High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/24351/2018disposed of

Partik v. Institute Of Banking Personnel Selection And ANR

2023-11-14Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil7 pages

!"## $% !"##

&' ()*&# + *+ ** &) ****

!"

# " !"

!"

$ !"

%

!"

& +,"

-&!. /%01 # '%(

)

"

&&* +

) , )

%& ) "

-

. '

( '&( $

/-

"

-

/,

%0 -

&*1" . ' !(

'

2 %( !

/

%3& 14 - )-

5

6

- "

#

! ) - %73 8

. '

2 3( ! &*1 -/ ) "

)

- 2 -

,%73

"

8

- /,!%&7 -

/ '3( , /-

)

"

-

! /-

% &! , -

- -

"

/

)

/

'7(

-

)

:3 %: &:%; !

%& "

"

'4(

%0 "

,

"

"

-

< -

/, "

-

- "

/,

,)

= /, / ,"

!

&

" ," , - , "

" , --

= "

"

-

'*( - - !

&0 - , /8

)

- / /

/, + +> %*?%& &:%7 ' -"

(

%? :3 &:%4'

2 &<%( '1( .

- ! /

- ,

@ %3& 14-

- 2-

, "

-

)/

"

/8 "

- 3 - ';( /, ! "

&

% -

"

&? :4 &:%;!

!) - " "/ ) *7 . '

( ! " ) , /

/,

%

:3 %& &:%; ) "

"

-

" + 0

"

-

! + )

2 )

&0 + 0

%&7 , " !

, "

"

& 9, /

"

'?(

'%:(

!- ) ! + %470+>0&:%?

)

- 8-

&% %% &:%; +> &?773 &:%; '/ - " ( '

2 %( )

/

%

"

& ) ) )

& -

)0

!

, '%%(

% ,

&4 :% &:%? ) /

- 8-

+>

&?773 &:%; /

/ A"

$0 11&;0&:%; # $ /

" &4 :3 &:%?

/ " ) 0

- 4 -

!

!

"#

# !

!

$

%

!

$ ! !

& "#

!

&

"

& '( () *('+ , '%&( - ! -

! /

/, + + )

) ) / "

0 - !

.

/

*('0#'1 -

"

- 5 -

" !

!

% 2

*('1#'+

23$

!

23$

"

23$ 2

!

! 5

2

"

%

!

.

!

#

!

6

!

#

!

!

"

!

"

$ 7

!"

#

$ %& !

'(

))

8#

- 6 - ''

2

!

$3

!

"

%

, 9 7

4 ! !

%

4

2

"

!

!

!"

*+%

%& ,-

)

!.(

%/(

!"

*+%

0

"

:

!

!

- 7 -

!

23$

*

6 ;- < !

#

= 6 ;- <!

!

'%3( " ) =

"

"

)

-

>= '+>0&?7730&:%;() /

/, + " :* :1 &:&3! )

- :* :1 &:&3 +>0&?7730&:%;! / "

'%7(

, / "

/, + +>0&?7730&:%; / /

) '%4( . , %7 %% &:&3 9 2+,"

-&!. /%03

. /

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No