← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4356/2012allowed

Chander Kali And Others v. Dharamvir Singh And Others

2025-09-05Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma13 pages

    



!"#$#%#&'#( )*

!"#$&+,+-#.#+"( )

 

 

 /%        ( 01222 2 

   ! " # 



    ! "# 

 ! " #  $ % &&&& 2 2   ' (          #       )   '*+'*+'* , 

""

  (

!    "

 

#

 "

'-- #

. "

"!'/00#  !

1(

2 # " #"



 "

     #'!30!*++45

)  6378 ! ""

 #

# 

. "

""

! ""  +0+**+'+ *    #  

  "

#  9   #"



) , (

!



 # #" #"  9    "# : #  , 22221 212 % ;"

 # "

 5

"

   , (

 

)  "

(# !    ,           

)       # "



 "  ) <   "

!    "

  #      5= "   !

)! , )  ,    #"



! , (

  ,  (# !,#    # 7 = "

 #   )  "

 # ")  

 " 21 132 - > 2

            "  # Sarla Verma Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another 4

)  2,5&#.#,&"!%#% 6!  ) )  #"



  #   ?30     

            

    

      

             

   

     

 

       

 

 

      

            

   

         !"#$             

%#  !"&$

    

&'   !"($       



  31)

       

       *  

        (+,                  











   

  

-  

  

 

      

      

 $         .  /

 

        

                *  

 

                     

   



          

       32 

                   (+,         

    (+,          

        



  

          

             



 

        

   * * * * * * 42. )     

 

    &$          0

 1   $        !2    !(%+ %!

%(

$ 

    

 3!4 %'#+

3!'#!#(

3!(#'&+

3 !&&!&(

 3!#&'(+

 



   

 3!!(!((

35 (''+

34'!'(

 3(''4+

3 > 2

   " #National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. 4

7  2 *6"

 #  )  "

'--!'-%5'-0 #

. "

"!'/00! #

)  "   "

  #     

  @     

"A B  "

 #

   #"A   #"   #  , 

A  

  #     "



 !   ,! 

  # !

 #"

  #  @!) " 

A C D   "# 

"   # #  ##  ) E

A #5

, # @ , (  

 #E    "  ?52. 6  conventional heads

    

   

 7/

8*

    7 %(+++       

  7  !+++++  

   7 !+++++ 



 

         

      

   7/

 0  9 

 





       



   

  

  



 

   :    

      6                    

     



 

    

   

  

  

   

  ; 

       

           

     

        

  

     





   



               

   

*

     

            

  

 

  

      

 

!(+++  7 &++++     7 !(+++  

    

                    



    <              

  

 

 )     

               

  

    

  

   !+,   

) 

 

 



  



 

= = = = = 59.3)   

  (+,   



 





 / 

  &+

    

 #+,  

  

&+ (+

* 

  

 (+'+

   !(,6   

   

 59.4* 







 $  

   &+,

 



  

    &+

6  %(,

  

  &+(+

 !+,

  

 (+'+

   

  

 

     59.5.              

         #+#%0> ?  



    59.6. 

        

  0> @ &%/

 59.7  

        

59.87   

        





 

     

 7

!(+++7 &++++ 7 !(+++

  

    

  !+,  

A 0 > 2

   " #!8.!#+#&!9+%,&!+-# .5!+:1;.;"#</%!+,!.!9;!%=,=&,!."=#&%4 * * 2 6#"

  2!&9!/#&.! %,5&! &!+!:2#"=; 2,5&!    ) "

    #  "   B216  <

  C  0 8         

  

         

  ;

   

      

 

 *  

D  D  

   



 D     D  D 

 D D  D  

      





 

 

  



    )  

      

       

  

 

%!! Spousal consortium   

        

         

    



D  

   

     

 /  D

* %!% Parental consortium      



              

   D    

   

     

   

     D %!# Filial consortium             

  

 

   6

      

           

 

   

    

     

              22  



 

     

       3 /     

 

  

E     

  

       

   

  3 /                 

   

           

 

  

      



 23 3> 

6  

    

      

  

 

   

* 

       

         

)     

                

 C       

    

    6 6      

    

      

  

   

           

   

 

         

     

       



               

 !

!!!        /   #) "5   )  @  ,7*, #  #""

("

#   F5'5 

"

)7*, #  # > )!  " , "    ) " #  (

D !      #")7+,  #  '+ =  

 # )  ,> 2

  

Sunita Vs. Vinod Singh 2025 INSC 366) > 2

@    " #   "  "

,!  

 "" #"   ( @" #    " 

 B!!      

  7 (2!5" 7

.   -     F

$            7 !++++"  7

 

  $             

       

  

        

    

   

  7 (!#4"  7

 .

  ;

    $     

     

                    

       

      7 %(++"

7

  .   $  



7 4'#4" 7

0   0      $     7 4+++"

7

0   $      

         

   &(

  C 3

7  



  

   



        



              !  #+

 

!(



                   

 

   

  

    

 %(#+

            !54+  Moreover, in the absence of material indicating to the contrary, there is no inhibition to accept the age

 of the deceased as per the Post2Mortem Report  

    

  !&  

&(

)  

  

 C  0 

$  7 &++++" 7

.   $  

 !+, 



   

    3 G

* 

HF 7  %+!2$  !2  0  !#+               

          

I7 &2+++"(J 

7 %&++++" 7

H

 .   $      

   

 A '' = ) #

!# E ! #"    ," 7+,  #""

 '*    #    "

  "   (

   )  ,   , "

 #"%+++45> )!  

#" #"! "

 #"  7-++45  ""

")   )"

#  5 :

) :  # E   ((

 )  , "'4% ) @   #"  #  , "



 '47!  )D !

(

  )  , 

 #3  #'%( (

  ),  )#   "D  (

  ) )    )

 #!

#  @

 #"

  (# !)9   "

#  

12 '% = ) # )   ) ,> 2

    

# E ! 

)() '*+'*+'*  , 

""

  (

!    #  ""

  ,( 

5"

      "   #"



#  5= " ,! " "



5  Sr.

No.

Heads Compensation Awarded '

 ,="

 7-++45 * D   "6'+8 7-+457-++G'+8 %  "

   )  

@  '47 '*%*45-'-+G'47 < (  ="

 </<045-'-+5'*%*

 '% -   ", 3!-0!3-045</<0G'*G'% ;

 #C '0!+++45 D  C@ '0!+++45 / ;

 #   %!%-!+++45   <0!+++45@-    <0+++G'

"!9.5#+%!";+ %>>7 *?

#<,-";+  ) ,(

%> >?

?

+=!+-#<!.,+"

% *?

7 *  '< #  "

"!  ,> 2

   Dara Singh @ Dhara Banjara Vs. Shyam Singh Varma ) 7

R.Valli and Others VS. Tamil Nandu State Transport Corporation 

2,5&#.#,&"!%#%7>

5"

  6

/8  "  #"



#  ##

 # "

 



 # 

H

 '7    $ %5= "   ,     "        " 

)  ) (

)  

 #) #  #"  #"

, # E ((

 "           

5"

      :  ""

 ( 

5"

  " #    :""

 

   (

'- > )! $ %5= " ,   "

 "  #"



#  $ *  ) #

##  "

)'*+'*+'* '3  

"

! #,!    #    2 2      )

    F:

4 5:

  I4$ F 

 I