Union Of India Through Its Secretary, Ministry Of Defence, South Block, New Delhi v. Rajpat Ram And Another
! "#$# %&''
!"
# !"$"
%&'
(& )*( ' ++
+ ,
)*( +' ++ + ( !*$ )+,- '!./0!0 ./$"/0 /0!102!0 3 $ "
3 4 !
!"5 4 ) 0 '" (0 6032)7 80
4 ! '!07)
( */2)7 80
4 !!
+ ,
-'.
*/ /! $*/ 6!
(
2 (
! /
(!0,"4 !"
*0"
!) !)0
): ; <$!
=0"
(0""
)+, 3 0!
)!1 ) !8 "!
+$ 038 8 )26/ +,
60"*!0
4! $ ) * 442 /$"24 !8 1($
*
"0+
,
"07 ") "0+
,(
1 "234 0%5'
0>(0 /0!10 60" ! 33
) 0 ! !8 : ?@?0 )60") "8/0!* )4! 1"
!7 6 4 ? "
A$
/ " ) "8/0!* 4! 1 "
!7 2
60"
4) "0+
,
4( B 0"( 4 33 6 *)
3"-
?
?@ 555@ ?
D 55E55 5
5?:
??@
@ 555? 5??@ ?
@ !3
555@@5
/0 "(
1
/ E 7 ! 1
4 ) '
!, 4 /0) ""$ )0( 3 8,3
!)0
) 20 )2 +0"
" 40+ 7 3
!;=2330/0+0)2/0"03" ""$ )0 !8$30! :?@)0
? 27 6/ 8/2 E 7 ! 1
/0) *!0
) +
4 ! $ ) * 442 4 ) "0+
,
6 4
@ +0"
" 40+ 7 3
!2!
60"*!0
4! $ ) * 44/ ") "0+
,( B C :
C6 4
@4 !3
6 !24
*0**!
)4! 1 04 !
"0 ) !) !2
4 )2+ 4 !
!
+$ 038 8 )!0 !4 !
*!0 4
4 0(( "
! $ ) *" 446 4
??@/
"0 )0((3
60"033 6 !) !)0
): ; <$!
=/ ( !0
(0!
4 ) !)
)/
!-
!
" #
$ #
## %
&
% ' # '
( & ))
*$' + :
* 0**!
) 4! 1 04 !
!) !2 (
! 4 ) 0/0"4 0*0 6!
+067#$$# %$ ! 8 1 4% 5" 0%$ 1! 4 8 9 # # % 4
@ $
2 3 0!
)8 $ "
34 !
!"
4 ) 0!
!"
;"= 470!
$">$)*1
"+, F+3
( < $!
26/ +,"2
) 4$!
!"$+1
6 4
<( "
$30
" 430610)
"2 3 0!
)!
+$ 038 8 "/ $3)/07
*!0 40!!
0!"
4 ! /!
, 0!"
033,20!
"!
A$ 10) (0!0*!0(/"
:0 )@ 4 )+, F+3 ( < $!
)0"
! "#"$$% &'#( )%"$!)%" #"$$% *+& &#,&* &* -. &'-2) )
/ )(0!0*!0(/" :0 )@ 8 1
)/
! %
) ,
) - ) ) . - ) )
(.
&
/ ) 0 )
,) 1 &
&
)
2
3 &
) 2 &
)
)
)
1
)
)
4 5
)
4
) 5 6 7 5
)
)
! )
!)
5
( 6 7
, )
!
)
) )
+ !
0) * 4(0!0*!0(/ : 4 ;"$(!0=83 0!3, $ ) !"8 !
408 0 ,830 1 "/
+, " 4) 30, 0 )308/ "2 /$"$3
3,044
* 0(( "
+3
:
*/ A$0 0!1,( !"
32+$
* 3, (0,1
!!
4 <0
4 (0, ! ( 2 +,"2 "0 ) ) 30, ) 830 12 !0 ! 8 1 *"
!0 */ 60,!
>
)2 /$"2 "!
A$ 033 6 )2+$ 6
04
0!!
0!" 4(
*!
)$( 0( ) 4 /!
, 0!"(!
)0
44 * 4 6!
? )80"
(0!0*!0(/ @ 42 ( < $!
830!
*/ $!
60" >$"
!
4 0!!
0!" 4( 8 7 *0( ) 4@, 0!"0 ) 6
/
603" 0(( 0!" /07
088
0 >$)*1
0!
*
"/0#"$$/ &'#(
%% #"$$1 *- 2.+& &#,&* &*
-3* **& %$ "$$/ / (0!0*!0(/"6/ 40!
)/
!
)
(
0 )
,# & #
* 45&*&4 *5-5&
5-
6 *7- -
#6- - *4'&*&4 *#4- 5( 6 7
&
6 7
)
4 &&&'& &5
## *8* &'-5#-
@ *#& &#-6 &/ 0
& )
8
)
6 7 )
(
) )
+067#$$# %$ ! 8 1 4% 5" 0%$ 1! 4 8 4 $9 %5 % '
!/0 )2 3 0!
)8 $ "
34 !
"$+1
04 !
)>$)*1
"0!
0((3 80+3
80"
2 0" 1 1+ ! 4 ) 8 1+0 0+3 "/1
60"
03!
0),
4 "0+
,( 0 ) ) 61
" 4
0(( "
"/ /! $*/10G *" 4! $ ) *;"= 442 /$"
6 $3) 3,!
"$3 0>$"
0+3 8!
"$(( !
4/ "0!*$1
"2/ (308 )!
0 8 0 /!
&$)* .
8/ >$)*1
(0""
) +, F+3 ( < $!
2
? @2
)0" :#%5 4+#%38;$' %# % !%5# %5
8 4$2 6/ 8/ #:#199 1 '<< = != "0""
* )/
(0!0*!0(/" 4 0!
)/
! (
9 #
) 3 (:
1 7 ) ;
#$
#
!( (
,
,
)
)
)
)
(
)
&&&& &&&&
/ )
)
) (
&
)
)
( < = 8
)
)
) ! *$'
,
,
)
) )
/
)
)
!
"#
)
)
;
+ %! 4 %" $ ! 8#$ 04 '
/ $*/27 +3, 0 ,) 30, )1
"!0 )+,
0**!
)6/ +,"08/033 * "80$"
0)
* !) !(0""
+, 8 8 )2 $( 2 !0 * 40) 30, )1
+$ 10G
"01 /
+, 4) 30,0 )308/ " 6 !2
<8
0+ 7 (!
(3 20""
/! $*/7 "!
8 !) )+,
( < $!
)0"+& &#,&* &* -. &'-0 )
)0"- 2.+& &#,&* &*
-3 2,
!"
38 8 )2+ 8 1 *
4 <0
4( "07 "/ 12+$ 6
/04$!
!!
) 3,4 !0( ) 4 /!
, 0!"4! 1
)0
44 * 4
.
0"
10,204$!
<8
"$(!0
)(0!0*!0(/"20" 88$! ";"$(!0=!
)+,
( < $!
2
2 0 +3 */ 8 1
0**!
)2 $( 2
40 +3
*/ 0**!
)2 /$"6 $3)4$ 30!
8$!!
* !08
$ $"
80$"
4 08
7 "07 " 0**!
) "$3 3,2 +,"
30, )!0 * 40830 12 /$"6 $3) 0
"!0 +0!
43
! +,"0 ,($!( !
4) 30,"0 )308/ 6 $3)
3,4$ 8
0"0"
$1+3 *+3 8G0*0 *!0
* 4
4$33
4 0**!
) : !)
!1
*6/
80$"
408
6/ 8/088!$ "07 (!
/$"60"0!
8$!!
* !08
$ $"
80$"
408
"4 !)
!1
*6/
!0 !,
0 +3 */
(!
2 +,2
""0!, 0! 1 408 $1 2 80$"
408
088!$ (!
2$( 2 10G * 407 +,
F+3 ( < $!
)0") %# % !%5# ;$'
7:
4F2 ( !
+ %1#% =2) ) 26/
"2 0) 830!0
"10)
2
4! $ ) * 442 !0 ! /0" + 8 1 ) 6 ) 8 8 ) / !
(0!0*!0(/"0" 88$! ;"$(!0=0!
)/
! 91)
-. 5
)
)
)
) ( -.
7 ;
-#.4 "4>-? 27. ) @ )
>
#
)
3 ?
)
?
)
3 ? %/
!/
) ,
-.
-.
)
"(
0
)
6 7 ) (
)
) + @ / 4 !
2"
+3 */
(!
2$( 2 10G *" 4 +, ( $!
2
)0" ) %# % !%5# ;$'
7:
4.$094 /' A$ 32 830!0
430610) ;"$(!0=26/ $ ) !"
0
*/ 8 1 ) 6 "07 8 8 )2 /$"
) "$3 3,2 ) 61
4 )!
*/ 27 "07
8 8 )2 /$" + 8 1 " 8 !
!"
4 ! /$" 4! 1"
!1
*2 6/
! (! 1( "
A$ 3
!0 ! (!
!0 )0830 120 )2 0 ) 1
/ 7 ;"$(!0= + (! $ 8 ) 0 )
!0
!1" 4 2 /$"0
4 !
!
+$ 038 8 )2 , 0! ?/ $*/2
!1" 4 ;"$(!0=) !0 0(! 1( 1
($!"$0 8
"2+$ !0 )01
3,04
!0) 30, 40+ $
, 0!" 0G *(308 6 !26/ ) 61
"10) $ ) !"
"07 (!
2+$ 0 $!033,8 4 !!
)0 +3
*/ A$0/ 1/ 4 !
26/ +3 */
(!
!0 /! $*/7 ;"$(!0=+$ 8 8 1
3, 03" 8 4 !!
)08
$ $"0 )!
8$!!
*80$"
408
A$0
(!
"$3 3,03" $ ) !"0 +3 */
7
) (!
!
4 ! / " "
* A$0
0(( "
! $ ) *" 44+
*10) / "407 $! 7 !6 "
) 830!0
4 306 10)
;"$(!0=10G )) 830!0
0 <( "
$30
4306
12 +,"2 <( "
$30
4306 120"10)
;"$(!0=03" 10G $ ) !"8 4 !!
)+
"7 "07
!"
38 8 )2 2 2
8 8 )2
/$" 0 0 ,
2"
G *!0
* 4 ) 61
"0"10)
$ ) !"2 0 ) 2 4$33 8 1(3
2 0" "(
$ ) !"2+ !!
"(
4 +0! 4) 30,0 )308/ "
#% 1 45 4 ! 8#$ 04 '
? 04
!10 /2 " $!
4 )" 1
6!
0 ) 6
/ +"
!70
" 04 !
"0 )2 "01 " ) "1 ""
) /
1($* ) !) "10
)0 )044 !1 )
10
34/0"+
)2 /$"2033
*0((3
;"=2 40 ,203" "
0 );"=) "( "
) 4 .+
+ ,
.+ + (/ ''
&% /
!"( 0G *5!
) - "5 /
!!
( !
0+3
- "5