/(89,#- ##! ,1,#, 1'/$,',$#$'#-#%*%,'14--'- %%$,26>'1$#6*%,'142-14<1 2$ 2# % # , $% 2'4$ %* 1$1 $#$'#1%2'% ,'%,'14$$'-*-'$,%%=$% >'1$# %# '%% /#( #4#%% , 2# , -,#-1-#%#22# ##! #1%,'%&3

, # # !% *

! "#$%

& &

'(())! # % $# **

+ , & '('-' ## !,

# # #!# , # ## 6 ) ! ( ## # 6 ! + "# 49 !% ( :! ! ! #%

: !# , # #% ##% !# ##% % #

! !#( # ! # / # ;

! # #% #% % # #% / ! !% !#

< % #% !% ( ( !% * % # ;

# ( # + ! # % ! # % ( !% * ;

* + # ! # % ##% /; # !#%( #% !# ( ( !% * % # # % ! <

-5

( * ! # ( , # ( # # ## + 6 !% % # ;

!% # %6 = !# % !#% # # # =; !#

! + ( # ! "# --> & ,#-16%#%$1#1614(, %$,,%'

::, 8.

5.<5 / 51#6 <. /// <.

3 0 /4 /5/ ". .7.

. A4.

@.11 3.

0 9( 1$11

*6,,%',#%,1#%'1&3

,1$%,%21%>$/,41, 2,#/$$('%,1,2#1%%#$$' %#-#/6,,411$'-%1%%'-#(/#( #4#%%$#4%#14-##1

6 6,# ,#% 4 4%1 #4* /'1 $%-#1''1#$%

",%'1#

%@'(*1/-,62*,%#-%1%-%%1 /#$1/4(8 1'/,$'%,#/

%114'1#/#%22$2 A!&'"%$$9 8%$9 !")* !")* !57:( .1 /0 0 0 /6 .2 @B ./

& /B

0 0 .C & /B