Sukhbir Singh And ORS v. Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitram Nigam And ANR.
!"#"$% !"#"$% !"#"$% !"#"$% &
&
&
& '
& '
& '
& '
&
()*+,"-("$.+ $/ + -# " "$ -# 0# - -1 $ "23"0" - $".
4 $/ + -# #5$/ $ #
6%7 6%7 6%7 6%786(9(96 86(9(96 86(9(96 86(9(96
- # $ % 6-#+:
$" )-;/<!
;
- + 5 " "$ -# 6-$"3+ :3 ;/<!
;
- + - #5$/ $ #
9(96; 9(96; 9(96; 9(96; " "$ -# = - + 5 - $ # $/5 " "$ ->"# + #"# - / !
# / ( "#+ 9)4 -; !$# ,3 "$ -1 $ 3"! ; /" / $
;$ !!)$ 3 ! -!) "$:+"3 !4"$."$!$ ! :" + 3"< 3 ! -"!" 1:"- 31"$."$ + " 3/#;:+"!+,-* /:$$ ?
/) # -4 $/+ <1- "$+ / +:
#- 5- / 3"! ( "$( 3*+ ; $"5 $
" # 3 $/ ) 5#1:
#!$/)! /+ !
)# / + :
#5"$ /,1 + 6 /"!
3
"! -;< -$4 $ #5"
3; $"5 ;<"/ +"# - 5- / /
;/) 3 ! -"!#+!*+ - #5$/ $ #+ < < -- / + "$-/ - # 3 + !3 "4 !45 $# "$# )5,1 + 5 " "$ -#; + 1+ /, $ #* / #),4" /!)4 $ #3"* !51 + ;!51 +
5# 4- 4 - 5- ; !51 + - "$ !
-/; "$!4 ! - "
"!
+ / !
# /;/ ,"- + + / !
# / !,) 33 + # /!)4 $ #: - $ #)553" /- + - + 5- # $ 5 " "$+ #, $ "3 / -$ / !)$# 3 - + 5 " "$ -# + # #),4" / + + ()5- 4 )- ;"$" #/ !"#"$- $/ - /"$@63 ! -"!" 1 -/ @63 ! -"!" 1 -/ @63 ! -"!" 1 -/ @63 ! -"!" 1 -/0#(+ "3 (+ "3 (+ "3 (+ "3 9)4 -"A 9)4 -"A 9)4 -"A 9)4 -"AB
C (
+ #+ 3/ + + - #5$/ $ #:)3/, 3"
,3 1 !45 $# "$ "-- #5 ! "< $1 $ .3". $! $ + 5 - + 5 " "$ - "# )- + -#),4" / + + !45 $# "$+ # , 5 "/$ + 5-"$!"53 #; 3 "/ /:$ "$ + 6 - 0 +"!3 # ! ; D&& # + 3/ ,1 + "<"#"$ $!+ +"#)- "$@ - 42" 9 )-<#( )$2 ,A @ - 42" 9 )-<#( )$2 ,A @ - 42" 9 )-<#( )$2 ,A @ - 42" 9 )-<#( )$2 ,A &B?C B"<"3C''
-+ -"$.3 -$ /!)$# 3 - + 5 - " # $/5 -)# 3 + - !-/; 4 + !$#"/ - / 5"$"$ + + 5 " "$ -# - $ " 3 / !45 $# "$, !
)# " + #!4 $- !-/ + + / ++ #, $!
)# / /) 3 ! -"!#+!*:+"!+"# <"/ $ -4 + - 5- + 4 /"!
3
"! / / D
:++ #5"$ / ,) + !
)# / +$ + 553"!
"$
"3 /,1 + $< # ".
"$.
"! -"$>?/
$/"$<" : + / !"#"$ + ()5- 4 )- - $/ - / "$ + # (+ "3 9)4 -" (+ "3 9)4 -" (+ "3 9)4 -" (+ "3 9)4 -" B()5B()5B()5B()5C; + 3"
,"3" 1"# + - #5$/ $ # 5 1 + !45 $# "$+ :-" 5 " "$ "# +)# + - ,1 /"#5# / :" + /"- ! "$ + - #5$/ $ #
:
-/ !45 $# "$ + 5 " "$ -# ,1 5531"$. + -4)3 ; , "$.
553" / ,1 + 6; "$ !
# / +; ,1 ## ##"$. + "$!4 + / !
# / 5531"$. + 4)3 "53" -"$ !!-/ $! :" + + . + / !
# /
$/
-/ /)! "$. E>-/ + "$!4 # F5 $/" )- , "$!)-- /,1 +
> / !
# / $ +"4# 3 + $ / )3 #+ 33 , /$ ,1 + - #5$/ $ # - / -4"$"$. + !45 $# "$ $/ " # 5 14 $ + 5 " "$ -# :" +"$ 5 -"/ +- 4$ +# -4 + / - ! "5 ! - "
" / !51 +"# -/ - B9(96C B9(96C B9(96C B9(96C
&
&
&
& '
& '
& '
& '
& + + -#5 *"$.E- #$ / %
#E + + - 5- ,3 %
#E