High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7901/2013dismissed

Parvati Devi v. Union Of India And ORS

2024-12-09Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj9 pages

!"#$%"&'('#)*+ +

* - .+/0

/+

!"

#$ %

&

'( )

* !" '+ 0

/+ 1+

2 3

, ,

(-./0.(. 12

*

3

"

& "

2,

3 35 ,3*'*

, 3

,

15 ,3* 1

0-.6(/+0 ,

3"

*2"

7 3

2% 3

*2

* '

8

1 & 5

8 ' !*2#

9'!:$.-./(/+07

,

%;" 1 (/+) 3

3, "

*2"

3% 3#;<$3

3

;< "

"

"

12" *

2 7' * = %* !

* 1

, & >

*>

12

2 7* ! 3

*

?

3 "

(/@. "

1

; #&

$& %

* *'+0+?&( (@.60../

2 &** 5

3 1*

5 ,3*

0+.6(/@/ ""

1

3 3

=

*

3

3

" 2 72 0/.A0../

3

72 7 3 3

&

" 2 72 ,

& **

1 2 3 0).A0.(.

)..A0.(. '+ "; *

27*

!

5 ,3*3

1

"* 1

2

C 2

*

2

(-./0.(. ')

" 2 72

"2

* 3

1

"

,

3

(/@.

0../0.(.

&

" 2

72

" >>

#'D $ 2 7* !

* % "

!

" 5 ,3*3 4 "

"

*

3 3

'! ,

* * , ""

5 ,3 * 1

=

"

*, 1

3 "

'( )

* "

3

,

>

* >

:

(/A03* (/@. 3 * 3

(/@.7 "

"

"

* 1

, ,* ** * * C* =

"

3

!

" #$

""

%

! ' %

$ "

'( )

*

+ %

(

( " (

" #!

'%

,

"

"%

% "#"(

'

%

-

,

!

"

% % $ "

' "

$ "

"#

+ % .

'

,

( %

"

(

'%

"

"

% "#"

,

/,*&*0(

"'

"

1

#"

2

'(

"'

1 3 <

"

1

3

""

2

"

'!& 2 *

"

=

'!& 1

23

"

,

>

* , , "* 2

1232& :?

: "

"

,3

,

"3 1

=

*

** " 1 "

& 23

"* 2

"** 12

? = 2 !* ""

=

"* ? ?

1 % 12

&

1 C* ,

2 "

2

3

(/@.

"* 1*

3 2" 3

3

3 %**

3 , "

!

4

1

' #!

'

# '

'%

" #

4 !

'

#"

'

%

#"

" # 5

! +

" '# ' " &

"

" ""

'#

"

""' / " &

""'1"

'

"&

"

" ""

!

'

# %%

( % " # 3 "

'( )"

** 12

1

122"*

=

, " 5 ,3 * 2>

**

* " 2 * C* 1

,

"

, "

"* "

*

2

1

** 12

1 " 1 , 7

2

12 '+"

3 5 ,3* "

2"

1

(/@/

!>E((A0 3

* "

"

*

1

3

" ,3* 1

,8

'!7

1

2"

1

" 1

5

1

'( ) 12

" 2 27* ! >

*>

1

" & & #&&$1*

=

C "

!

6 $ (

"

" ' 2(

! "

(

' (

# %

"

7

( &

(

2

1 # # #' " (

" &

(

,&

# #' "

#" %

$ "

'

% ' % "% "

#"

%! #

""

"

"

' "

#"

' #' $

2

8"'9- # &

,

$ " *'9:

"" " &;< "

"

%

( % '

"

"

$ "'#"

' ('#

' '#

' #

% "

(

#

" "

#"

%! " #' '

#' $

2

8"'

9- '

$ " *'9:

#'

#

2

(2

" % % " =-=9 "%

"

(

# 2

2

""'

" ==99- ->-9- # #'&

( # $

2

8"'9- # "

2 ?

( "

# "

2

# "

' 2

" %

" =-=9

7

,@,- % !

6 $ ( "

&

#

"'#

#'

"+ %

#'

+ %

6 $ (

" &

( + %

7

%

#"3 " *

,

& & 1

5 ,3*8 '! F 2(/+0 3

" '! 3 "

.(./(/+0 7

3 "" 5 ,3* 8 '! F 2(/+0!"" , 2

& & 3

2* 7

1*

, 3

3

6

*

" 2"

* ** , " 2 1

1

"

3 "

8,*

7:1

& 3

7

& "" , 3

2 C*

2"

<

"

"* * 2

"

'

8 1

,*

I have heard learned counsel for the parties ,

,

"* ,3

=

*2 " , 1

3

(/@.

3

,,

"

1

* ,,

1

*

** 1

, "

!& & *

"2

1 2 *2 =

& &

,3

"

*

1 8 '! F 2(/+0=

2"

& 1

* "

12 ,

"

'!.(./(/+0 3

'! 1

2"

1 *1 (/+0

3"" 5 ,3* 8 '! F 2(/+0

& & 2

"

" 2 , 3

2"

3 1

1

*, *

2 =

2

18 12

*"

" "

"

3

" 12

"

3

(/@. 1

3

1

*

& " "

" 18 1 *"

"

, "

"* "

2

,

1 3

% 12 "1 1

, ,* * " =

1

1

1

1 =

3

"" , 2 * + + 0

/+

7 <

% ,? ?' <

1

?'