High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/8055/2013allowed

Sharda Devi v. Union Of India And ORS

2016-03-02Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan11 pages

!"#

$ %&

' ''

'' "

"# " "

$%$&'$&()

*%+

! ,

- . /'

0! * !

" 1 - . ($2&32$40 -

5, 667 - . 8 9 &:2'$$& 0

- ; -.<)/ + 4

&22'$$&1 !<)

*&+

0 " 0 0

0 * ':2'$$& 1 4 ," 0 !

" '22'$$&)

*'+

0 '%3'$$& 0 < < 667 '%3'$$& 1

0! &6 !

" 0 0 0

0 0 0 " !

;* !. !

0 < 0 . !

= !

" 3:'$&')

*(+

0 ! /' %&'$&( )

*%+ " 0 !. !

6% - - )

&3>% "" 4 " "

%&'$&()

*%+ !

0 , 0 0 !

? &23:5 0'22'$$&':2'$$2 ?

&':65 " > !-

0 %'235 0 &&'$$> ':2'$&&

(6$$5 0'22'$&& 0 -- )

&3:'

1 " 0 "

* !

0 , !

0 0 0 @ !

-"!

B- - );* !

"0 0

* 14 4-

," 0 0 '>2'$$&

':$2'$$&)

*6+ * 0

!"#$% & '()$* +,"*" *"

- "#(+'

%'/#!

#% (&'/ & '%% + '(

!) (/1 ('% 0'%$ 2#3 !5!

'%% (%%16 7!')#!&8 2# 9# '%'()& #3% ("

2# (/#(&/'#:&( &&* $!&" # 2# 3'%&2$

'(;:!1"

# 2# /#:)$2

#6%1&'&" >"*" .!

- !'

(% !'/ (/ 6$ - -& $1+!

%'#( (+ '&&'#(<:--1/#(&/'#:& :6'-&

/%'()&-:))'&$-1" =2>**6 $1+!

-< '-:!

.+" &&"!'( #:%6:%('-&'(/

#!('()" %" & 6:% #( ? 3-:'+& 3%!'

@#( &% !#'+& !'A

&& +#(-1 -#3:!'( '(B$!&"'--

#!('() &-')$% '

6!#4

(%"

&$) $#(&!

- +C&'(:!'( #!

- " - - %&#!

- *

0'+ -D4 > +4"

- !'

- ) &%:+1" E $ &%#!

+4" / (2

:% %C& /#(+'%'#( !'#!

+4 !13 &%@6%/#:-+(#%.

(%3#!&/ (('()"

%" 0 & )'4 ( G 4 3-#@ /'( 3%!'

@#( H:'('#( 1+!# !$&#( '/ / ( !'6$1--'( 6%#'( ?

3-:'+&5 &#-1% I/#% %/"

% + -#6 + !+'#" &6" !!

&% ," (++ /- ++

+ %*"

0$ ( --!

&:&/'% %'4

&:!

&3 '- +"

+2 !""J" ;

"" ""

< 5 7 5 !+'#-#)'&%G $1&'/'

)+"#"K*"L = -

#$%& # '&(% ) & *+ &&) ,&%) $ -.*+ &&)$%& /(&%0 &) 12& $ <'3%$ (%!

'&&'#( (+ '.

-'A +

(&'#( !10 !+&"$ <'3%$ (%!

1 #

'&&'#( '(% -'

+ %$ % 3#!

'('()%$ /# (& %'#(6 .- 3#!+

%$#!+'& .'-'%1 :(+ ! +'33 (% /'!/:

&% & %$ / /#:-+ .

.!# +-1 / )#!'A +'(3'4 +'&%'(/%/ )#!'

& &:(+ !

%$#!+'& .'-'%1+:

%#( %:!

-/ :& &(#% %%!'.:% .- %# #4

(%& !4'/ "@

6- &0#:-+.

/$!#('/ '-

(%& -'8 $

!% (+!

-+'&

&6!#-#() +'--( && //'+ (%& 0$'- (#%#(+:%1 %/"

)#!1 CC

%$#!+'& .'-'%1+:

%#/ :& &0$'/$ // 6% +

%%!'.:% .- %# #! ))!

+ .1 #4

(% & !4'/ '&

/#(%!

/% +.

/ :& #3/#(%'(:

+ @6#&:!

$#&%'- 0#!8 (4'!#(

(%&:.;

/% +%# @%!

/#(+'%'#(&#!#//:6 %'#( -$ !+&!

&:-%'()'( +

%$#!

+'& .'-'%10#:-+.

6- &"

)#!1 CC

%$#!+'& .'-'%1+:

%# //'+ (%'(%$ 6 !3#!

#3 +:%'

&" #

6- & //'+ (%&0$'- %!

-'()#( +:%1'(#4

(%&4 $'/- &#!6:.-'/%!

(&6#!% ;#:!( #(+:%1'&6 !3#!

+.1& !4'/ '!/!

3% '&$ 6& %&

- /%!#/:%'#(0$'- #(+:%1 %/"

)#!1 CC

%$ #! +'& .'-'%1 %%!'.:% .- %# /%& #3 4'#- .1 !!#!'&%& (%'&#/'

- -

(%& %/" 0$ ! '( %$ '!

!3#!

#3+:%'

&#!#%$ !0'& "6 !%3!# / &#3

%$#!'(;:!1&:&% '( +.16 !&#(( -#3%$ (%!

- #-'/

!) ('A %'#( 0$'-

6-#1 + '( '+ #3 %$ /'4'-

'('&%!

%'#( '( M:

--'() )'% %'#( !'#%& #! !

4#-% .1

#(&%!

%#!& #%$ ! 6:.-'/ & !4 (%& '(/-:+'() 6#-'/

!&#(( - %/".# ..- &%&'(6:.-'/6- / &#!%!

(&6#!% '(+'&/!'

'( &$##%'()'(/'+ (%&'(6:.-'/ %/"0#:-+.

/#4 +:(+ !%$'&/ )#!1"

)#!1 CC

%$#!+'& .'-'%1 !'&'() & !

&:-%#35 7 %% /$.1#!

+:!'() /%'#( ) '(&% @%!

'&%& (%'&#/'

- -

(%& %/"""

(+ 5.7

1 /%'#( '( '(% %'#( - 0 ! #! .#!+ &8'!

'&$ & (+0 !-'8 &'%:

%'#(&'(/-:+'()/ &0$'/$

%%!'.:% .- %# 5'7 @%!

'&%& /%& @6-#+'() '( &

%/"""0$'- #(0 1%# (#6 %'#( -

5''78'+( 66'() .1 @%!

'&%&N (+5'''7.

%%- '(#/:- %'#( &6 !%#3%!

'('()

@ !/'& &0'%$-'4

:('%'#("L )#!1 CC -"! 0 !

, ;*

0 !-"!7 0 ! 0 "" ! , * 0< 1* 0

@ " !

0 * -"!7 0 " -"!

&:2'$$&)

*&+ 0!

- ; -.<)/ + 4 &22'$$&1 !

':2'$$& 4 6- -

" +

&3:3 0

5K757$ ;#'('()%'

&$ -- /#

3!# %$ + #3 -'(M:'&$

(%#3/$ !) #3%$ #-+6#&%'3%$ /$ !) '&

#4 !'(%$ 3#!

(##(#!%$ 3#--#0'()+ '3%$ /$ !) '&

#4 !'(%$ 3% !(##("

57$ ;#'('()%'

&$ --.

/ -/:- +3!# #-+$

+M:

!% !& '( --/ &'(/-:+'()0$ #4

(%& !4 (%!

/ '4 $'&%!

(&3 !#!+ !&#!

&#4 !/$ !) #3%$ #-+6#&%'(

6- / #%$ ! %$ ( $'& #-+ $

+M:

!% !& #! 0$ %$

+M:

!% !& #3 #4

(% & !4 (% 0$'- #( %#:! '& /$ () + %# %$ %#:! &% %'#( '%& -3 #! 0$ $'& %

6#!

!1 %!

(&3 !'&/#(4 !% +'(%#6

(%%!

(&3 !"

57#% #!

%$ (#( + 1O&;#'('()%'

&$ --.

--#0 +%#

(%& !4 (%%#;#'( ( 06#&%0'%$'(%$ &

&% %'#( #!0$'/$+# &(#%'(4#-4 /$ () #3!

&'+ 3!# #(

&% %'#(%# (#%$ !"<#!%$'&6:!6#& %$ % P&

&% %'#(O0'-- .

'(% !6!

+%#

(%$

3 --'()0'%$'(%$ ;:!'&+'/%'#(#3 :('/'6 -'%1 #! /#!6#!

%'#( '(/-:+'() &:/$ #3 &:.:!.

:('/'6 -'%'

& (#%'3'

& #! / (%#(

(%& &

/#(%'):#:&%#%$ (

+ :('/'6 -'%1 %/"

5B7 (/ &'(4#-4'()%!

(&3 !3!# #( &% %'#(%# (#%$ !

-&#'(4#-4'()/$ () #3!

&'+ %$ #4

(%& !4 (% &$ --.

--#0 +;#'('()%'

0'%$!

%#%$ +'&%

(%$ #-+$

+M:

!% !& (+%$ ( 0$

+M:

!% !&.1 +'!

/%!#:% (+#!+'( !1 #+ 5&7#3%!

- &'(+'/ +'(%$

3#--#0'()&/$ +:- "$ ($#-'+ 15&73#--#05&7;#'('()%'

(#!

-;#'('()%'

+%#$ .

( @% +%# /#4 !&:/$$#-'+ 15&7"

#'('() '

'&&'.- 0$ %$

(&3 ! ( / && !'-1 '(4#-4 & /#(%'(:#:& %!

- .1 !# + 3#!

%$ (8 &"

'&% .

#-+ $

+M:

!% !&

+M:

!% !& #'('() '

'&&'.-

8 #!- && + 1& + 1& #!

%$ (8

+ 1& K+ 1& K 1&

@/ 6% '( / #3 %!

- .1 '!

3#!0$'/$ %$

0'-- .

+ 1&"

%$ (8

K+ 1&

" 0 # 0# B 0

&6!

" 0 4 !

. (,;=/;

.D -D/-;/,

7= E D.

7=;;/ D ;

4 ,D9;/;/ ;9-;% - -

);* !

" 0

9 9 4$% 1 &% & & -&

-&#5&%#

4 " (+ /'+'()#(%$ '&&:

#3 (%'%-

(% --%$ 4'+ 5.#%$+'!

(+ /'!/:

&% (%'

-7 0'-- .

% ( '(%# //#:(% (+ %$ .

3'% #3

&#( .- +#:.%0'--.

)'4 (%#%$ /- '

(%"$'&.

3'%0'--.

)'4

-'.

--1%#%$ /- '

(%'(3'

-+& !4'/ / &"

@@@ @@@ @@@

& 5'7

(;:!'

&&:&% '( +0$ (%$

('&C#(+:%1C0'--.

+ %# $ !'& ( '( #! !

&:-% + 3!# #4

(%& !4'/ N.:%'(/ &#3'(;:!'

&+:

%# !'#:& ( )-') #! '&/#(+:/% %$ M:

&%'#( #3 +:/'()%$ +'& .'-'%16 (&'#(0'--.

/#(&'+ +"

5''7

( / & #3 & -3'(3-'/% + '(;:!'

& 0$'- #( +:%1

%%!'.:% .'-'%1 0'-- (#% .

/#(/ + :(- && '% '&

&% .-'&$ +%$ %& !4'/ 3 /%#!&0 !

&6#(&'.- 3#!

&:/$ /%'#( N '( / & 0$ %%!'.:% .'-'%1 '& /#(/ +%$ M:

&%'#(#3)!

(%#3+'& .'-'%16 (&'#( 3:--#! % !

+:/ +!

0'--.

/#(&'+ +"

5.7 6 !&#(&:.;

/%%#%$ +'&/'6-'( !1/#+ #3%$ (%!

- !

+ #-'/ %% -'#(&'&C#(+:%1C 5'7 $ (6 !3#!

'() (#33'/'

-% &8#! % &83 '-:!

%#+# 0$'/$0#:-+/#(&%'%:% (#33 %!'

.- :(+ !%$

+'&/'6-'( !1/#+ 66-'/ .- %#$'

5''7 $ ( #4'()3!# #( 6- / #3+:%1%# (#%$ !6- /

#3+:%1'!!

&6 /%'4 #3%$

%$#+#3 #4

(%"

5'''7 :!'() %$ 6 !'#+ #3 6 !%'/'6 %'#( '( !

%'#( #!) ('A + #! 6 '%% + .1 & !4'/ :%$#!'%'

& +:!'()%$ 6 !'#+#3%!

--'()'( .#+1#!&'()-1:(+ #!) ('A + !!

()

(%&"

5'47 $ (6!#/

+'()3!# $'&+:%1&% %'#(%#$'&-

&% %'#(#(!

%:!('()%#+:%13!# $'&-

&% %'#( 6:.-'/ @6 (& &%$ %'&#( '-0 10 !!

(%#(/ &$ 5'!!

&6 /%'4 #30$ ! '-0 10 !!

(%2/ &$ '& '%% +3#!%$ 0$#- ;#:!( 1#!3#! 6#!%'#(#(-17 '(#4

(%%!

(&6#!%#!0$ (!# + '-

) '&6 '+ 3#!%$ ;#:!( 1"

$ (;#:!( 1'().1 !

&#( .- !#:% 3!# #( C& #33'/'

&'+ %# (+.

/83!# %$ 66#'(% +6- /

#3 +:%1 '!!

&6 /%'4 #3 %$ #+ #3 /#(4 0$ !6!'4 #!6!#4'+ +.1%$ #4

(%"

5/7 ( //'+ (%0$'/$#//:!&0$ (

('&(#%&%!'/%-1 C#(+:%1C &+ 3'( + .#4

1 -&#.

%%!'.:% .- %# !4'/ 6!#4'+ + %$ % '% '(4#-4 + !'&8 0$'/$ 0 3'('% -1 ($ +'(8'(+#!+ )!

.1%$ ( %:!

/#(+'%'#(&#.-') %'#(&#!'(/'+ (%&#3$'&& !4'/ % %$ &

0 & (#% !'&8 /#

#( %# $:

@'&% '( #+ !( /#(+'%'#(& '( (+'

" $:& 3#!

6- 0$ 6 !&#( '& 8'-- + #! '(;:!

+ .1 &#

#( .1 !

&#( #3 $'& .

-#()'() %# ( !

#-'/ %% -'#(5 (+'(%$ /#:!& #3$'&+:%1'(&:/$ !4'/ $ $ +'(/:!!

+0!

%$#3&:/$6 !&#(7$

&$ --.

+%#.

C#(+:%1C %%$ !

- (%%'

$'&.

3'%0'--.

)'4 ( #!

-'.

--1%#%$ /- '

(%'(/ &#//:!!'() #( C /%'4 & !4'/ C & + 3'( + '( %$ !

- (% /%&2:- & 5 ")" %$#&

66-'/ .- %# <2 < %/"

!&#(( -7"

4 (!

&6 /%#3+'&

&%$ 3#--#0'()!:- &0'--.

#.& !4 + 7 & '( 0$'/$ '% '& &% .-'&$ + %$ % /#(+'%'#(& #3 #4

(% !4'/ +'+(#%+ '( #!/#(%!'.:% %#%$ #(& %#3%$ +'&

.:% '(3-:

+%$ &:.& M:

(%/#:!& #3%$ +'&

0'--3 --3#! // 6%

#(%$ .

&'&#3 ))!

%'#("

5.7+'&

0$'/$$ &- +%# ('(+'4'+:

-C&+'&/$ !) #!+

%$0'-- #!+'( !'-1.

+%#$ !'& ('(& !4'/ '3(#(#% #3'%0 &

% %$ %'

#3 %$ '(+'4'+:

-C& // 6% 3#! #4

(% & !4'/ #0 !'3

+'/ -#6'('#($#-+&3#!!

&#(&%#.

&% +%$ %%$

+'&

/#:-+(#%$ .

(+ /% +#(

+'/ - @

'( %'#(6!'#!%#

// 6% 3#!& !4'/ %$ +'&

0'--(#%.

+%#$ !'& +:!'()& !4'/ 5/7 3 +'&

'& // 6% + &$ 4'() !'& ('(& !4'/ '% :&% -&#.

&% .-'&$ + %$ % %$ /#(+'%'#(& #3 #4

(% & !4'/ + '( + #!

/#(%!'.:% +%#%$ #(& %#3%$ +'&

(+%$ %%$ /#(+'%'#(&0 +:

%#%$ /'!/:

&% &#(+:%1'(#4

(%& !4'/ 5+7 (/#(&'+ !'()0$ ! 6 !%'/:- !+'&

'&+:

%##4

(% !4'/ '%'&( / && !1%#!

- %$ &% .-'&$ +3 /%&'(%$ %'#-#)1#3 +'&

(+#3'%&(#!

-+ -#6

(%%#%$ /%%$ %/#(+'%'#(&#3 !4'/ ")" @6#&:!

&%!

&& /-'

%/"

1 $ $ + #( '%&

('3 &% %'#(" ) !+ :&% -&#.

$ +%#%$ %'

3 /%#!5-&#&

/$ +:- 7"

&62 (&

()+$ 2& -7 '&

&&:/$ &!#(/$'%'&$ :

%'& (+ 6$!'%'&'(+

#&%+'&

&#3%$ !

&6'!

%#!1&1&%

;#'(%& (+8'+( 1&

/% +.1/-'

%'//#(+'%'#(&"$ 6 !'#+ (+%$ /#(+'%'#(&#3 !4'/ % (16 !%'/:- !6- / &$#:-+.

% ('(%# //#:(%'( '('()/ :& -/#(( /%'#(0'%$& !4'/

&62 (&

() & &7 $'&&$#:-+.

+ /'+ +0'%$+:

%#%$ ( %:!

#3%$

+:%'

& 0$'/$ %$ '(+'4'+:

-$ & $ + %# 6 !3#!

'( #4

(% !4'/ " %

%$ %'(&#

/ &%$ '(+'4'+:

-$ +.

() ) +#(& (% !1+:%'

&0$ (%$ 10'--(#!

--1(#%M:

-'31"

'& &&&7 '&

&&:/$ & - !'

J - !<'- !'

&'&1& (% !1$#-

%/"

'/'(/ !% '( &"$ +'&

1 -&#.

'(%!#+:/ +.1 #4

(%&#3'(3 /% +6 !&#(&"

(+ '('()/ :& -/#(( /%'#(0'%$& !4'/ '%0'--$ %#

&% .-'&$ +%$ %%$ /#(+'%'#(&#3#4

(%& !4'/ @6#& '(+'4'+:

-%#%$ '(3 /%'#(& & !

&:-%#30$'/$$ /#(%!

/% +'&

"$ %$ '&

+'/ - 4'+ #3%$ /#(%!

/%'#(#3 +'&

& '%$ !6!'#!%# (%!1'(%#& !4'/ #!0$'- #33+:%1#!

#(-

#!+ !%'#(#!:( :%$#!'A + .& %/" %%!'.:% .'-'%1 &$#:-+ (#% .

// 6% + :(- && %$ +'&

#//:!& 0'%$'( %$

'(/:.

%'#(6 !'#+"

5'47 '& $

7 (%'%-

(% %# (&'#(0'--.

'%% +'3%$ @6#&:!

%#'(3 /%'#( !#& 3!# %$

/'!/:

&% &#3%$

!C&#4

(%& !4'/ .8*'9/* 17

< <

9 "

& /% +.1/-'

%'//#(+'%'#(& 5'7

:- #( !1:.

!/:-#&'&"

5''7

:- #( !1

5'''7

:- #( !1:.

!/:-#&'&0'%$6- :!

- 33:&'#("

5'47 :.

!/:-#&'&#(6:- #( !1"

!#(/$'%'&"

54'7

- :!'&1

-:() .&/ && .!#(/$'

/% &'&"

54''7

!6( :

#('

54'''7 6$!'%'&5 /:% (+/$!#('/7"

5'@7 %'%'& +'

5@7 $ :

%'& /:% 5@'7 $ :

%'& /$!#('/"

5@''7 !%$!'%'&"

5@'''7 -)'

5@'47 :

)#"

5@47 <!#&%.'% -

+'()%#

6:% %'#(#3-'

.2-'

.&"

5@4'7

% %!#8 "L

%)+) + ,

1 !- 7

!0 " ! !

"0 6 - - )C

" +

&3:3 !

A !B0

-"!7 0 ! 0 "" !

, * 0< 1*0

@ " ! ! *

0 667 -.8 -

" -

" ! !

- 0 8

! ! 0 - ! 0 0

" 6)+) + , !

F @ .

- " &

! " ) + /)* + " !

0 0

, *

0 7 0 !

0 ! @

, # "

) +0 <

0 " 0 " !

0 0 - 0

'>2'$$&

14 4- "

0 0 "" - ;

;

- 0 !

* 0

" ! "

" !

;* !. !

" "

A-"!7B

A-"! B . !

" ! ;* !. !

! "

! 0 0 !

!"# ) '' * "