High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/21751/2019allowed

M/S Essen Auto Forge Pvt Ltd v. Union Of India And Others

2019-11-04Mr Justice Jaswant Singh,Mr. Justice Lalit Batra3 pages

!"##$%&%'() *

() +, --- +, -,,

!"# %&'()*+*# (,*-.#()*-/#(())+',)./ %&'(*0#+0.#-*(*#.)*.0#.,*0(#.+,(.',).* 1 3"# 4 1"# %&'.)5+#../5#.,(*#.,**#.0*-',).* %&'*-5#(,-0#0*/+#-))/#/+)-#+-/*#+5/,#0(*+',).* %&'0(*5#05)(#5)-)#.),0,#**./#.+-,*',).* 163!"#1 43 # %&7 ,*0(- ,)./ .5-5-#.5),#-*//#-**0#5-0,#55*/#/.,,#/.+,# /./5#,0,/(,50,, ,).* 6 !

# 1 # %&'+/+,#0*55#0*/(#-.,+',).* "

"# %&'.*5-',).* 9 :# %&7 /(0. 1 #

# .*0.-#,5/*.#.0,-*#,/+)/#,/+-*#,55+)#,5*.5# ,5//+#,5*)(#,5//0#,5*.*#,/)/0#,5*-)#,/.-0#,5+0)# ,5+,-#+-+/#*.5(#,.50.#,.*),.,(-0 1 # !"# ;< ;%&7 +005 ,).*<

61 # =

78 "1 # ;< %&7 005+#-,).#/*--#.**-0#-(+.#-0*) 9 #

# %&'.)*/5#*-,5#.)5(0',).* 1!# %&'.0,/-#.005/#.0--0',).* !"=1 # %&',*0(-',)./#.5),',).* =1

# 7 82

# %&'/0*+',).* 89 # %&'.-,)-',).* 8 1 # %&7 ,+/)*,0()( >? 2# %&7 +005 81 8 # =

636

3# 6 1 # ,/,)( # "!

# ;< (*5.++).+ 8 "9 # **/. 631> ""

# 68 "# ,/+)/ ,)./ 1"@"=#>

3 2"# A3 862

# " 2"# 64

4 "#1 1 %

169

7 .

(%&'(,*-.#(())+',)./# %&'05)(#.0--0#-,).#-(+.#5)-)#-0*)#-*(*#.,*0(',).*# %&'-))/#++./#.-,)-#+0++#0(*5#0(*+#+5/,#+-/*',).* %&'.),0,#(,-0#/0*+#.)*.0#/+)-#(,,(.#*(,,',).* %&'.+-,*#.0,/-#.005/#.5-,.#.5-**#.**-0#,.)(/# ,50..#,0,/(#0+/+#,)-.0',).*.

(%&7 .5-5- ,).*

+%&7 ,.50.,.*), ,).*#

(%&7 ,.**,#,++/(,++0.

,).*.

(%&7 ,*/0, !" #1 1 %

" 43 7 #

%&'*55# 0*/(#(*5.#+).+#+-+/#+/+,#005+#/(0.#-.,+#-*//#-**0# 5-0,#55*/#/.,,#/.+,#/./5#*.5(#/*--#.)5(0#.)*.0# .)*/5#.,(-0#.,*0(#*-,5#**./#.0,-*#.-).5#.*0.-# ,5//0#,/)/0#,/+-*#,5*)(#,5*.*#+005#,.50.#,.*),# ,+/)*#,5+,-#,5+0)#,5*.5#,5*-)#,5//+#,/.-0#,55+)# ,5/*.#,0()(,/,)( "# 3"#

7 ,(%&'()*-/ ()*+*',)./ @6 #

(*0#+0.#++./#005+#-,).#-(+.

-0*) BBB --/

" # 0

1 "2#3"#$4'56%#& 7","2 '%''2%! 3&

-- ,, 7#89#3 */

! "

#! $ %& #!