High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4103/2009dismissed

Balwinder Kumar Etc. v. Janak Raj Etc.

2017-12-15Dr. Justice S. Muralidhar16 pages

!"#$!$%& ' (

)*+#%$!,-./),)%$01!,2 33!**)%02 4!,2.2

)%)5)6$!"!)2!$01,.7182)%$01!,2 !23%$!%02 ,)/& 9 8

:

,!2!%0&

)6;#,!1,)+)0< ,)*

" "

# # "

"

# $

" #%

!& & '# (" ) (

%

!

% *#

& &

+

" %

#"

& & %

%#

,

!

%

" #

#

% %

+ -

% % &.

#. # ##

' & "%/ # 0#

%#"

1#

% " #

%

!

! ) ( #

2

%#

2 #

#! /%

%

%

# ! / % !)%

# ( %

# (

#

#

)% )% #

% ! ( #($%#

"

"

# (, " " . , %

"

"

( " " .

" .

)% ,

% "

"

( #(

%

,% %

!)% $%#

! "

!) ( #

2 , #

! !

2 #

, ! " # ) (#

1#

!$%#

% #

#

#

#

%

2 #

# !

# % #

"

"

$%#

#

" # "

#

# % !

"

3 "

"

% " !

#

!3

2(# 2

*&*3 %

/%

%

# !$%

)% %

+# %

# !$%#

)%

#

% .1#

)% $%#

)%

/, ! ,% #

#

' & "%%

#"

% !1# % ( " ,#

#

' & "% " "

) ($%#

)% % "% ! ( # ( #(%" ! # #

%

# % '# (3

( )% % " ,/#"/3#

"%

,)%

" 4 ) 5567 % "

#/#"/ "

4 %" "

$%#

4

( " /

4 /

7 556 $ 4'# (%!

! +

#

#

' & "%,

)% /#"/

%

! !

)% +

/#" / %

# !,

"

# % 8%

!

59:, "

# # %

/

" 8% /#"/ "

( &

!

! !

% #"

# ! "

"

3

/#"/ 8% #

!

! %

#

8%

"

,

" 4 #

266 5;

! 1# "

" .

# %

" .

!

$%#

"#

, "%

3#

,

% #3& /

" "

!#

2 556$%#

# +

/

#"

#

# # ,

7

, %

"% !

# % #

'

!

5< #

%

2

$%#

"

# %

"

, #"

"

!

/

2

% %

%

%

=#= # % %#

96 55

%

!

"

% +# % !

"

#

( "

266 5;

!8% % /#"/$%#

2

=#=

6955 !

% %

#

# !

2

6955 #

!

#

# !

"

65655<#

# "

*#

#

#% #

>.

!

" ! " #

=

$

%

$& $ % & '

% $

%# " ""

$ & ( % $ ) ) " !

" #

& * # !

" " &

%# ++ &, &

% +(

!7%

#

&4.&4.2 "

&4.

(%

"

% +

7

! ?+&@ ?+&A%

3

+

/4. "

7

/4.2/ # ( " *

/ #!* # /4.

% "

/4.

"

% %

#

4 #/#"/ ) 5567 /4.9 $

/4.:

"

/ #!

* # /4.<((

# ) (

/4.;

%

+

/4.5/4.

"

"

( *#

#

4 "

#

*#

"

#

! %

#

!$%

*#

+

&4.7%

# &4.2 "

#

!

!)% ! % &4.2 "

# ! .1#

!)% ! !" !)% % #

#

' & "% 0#

% %

) (

%

# !

!

2 "!

*#

# !

.

1#

!)% *#

+

/4.:

"

%

/ #!

* # %

4 " % "

) 5567 ?+>/ "

!)% #/#"/0#

/4.

% "

"

!/#"/ # %

8% /4.9%

"%

266 5;

#

) (#

/4.5( # # *

& "%

$ "

) (! # + "

#

*#

4?+>/@

!)% #/#"/

) 5567 $ 4)% !

#

> ( '# ( + #

' & "%

"# #( '# (% "

" #8% #

48% #

) (

) ( !# !

%

!

( # !

#

!

%

""

" # "

% *#

%

% *#

7

% *#

"# # " "

!)% #/#"/%

*#

4#

%

% *#

"

! "

%

4%

!)% #/#"/

% "

% !#

4)%

%

!# %

% *##

%

4

!/4.

"

,% %

#

4 % #!

4%

)%

%

% "

4 )% )%

"

4

% %

" "

4$%#

/

#/4.2

# 1# 4 !8% #) (8 %

"

!/#"/ #8%

!%

"

% *##

#

"

*#

# %

%

# ! #

% *#

!

4 )% #/#"/ 6!

#

" # !

"

#!

% *##

%

# !

! %

#

# ! % %

! ! "!%

% *#

! !

#

# "

!

"# "

#

B #

# ! !

#

!%%

!)% " B" ." .

! " #"

!

!

!

!4

#

"# !% !

)% %

!4 # " /#"/ ! +# "

"

#($ # "#

#

#

# " *#

$"#

!

#

+ "

"%

4 #

"#

!

#

# 56

?

4 # ! 4

% "#

4 % :

$ #

:;

?

$ # "#

#

#

# "

= #

*#

! "# $ %&'"#()0#

"#

#

% +

4 "%

4

% :

$ # :;

$ ?

#"

4 # 3

#

#

# "

&!*#

* + ,-

#

.

/

0!

$ "

4 6!

# #

56

$ ?

%#

48

# #

# "

= # *#

*+ 1 2! ,

$

%31 ""& 2 1 ""&

# #

56

" 4

*# % #

" 4

$

# #

" 4

#!

# 56

?

"

!

% *##

#

!

#

"

% %

4

1# :5

$ ?

/4.

"

#! +

" #

"%

" #

#

4 % #!

%

%

4%

%

#

4# "

" #

4

" #

4#

4 #!

#

#

#

B

!

%

#

!

! " .1#

! )%

!

"

41# $#

#

% "#

! !#

%

"#

#

"

!

!

#

,

"

#

# "

%

*#

#

!

!

%

# !, "

! %

!

#

# !

#

# !

% 1#

!

)%

# % # ! !

# !# )% % #

%

# ! #"

.

+ #""

% #

#?

!%

&4.

% &4.2 +

! !

!

# ! !

!

" $ %

# "

!

#

#

!

! 0

% #

#

% *#

"# # %

%

% *# "

!

%

!

"

# %

!

!

!)% #/#"/

1#

%

!

"%

4%

%

% "

# +

!% 1#

#

:;

$ ?

1# :

$ #

% %

!. # :5 ?

"%

4

! "

" # % "

#

"% $

#

#! "

B

! + "

/4.

"

%

%

%

4%

#

%

#

4" "

4

" #

# %

%

4 #

#

4

% "%

4 ! +#

! ! #

#

:5

$ ?

B

#

4 !

)% #/#"/ 3

%

4

) 5567

? " *

!

5

4#

6!

"

#

!

266

% *# "

!

4 % # !

*#

*# "

!

# !

4

# " # !

#

!"# 2

#

"# $

"%

4% !# /

%

+

"#

4

= #

*#

# ,

4 1#

% :;

$ ?

! "

"

:

$ #

6!

%#

%

# !

4 3

"%

! +

B

+

"%

+

% %

%

%

4%

%

#

4 :5

$ ?

%

,% *#

#

4

#

56

$ ?

# "

&!

*#

0!

2

# "

= # #

$

%31 ""&

2 #!#

#

# " / 7 / "

*#

-

1 "4## 5 '

#6

'

"%

# ! # #

56?

4% # " !

!

)% #/#"/

$

" % %

!

# ! # #

56?

4

%

! %

)%

"

%# #

+ 7#

! #

4#

!)% #/#"/

"

! %

# !

!"

1#

# !

# 1# 4 1#

!

3

%

% # 1# !

!%"

!/#"/ % 8%

+

/#"/ 8% % !

%

8%

4 #

#!

%

!

#

1#

#!

B

! "

!"

# ! ! !

%

!

!

=

"# %

!

#

$ %

"! !

# "

*# %

#

!

'01!"!/;!,< ( ?

:@ 1#4)%#-).21#5 - . /.0 1 % /.0