Bimla And ANR. v. Krishan Kumar And Others

GAURAV SOROT 2024.02.12 23:13


    









    





 


 











!"



   ! "

"    $

 
 %

&
&

'
#%
  
 (&%
 )'
#% 
&
 * +


 
,(
 )&'
#%
 
- 


./ 0

  




*!

+ 2 &

&
(
 #
(0
 3 )
 & / 
 /

/

'
4 ##
% #

##
25&
6

0'
7827


(0


#

 # 
. /


'
6&,,
*& 

(



#

9&


:+'





#&




/

%&  
 # 
##
8;227828 7 !

8;227828'

( 
8788
/'


#
&
4 43 )
4
% )
$
, 

 
6&,, '
4&
&0
4 
& 
(0
" &
.
(

)
)
 <= ;<-5'
#
(0





2


&
 ) ) 
/






,

&
 # 
 #


 /(#

&/
>
-2<
##
;&
%/( '

7828
)

 

7;5'
--;'
-8?


$.

$ 
  '
 '

6&,,
4 ) #'
)


&

2@# ) )
&  # 
-
. /



# #'
 #
&
  

 

2==


& 
'
25AA
*&  

#


9&
:+


#&



3 )
/


&





<8'88'888@  ) &
# #
4
)#
( 
2A
0

#

(   




4



)

7<'888@

/ &
(0
# )
 '
)  


 #
# 0
 ) 4 3


*# '
4

+
 #
&  % # ) '
# #
&
% /

&
 /




 #
/

 &
 # '
)
 /

&
# #'
# 0

 /

# #
 #
&
  / 

3
/


>

&

2
 #
7
)#
&
 
/  
& 
 

&
(& 
 &
 / 


-
 
#
&

2
&#
% #
 #
 %
# % )
 



&
#

 # 
 #
# #
&

 (  0

0
 0
/


&
 /  < !

&
# )

&
   '
&



 /#
4 )

 B&&
&
 # 


#
# 

&
 ) ) % )

%& 
 <= ;<-5
(0

2C !$$

   B&&
  


  #

%
/

 /
&
C



4&
D C
!$$  B&& 
2
&#

% #
 #
 %
# % )   

&
#0

 # C
!$ %
  = 

#


'



/ 

% # '


4 #
&

%


&
 / #


#
&
4 #


7'-='888@
 ) 4 &

E
;<F


/
 /
&
#

  )

&
  
 


 G  #
/#

, 0
 % 0
 (

 0
& 4 #
 )
#

  #
4 &
&
4 ##
/

'
&
 / '
 

&
 ;


#




&

&%


 #
&
 )


&
)

&


#





)
/

&
# #'

4&
4
2A
0

#
0

)
/
4 &

( )&



&
# #
4



)
&
 /#
/
(0
) % )
 '
)  


4 3
 #

) 
/ 3
#  0

) #
&
%
/ /
4) %  )

&
 /'



3 #
4 3
4 

?'<88@

/ &'
0
&


#


 # #
/ &0
/


7'888@ '


&
&
/ /
4)   (/  )
&
&
/
& #

&%
(

#


4
&
& /
4) 




&
 ##
&
&


#



&

// #



4& 
4 )
& )









&
/


4 ##

&
 
&# 




4 &
&
4
 #
#4
(0
 :(
&
 /
.



$%&'($) (*+,$(-.

'/0$(1 2* $,($1 ".%3&#
  &2&) 4

 A . 0'


#



 
- 

 ./ 0
#
&
/

&
# #
&
( )&0
# #
E
7'888@ 

&
# #
( )
(& '
##  

<8F
&
( )&0 /#
(0
&


#


'
 H


 
(0
&
.

 4% '
&


#







./ 0
 #

# 0
& ) 

/

&
 
&#

) 









4 &
&
#  

 #
#4
$,($1 ".%3&5*  
*

+
 #
4#

%

&


H 
,  5 

#




&
  
&%
) #
&
 
 (
# ##

&
(


/ 
% (

&

(3 28 
&%
& #


#




&
   #
&%


#
& 
(3 22 & 

# 
&


# #
#
 # 

;& %/( '
7828
%% )
&
 )
%& 



#




& 


./ 0
4

(

# 0
&
# #
4
2A
0


)
 &
 /

 # '
 #
&
/ /
4)


3 #
4 3
4
?'-?A@

/ &




&
# #
4

/

#






&
 @ /
 
 #

# 0
&

# /  
&
/
  #


&
   /

&
# # 4% '


#


'

)
&
/

&
# #'
 #
   
&
# #
4
0

)
(0

2A
0


)
4 &

( )& 


"%


)

&
/ /
4) %  )

&
 /
4
?'<88@ /
'
&
#


7'888@ '/
(0
&


#




)   0
4

 #



(
,

  #

 
&
/

& #

#


?'-?A@

/ &'
( #


/ /
4)


6 27  /  0'

) 






&
/
 # #
  

/   

(


&
)

 '

&


(


)

&
# #
&
(

 #
(0


#





 / '
( )
 0

&


 
 #
 




*

+    

2A

(


)

&
# #
 #
) 







?8F
&%
(

)#
(0
&




&
 / '

(
3 '
4&    )
&
/


2-








#/ #0'

 '


#



&
3
&   

&
(


)

 '
4& &

  0


 #  4 &
&
#  

 #
#4

     

          







   

 ! "

# 

$ " %  &'



(((  )*  :(
&
 /
.


&
( %#


I2;
&
 

/   
( #

&
)

& # #
 

&
(


&
)

#  & 
/0
(


/(

#

&
# 4& 
)
/0
(
#  
 #'
&  '
&
)
 #
& 
D

4 &
&
/  
 /

J




>

&
+ & " 

( %#
&
&
)
 # & #
(
&
(


0 )
&
/    
2?

 
 '
 /
 


&
# # .

)
&
)

# #'
/   

2A
#

(
 #



&
(
 % ##

&
, 
# % #
(0
 :(
&
 / .



 " 4& &
4
 %#
(0
&
.

    &
, 

+ & "  #
4#

%

H

7 ,  2<
$



4 &4
&

/


4
) #
4

9


 :'
9


  


/:



# #

+ &  " '
, 
# % #

-228782;'
 :(
&
 / .


( %#


I<5-
B& 
#

)
&
/'

##  
 <8F

 
 0

&
/

&
# 4



 '
4& 
&
# #
&#
  / 
,(
 #
4
(4
&
)

?8
0

& # (
/#
&
##   & #
(
-8F'

&
)

& # #
4
(4
?8

<8
0



 
& # #
4
(4
&
)

<8

=8
0

'
& ##   & #
(
2<F
 
 0
& #
(
#


 
 0


D <5?

 
&
# #
4  /0#

  D#
 0'

##  

?8F

&
 ( &#
/

& #
(
&
4


4& 
&
# #
4
(4
& )

?8
0



##  

7<F
4& 
&
# 4
(4
&
)

?8

<8
0

#
28F
4& 
& # #
4
(4
&
)

<8

=8
0

& #
(

) ##

&


0
/&#

/   
& ( &#
/
/

&
/
/

&
D /  <5A
 (
 )


&
 
&# '

/0'



 '





/
 #


 D

& #
(
 2<'888@ '
 ?8'888@
  2<'888@  %0
&
  #
/

& # (
 & #

&


28F

% 0
& 
0

J
2= &
  #
( % 

4 
  #


,- .  $ " %  &'

# "  /""  

 () ()"  " ( 
( % )
&



)
&

 
& #


/

@# )&
/
 # 
 
  #

( 4 ##
/


9




/:

&
&#

9   

/:


0 



 %1

$ " % '

(     (22
( %#
&





(
) #



 

)

  
/
 :(
&
 /
.




 , 

".    3   '4   ,"

 5  

 "-'



 

  6
4& 
0 )

&
, #  
 #  )
+ & " #
  "
 ) &
--
( %#


I--

&
 
 '
&
.
&#
) #
 /)
/




<'888@
4





/ 4% '
&
 )&
.


) #


/



;8'888@


 ##
/




  &# '
4& &
 ##





/'



  #



D



&
 

$ 0
&
*

+'

.

 
 &

&
.


&#
 % ##
&
 # & #
(
 0
4 ##
4


 

/
 #
&#
 0
4 ##

?8'888@

&
 &
# 
.

)
&
/'

/



?8'888@
&

4 ##

&

&


#

4





/J 2; 
% 4

&
  #
#
)


  '
 #


/

, #  
#

'
&
 / 
  #

(
/

#

&
 
&# 
&
4 #
/


# #


(4

/

&
# #
K


)
K
2A
0



K
/

/


) %
(0


#
.
K

7'-='888@  )
4 &
;<F



/

8 .$**.**/.(% '9 $:$,;

$/'+(%

", '

.$;* (-'/.

&( +0..* 2 


 /
<7'2;=@ 7 #  
2@7

( )

/

7='8AA@ - >



?8F

% 4

,$($1 ".%3& $(;

<&,%&
*

+
-='<7-@ *
7='8AA@
L

28'?-<@
+ ?     2A < 



# 0
='<;'?2?@ *
-='<7-
D
2A+ = 


 
*28F
  

% 0
& 
0

% 4

$ 0
&
*

+
2A'2<8@
2A'2<8@ ; 





D

*28F
  

% 0
& 
0

% 4

$ 0
&
*

+
5='A88@ A 


  


/
D
7  /

*28F
  

% 0
& 
0

% 4

$ 0
&
*

+ 5 
;'58'<2?@ 2A

##  )
&
/


 #0
4 ##
(0
&




'
&
 & #
/



/

&#

(

<'<?'<2?@ *
;'58'<2?@


7'-='888@ +
&

'
 / 
  #


<'<?'<2?@
%

#
(%'
&
/


 #0
) #
(0


#


'

 )
4 &
/





) #
(0


#



 /
&
#

  )
&   
 
  G  '
0(
4 &
-8
#0
 /
&
#

 
    #
0

&
, 
/

)
 #  


#



/

) %
(0


#



&
/

 #
#


/
& &
/

'

 0'
 #0
# #
(0



/ 0
&
( #,

# 25

&
 
4 #


#

78  )0'

 

#
(0
&
 /
4#

& (%
 
25 


 

4 78
 
&
/
 
&
(
# ##'
 )
/  

   * +'

 0'
 
 
# #

 )0

     


   $+,$2 "','% Whether reasoned / speaking?

Yes / No Whether reportable?

Yes / No