High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/24296/2018disposed of

Abhishek v. Punjabi University, Patiala & ANR

2018-12-18Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma3 pages

! "#$%#&'

&($($)*&+ &+%,% ,*-."$*$/&+%$(0! .($.1..*2.*)(#&+

&%3)*2&*(% 4

+&%&*( +&%&*( +&%&*( +&%&*( + .2#+.*!2/)6.(&7)+(#&3&($($)*&+ + "#$%#&'8.,%#$'!2/)6.(&7)+ + $3,1$*2.1!2/)6.(&7)+(#&+&%3)*2&*(% 9:9:9:

9:9:9:

! %#)+(;+$((&*%(.(&<&*()7 +)7 .*-$( $*=# $--.+!

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

&($($)*&+$%%(.(&2()#./& +&<.$*&2+&=,1.+%(,2&*()7(#&+&%3)*2&*(4*$/&+%$(03,+%,$*=

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

$*6&(#&3+.0&+.*2=+$&/.*6&+.$%&2$*(#&3&($($)*&+ )(#&+;$%&#.%"&&*+&2+&%%&2!$*%(.*(3&($($)*$%2$%3)%&2)7.% $*7+,6(,),% $"&+(0! #);&/&+! $% =+.*(&2 () (#& 3&($($)*&+ () .33+).6#(#&6)<3&(&*(.,(#)+$(0,*2&+(#&+&%3)*2&*(4 ,*-."$ *$/&+%$(0! .($.1.%&&'$*=6)++&6($)*)7#$%<)(#&+5%*.<&7+)< .2#, &&*.1() .2#, &&*.$*(#&+&%,1(46,<42&(.$1&2<.+'% 6.+2E &=+&&3&+(.$*$*=()(#&(#+&&0&.+% &=+&&6),+%& .1)*=;$(#+&1&/.*(%,33)+($*=2)6,<&*(%;#&+&$**.<&)7(#& <)(#&+$%+&71&6(&2.% .2#, &&*.

*(#&&/&*(,.1$(0)7.*0 %,6#+&D,&%(E+&3+&%&*(.($)*"&$*=<.2&!(#&+&%3)*2&*(4 ,*-."$ *$/&+%$(0! .($.1.;),12"&)"1$=.(&2()6)*%$2&+(#&%.<&$* .66)+2.*6&;$(#1.;.*22&.1;$(#(#&%.<&&>3&2$($),%10.*2$* .*06.%&;$(#$*.3&+$)2)7%$>;&&'%7+)<(#&2.(&)7%,"<$%%$)* )7%,6#+&D,&%(E+&3+&%&*(.($)*

$%3)%&2)7 ?

@ ?

)(&

)(& #&(#&+%3&.'$*=E+&.%)*&2

&%E ) #&(#&+&3)+(."1&

&%E )