High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4498/2012dismissed

New India Assurance Company Ltd. v. Ramesh & ORS.

2019-04-04Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan16 pages

!"#$%&'( ((($$))'

+# ,-+# ,"',

(((+ $"'

!"#$%&'( ((($$))'

)$"',

(((+ $"'

!"#$%&'( ((($$))'

/#'(/ ,01 "',

(((+ $"'

/#'(/ ,01 "',

((($$))'

/'$)"', (((+ $"'

0'"20

"3((

4 '3

(* "5 $'61" ' 2"',$$))'7

"#$% "

(6 "2 (

(# ' 61" '2"

(8 "61" '2"',$$))'

"( 2" $"'

"( '" "( (

(*(+# ""$61" ' 2"',

"#$% "

(6 "2 ( "2" $"'"( "2 (

(0(/():,61" '2"

$"'"(7

"#$% ( ;;;;

<%',

"6 ,))

"22"

(( 6 2 )"9,)2"2

!"#$% &'( 6 2 ) " 9,)2 "2 ) "2 !=! "( "2

6, ,,1

'"2',

# '( < 2)% ''6',2 '

"2', ','" ((

'3 (#(6+> ,) +>8 '-.)69"',"2',#

)"? ',.

)$?"

?'"4))2"# )'"!9 ??

""(@+<9 ? 19%:

',',', , "

8 '% ',"29

'"21 ))?<

,$ 6 , A%)"1, )9 ??

"(4<. , 2'2'" ',"22 ?1, )9 19% $"'"( /'$) ,?) ?'# # 2"#',"$$"

',':

'"":',)'" " ?,',

"'"1"

', '9 '',"22 ?1, ) :',)'" ',# )6

)'))',"

"2',)'"

22?

','2'',#

,$6', $"'"( 7/'$)% 2"#', $"'6,"16 1)$"$),?',',',%'"": "

'', > 2"#', ))2'1, ) ',#, )$") 4!+ ,',','))', > ':'"5)@"

$ ')68 2'9 ?$"1 2

' ',6:$ 1 ', "

" "2', > 6',%2'"456+",':6,"16',% ':'"8 )@"

$ ')6@

',' 2"'

')% > +> ,-+> 8 '-.)

#9'"', >

"',%'"8 ) @"

$ ')6@

','', 2# )%##9 9"

?,'', 9" '"

#' ',# ', ',"

' ?''

? ', $"

'#"'# B# '

" " '','2"#)+"(' ((

2"', "22 / '

6 4! ?

''4") /''

"/68 ',?'"', '( /#'(/ , 01 7 "6 ' 0$

7 " /#'(/,'

01 7#"',"2 +> ,-+>,9"

?,' ) $'

"9 !=! "( "2

? ' $"'

(( /'$)7 1 #"C '

!"#$%',"

< , ?6 8 < ,

"2 ', "22 ? 1, )6 ) ? "#$ "'"','

"2+ ( ) " "

'"2',"2

+> ,-+> ',#"'"1,

) '6 "' ?',' +> , - +> ? 9"

' % ',' , ":

' %2#6 ?+ 6 D$#"',,

) "$$ ?2"<((EB# '

"',', ")9 "2', 2# )%( /,(+# ,-+# ,/#'(+"

, 01 6$'

"2 8 '-.),9"

?,' ) #$'

"9 != ! "( "2

? ' ', 9"1 $"'

6 ) "#$ "'"','

"2+ ) " "

'"2',"28 '- .) ',#"'"1,

) ' "' ?','', '-.) ?9"

'% ',', ":

? 1 ?+ (6 D$#"',','', ) $'

$",

/,(:

,9"

?,' ) #$'

"9 !=! "( "2

? ' ', 9"1 $"'

) " ? $"'"(*4: ,7" $"'"(

!"#$% &'(

"2 )'" 9 ? ?

"(@+<6 ) ? "#$ "'"','

"2+ ) " "

'"2 >

229%, # ',#"'"1,

) '9% "' ? , ? + 6 D $ #"', 2"# ,

$ 1'

22 ? >

', '6 , # # '' ""$'

' 8 )@"

$ ')6@

2"# ((

$'"

((

',', "$' $"',

#"2+ )

$'",

''#''

))'

"'2 ))% 6,

?''

',''#' $ ?#"%',',, 9 "#

9)'""% ":',', ',")%9"2',2# )%( /,(.

)$,9"

?,' ) #$'

"9 !=! "( "2

? '', $"'

" !=! "( "2

6 ) ? "#$ "'"','

"2+ ( ) " "

' "2 >

22 9% , # ', #"'" 1,

) '

"' ?',',, 9$ '

?1" ''6 + ( 6 D$#"',',' '"

22 ?"2 >

',"

'6, # '' ""$'

' 8 )@"

$ ')6@

2"#

((

$'"((

?%',','

#"2+ ( ) $'",

''#''

))'','

,, "'92 ))%

))?''

?''#'2 ??'$,%

), , $',', , 9 "#

9) '"

22 >

',#

9) '""$ '

( / )) ', 2"

) # $'

' "2 ', # '6',"

'"?',

"21

?) '(( $

9% "'" '

!) = )68 ( "'

6 ', $"'

$ ' $$ ( ))% $"'"(,$$ '" " ' ) #$'

',"

?, "

) 9 ' )' "

, "

) 9 ' ', " "', $ ''

""9,)2"2

, $"'"(6

, $" ? 'B$'(+ $"'

"( 6,,"1"22 "' '"', ) #$'

+ $"'"( ', '' ''#'

2 ) ))',

"22 )'"',

', ) #$'

?','"

, ',1':$) ',',1, ) F "','

1"2',)'" ' ,?) ?'#

, $"

9)2"',#

,$','', ,, ' "# :" 1, )','',+ )"?2')%"22 1% "?)%"$ ',"22 ?1, ) F "1',)

1, )

', $"'"(, ,1 ?1) 22 '

1) '

','

#"2))? '6',2"6', "#$ "6 2%6

'"9 $ 9%',

"#$%(/ , $"''"": $1 "

)?) "9> '

', '' ''#'

2 ), ) 1 ?2"

)"2 ', ) #$'

+ $"' "( ', '' ''#'

) "

1")1#'"2',"22 ?1, ) F " ', ' ''

','', '6 2%6,':$) '" ")2 )'"2)'" 1:

" ',)''

16 ' "2 "'

'"%?) ? 6 ',2"

1 "29"',',1, ) "',") ?%1) 22 '

1 ?) '','

#"2 '',1, ) 9 ?$) 1 ")'

""2'# " "2',

$") %( / , $"') " 12"

)"2', ) #$'

+ $"'"(7

"#$%"2)'"! '"

'"": $$)',' ''"":$) '" ,?) ?'

? "2 "22 ? 1, ) 9% $"' "( ',' ',

" ' B$) )%"22 1% )"?

?',+ '

9' ',# 9"

',2 )

"2))?'

( " ?'"',

? $"'6 ' "') 9)'"$%% "#$ "

', 1"2', "',1 ?1) 22 '

1 ?) 9 ?$) 1 ")'

""2','# " "2',

$") %','', ) #$'

92"">"

% $'

)'" "'',"22 ?1, )6',2" $"'

% $'%( / , $"' ) " $% 2"

)"2', ) #$'

( ',$) "2',$'

62"))" ? " ") '

2#3

( G,',', ' F "

9% $"'"(

, ) ?AH& , "(4<. , ?) ?'#

?',"2+> ,.

#-+> ""2 </ ?,8 '-.) ""2+# ,-+# , >

'":

""2*4: ,.

)$ ""2

% / ?, ))?I44( ( 2

$"16,', ) / ,01 ' ( '

')'"% "#$ " 2 "6'",'B''2"# ,"#I44( ( 2

$"1,', ) +# ,' ('

') '"% "#$ " 2 "6'",'B''2"#,"#I 44( ( 2

$"1,', ) #':

')'"% "#$ " 2 "6'",'B''2"#,"#I44( ( 2

$"1,', ) #'.

')'"%

"#$ " 2 "6'",'B''2"#,"#I44( ( G,', $"'"( ,1 ")'%'# " ""2

$") %I4+( ( +) 2( <"',',$'

$$"'"2', $ '

1 )

? ', "

"2 1 6 ', ) +# ,- +# ,6.

)$6:

/#'(/ ,01 ?"' "',

''#'

4G '"4G4G6 $ '

1)%9

B# ?/ 0,#9 4G60(/'

,*# 4G6/,(* :#/,#

4G6/,(+> 4G6/,(4#/ ?,6+ ":$ 4G( ', "', ,6 $"'

' '" 1 "

EB(+ '"EB(+( 2' , ? ?

6 ', = ) ))" ', ) $'

$')%(!) /#'(/ ,01 ' ( !) #4'

!= ! "( "2

"#$ " "2 + (6 6 D', ) +# ,-+# ,,

2 ) $'

"9 !=! "( "2

"#$ "2+ (6 6 D F ) , ', ) #':

"2 ) #$'

9 ? != ! "( "2

+ (6 D ) #'.

)$"2 ) #$'

"9 !=! "( "2

"#$ " '" ', '

"2 + (6 6 )"? ', $"$"'

"' "

' ''','"2J$ #2"#',' "22 ) ?"2',$'

))2 )) K'

"( ',9"',', '

$"'

(("

"29"',',1, ) F " ,)) >"

')% 1))%) 9)'"$%,)2"2',#"

''"', ) ))', ) #$'

'" B $''" ) #':

) $'

"9 !=! "( "2

','

""2 3 (=, ) #' :

,) '

') '" ?' ', "#$ " ")% 2"# $"' "( $"' "( (( "

"2 ', "22 ?1, )'"',B''"2 J")%,

) #$'

"? $"'

( =,# , ,', "#$ "

'"9$$"'

" ) "?

1 ',( ) ?

',',

!"#$%&'7

"2)'"!9 ??

""(@+< 2 ) 6 $'

" D ) )?)$ ''

1 "2 +> ,-+>

!=! "( "2

2 ) ( "'

"2 ', $$)

'" ', $ '

1 $"'

6,"$ ' $$ ',"

?, "

)( ,1,) "

)2"',$'

',"

?,', "(

')%':

$',$$)2 )9%/#'(/ ,01 ' ( )?)$ ''

1 "2 +> ,-+>9 ?"( )) $$)2 )9%

!"#$%&'( (( ? '/ ,01 "', =,= )"$$ ""21 9%',

?',2 '

' "2', , ) ?

?1 '"

"( #'"', " )

"','', 1 "2 9"', ', 1, ) , "'

' F ))%

? ', '6 ',2"6?) ? "29"',', 1 $$"'

" ','

""2 3 (!"# ?'"',#"

'"2 "#$ "$%9)'"', ) / ,01 "', 6',= )'"":?"2', +> ,- +> '" 9 % "

? ,

' "2 9 ', ' ,

" B# '

" '

' EB(4 # ) B# '

'EB(+ (( ',"

?, " ?'"', ) 6,

?9"

'% (=,= ) >

)% $"',' "29 ',"2 ' ,

,"") '

' ( ',#"6',"

?, " ?'"', ) 6, ?+ 6 D$#"',2"# ',1" '

""2?

%2# ?9 ' "

?',$)% ?

19% ""2', / ,01 $$ ? 4G , "

B# '

"','',%,1 ?'

" "29)"$"1'% ) <4& 9 "2%)1'"

#' ," ?',' "%?

)) 9 "2% "?' "1 1 ',?'" "#"2 ''

?, #

) )9"

6',= )'"":,

#"',)% "#'"9+ (6 D$ #"',(=,"

?, " ?'"', "

)2"', ) 6',# ' "2? ',/''"2@%" (( + (6D2"

))":+ (6D2" :

))":,, ," $,"'"

'' "$%"2"

#' ','?9 ' 9 "2% ','

#' ',2"#"2 "$%"2"'

"6',

"' ) '"

)% $"',

#'(=,= ), $$) '"2 D'"

$ ")B$ "2', 6":

'#"',)%$ %"2 ', ) '"9+ (6 D )$ %+ (6 D B

( @"16"', ?'"9"'

','" '" 2 $"

$ '

, 9#( =,= ),':',#"',)% "#"2 '"9 + (6 D $ #"',( 1 "2 ', '

" "2 ',"

## $"

,1'

) '% J"2',#"

'"9 '" 2 $"

$ '

(0"

?','',#"',)% "#"2',

': + ( L M+ ( D( ',

',= ), " ')% ' D"2', #"

''" )2B$ '# "2','

""2 ',"

& '

(

% )"## $" 0"

?','',$ %"2 ) "#

''"+ (6 D$#"',6 )$ % "# "

''"+ (6 B

M+ ( 6 D( =,= ),

# )'

$) "2 6, ,:$ ',?"2', , 9$"$)%

(0"

?','', "#$ "$%9) "# "

''"+ ( 6 B M66 D( =, = ) , ?'

# "2 + 6 D "1'

"), 1 "2 ', '

" "2 ',"

$6', )

')'"?' "#$ " "1'

"), ((+ 6 D " "

'"2)"

"2 ''6+ ( 6 D'" )"

"2 " "'

# + 6 D 2 )B$ 6'"')+ ( 6 D(=,'"') "#$ "# "

''"+ (66 L 6 M6 6 D( =,= ), "#$ ""2+ (6 6 D( ',

%6',, #"

' "# "

''"+ (66 D

6 6 6 6 (=, ) "

)9'

')'"?' ' '- (J$ #2"#','"22 ) ?"2',$$)'

)) '

)) K'

"',, #"

'"2+ (66 D(=,"','# "

1 ',) 2 )

,))$$)%'"',, #"

' ))( ',

, #" "6 ', *(+ ,-+

)

))" $')% ', "

& "

)2"',$$))'7

!"#$%&'( , "'','', )

,"' #$)

!"#$% $'% ', ) $'

"(@"16',= )"?)% ''','',

"#$% ) 9)'"$% "#$ "( G, ', "

)$ '

, ) "' ','

))',2"

) #$'

'"2', # '6',"

'"?',9%',= ) #''"22 '))',2"

) # $'

" ") ' 1 " ' (

(

") '

2#',$'

22""$$"'

'")1 ',2', ??

))',2"

,',

"#$% 9 ?$ '6',,9 "

( =,2"6 ',

$) "' 9 ': 9% ',

!"#$%&'( 2', ?) "

)2"',$'

', "62 ','',B$)'

"9%) "

)2"', )

' "1 ?($

)"2',?" '" ,"','

!"#$%&'( 9 ?$ ' ))',2"

) !=! "( "2

2 )9%/#'(/ ,01

"', ', $ ''"',"2+> ,-+> ',#"'"1,

) '?

))',2"

(=,= ) )' ',', $ '"9 1 ? 2"))"

! "

# $

& & !

! &

& %

( !

% % &

(

& ! ! & !

)

*+,+ "

-.# -.//

0.10.+ & %

! "

/ -

* ) 0.2 ! %!

% &

',#"6/ '

" "2', "'"*, ) '

$ "2)2)?

"(' '9%',4) #''"$"1 ) 2'"',$ 6,"

22 >

',#"'"1,

) '

)) '"',)?)$ ''

1 "2',1 6," 2"'

')% )"

'', ) 1

,$ (/'

' ) "21 $" "'$$) 9)',(

!"#$%&'( "'

$) 9 ) '% ',

"1(+', '

'"$$2"#

?',

$)'',

'?( =,2"6 *(+!-

2 )"9,)2"2

!"#$%&'( '

( 2 "("2 2 )"9,)2"2$$))'

!"#$%&'(

" 6',= )"', 9

"21 9"

?,'"2 ) ',2"#"2# )9 )) 9"

?,'" "6'"')#"

'"2, , ) )''"9+ (6 D#:

2 ?

))"

#"2+ (6 D "

$#'

9 ) '%'"9 J $

9 ) '% '

'EB(46?'

#"2 + ( 6 D " ',' "

'6 , ) ? '"') "#$ " "2 + (6 6 D $' ) 9)"3 / "

'"2 '

)B$

$'"# )''#'

+ (6 - 4,%

)$ #')?"% + ( 6 #

9 ) '% + ( 6 $ "

'"2)"

"2 "#

?',''#'$ ""2 #"', '','"2 + ( 6 D$#"', + ( 6 0 "

'"2'''6 $ ) 'B$ ' $"'

+ ( 6

! "

& "

) 2" ', $$))' ,

) "9> '

" , 9': "2 ','$$))' "'

#$'% ', ) #$'

"9 '',

"9> '

" "'9 $,) "2',' )

$( =, "#$ " " ' )%9"'':'"

9B"9 ''"", ?,

""' %?"

, "#$ "( =,

*(+!!%%+

2 ) 9% $$))' 7

!"#$%&'(

'"2 )9 ? ',"

'# ' '

( !"# ?'""2 2 )9%$$))'

!"#$%&'(6',= ), ':?"2 8 '

-.)'"9% 6,

1" '

" 1#"',)% + (6 D "

?',', # 6 J"2',#"

''" $ ")B$ 6',2"6$ %"2,

) )''"9+ (6 D$#"',6 )'"9+ (6 D )'

$) "2 $$) 6 :$ ? 1 ', ? "2 $'

) )'

?', "#$ "'"9+ (6 6 D

#"2+ 6 D "1'

"), 6'"') "#$ " ": "

''"+ (6 6 D( =,= )"91 "

)%2)) "

?',# )'

?',?? "2$'

"2', , 1 "2', > ?#'

!"## $"

%',?"2

'"9': '"

""'','"2',$'

( ',#"6

#"2 + ( 6 D

"' ', "1'

"), (@"16

', ) ,1"'2 )% "

$$)" "

"9> '

6""'

'$"$'"?'

,92 '"',#( =,2"6 *(+!!%/+

2 ) 9% ',$$))'7

!"#$%&'( ' ) "

( (( #$ < > %&'&'(('

)'*+ ,'

-.)/ + %&'&'((',( +