High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/8117/2013allowed

Jagmal Singh v. Presiding Officer Etc.

2017-08-30Mr Justice Jaswant Singh13 pages

!

" !

"#$%&!'()*+&$$ '

*"!+

!" #$ !

$ !

$ % & ' "

$ $ ! " $(

)*)&&)'+,-

./0 & ""

#$ $ 1 !

#$ $ " ! !$ $

! ! !

$ 1!

#$

$ 1 # #$

! !$ $

!

#$ #

#$ "

$ ! $ " #

# ! $! "

#$ !

! " " $ # $

(

" "$

$

2 $ 1# # $

"

$

3 % *4/& &))' " ! )5')&))4" # # (

6

(

$

"!

#" $ 6 $ "

$ + ( !

$ #$ " ! 2 " !

! # "

#$ ,! $ 0 $! "

#$ !

! " #$ $ # #( !

# !

# #$ $# #$ 2 7! ! 8

$! ! 6$ !

! "- ! $

6(

$$ ! "! ! " 9" #! 2 # #$

$

:;6

" $(

* !

!

$ 1# # # !

2 !

# #$ $

$ ! #$ $

$

#$ $ (

!

! '' <$ ! ( !

$ " ! 1 ' !"#$

% & '(

) & ,-.//,0 $.,1/%-2$., //,034,(., .,14

5) 6,

6

"

! ! -(

!

! ''1 <$ !6 $ #

! "(

8" = !

$ 5 2 7! 8 $

1 #$%&% $ '( (%)*!+ $$ (! % !( ( $ ,'! - .

% ' . &'

!..&.&(% '.%&. -.

% '

$/ "0

% ,% ,

,& "

& , " 33456

78 "

354

7 )

3374

7 "

3:659

7 ) ; < 46&-= > . - =&>/"" ( ?0 !

@ &0 - = &>

"

( ?0

.

?0 37 46 :

"

( ?0 0

. "

" 9

.

2

" 0 "

2 3

&-= >

?0

&-= >

""

( ?0 2 <

?04

"

"

" :A

'

"0

@@./&0

&- = > 9

/

2B

@@ ./ 9 46 "

0 " 0

96 4 9 C

.

2 ?

0

@@./

?

"0

/ / D

?0

"

?0

0 /

0

04460 /D

/" " * /D -/ 0 "

B

* 2 2 0

7 "0

=2>

" 0/ / 2

-*

? 0

@@ ./ ""

/ '

0

9 46:

7:/

/ " D

0 7 '

2B

% "0

'

/ "

/

/

0

" 2B"0

" /

"

0

0

" "

/

2

0 2 - * /

2

"0

=2>

2 D

"0

-

E 2

"

"0

"

'

"

& . ;

D

"

'

"

- * /

0

0 !

0

? 0 0

!

- / 0

F 0

F

/ 0?

" 0 2 " 0/ 0

"0

0 "

0/

"" 0

0

F

/

*

"0

"

/ ,

! 0+ ! @ @ -D D .0

/ 2

@@./

/ "

" $0

! 0

/ 2

/ 0

2 0

/ 2B

@@ -D / / "" 2 "

$

"" 2$

D .0

/

"0

/ .04

$

"

D

.0

/

0 2 $

*

"

$ 66

/

4 - .0

"

0/

0

/D

"

0- .0

/ 0

0 /

"0

.0

/ 2 "

"0

/ "

' 0

2

- - / - D .0"

"

/ 2

2

/

D " 0

2

/ 2 0 0 /* /D

/

/ - D .0

&

96 46

@@-D .0/ /

$

/-* -

'

2 0

/ 02 2

0G

"

/

0 ,2 - * /

0/

"

/

&; "

2 2

/ "

0

2 0

/

2 2

?0

2

0

/

7

2 7 ="

> 2

"

0 0

/ "0

C

2

"

"0

2

0

"

/

462B 2

@ " 96

2

9 46 2

? H

" 0 00D

?0 / 2

"" 0

?

"0

I

2 7! 8 $

2 $

! ! >

!

! #$

$ $! ?

2 7! "-! $

! #$ 6

2 7! 8 $

2 7! 8 $

$ #

! + ,-.!" $"/

0$$" $

1%& 2 7! 8 $

# !

!# ! !

! =5 # #:

2 F

""

8 2 "

"

( ?0 / " 0 ?0 ? E ?0

" " E

( ?0 0E0

( ?0 ""0

2

2

/

2

'

0 " F

"2 '

/ 0

2 " 0

""

""

/ / '

"

"

" / 0

2 " 0

""

"

2 " 0

""

.

?0 " ? E ?0 /

" F

( ?0 "

D

"" 0 / "" 0 " - 0 2 *

2 "

D / / "

" "2 0

0 - @2 *

0 " 0

0 "" 0

""

0

/

? E ?0 0 "2 2

?0 "

/ 0 "

/

?0" 0

"" " /

-

2

""

2

"" ?0/ 2/

' <

" 0 ?0

2 D 0

/

" " E

F"

"

0

?0 0 2

C /

2

/

/ / "" / 2

?0 "

/ ?0 /

"

"" /

I 6 2 7! 8 $

!

# 2 7! 8 $

-

.*62 7!

$

9 "

/

0 ,2 - * /

0/

"

/

&;

"

2 2

/ "

0

2 0

/

;

!!$! !"" ! !

! " ! #! !!$ -

# !6

2 7! ?

2 7! !

0

/

7

2 7 ="

> 2

"

="

> 0 I 6

@ # " !

# ! 7# @ < " !# 7# @ "

@ # @

!

6$ ! 2 ! #$ 8

$ !

> ! 1 $

! 8$

" - !

###!

!

# $

2 7! ! 6

$

!

# # 2 7! 8 $

=

$ #

! &$ +!"23"

$

11'& %' 2 ! 8

$ !

>A- ! # 1 #36

" / / 0 0

"

&

.

" C /

"

2 / "B

"0 0

/

" 8

/ '

F"

" 0 0 F

"" 0 ?0

/20 44!

F" / 0

?0"

"

& " 0 &

. " " /

F

2 "

?0 /

""

E F

2 /

/ / " ""2

0

/ 0G " 0 0

?0 "

0 "

F"

/ 0 0

/ 0 0 F" /

/ E ?

09 44:

"

" "

&

3A44: 44<

0 ?

/ ; 5 ( !

$ #

!! $2 7! 8 $

3% *4/&

&))' !

!

!

$!! "1 #

/D

( ?0 /

2B 0 ;

6 $ B"

#"

!

2 7! ! $ 8 !

$2 7! 8 $

!?

! $ ! $

! '' <$ !32 7! 8 $

!!

! " "

2 $

$

#$ $ ! ''1 <$ !$$ ! (

!

"

# 6

(

" )*)&&)'+,-

./06$ #!

2 !# 6#!!

"$

#

# 5 !!

"

$ "

7$$8.,9

'

- 3 $ . C 3 $

C