High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/21672/2019dismissed

Surender Singh v. Haryana Vidyut Prasaran Nigam Ltd And ORS

2023-07-17Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil9 pages

!"#$!%&'&"()**+

+,-+ !"#$!%&'&"()**+

+,- !"#$!%&'&"()**+

) ./0 * 1 01 00 / ****

!

!

#

!

# $ 1($!!2 "3$4&56 * %&'

( ) #* *+ !""

!

, #

"

# ! %-'

(

*# !

--. # ) #/ # !# # , --0-1 -2&1%4 5&2' *+ -

*+

! %$'

( # ! * 6#")7 5-&.3-5 -2&1 8

9

# -- -2&2 5

*, +

" : *5 +

- 2 - -2&$ #

*+ # " : *5 + -2&;

+ 6 < = ! + -2&> ..? *5

@ !

(

"

!

! # !

2& -22;%4

&' /(/ @ = ! !

( *+ : " /

( / A

$2 2& &11B%4 -'

%B'

!"

! ,

+ # /(/ ! # !

# # + + -2&B # + -2&.

# !! , + !"

#

# *+

/(/A

-3 2.

-2&B%4 B' #

*+ ! *+

-3 -2&. %4 53'

*+

$2 && -2&.%4 5>'

+ # ! #

!" /(/ ( (!!#

+ /

# #

! # !

$2 2& &11B%4 5-'

*+ C /

( / + *+ : "/

( / A

%;'

"

!"

! #" "!"

)

0@

< ( = + +

" " % ## D 0 -E

+ ! #"/(/

!

! # !

( !"

#

@ 0

! : " *+ @:

5!"5@ !0

!

!

6

-.

&2 -2&>

- 3 - @ 0

!

!!

2B -2&1 %4 5B'

! #

" *+ *" # 60#

/(/ ! # !

!!

+

*

! -- -2&1%4 &2' !

5

3

B%A'#

=A=" +% "

'

&112 2;

-2&1 %4 5;'

A

# ! "

!

## +

%.'

! # !

*# #

+ ! !

+ + #

" !

* 6 5" "

* + F ! " G # *"

, # ! +# ! # !

# !

#"

# /(/ !!

# " #

*

+

! %3'

!

*

! ?

)!

! "

!

!! # , +0 # !

*+ " + ! # !

+ * , *+

" 4 !" +

#

" !!

!

! " , 0 # !

"" *

- 4 - %>'

! !

! #

!

!

! * # "

!

#

#

+

" #

" #F ! *#!# !

*!" #

* ! " +

"

#

*

!

" *+

* 4 !

#

)

# "!

! ##

+#

* # " ! #* ! !+

# "

! !#

"!

*

#!

*"

% ' #$

%& '

(!)**+ H% '% ,-'

.

)!*/0 %1'

!#"

# "

+ *+ ) &1 -2&1

5

"

# + 2B -2--

*+ A

C ! +05///

**"

" " # ! * " &1 -2&1 *+ ) # !#

* &B &2 -2&1 %43' ! +!

%&2'

!

# *"

* + # # 60#

- 5 - /(/! # !

"! " #: # - #

!

5

! ! *" +

! #"

## ! "" -2 2$ -2&1

!

# *" + !!# #" + &11&&11-

&11$ "" -3 2$ -2&1 "

@

!

@ /(/0= ! !

#" / ! # !

"

6 -B-B # 6

* *+: "/(/A

# # !

/(/! # !

# !

#"

: " /

( / -3 2.

-2&B -1 -2&. $2 && -2&. %4 B 3 > ! +'

!!

*"

! + !

#

+F #

!!

+ * " %&&'

* # *+ !

" "

*+ " ! *"

! !"

"

*+

"

# "

* # *+ "

! # !

*!

!

+#* !

!!

##

!

## # !

*+ +

!!

" # !# # ! # !

- 6 -

1 + # * " ! ! * !" ,

#

!

$" %&-'

%&$'

/" * !

*# # *+ * #"" -3 2$ -2&1%4 5>' *+

: "/(/A

@ /(/0= ! !

#" / !

"

* ! *+ " # " 6 *# # !

# 6! # !

"

6 %&B'

/ +

+ -2&2

#

! " + -2&$ -2&; #

*+ " < = -2&> /

!"

"

*+ )

# ! # !

# /(/ 5

"

#" !! : " /

( / A

! + (

-3 2.

-2&B%4 5B' # "*!!

+ -2&. & > -2&. !

*+ @+ # ! : "

! +#! # !

#"

#" /

# * !!

0 -1 -2&. %4 53'

# 5

"

5 #

! # * !! "

$2 && -2&.%4 5>'

%&;'

! # # " !"

*" !"

"## ! "

- 7 - @:

!

: " /(/ A

*" + !!# ( #

/(/ A

"

"" -3 2$ -2&1 %4 5>'

+@ #"/(/ %&.'

/ !! *# )

* "*+! # 6! # !

*+

+ # "!

* * + #

!*+! #

! # !

* " !

#

"

+ +" +

!# ) %&3'

6 , + " !" !

!" ! #

!

"!

, + !*F # 4! , +F ! #

6 , + " ! # , * "

=, + F ! *4! !

#

" * # #

! # !

*+

+ # +" + , * ! !

!" ! / " #

, + !" !

*

* "#

!

!, *+ ! # %&>'

(

+ ! * # #

! # !

!

" # ! *# " ) # $

2 3

4!(**)

# F " .$

,

% 3

- 8 -

!1**)0

!" +"*+ 6 #

!

"

!

"

!

%&1'

*, + !

" # ! *# ") " -% 3*-.$

% - 56 3

4! +**

F " # A"* +

) " )

! # " +

!! ! "! * *+ , * ! =

+ # !

# ! # !

!

!

#

! # !

!,

" /

!

" +

6 # 6!

! # !

# #-2+ *

")

+" +, + +

!

" # 6! # !

!

# " %-2'

/ !

!"!

/(/! # !

@ = ! !

#

,

# !

#* 5

"

#* # 6 # !

!

# !# !*

" ( "

* !

+ " +"

"" / "

#

! "

!

* *+ 5

" #

!

"# #

5

"#1+

$ " , + !" ! !

!

+ # # " !

*+

- 9 - " ! !

+ )#

+##

+ #! "!

! 5

"

!4

*+ #

+ ! ! ." #" # %-&'

!!

+ * * !

" * # +" %--'

( 4 # *+ )

+

+ # ! ! "

*#

! "

! *+ 5

%-$'

!!

+

+ 1($!!2 "3$4&5

3$4!

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No