Rapal Jaidka v. Punjab State Power Corporation Ltd And ANR
!"#$$
!"!%"& !"$$
'( )*'
$ +', '
!"# $ %
!"#$ %&
!' #$ % & ', ' $ ( ) * *&&
$ ++,-++.&
& / &" " 0(12
" * *" & # &&" &+3* &
% " &$
4 -$$4 & 355,+5(6#
" " #
7 + )&& & # % # % & 4* 8
" 5((+(9.9 " & " & 4 +,5,+555:
%#
;
+<5.+5(+ $
=;(
4
'% & (3(5+555# "" %
-%
) & * 5<59+5(+
$
=;+;
)&# &" %# &
# 3559+5(6 & # " & " >+% 595.+5(< #
% ;
% % *
7* * &" %#&#* % #
" & *"# %* && &""# "* &"
* )&# " &?#+5(<# & & % ;
+ $ !$ -./0 1!%"-
$3 ( @* 9#3<#(.5-;
+
"" &
6#66#9(+-;
3 %4 "
*+5(3;+5(6 +#+5#555-;
6 $ &
6#(3#,15-;
)&# " (5((+5(< " &&" &+3 * & % "
&A >(.-(995$ )/ &" +6(++5(< $
=;.# $ &(999;+555
%/ &% #
* " 1593 4 # &*& " &$
4
* " % $
= ;9 ;(5# %# 355,+5(6#
" "* '
>159<# %
>1599# !"
>1(5(# @"
>1(53#?
1(5,#%
1((3 !
>1((1# " $
-$$4 &
& " *&;
' *& # & * % +.((+5(1
>(.6<;
:&+5(1#& /
#*&
# " & & ;
/ * *" &
&(3"
" &+3* &
%
" &$4-$$4 &355,+5(6
"% " 3 ?
& &" #* & * "
& * " +3* & % *+553 %"
& % %
355,+5(6#
" " / & &" %# &
# 3559+5(6 & " ;
+<5.+5(+
")
;
"
& &
% && 595.+5(< &;
#
&
*" " * 6
& " &" %# &
# 3559+5(6: %#;
+<5.+5(+
"# & *"
& &
595.+5(< & %*# & *# "* && &" # %# %* && &""B& " & &(3" &"
" #&# & * *" & B " 355,+5(6 &
*&;
+<5.+5(+ & "
&&" &+3* & % B &
(95+(99.
* 4*8 C@ & " D % &&&
" &&&-&&B " (<59+5((
*
!"#!
$% $ & '()*++ < #
& " ;
+<5.+5(+
" & " ;
"
& &
%* 595.+5(<# & &
"% " &?#+5(< & " " +3* & % *+553 %" & %
% 355,+5(6#
" " #&# #
"" & , /%
& %
. $ " *#;
+<5.+5(+
" * 5<59+5(+ * " & *% 595.+5(<# *
&
*
% % * 7* * &" %#&# % #
& *" * %* && "# ""* &"
* > *%*
&& &" & * % * ;
& && %*) & % &(3" $# " +3* &
% * +553#
& " &+3* & % &)/ &" +6(++5(<
& $ &*(999;+555
% / " & % 355,+5(6#
% "
# *
&;
+<5.+5(+#
&" * # %
;
% % *
#&# & & 0,2
"& * *" &
* & & " &+3* & % & " &$
4 -$$4 &355,+5(6#
" " 1 / " (<59+5((
*
"
# " &
% " & &&
9 / & !"#!
$% $ & '()*++ *
" " &
& " )% & " ;
!
$% $
, '() -
!
" #
, #
,.
/
$ %
& ' !
( ) *
+,-
./
&
! "
! $ 0 1## 2 3 0 .44/
+
! $ 0 1## & . #
1
.5,.46%
' 31,7
/, 8 9 6% $ 7 45/ 3 $ 63 :% 7 45%
$ ($ !
% $ - ;
" -; ;
6 7 4.46%
' 3157!
! $($ !
% !
' < "
/ #
.=.> $ ;
;
$
%"; -;
;
& " = !
&
1 %
1
& ?
(5 A#
(95+(99.
* 4*8 C@ & " D% &&&
" &&&-&&)
;
0 1"..%2 '3..% 1-2,2* 4") *@- !$
3 $ 9
! % 0-+9# + 9 3$9
. +* 3$9
3
/% %+ %+ 3
=%03+A:$ 3$93 3
,% $9+ 3$9 >% B9( 3$9 5% $ +D$ 3$9 -(@.,=+.5,=+- 1=4 4.445 $ C10 3 3$9 1
0 " -( 5/</>+5=,/>+- 1=4 .==44>
" !
: * " " "
"
%
& "
#
! &
!
"
" 3$9 C1 6%79 3
51--1*3678 91 % E %
+
51--1*367*9:
%
+
1
!
/
& . % C1 * '
C# /
% F0F
% FE 2
F ( 9;1361;*1 2 % #
% ) @
0 ! % 1 # % !@ % : 0% 0 ?
((
& * *" &
#A8 & 7 * <
&//='() - +
* * &# "* & )% & " ;
$
3
$ %
'
% ' -3
( G
6 7# $
?
(+ $&" # 8 & >
$% & +'()**'?")(
4 "* & " * *% & ) % & " ;
!
G # #
6 7#
$
$ ?
(3 / % &%# 0,2
" * *" & &5((++5(6 & " & " &*"
& & &" &+3 * & % & " & $
-$$4 &355,+5(6#
"% " #
7 # &53" &" &&& *& 2', ' $$ : - E -> : E ->