Hmt Machine Tools Ltd v. The Appellate Authority Under The Payment Of Gratuity Act 1972 & ORS
!"!#$%&%"
'(
!!
!
$
" % &'
(!
)
!!
!
$
" &'
(!
* (
!!
!
$
" &'
(!
+ ,
!!
!
$
" &'
(!
*
!!
!
$
" &'
(!
*
!!
!
$
" &'
(!
) *
!!
!
$
" &'
(!
( **
!!
!
$
" &'
(!
, *+
!!
!
$
" &'
(!
*
!!
!
$
" &'
(!
*
!!
!
$
" &'
(!
+*)(
!!
!
$
" % &'
(!
* +(
!!
!
$
" % &'
(!
+ )
!!
!
$
" % &'
(!
)
!!
!
$
" % &'
(!
-$ ./- 001 2&% 345$
))
%*
+ %,
) +* % +
!
" - % +
!
.
* % + %
- / % +
!
.
1
/2 % +
!
.
345
01 ' ## 7
,
+ +
) + , ! #
" !
8
" #! "
! "%,
!
% , !
9 ! 8
!
:
"
%
)8 9
# .
-- 6!# 7"/ 3 8"6 99 77
% 62!
%#3 2 6
5: # 2
%!
5 ,) #3 6 2"
%;
<! "<= , ! >'
5
,
7 8#! 8
0
?
; @ >=!
)" !!
"%
!
0 ; @ >0=!
)"
8
"% !
%, )"! "
, "( % '> ,
8
"
( 0% &%' >
!
#
'
?
:
+
!
!
, ! A $ ) 9( #;
!
.
0= #! ", ,
98
+8! "%
#> !
%",
"
8%!
8
", # )" ! %" !
, #
!
# %
#, !
)"! ", !!
$
"
&';
%B$
" C=
*
!
8! "
! " ) ) # 9 !
"# ,
+
+8 ;=%1
, %
") ,
" #! "
! " )
8 8 ,
<*9 "< *9 5 ;*!
+ = % &?;
%B *5 C=)"D
5 : ( ;
%BD5:(C= :
!
!
% , # *
*5 )
D5:(
*
! "
! " ) 8 , D5:(% ! *
*5 % +# )
*5 !
) !
8
:
" % + !
+
* % 0
*5
@
) ,E ;<= ; !
"% 7 " !8
"#
' !
# #!#
,
!! 8 " !8% % , 8 "8 % & ;
& =%
" ,
##
#
"
" # +8
,%
8
,8 !
"
@ %
9
"
!
!
"
!!
#
+ !
# "
#
" "
"
"8
!
"
+ 8
"F
)!
,
%@!,
D
% # ")% !!
"
<*=B 7 " !8
"
#
' !
8 !
"# ?
, " # %
#!#
#% D
# " )"
, ! 9 " !
"
%
!
! "% #%#% ,
% 8
#
% , 9 "
"
,# ") !! ) 9 "## ")
% # !
"
8% !
+8% )8 ) 8
8 )
% # !
)
), ! #
# ")! )"D
E
+
)#
! @8, "
,# ")@)" "
# % ,+ % ! @+ "
8 B0 !#99 7;
= "! +)"
D
# # "%,
" + "
# , !"
#% !
!! !!
"E
+ !!
"# " "
!!
!
" + ")
@" "
#
!! , !
+ )"
# 8 !! # ;=4 !
!! ) ;
=% !!
"# "%
8+8 !!
"
!! )
% %
98
7 # % #% "
!!
# # D
;0 !#*
6 # 6 2/ >"E ;
= !
+
"
# # +
, 8 "8 , " ,@!!
+
:
8G@ 8(8 % &'0;
&'0=
3 ) ;8 (8 = % &'
;00
&' =
# )8
#
#
"
" # +8
)"
+
" , C
*
! "
8 <) !@
- "6 %4 " / 3 ?" 0
#3%"
2!
7 #3#8 "
: # 292
!# - "6 / 3',,*<= 0*' ,
<!
8< ! ) ;
= ) 8+
,
# 8 ! +, 9)" <)
!@
85/ 3?"0
2!""
@ 6 2"'<,,*=)( :9 #5 " "(*'+8 !
8 8
@
# ! '
*
! "
$
" + 8 !
+
! " #
8
#! 8
#! 8
) )
?
5 !"% !
.
0; # =
! !
# ,
!!
8
$
" ", )8!
8
"
8#% 8!
8
" )# ,0 "
) #!
"
) # ! * '
$
"
(!
#
9! ! +, 9)" !@
, )"
%!
8
"
)7 , #
# "#!
%!
8
"!
#@
"
"+%(+
#
!
*
$
" %!
+
$
" %
# G+
" !
"#% ! !
+ 8#!
# )!
+ $
"
* # ) !
8
# ) $
" ,
8 !
+
*5 , ) !! )!
+ ") #9 !
+
*5 %
" ) ) )" "
! * 0
$
" ) , ,
)" #! " !
8
"
"!
"#
!
"#
) " ) !
#! " !
"
8
5 % !
+
, +, 9)" H) !@
%, "
9
,!
8
8 !
, ! +#
&
#
8 #%
!!
8
!
#
!
"#
8
"
( ?% &%?> " !
, !!
"%, )
!
# ! " # 9 "
!
8
8
" 7
" +!
%
8 9 ")
D5:( !
# + ,8
8
8
" "!
)
)
# , ! , # )
!
)"
8
" !!
$
"
"
, ,
!
8! "
" !
)" ! " #
8
!!
8+ @ > 8,
+
* !
*
%$
8 %
% /
% ) ,
) !
# ) ) 9 ! "
8
#! 8
# " )
> I
# 8 #! "
! "
+8 )# # )"
!
!!
%
+, #
", 8
8 #! 8
!
)"
8
" !!
$
"
!
!
" )# !
,
9#
%! ", ! " ") 8 9 ,D5:(
#! ,
)
) , , #, " )"
!
+# )
"% +8) 8 9 ,D5:( * % 0
*5 % !
) ,+ %
% ( ?% &%?>% "
!
7
" + !
! "%7 #,
! " 8 "
8 # 9!
8
" !
,
9#
")!
8
"
#! "%
,
" 8!
,
* '
$
" , # !
+
* '
@
) ,E B* 'E 2:!#
!# 6 :%# &2
%!
J ;
= ! , 8)
8
"
"!
%, 8% ) , !! #! " %, #
#% # " ) !
)%
!
8
"
;=
8
" ) # !
"
)% #! " % , !!
) ;
= )#
% #
" 8+ , 8 ! , #
" !
"
)
8
"
! "8 8
" #
;0= #! "
8 "
", " "
# ) #!
"
)
! , #8
"!
"
)
;0 =
8
" !
"
) ) ;0= !
)" #! " , ! ! ) ;0=%#! " !
"%
# ,8
") #!
"
) ,!
%#!
% @8
)"
$ #
## #
!
8 #!
% $ ## "%)"
! "E
+ ) !
"
) "!
"#
#! " #! " ) ! # , 8
#
8
"
"!
) +# !
+ # 9 #!
") # 9!
8
",0 "
# ,) #
8
" !
, ! !
)#! " !
# , ) #!
"
) !
%#!
%
) #
8
"
* +,, 9)" H): D
0
#36 >
?"0
%#A 4@ 6 2"% ,,)<=/ < @=*%, , E B7 ,
,
!!
# " "!
!
) ) +
%
" * ) !
) ## ",") # !
" " , 8+
# #! )",
8
# !
9
) #
8 # !
) ) !
)8 % #
)" !
)7 , #
# "#!
"
8
)8
% #
8!
) , * ,
8 " ,
+ # % !
)
# )! # )
) *
!
" !
"8
,) # 5+,
# %
, , 8 ##! " 9
#")"+ 98/
#!
) )"
,
# #
"
%7 " 9 #, "
#8 " "!
"#,
#
# 8 5,%
% ) ! * ! !
+ )
"# !
) !
) 8
#! " " #)"# !
"% 8 # #! " , , "!
!
"
) #% , )
* , 8 "
" !
) "
)
8
"
"
!
", +
)
!
8
"
!
+
* 0
$
" , " , !
8
" ) +@ !
8
"
"+%(+
#
* 0% !
) ,E ;* 2
!# &2
%!
5 .
8
"!
"
) 8
"!
"
) #! "#! " "
)#%
"%#% %! %!
%
, "
"
!@#! * ) )
#@
"
"+%
+
#
C
*
$
" 8+
8
# !
+ E ;+ 8 22!3 6 2 #
: # "' !
+
" # +
, 8 "8 ,
" #
" #
+8
)"+
" #
. # !
"#
) #8
!
$
"
#) # ! * &
$
" % + ! !
+ + )
!
$
" *
8
+)!
+ $
"
,
9#) ! )/
$
" ,
8 "
!
+
*5 , ) # )
8
"
'
8
" !!
$
" + 8"
"
#! 8
!
)" !!
"% !
8
"% !
( ?% &%?>;
@ > = "
)!
, !!
" #
+
)
! "% # )
!
,
9#> # , !
0 "
#
!
!"
,8 !
?
, ! !
) + #
<01 = %&%"
'( ! 98> K E L !
)K L