Darshan Singh v. Union Of India & ORS

  


   

 
   

 !"# !"#

$%& '&()*)+, -.


  

    

   

  
 ", / 0"1
 1 

/ 0"1
  11  2&*&+%, "2 3*4$5 4$+61&+)2 '7($%&8)%4 "2 9$+'&&:1)+;4$<8$26 '7($%& 2%4&:&%)%)+&2  $=&*4 )+'$< 4&:2&*&+%:&%)%)+4$*>&&+ )<&'(4$<<&+;)+;%4&7)2&*

1&(%)+  %4&);4%%$)2
9:&+*$%)+$+'2$+*:$2&+(5)+0$+'

(?@)*)%)+6&4$>)<)%$%)+$+' &A*&%%<&9&+% (%6

2*42%6/%4&

(%/# 0&$2+&'(@+*&< 2%4&:&%)%)+&2*@>9)%%&'%4$%%4&<$+' :&%)%)+&2  8$*  +%) )&'  2  $(?@)*)%)+  @+'&2  1&(%)+      %4&  0$+'

(?@)*)%)+  (%6   -  2  *42%6  /%4&   -  (%/#  +   

  4& :&%)%)+&2 )<&'>=&(%)+*@+'&21&(%)+

 %4& - (%+ 

B %$((&:%)+;%4&*$9&6%4&<$+'8$*+%) )&'@+'&21&(%)+ %4& -

(%  +  

B  4&  0$+'  (?@)*)%)+ 
<<&(%2  2  *42%6  /%4&
<<&(%2/#$++@+(&'%4&$8$2'+

-4&:&%)%)+&2(4$<<&+;&'

%4&$(?@)*)%)+>5 )<)+;
 

$2*4$+1)+;471%$%&

$25$+$$+'%4&2*6 84)(48$*')*9)**&'>5%4)*(@2%7)'&2'&2'$%&' 

7&+&%)%)+ 21:&()$<0&$7&% ::&$<
)7)<#-.

)<&'$;$)+*%%4&2'&2:$**&'>5%4)*(@2%8$*')*9)**&'>5+/><&

  %4&1@:2&9&
@2%+-

+%4&$ 2&*$)' $(%@$<9$%2)D6%4&7)2&* 

(%$2&*@;4%%>&(4$<<&+;&'+%4&;2@+'%4$%%4&:&2)' )D&'

%4&2&)+4$*++&D@*8)%4%4&>=&(%*@;4%%>&$(4)&7&'4&

(% 4$*  >&&+  &+$(%&'  2  :27)')+;  =@*%  $+'  $)2  (9:&+*$%)+  %  %4& <$+'8+&2*6 84*&<$+'4$*>&&+$(?@)2&'4&2&)*++&D@*8)%4%4& >=&(%*@;4%%>&$(4)&7&')+ )D)+;%4&:&2)' )7&5&$2* 29%4&'$%&  (99&+(&9&+% (%%*4@<'4$7&>&&+ )7&5&$2* 29%4&'$%&  $8$2'+%4&($*&)+4$+'6:**&**)+ %4&<$+'4$*+%>&&+%$3&+& $<*  2& &22&'  %  $  (99@+)($%)+  '$%&'  

  29  '9)+)*%2$%26 

64%$3%
4)& '9)+)*%2$%26

64%$3+*@::2% 4)* $2;@9&+%2&;$2')+;$2>)%2$25 )D$%)+ (@%A

'$%&62&<)$+(&8$*:<$(&'

@:+%4&=@';9&+% +/><&%4&1@:2&9&
@2%)+ 1$3$2$$+'%4&2* 7+)+ +')$6 - .#1

.

$+'=@';9&+%* %4)*(@2%)+
   

BC"$4$2$+$2$%$:
4$2)%$><&2@*% &;'#71%$%&

$25$+$$+'%4&2*6'&()'&'+ 

$+'




C 1@+)%$1$42$8$%$+'%4&2*71%$%& $25$+$$+'%4&2*6'&()'&'+

-



%&24&$2)+;<&$2+&'(@+*&< 2%4&:&%)%)+&268&'+% )+'

$+59&2)%)+%4&*@>9)**)+*9$'&4&(4$<<&+;&)+%4&:2&*&+%:&%)%)+% %4&7)2&* 

(%)**@;4%%>&9$'&+<5+%4& ;2@+'%4$%%4&(@%A

'$%& )D&')*$2>)%2$254&2&<&7$+%:27)*)+* 1&(%)+$2&&D%2$(%&'>&<8, E           !""

#  

$       "          % # %8)%4*%$+')+;$+5%4)+;(+%$)+&')+%4)* (%6)+$+5($*&

<$+'  $(?@)*)%)+  :2(&&')+;*  )+)%)$%&'  @+'&2  %4&  0$+'

(?@)*)%)+ (%6 -6A $#84&2&+$8$2'@+'&21&(%)+ %4&*$)'0$+'

(?@)*)%)+ (%4$*>&&+9$'&6%4&+6$<<:27)*)+*

%4)* (%2&<$%)+;%%4&'&%&29)+$%)+ (9:&+*$%)+ *4$<<$::<5F2 >#84&2&$+$8$2'@+'&2*$)'1&(%)+4$*>&&+9$'&

. %4&+  *@(4  :2(&&')+;*  *4$<<  (+%)+@&  @+'&2  %4& :27)*)+* %4&*$)'0$+' (?@)*)%)+ (%6$*) %4&*$)'

(%4$*+%>&&+2&:&$<&'

#%8)%4*%$+')+;$+5%4)+;(+%$)+&')+*@>A*&(%)+ #6)+ ($*& <$+'$(?@)*)%)+:2(&&')+;*)+)%)$%&'@+'&2%4&0$+'

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

:&2@*$<

(%*48*%4$%%4&*$9& *%$2%* 8)%4$++A>*%$+%&(<$@*&1@>A*&(%)+ #%4&2& :27)'&*%4$% 84&2&:2(&&')+;*4$7&>&&+)+)%)$%&'@+'&2%4& - (%$+'+$8$2'4$'

>&&+:$**&'@+'&2%4$% (%6%4&+%4&:27)*)+*2&<$%)+;%'&%&29)+$%)+

(9:&+*$%)+@+'&2%4&

(%*4$<<$::<5 +  %4&  :2&*&+%  ($*&6  $'9)%%&'<5  %4&  $8$2'  8$*  :$**&'  + 

->& 2&%4&&+$(%9&+%

(%4&2&%4&$8$2'4$'>&&+ :2+@+(&'  @+'&2  %4&   -  (%6  %4&  :2(&&')+;*  @+'&2  %4$%  (%  8)<< (+%)+@&) %4&*$9&4$'+%>&&+2&:&$<&' 1@>A*&(%)+

(%6%4&7)2&*

84)(4  4$7&  >&&+  (4$<<&+;&'   >5  %4&  :&%)%)+&26  :27)'&*  %4$% +%8)%4*%$+')+;$+5%4)+;(+%$)+&')+1&(%)+  #

(%6 84&2&$8$2'@+'&21&(%)+ %4& - (%4$'>&&+9$'& 5&$2*2 92&:2)2%%4&(99&+(&9&+%

(%6)&6

>@%:45*)($<

 :**&**)+ %4&<$+'4$'+%>&&+%$3&+2%4&(9:&+*$%)+4$'+%>&&+ :$)'%%4&<$+'8+&2*6%4&*$)':2(&&')+;* *4$<<>&'&&9&'% 4$7& <$:*&'27)*%%4&$ 2&*$)':27)*)+:27)'&*%4$%&7&+)+%4&($*&* 84&2&%4&$8$2'4$'>&&+9$'&>@%(9:&+*$%)+)+2&*:&(% 9$=2)%5

%4&<$+'4<')+;*4$*+%>&&+'&:*)%&')+%4&$((@+%* %4&>&+& )()$2)&*6 %4&+$<<%4&>&+& )()$2)&**4$<<>&&+%)%<&'%(9:&+*$%)+)+$((2'$+(& 8)%4%4&:27)*)+* %4&

(% 4&;2)&7$+(& %4&:&%)%)+&2)*%4$%%4&:&2)' 5&$2*2 92& :27)'&':2)2%%4&'$%&  (99&+(&9&+%

(%)* @+2&$*+$><&4&:&2)'*4@<'4$7&>&&+ 5&$2* 29%4&'$%& $8$2'6 84)(4  8@<'  4$7&  2&*@<%&'  )+  %$3)+;  %4&  '$%&  %  $  '$%&  $ %&2  %4& (99&+(&9&+%

. (%684&2&$*%4&>=&(%)*%;)7&>&+& )%% (&2%$)+($%&;25 <$+'8+&2*84&2&%4&1%$%&3&:%?@)&%$+'')'+%%$3& *%&:*&)%4&2%%$3&:**&**)+ %4&<$+''&*:)%&:2+@+(&9&+% $8$2'

2%:$5(9:&+*$%)+%%4&<$+'8+&2*

%&2(+*)'&2)+;7$2)@*=@';9&+%* +/><&%4&1@:2&9&
@2%)+(<@')+;%4&=@';9&+%)+  1$3$2$/* ($*& *@:2$#6+/><&%4& 1@:2&9&
@2%)+ 1%$%& @+=$>$+'%4&2*7 9$2$%45$<$+'

%4&2*6

#1

B :)+&'%4$%8)%42& &2&+(&%(@%A

'$%&6%4&2& ($++%>&$+5*(4&9&84)(4($+>&4&<'%>& <:2 $*%4&2&*4$<< $<8$5*  >&  $  *&(%)+    :&2*+*6  84  9$5  >&  $'7&2*&<5  $

&(%&'  2 &D$9:<&684&2&(@%

'$%&)**%$+@$25 $5&$26$+5:&2*+ $<<)+;+ .*%  &(&9>&28@<'>&$'7&2*&<5$

&(%&'$+'9$52$)*&$:<&$%4$%

)D$%)+ (@%A

'$%&)*$2>)%2$251)9)<$2)*%4&7)&8&D:2&**&')+%4& *@>*&?@&+%=@';9&+%* +/><&%4&1@:2&9&
@2%)+ 7&2+9&+%

+'42$2$'&*4$+'%4&2*71@>>4$2$5@'@$+'%4&2*6

#1

F 1@'4)2H@9$2
+*@<7 <<$4$>$' $+36

#.1

 $+'

")+&2$<D:<2$%)+
2:2$%)+0%'7 27)+'H@9$2 )D)%$+'$+%4&26

#.1

 .

4&(+%&+%)+2$)*&'>5<&$2+&'(@+*&< 2%4&:&%)%)+&2%4$% %4&(@%A

'$%&*4@<'4$7&>&&+ 5&$2* 29%4&'$%& $8$2'69&$+)+;

%4&2&>5%$3)+;)%>&5+'%4&(99&+(&9&+%

(%6)*9&2&<5%>& +%)(&'$+'2&=&(%&' 2%4&2&$*+%4$%%4&*$9&8@<'4$7&;)7&+<&7&2$;&

  %%4&
<<&(%2%%$3&:45*)($<:**&**)+ %4&<$+') +%$<2&$'5%$3&+ +%4&'$%& %4&(99&+(&9&+%

(%2:$5%4&(9:&+*$%)+ +($*&%4&:&2)'8$**%)<<$7$)<$><&6%4&*$9&(@<'2&*@<%)+')*(2)9)+$%25 $+'$2>)%2$25&D&2()*& :8&24&$2<)$9&+%)+)%*8)*'94$'2);4%<5 +%<& %%4$%')*(2&%)+8)%4%4&
<<&(%2 2%4&2&$*+* 9&+%)+&'$>7&68&' +% )+' %4$% %4& :27)*)+* 

. (%$2&@<%2$7)2&* ((2')+;<56 %4&82)%:&%)%)+)*')*9)**&' $=&*4 )+'$<# @';&  $2)+'&21)+;41)'4@# @';&

-.

 & &2%&:2%&2#