Ashiya & ORS. v. Jitender Kumar & ORS.

   
         

 !" # $# % ! &!' !" # $# % (   (#
######))**+!,

#   -.  (#

###### ) !!,

."

 /0 .(# (  (

(. 


 
  

 

  
  

 





 
  
  

  ! 
"# $

% &
'  
  

 (

)))) (

(.

#



*

 
 
'





+ 
   ,-

,
 
'$

 

 
"

#
* 
 

 

#
 
 

 
..



/ 

011
2 
3
* 45

 #

# 
 

 

# 


 

6 (,11,,7

+ 

8
.9

 # 
 

 


& #



/ 
 
 
 .

,.

,,



 

# 



 

  
:

 #

# 
+ 
'$

 
* 





  


 


 


:



'
 


 &

' $ (.

(( ( 

0   (0
 



(

*
 
 




#   

 
# 

'$

 
* 



+
 

 
'
 
*

 $
 


 
'
+


# 

# 
'
 


 
 +

(


 

 

 
* 
 

# 

 $


 
!
 

 

  * 
 



 

#   


 





 $


  


 

#  


2#
 
 ( 6 5


 
 

'  
$
# 

# 
 


' 
 

 #

-


 

 

 
* 
 


  

! 
"# $

 $

+ 


 
 


+ 
 '$



 #
#

+


   

.


 
 
 


 


+ #$
 
 

+ 
 
 $
'
 


# 
 # 

'$

 
* 
 
 $
'
 

*

 $

 #  




;

< 
 


  ! 
"# $ 
 

 
* 
 
+ 
  
# 
 # 




# 7   
 

 
 #  





 

$
# 

# 
+ 


1 # 


 
*

 
* 
 
 $

 # 


 $

 #  




!
 
 
 
 


 

 
 +


 
 
+ 
 '
  

(0 02

. (

4'
 #
" 


 

Sarla Verma Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another 34 $5  (&) 6  & , + 

7


+

 +

#

# 


 
 
 
 #

 =30
  

      

      

    

          

  

   

  
  

 

 



   

   

  

        



    !"#$      

  %#  !"&$       

  &'    !"($      

 


31
)

      

         *              (+,      

    





 

                 


 -

  

           

        

   

         $          .  /

 

     

    

            

  
*  

 

               



         

     
32
 

     

            (+,           

           (+,    

    
              



  

                                            

 

             
* * * * * * 42.)     

    

       &$        

     0

 1    $       

% !2    !(%+ %!%(

 $ 

    

  3!4 %'#+

 3!'#!#(

 3!(#'&+

 3!&&!&(

  3!#&'(+

   

    

   3!!(!((

 35(''+

 34 '!'(

  3(''4+

 ,

4'
 #
" 


 


National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. 34  (  7
 
  
 +

 
..
. 

.1



/ 

011
 
+ 
 25 >  

 

 
?
 # 
#   @ 2A5  

#   
 


  @ 2"5 

 

'



$ 
#   @ 2>5 6  '
  

  
 
 #$ 

 




#

  
? + 
 @ 2B5 % 



  



 

+ 
# 
C'@
 #$

 ? $ *
 
 


C #

 
 =52. 6  conventional heads



  

   

 7/

8
*   7
%(+++   

7

 !+++++    

        7  !+++++  

   

   


  

       

 

 
7/

  0   9 

 



         



              

   



   



 
:    

  

    
6          
       

 

     



  

      


   

  

  

 

  


; 

  

     

  

  

   

        

    

        



                    

  
    

  

 * 

           

 

         

  

  

   

 

      

   7
!(+++
&++++ 7
!(+++


            

  
<       

   

 )        

8      

 

   



   

  

 !+,   


)   

  



   

 

 

  = = = = = 59.3
)    

  (+,     





 



 /      &+

   


   #+,  



 

&+(+


* 

  

  (+'+

     !(,
        


59.4
* 







 $       &+,

 

  

  

 &+


6  %(,

  

 &+(+

  !+,

  

 (+'+

 

 



 


   

   

     

 
59.5
.              

    



     #+#%0> ?

    

    59.6.

                0  > @         &%     /


59.7
  

         
59.8
7   

        

 



 

     

    7  !(+++  7  &++++     7  !(+++


 

    

   !+,  


A 

4'
 #
" 


 

.+96+ ! +*

!

& +!'  6)+!:

0;6;, < #

+!& +6 +*;+

=&= & +6  ,=

3 4 5 ( 1 7


  

(+ *+ < 6+
4 &) +5

 +!+:

(,=;

4(&) +5 


 +
  


#

6 
 

 #

 
 B21
6  <

  C  0 8        

 

    

;



   

  
 *     

  D  D    

      



 D  

 D  D    D     D

 D
    

           

  

   

 

  

  

$ )

 

 

 



 

%!
!
Spousal consortium 

   

         

    



       

  

    /  D
%!
%
Parental consortium     



  

D  

   

      

   

     D
%!
#
Filial consortium     

  

 

  


6 

      

          


  

   



   

      

          

 
22
   



 

     

       3  /     

 



  E   

    

   



      
 3   /                 

      

 

    
       

 

   

       

 
23
 3> 

6  

    

     

  

  

  

* 

  

          

     

 

     
C  

    

     

    6 
6   

 

    
   

      

       

   

           

   

 24
        

         

     

 

   D

  D   C  0 8
*  







     

  7 &++++ 

  


 


+ 
+
 

 
+ 
 

' 
-
$ 



+ 

'
  
6 ;,,,7

#
  +

 





#

 ' 


 # $  

' 


!
 +


 #

 
* 
 # 

 $


 
'$
 & 

 

# # #

+ 


& 
 ' 


 


$ 

$ 
,

* 
 
 
 
 $


#


 
6 (-,,7




+  
'$

" 

 
 




 
 


+ 
 
 

# 
 '
 


#  



2#
 
 ( 6 5
 
 
*
 



 
# $
  

#  





 

# 
+ 

#  

 
* 
 






  

 $

 +

(

!
 
 


 





C #



3'
 #
" 

Jitender Kumar v. Sanjay Prasad passed in Civil Appeal No. 7199 of 2025 (Arising Out of SLP(C)No. 27779 of 2023), decided on 22.05.2025
+ 

" 

 
#  




  



#
# 
*
" 
# D
 

 #
 # 
?

'
#  





 
 +
$

 

$



 


*
?

" 
:

 $

 

 

' 
#  


'




#
 
# 

"*
 
*
    

Jitender Kumar's case (supra) 
 
 B!#
*         

      
          Birender (Supra)    

    F D!&
 *    

             





 

 


         

  /   



         

        



           

              



                 



   

          

 
D

14. Such exposition came to be followed by this Court in Seema Rani and Ors. v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. and Ors., 2025 SCC Online SC 283., wherein it was observed that the application for compensation, even by married sons and daughters, must be considered, irrespective of whether they are fully dependant or not
*  

           $ 

       

       


3        . 3   

    

     $
*    





              $  

    


A -

!
 +

C #


'

 $
 
 #  




:

$
 

# 



#



 
 
!
 
  
 #+&
 
 
  
 

 

$

 
#  





'


 
 
  
*
 
 

# 








1






 
 

  $
 





   
 

 #


'

.

":

$


 
 
#  



C 
 &


#  
  
#


+  



$




C  

'$
 

# 

;


 
 


+ 
 
 
 
* 
 


 
$
# 

 



#

  
*

 
+ 


 +

# 
 
 




 
 >


'



 $
 


1

% 
 


+ 
 
 

 
* 
 

 


#   
 & 

 



  




#   

 
 
 
'
.
 

0


 +


# 
+ 

  
?

  





#



+
 



'  
*

+ 
:


 

 
" 

 0(

0

!
 +


 +



+
'$

4'
 #
" 

'


C #


 
+
*
+  
 ,-

, 
#  
 $
*
  

# 
  

 
# 



  
# 
  Sr. No.

Heads Compensation Awarded  $
!# 6 (-,,7 % 

8
(,9 6 1,,7
2(,9

(-,,5 >  
+ 
 
?  7-
6  .,7
2.,,
E
7-5 ( * 
!#
6 -,(,
2.,,  .,5

 -

  
.

.




>$
6 0.;.1,7
2-,(,E E.5 ;

<

B  6 1-,7 %  
B? 6 1-,7 <

"

# 6 -1,1,,7  



6 (1(,,7 ?
  


6 (1(,,7 ?
0 %









6 (1(,,
?

,  ,+*  6)!

+,; !

# %??8 @  &',; !

# 
+ 
'$

* #? ? @ 

!=+!' +6 &!, #

?8%?$ @ %??8 ? ? 5

,


 



 




'$
4'  #
" 

Dara Singh @ Dhara Banjara Vs. Shyam Singh Varma $  8

R.Valli and Others VS. Tamil Nandu State Transport Corporation (2022) 5 Supreme Court Cases 107 ?


  

# 
  


8
09

 #


 
# 
#

  
 



#
 
 

 


 



 


 



'$

 
 



 7

# 

 
'

 
 

 
* 
 

  
  
  


#

 



 
 $




  

 
# $

 $


+ 


 
 
+ 
 '$



 #
#

+
 
 
 
* 
" 
 
  '
# 




'#  

!

+ 
 

 +
 


 
+ 

' 

 $
 

  

= $

F
 '
&

'



 




# 


 
*
  

$ 
 
  


 
 


   $
  #



%  

C 
# 

 

  

  
'+


 


 

*
4'
 #
" 

National Insurance Co. Ltd. v.

Swaran Singh & Ors.

2004 (3) SCC 297, decided on 05.01.2004 

 



' 

 


 
 $

 



 $
'  

# $



$
+ 
 
   + 
 '$



 #
#

 

(

% 

# $
'
# 



 #
 
4'
 #
" 

Sunita v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd., 2025 INSC 867
+ 

?
" 
+ 
 # 

 $
 
 

= $

F
'

+ B!!
 

  

       



  *   
*                  

  
!%
 

  

   

   * 

     



                   

 

        !#
6            

      

 

  DG ;  C

D  

 

      

   
     

       * 

 

   

           DC  7

 D  

  
6       

        

 !&
)         H * 


G

</I %++&$%0 !



      



        

      
 * 

 

 

       

  

 

      

       

  


!(
     

    Anu Bhanvara v. IFFCO Tokio General Insurance Co. Ltd., (2020) 20 SCC 632
    /   

    

        * 

C

    

           

   

  
        DC   

 D 

 * 

  

    

 

      !'
   

             

  /

  6 G0 
I  9  !552$#04&&
JH * 




G


3
K  %++%$%0%42
J H   * 

 
 G
 
   :   7 %++&$20(!4
JH * 6




G

>  %+!+0;  0&5
JH * 


G

0/C
C %+!#$%0&!
J3 I 
7/

I 0  %+!4$&045'
J C
7 H%+!20;  0#&5'
!4
6               

  

 * 

    

      

 

!2
                    







    

8 * 

           

  

                 

 

        
A

-

!
 



 
 #


 #
" 


 
 


'C


'
  


 / 

 
" 

 

 
# $
 
'


'
 $

+ 


 
 

 
 
'
 

 
# 
#

 

+


 
 

 
+ 
 +

.

*
! 
"# $ 
 
 

 
 
# 

# 

+ 

+ 

* +  

 

+
#
#

 

$

 
C #
* * 

 

 '



 
# 

# 
 + 



 




# 7  


 
 '$

 
* 
 

+ 
 
 ,-

,

* 

# 7  

 

  
 
'

&
 




 *

;

 
 
25

$

 
 


# $# %

4(

(.5 




G
 & 7  & 


H7
G
 '


H