Kohli Holdings Private Limited v. State Of Haryana





    
 


 



 !"#" $%&'(  % & ) #%*  !% +,        !"#  $ %"&     !"# '"& (")%" % 

%')% -) %.&/!

%+!.$$%/"-.&- %)!" %0 -) %.&/!

%)!"**%-.&- %')!%(-.&-%0&%1&-.&- %
23"-.&- %&*)%4,-.&-

%!, % %.

54%"-. ".&-3 %"-#%*  % 6! 5!%-. .&3 %"-#%*  7, !/ -.& 


- %) ,4$"-.& 


8

- "(!%-.& % %,52"* -.&- 
9

 :

- %)45! ,) $!-.& % %'5!) !"-.&- 
 :9 8 :- 8 -



  6) -.& % %)4,!6 -.&-



8-9 - 

- %#);;
 % %2%%-.& % %.5!,) $!-.&- %
+2

$ %"&*  <!%%/"", /%, =% $
  -  8-

- 

- 8 -  :-

8- :

-

- -

-9

-

  9 -9 -9 -988-9

-9

-9 9-

8- :

- :9- 8 - 8 :- -  - 9-  :-

-

 9 :

  (( >4 "/  % &"&!%  <!, %!% !&!"" $!>4 /!% 4 8   !' .>4 .- 8 %!%-?!9 8.?/%4 8

:  :

8- %,&"*<!" /4$!=>4% % $%,"

$ &",( !@A-;

4%""</ !, %=4

%;

4%"-+ "-
((%"-;

4 "-%% " !% 4="  7"    &""$  '5!

4"-  !%,4%   -   %- 4% $,4%-  <!"   %     &""$   5%"-  <!"     % 34%$  /34%4$%( '%   4 "  %  !  , %  4=(  !  ! >4 >4 !", "* 8.!= 4,%%! ( !+$!B%
(, <% ,% * ' .>4 -+!=" +"( .-

: %!%-!

:.?;

%( 8 

:.-  >4 !=!%4 %!".-

("*-!9 8.-/!!/!4  !% ;

!,% -   8. /4 :

8<!4!= $  =*B4""2 !

!
4% 
8:



 
 

        A64$( :9

-!=

, ! "*!/!%   .!= 4,%%

8-! 4%!%,% $ =

: %% %(

:.- %!%," 9 8. ) 8

:.%,%4!%4 % @

8 +&#," "!"-# & #! ./ .012  %    &

 &  !  %'

 - &  "  # !" #

3 /!  $   *! $      

!.- * >4 ,% $ 4 %!' .>4 .-9 8

8-@  /!% /%4 %  ! '   .>4  .  !  =  (-  ! -  ""

,%& !.%" $!%( 

(, !"",,"*C% =/!% /%4 % !=

(-! 4!,% $!""  44 %! ,%& !' .>4 .- .! = %,"D <! ",  E,%=*!B4""2 ! !
4%

 

?4,%-E%="/ @  <!  ,% $    ,4%4   

8.%"( "*

%,4%,  4 $,%"( %* >4%* % %%* $  4  !  4%&*    4="*   !  " ,%,    =  >4%  2-  ,,%  ! " / % !,,%,%3&% ( F  

>4%!" !!* "=6 -

 * "!%!=6  = B%!,4%, ,*( (, - ! !" 8.=5 %!,4%, E $! %=, %,4="  " ,% %G !%%  4%!%%  - =- !%%"!$-!%

8 ("*%"<!% %-& !4$! !  .5 ! %!%(  %  (, =4  &%!"      = 5 !  ,% $4 %! "9 8.<!,% $ %>4  ==  "* %4,,"

( /!!!$ "%  8.  <!'$"4%=*) 8 !/

:.!,%& %!" >4 ,% (!&", % 4 %!" 8.;,%&! /!  $ *! $    !/

:. *!" >4 ,% $H F4 %!"9 ./!% /%4 !% !=

(-! ""!,%& !/

:. %" $%(  (, %,,"* <!,,"="* !,%& !/

:

. %,*( (, /4" "*=

,% $4 %!"9 8.!=  = %  

8/!!!,, * %! 

%( !/

:.  <!,,"="*  ) 8  !/

:./!!"/!%," & $"% !E  &$!!"9 8.!""

 %,"<!

 )4=)  ! &!%/,%& !/

:.-! %,"  4 %  )4=  )    !""    =  !"   ,%64%

!$ %",," 

3
.+," (% (%

%(=4 4= ,  $ !  

!  '$"4%  ;

 !         !% E,%"*%=* %*(," !/

:

 ./=%$%/,

8. /!""*% ,%! /4"= "%   %,"<!%," %, 8. "  %)4=)  8 /

:.,%&C!/&%-=*)4=)    ,%64%

!$ %",,"

  

3
.  <!  / 

:  .  ,%&  %  &%"

 (,%%*-  ,%$%&     ""*  =  "

"$"&(4%=%5 $/* %(!

  !,%!"/ ,%&(! ( % %(     "  (,     ,4="  ,4%, /!! !% 8.<!/

:

.=" /%,%& $ %!=  "

,%& "$" !" / %/!" 4$!=>4%!!*$!=  

! /"$"&,   <! 44 "9 8.= %!,, *  

8 %!/

:./4"  4%(

,%& %(   ) 8

3
. "* !,% $4 %!" 8  .  !&  =  H F  = %   

8 /!!/4"=!!%!= 4,,"

(  ""/=*"%   "9 8. $ . ,4="!4 "  9 8  .    !  

"  3G  =4    !

/,,%"% %!(( ( !/

:.  

8/4" =4 ="

"/!" 4!,4=" !$& $  4!,4=" =5 ! ,4="    !    ;     "*    ! ,4=" !" ! =

  !!%/ !

,%  ="!( "=6  ! <!!% $ =6 4 @. !,4="   "9 8./4" =,%(=" %%,"

  %(( ( !/

:. %(

 

8!,% $

=!& = H F4 %!"9 8. ! "%  4 %  )   !%  !    =

4  "*/! !"% 4! !" >4 ,% =!&=

H F;

!%/%- "%

%(   8.   = %  

8-!" >4 ,% $ 

=!&=  !% %- /4"",=*&%4 8 !/

:.D '% 4 " %!) ,4! % "$", # 4%!%4=(! %!>4%" !/%/ ,



-!/&%- !,%  -!/%/  

4 =*!' .>4 
""%-!%/ %(* $% =*!
4% .

%!% $"% 4 " %!,%  % $ !4=(  =& !&/E,%=*B4""2 ! !
4%  

?4,%- 4%&/-! % ) 8.- 8

:-!",>4!, %- "%   8.! = 4= % %," 8.  (

:. 

8;

,%      4 %  )     !  .  /  4  

 

:

8 #/&%-!)!""="=%*!%  %!

,% $ %>4 % $/!!" / % % ,4%! $% $!"  % /!"/- !" 

>4    %>4%  %  (,"     *  ,%6  %  !%/  <! , %!""(  4>4%$% $!"  >4 % ,% E( ! ="!)5 .""!%4 % !/%, %" , !
4%! E,% * ,  !%  <!/%, %, % $"* +6!2 " 04$ 

34%& %) $!3"" & 04$ !!%,5 $%  1 !!%+,%=" 1