← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/36185/2024dismissed

Mukesh Kumar v. State Of Haryana

2024-08-30Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel17 pages

     

   

   



#$%&'(%)*+*&, !

 

     34

 

  (    ! 



     0 

#0 5

      6 

#207# 

   88888 

"!

  9          

     





   

 !"

# $ %&'(" $%

%$ $) $   * + ,+ ,#*-+,#) #)-+ ,#)*#)#%- +%,  !"

# $ %   *  ./ .

. 0 

  

  

#2

 !1   9&'(: + 

  ,

   

    45 

  



   

   !!" 



 # $ 

#%

&  %  '

!  



 %( !!

 "

 !  6    $  "



)   3- "  !

  "

 * !

  )"

 )  

+ + ! 

" !,

!  "

 1./ /0/1

-./0/1 "

   

!"  ")2 ,

% "

 !     !           2   !

    



    "

     



! 



"

" 30./0/1



 



  "

   



    "

 

   

!   

   

"

"!

2 !!

"4      "





! "

" #

$ "  2! 



 

         "   

 9 !

   # !!  !" 2 !" 2 " % ;

  

 



   

   

  &'( :  $$) $ #1 

   1    5





 +,  

    



1   1

      #   1 %= 

 5  

 5





       9  

 5

5  5    

 :

 1

&

# 

 

      5            

4

  #    

       

#

#     1  

    

    5    ;

    

  

   # 

   #

 

     5   

      5    1    

 



($$$

      ;

  

 

    

 

+,         

   5 



  

     

 ;

   



  5  

  

  

  1

 < <5 





9 9# 

 

   

 7 8 

   





    

    

 

 5  

 



  5 5 #

 5   &'(: #



 5 

 



 + ,  !"

# $ %  &

# 

   

     >

 

 

 





        

    

5 5 

  ;



 

 

#5 1  





   #   

       >   9#

 

        

 

 - ' 5

  

  5 





 -*.%*++ +/% * 9  

 

 1





      

     9  





 

 1   

 

     % / /#?)% 

  %)*+%,4   %)*=0!4    %)*=204   %)*=2!  ' /# *$ @        !"

# $ %       *-+ ,4   )$+ ,  !"

# $ % 9 

 

 

 



     #1



 

  %0%1#,$ +$#$/$&-23-&1*+*&,+ 4%&(%&'-*.*,#0-&) )%(/-%"56+  

 / / /#?)%,

  %+ ,

  

 



  

      :3; <<< <<< <<< <<< :/; <<< <<< <<< <<< :=; <<< <<< <<< <<<

:1; >     !! !" "  !

 

  "   



     4  :=;     =.?     =.?&    =.?6& & 

!@ 9  =.?6 #

7

,(*#,%,#0&(%" +   

A'/B B, %)$*&,678&'$4%"

 = C 

   :3; <<< <<< <<< <<< :/; <<< <<< <<< <<< :=; A 

  

  <"  

 !!      

        !!  ! ""    

"< 

         !!

 

   

      B  !!

  !! ! !

!  7

    !!   

!   

!< 

 



 7

  "



    4   !!







9 %)$*&,6&'$4%"

 =  

   

    

    !  "    A 

  

 !

"    !!     

       !! !  ""   

"

"< 

   !

   !!

    

  B  

     7

    !!   

!   

!< 

 



 7

  "



     !!





C %)$*&,6&'$4%"

 = #  

    

  $

"     =A 

  < "      "

               

     !!  





      !!    

   !

 

 !!

    

  B  

   7

    !!   

!   

!< 

 



 7

  "



     !!





 %)$*&,6&'$4%#

 = %

 

    

   ! "



 & A 

  !

"      " 

         

     !!  





      !!    

   !

   !!

    

  B  

    8 7

    !!   

!   

!< 

 



 7

  "



     !!





 4%4#-#$*1##9#-*:/ /-#:+4##,4*$#"

+ 

 

D!""

D, %)$*&, 78&'"

  E'

 



 

      :3; <<< <<< <<< <<< :/; <<< <<< <<< <<< :=; <<< <<< <<< <<< :1; >     !! !" "  !

 

  "   



      ?-   4  :/;     .0     "

 >"

"

"

  /0/=9 4% 4#-#$*2# 2#2# # #,4*$#"

 +   



D!"

D, %)$*&, &'#

 

 %

/ 

      &:3;A 

    

    <  "      !!       

          !!   !    " "   

"< 

   !

  !!

     

     B   ! !

    !!

! !

!  7

    !!   

!   

!< 

 



 7

  "



    4   !!







 :/; A  

     

   !

 "   

  !!     

       !!

!

! ""   

"< 

       !!

   

  B        7

    !!   

!   

!< 

 



 7

  "



    4   !!







 %)$*&,6 &'"

  E01  &:3;  <<< <<< <<< :/; A 

 

"      " 

         

     !!  





      !!    

   !

   !!

    

  D  

     7

    !!   

!   

!< 

 



 7

  "



    4   !!







F %0%1#,$ #+%#; ) 9 =

1# #  +,:  

1 1 ' 2 &





" 3  *+  %     (  %   ) * !





 +

,-..

+,

6 0 G ! D   /

<

  !24( 56

7 89&'0'0*+% %(( '# 

  C&&)  ,8 C30 @    !

"   

    1=E @7@  !! !"  & 3*E*  

  !

 

2  

   !

"  

 & 3*E* 

  " 3E 3E& E&:

;  !! !"A

!

   ! 



  C &%

 , , C=3& 

  3E&  "

   )  ,       



!<  

   !

   

  4 

! =/#!

!"



  

 

F   !

 " !

2 4 

!

 @ 

     

     

        1=E    @

7 @ 3*.=    !"  

" <  !     

   

     5#%  

!   

 !

      !

! !



!"

 

      

       # 

        " ! " 

!

!!"

! 



 !

 !         4 

! !

  

  7 !

C +, 9 D    /

  <  

 #%4 4 %:! ) % ; 8 &< (

< '0'7<%( '/# 

  C13# !    

   3E & & 3*E*  



!            <

 

    

 & & 3*E* 

&

   3E !



"   !

  "   

 

   & &3*E*     "

  1=E @7@!



!  <<<< <<< <<< <<< <<< <<< <<< <<< <<< <<< 1. 7

  '

       !

    9 9 

   

 9   <    



! <         !

  5#%9 !

  

  

   

    5#% !

9    "



    &3*E* 

   

     !

      

  <  

 1E &  $    

" 

         &3*E* 

 ! 



 

!! ! !!  !

5#%    

 < "

"

    @

    3E !

  !"

   !

 

! !" !     4  

!   <<< <<< <<< <<< <<< <<< <<< <<< -0  "  

 

 <          

   "

     !

" "    !

" $ "  

           !

5#% 

!   



 $ 

      & &3*E*# <   

!" 

 

 !! ! !!

 !

 !



   " 

   

!!   !

  

!





    !

"  

    !

5#%  

  !        



    

             !

    2  "

!  

!!

" 

 !9

 

 

'' 2 &



"    

  *+   

  = > >

*

2 

!

 +

-.

+,

5 0 G  D   /

<

2 2 ?!% ;  

 &'0'- 72*%

(  +''

'/ 

  E*

 

     !!  !       .:; &

    

"

!  1=E @7 7@3*.=G !

:;  . !

   

                 

! & !! !  

!!)   !

! " 

    

 )!



 

$      

 

!   

!C <<< <<< <<< <<< <<< <<< <<< <<< 3.      < <   ! !

      ! @   ! 

:7   & ;&3*E* 

  "

  3E  4 :/ /;    3E4&   !

    1=E    @7@ 3*.=   @ !

 

 !!  !" !

  

2C 

 C   !

" 

  & &  " <!          

 

   !"   H<!



 

"

  

 !

"     @   :  ; !

 <!  !!    !

   

      !

" 

    ! @    ! 

:7   & ; & 3*E* 3E 5

  

 !              1=E   @7@ 3*.=

 .:; &  

   "

!   

  & 

  

   

  )!

 

   

   !

       "

!# !



     

4 

 !

         "   

 "

!



  

 ) !



9 ''' 2 &



"   

  *+  %

 *+@  @ @ 7(

+,

9 !    /

  <  

   : < : ! )  %  =    

 

< .- '0''# 

  ) <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< 

    !   !   !

 !"

"

        %  ;  =4  5 %

 =   *'0-+%(( / 2 ?5% ;   

  *'0'-+-%((    !"      

!

  4 

!

  

 H< !   !



   H<!    @B

  



!   

"

!  !!  !"   

   

  #      6 

)  : ;



     

! 

   =3* =/?  =/     !  @    !  

 :7   & ;&3*E*   3E/3*/3*=/0= /3* 

  =1 #7@ !  !

#  %  , !:  ;     

!     .

.    )!

 A  :7      %  ) 

;&/03*  !

<<< < <<< <<< <<< 30 &  !"F   



   

     @

@     "

!      1=E   @7@   B !   @   !

   

 

     !

     1=E    @7@   

 

!  

!

!

 !

 

    4  :1;   

 1=E   @7@        =.?:=;=.?4&=.?46& =.?46 !

 +, 9

/

 < <  

AAAAAAAAAAA AAA !%

;  

 &<   (

< '0'@;B2@//#

  6  4  :1;     1=E    @    @

7   

!

    4 

! 

 !

   

 !I<<<<<<<<<<<<<< <<< <<< <<< <<< <<< <<< <<< <<< <<< // <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< # <!  

  4 !



!

 1 1=E:1; @7@   

!

  !! 

! 

 

! 

    

  7      $ !!"

 !

2

   !"

! "    2

     !"   

    <!   !

   " "  

!

       !

!     

   

!!    !" !  

   '

  <!         

!     

 !     !

"   & !/ /3 @   #

 /= #   2   

  $   

        

!"#!

 <!   4 

! 

"   1=E:1;   @7@                 



!  



! 

!!   !" ! 







!<          <! !

 !

!"

" 

  

    

 

"

 

 "@      

     ,#02+*+ 7-%0#;8 

  %)*+%,# %)*0!# %) )*20  %)*2!  '/



  % %+ ,/ /#?)%1    

1    

1+ ,!

# $9 

  < 



= E% 

            

     <"  !

" 

 2       >                      <" 

!

" $   

 ! !

 

       

 " 



2 "    "

!   

 !   !!

 

        " 

2   ! 

   

 



     "

  9



9  



 5  *-+ ,4 

 )$+ ,!

!"

# $ %    !"

"

# $ %   H1



  

 5

   

 

 



   B  H 5       5

  #  

 # "

    

5 

 5   1

 

    # <  

  5     5

5      

   1 5 

>

 5 

   

             

# & H      

' 

1 

= 





5 #   



1      



5 

   I  >

 5

    

#

5

  @          



 I 

=

 < 

5

H  

      

# 1        5 

  1

 < '

  1

 

   1

5      

 >   0

H 1   1

 

 

5 

 

H    5    

 #     0 

 =E      B <   #







 5  5 9



1 # #   5

 J   #  5 



 9  # 5     1   #

 5  5

 ? K>      + +  

  ,

     

 

9 



;

2

 2#1   1   5

   B    /

 "  !   #       " !

4

F   2     !!   "     !!       !!    !

 !

!        

" JJ # 

       

 " "   #              

 "  !

 9 '

 

  <  







 

   

 1         

  #1 #  

 

  

 1    

#1 



   5 

     

5   

  



#  5 5 1

  #   5

 < 



 



 

1 

  

 >  #  

  < 

#1  5 

    5

  9

     

 



#   #  

5

5 







 0 0

#  



  

   

# 



1 

      

1 $ 9 

 :  1  

 



 

# 1 





 =





 #1 



 

9 

      

 # / /4!"

# / 

/

 $ 2

 1   

 /   9

 + 5  0

 ,0 #??HM

  

?

?? 4#, 0 L  B    /

      -#$41* #< 4#/4

+

, 

 

H 

          



   +,  ??0  H

  1

    5      1



   0 

  1 =

  

1



 

 <   

1  

# B    / /

  4#<#,:# #-*# +

, 





 

   <      B B

   -#$41*#<4#/4#,! $  2

1   5   I +    (  25 ,0 ?*H  B   /

    2  ?

? : ;   

 5 5   

 

 





    /

  

 

  

   9 B  !    /

  B  

/

1

1   5   %)*+%,'/H1 

     <    B   /

  -#$41*#<4#/4#,+

, #4,##0#0+

,H 5

 

  

              =

 

   9#  

 H  1  

 

 

 

    %  / /       %)*+%,4%) )*0!4%)*204%)*2!'/@     !"

# $ $ %     *-+ ,4)$+ , !"

# $ %H

  0  



     

 5  

  

 1



 

 $   H 1    



4  



#

5

 

       

 1  =

   



 1

  

<     

19   

>  5    

1   5   < 



  5   # 

   

 #  1

  9/

   

 1

   '    /

    

 

       

 



 # /

  

   1 1



  

< 

    5  9



  

1

;

/

J JH        !!!!"    



 !   

2 4 

 !!     

!  "        

     ! 

"

!





 

  !

  !

!     < 

 

  "

 

F

" !"

 !

 "" 

 

 K



!  "   

!!

DA

!

 

  

9  !!   % 0 :   5  

# 

1      ' 0     

   

  4 =

   H 

 

%  / /   

  %)*+%,4%) )*0!4%)*204%)*2!'/@     !"

# $ $ %     *-+ ,4)$+ , !"

# $ %H    ''

   

 1< 

 



>   

H 





   +, ,  %)*+%,4%)*0!

!4%)*204%)*2!'/ 

 9 *-+ ,4)$+ ,!"

# $ %

 H E>

  







 

!9    

 9 1  4     ! !

 

 

  

     !

9 '

    

    

 

 1

 >  5 4 5 

 1 1

 1

   =  

    5 #

5    1

> ,#02+*+ -%'#)$+&'$4%3-%+%,$)#+%   "1  /

5



          



   9        # 

 

 

   

    

  &'(:



!"  5 1



 # !"#   

5 1     



   #  ($$$

       9

 

 H  1

5 H  



  

           

 

       5



 '

1

  

   5#

 

#  



 

   

  

   

 #  5      #     

 

 5 



 

       #

  4

5   5

   

  &

#  

    

 

   

 

   

       0 < #

 

   

 



  5   

5 

    

    9     

 



    

  - - 

   





6

   

   55 

@ @  

5 

0

 # 

   

 





     <  %)*+*&, - '51  5# 

 

1 +, 9 # 

  =

# 





   &'(" $ $%

%$) $    * + ,+,# #*-+,#) #)-+ ,#)*#)#%-+% %,!"

# $ %  * * ./ .0 0 

 

!



#2

 !1  #

 

 +, 0



4      5 

 5      

/



 1 1    1   

 +,    

+,#  #

   0 %$ & "   7



8  

 $# $ I  4   64" I 

 64"