Sri Ram Tubes Pvt Ltd And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS
!"#$"%&'&#() *
+",'-'
!
"
# ) ./
0+ 0 $$$$$ % & '(#) *( +
,"
)-,.,(##'/ 0( +
"
# 12 3 ,4 ,
(#) *(# &
'
-(#) *(
"
# #5 $$$$$ + 0
/ 6*, +"
6 7#* ##60* &&
# , * . ' +
, " , . ) ')# , "
6*, + "
* && , # ' + , * 6.'# .# %8
-2-
.&6 ' 1 98:;<:8 <1=>
2
985?<@8 <1@>
2
5 985:;=8 <1@>
2
: 98?@A<8 <1@>
B 4
2
? 98=?:A8 <1@>
B /
2
A 981;A@=8 <1@> C2
; 981;=A<8 <1@>
2
= 81;1;8 <1@>
4
2 4
@ 981;@?18 <1@>
2
1< 98?1518 <1@>
B /
2
,+* '
0 + + *(+* 6 7 +
# +
& 9 :;<:8<1= '#D
&.6
) & ## , + 0# , E
-3- , 6 ) # F
"
*,''7 , #&# * ## <A<@<1= G.
8? 8= F, 60
"
# 5 - , 0 3'
7& & # , + 6 +
# DE , ) # #&# + #)* .&"
"
, + 6 +
# DE ,"
* #,,0 , &" 7 #F ,,
7 + &" # *
7 &.+*.
7* ) +
' &
, F #*# ,0 ,) 6 7.' '0 "0 7 ,
'*
* 0* .&"
*, 7 F , .0#+.' "
# :8 0'*
* 0 7.'
0 &&
, + 6 +
# D E ,# + # 7.'
25:2<1A ## 11<;<1A "
) #+
.""'0 +'*
* 0 H. #"
F
* ) G"# .
*.
## H.
*.
0** # ,
7.'
?A + , +
# 7.'
25:2<1A ## 11<;<1A"
, , "
# +
&
72#&# 7( .*,#&#* '06 #+
&,F*'
,* .& F, & , ##
' '
# *
# , ') 7.'
"
#.*# .# %8
-4-
!
"
#
#$$ %
& '
()$ * "+,
#$$$ - .+,
#$$$ )
#$$$ / & '
#$$$ ( 0,+ #$$$ 1 " , #$$$ 2 3 ! !
' #)$$ #$
" %$$$ ##
4
0 4
#)$$ #% , .
" %$$$ #* +
0
5
4
6 )/%,
4
7
8
) F +,+
# 7.'
( 7.#, * .'# '0 ,) 6 #&## +
& F * .&
+
& * .& F, &##
''
#,#6 *
## +
& G 7* .&
-5-
& 6,'+ + "
# #5,# 6+ '#F, , 6)
#,,#&# * ,)6
# **
#* F , , 7.'
+ # 60 , ""
"
&&
, ')G * +,
"'0 G *# .# %8 9,
4 4 ))
6 7 3 4
:
3 4
6
%$#/
.;
## < %$#/ :4 4 :3=- ))#
4
% :
.+
, .+
7 4
4
,
7
&
4
> ))*
+
:= =#
=- 4 4
+ )) %$#/ .
>
?=
#, )#7
@
-6- +
4
:
.+
, .+
7 4
4
,
)/ 6
)2# +
%, 7
7
)2# * )) #7
)2 # :
A 4 6
- +
4 *$ A , 7 6
&' , #
5
7
7 '
-7-
4 4
4
4 ;
4 4
4 6
4
+
'
&' , # .;
7 )1 .;
## < 7 %$#/ , 4
7 4
+ A +
:=
=)
=14 4 %+ 4
4
)2
)2 .
>
?= )2 4
4
# 7 4
6
0
:
.+ ,
6
6
-8- .+ ,
6
6
! B 6
3
4
7
3
'
%+
4
4
:
7 4 7 4 A 6 4 4
7 %$#/7
4
7
:
, +
7
+ .;
## < 7%$#/7 %*% B
B
-9-
7 4
' 8
.""'& 0 "'0 F '
+ '# 60 , "
#
6.
* ?<?<1@
7)
. . 7 # 7, & 6 '
0 +,F
"
,'
7, +++ **
. ' )
&# "
) ##.# , .
0 *,& '+ )
#,,
."
) # +
++ **
. +
, .& /
)*
# '
.&, + +
# D/ '
,
.&
+ '*
* 0 &6.# & .# *
: ?
# : ;
+ , '*
* 0 *( <<5 # 7.'
+ &# , .# "
H.
# +
G,. , &# "
) ##.# , .6+
""
*, 7 7, .
.# F
3.
# *
, "'0 F '
+ '# 60 ,
6.
* F, *,'',6 ) 63*
F # ,
"'0F + '#60 "
# :8 F'' +
# "
' + , F
"
'
7, + , .,
) "
.*& +, .
F'' , E6' ."
& .
, ')G * +, ,
"'0 # .# %8 - +
4 ;
7 %$$*
' 4 A
;
7 %$$*+
4
4
;
7%$$*
-( ;
7
-10-
4
4 6
-*
;
7%$$*@= ,
?
,
+
6
4
;
:
7
. 7 4 7
;
% ,
4
7
;
7%$$*4
4
6
,
7
6
4
7
=-(-
;
7 %$$*7 . ;
-114 6
4
+ 6
' &' , # :
)+ 6
4
;
7 %$$* +
4
, 7
=-(
7 7
6
4
4
;
7%$$*5 7 74 4
&'
>
+
A
>
7
. 7
!
4
-12-
;
4
4
/+ .;
4
;
7 %$$*
.;
%2 %$#- . ;
;
7%$#- .;
*- %$#/
6 7 3 4
:
;
7%$$*8 # * . ' +
, "* ) " ,) # ,
.6&
*#6 )(#.
7,* .
+,
7.& 9, '* . '+
"
"
0#,,#&# * F '
6' 6 #(, "
# 7.#,,F
"
.7, 6 # & # ) F + .0 .""'0 '*
* 0 H. ( "
F H.
*.
0 7.'
<1A9, '"
'
#
7.'
?A1 # 7.'
?A( , "
# '
#
7.'
?? # 7.'
?@ ##
' "' + & 6 '
0 F '
# ) F +' ) &#
,), #' #* . '+
," #,)7 ,
.7,,"'# 7 F'' # *.& * + '#3.#7& * #60,& , "
'
& 0 63*
H. & 6 '
0 6 7 -."+
-13- ) '6 '
0 +' )++ **
. &# 7
.# +. 7F
"
, 6F'' * 7 I# )'
# "
* "' F
.
&0 ,. '* G * F
3.
# *
G*"
, F) * 7 I#60'FF,
*6 ## "
G * +' ) &# *(
#
'0(,& F .'# 6 # F
#'
7 &. G,. , .
0 &# (,"
+'F , 7 # F'' '#,6 6 '. ,* ,#, & #"# 7 , .
+
' ? 0 &
7 , "
#
* , "
) ' ' ) &# , 7&0*.''06 ) 0 +3. *
( , H.
) ') ".
'0 , "
# ""'
*6 '
0 + .
0 7.'
# F,, , #&# F'' + .## ,
, H.
6 7 ".
'0 '7' #
) ') 7 0 H.
+ +* * 6 '
-# 60 , 7, .
'7 7 ,& ' ) &# F .'# '0 #'0 , #3.# *
, . ''+.
, *( ,)#* ## "
*# G& , * &
, 63*
+ "
# ,. #*'
# , 7 7 "#*0 + & 7
# 7
.# G& , .+.
, 9, ' G& 7 , . &
( ' # * . ' +
,"
, ,) '0"'*# '
* 7.'
?A1 * # ,,* .'# 6#&##+
&G 7* .& #, .*,#&#F . 6' '07 ,F*'
7 , * .& F, *
###
''
#
-14- ( ' # * . ' +
, "
# ,) .6& # , , "
)
+ 7.'
?@ &"
F ) F +
*.
0 #"
+
"
F * .&"
# , *
:; + , '*
* 0 *( <<5 * * .& #"
6' *.
0#2
&-"0& +''& F, *,&06* &#. + # &
**
#*F ,'F + * &# 7.'
? * # , , &&"
F
6.
* *''."
* .& &-
#,#+ * *02 .++ * *0
F'' , ')"
)
+, 7.'
'
#."
60,
"* )" G *# .# %8
!"
! #$%! $!%"& )# ,
-(
7 6 74 6
7
74
@=
? 4
7
?
7 7 ' 7
4
)% !
)#
7
-15- 7
7 6 7 4
7
4
)*,
)%
7 7 ' 7
4
)-+
6 )#
6
'
=
#, )#7
@ +
4
:
.+
, .+
7 4
4
,
)/
6
)2# +
%, 7
-16-
7
)2# * )) #7
)2 # :
A 4 6
- +
4 *$ A , 7 6
&' , #
)/# 4
!
"
#
#$$ %
& '
()$ * "+,
#$$$ - .+,
#$$$ )
#$$$ / & '
#$$$ ( 0,+ #$$$ 1 " , #$$$
-172 3 ! !
' #)$$ #$
" %$$$ ##
4
0 4
#)$$ #% , .
" %$$$ #* +
0
5
4
6 )/%,
4
7
8 ::: ::: ::: 9)2 !
'
' ( ) # 7 4
6
0
7:
.+
76
6
.+
76
6
!C D 6
@ 3
4
7
-183
'
% +
4
4
:
747 4 A 6 4 4 8
) # +
& " . ' + , 6 ) '. ,
7.'
?1 &# "
#"
*.
0 7.'
? +.
, &"
F ,#
6.
'
* 7 ) .*, *.
0 &0 6 )'
#
.++ * ,. ( , # 7.'
'
" * ) #&# +##
' *.
0 + *.
0'
#0# # .++ * .
, ( 7.'
?? 5 ( , * .&"
*.
0 #"
&0 6
) # .''0 " "
*#.
.# 7.'
?@( F, *, &"
F #
6.
'
* ) F, *.
0#"
, 6 +* .&"
" #) 76 '' *( , 7.'
F, # F , *
:; + , '*
* 0 *( <<5 &"
F )
+ 60 , #
6.
'
* ,+
# "*, '
6* # #60 )
*, + , .
, & + * + % , - . ' / 0 1 234 () ! ! ( ) 5 ,
')G * +,+
#3.#7& # .# %8
-19- #*& 4
7 4
+:
4@
641 ( ) ()1 7 (2)()() (8)' 0 64 9
=# A
7 6
74 6
-*7
7 7
4
=
?
4
7
7
7 7
' 7
4
% !
=
#
7 7
7 6 7 4
7
4
*,
=
%
7 7 ' 7
-20-
4
-+ 6
' 7
7
=
# 6 4 )
6 =
#
6
'
= :::::: " '' + =+
7 A
7
7 7
47 @= ::::::
4 4
7 7
7
?
>
7
:::::: 7 ' :
+ = :::::: %, 4 A
4
=
#7
4
7 @= ::::::
-21-
=
#
-(? 4 =
-
-(? :::::: E
/#? ::::::
'0 !
+ 9
)# + 6 74 6
-*
7
7 74
)##
@ )#%
? )%,
7
)#7 7 ' 7
4
)*
)*#+"+
4 6
4 = 7
4
-22-
@ 3 4 = 4 7 :
7
A :
)*%+.+
4 6
4
7
)** , 6
"+ .+
'
= 7
3 :
"+ .+ 4
= 7
A = 77 )*-+
6 64
4
::::::
4'0 !
+ 4%
;
+
-23- &'
&' , :7
+
A 0
8 #-
-(
7
7
4
' 4 6
7 +
74
4
,
7
,
7 7
76
F
7
=
-
6
' 7
6
+
'
'
= #)
#1#% 7 4
4
4
-(
,: 7 4 4 '
-24- %$$)7 4
4
7
4
4
#/&
7
4 ;
7#2-1
-2 ;
&
+ 4
+ 4
.
> < -= .
>
A
, 4
A
,
+
7 7 7
4
' 4
+
5 7
7 & 7 4
' !
' 6 ,
4
A
7 7 +
'
+ :
4@
-259#$$ + :
6 4 @ 4 A
G #$#+
A
+
+
+
4
& #$%
7
, ' %H
'!4 A +
4
@
*$ 3
'
#$ 3 4 #(
( 3 '
:
#$ +
@ (- #$*,
7 ' 4 4
7
6
.
+ & %=# %
-26-
,
:
#$- +7 4
:
'
,
A + 7
'
'7
' . 7 '
#$)+ &
7
+
:
6
&
&
, 7
4
&
+7
&
#$/5
&
7
=
5
7 ' +
'
3A;
& 4
4
F
4
-27- )$ +
4
4
4
3A
4 + 6 4 ' )% '
, 7 /$ ' 6 + , "
4 A
4 ' 0 &.;"
A
+& 6
4
A
+37 .3
4
5
4 & F
&
+
7 &
,
'
4
4
, &
'
+ 3 4
," ' &
,"
#$(5 7 4 ;
& 6
'
7
%
*
+ =
4
&
&
-28-
7
6
'
4 &
+
&
A
+ 7
I;
J :::::: #$2, 74
A
:::::: #( 5
4 A !
'
7 3 ;&7 K
7 , #2(2 3 %2# 4
@ 9
4
4
7 & 4 ' '
,
'
+ 4
4
4 6 >
4
B #1+ 6
' = 4
+
4
-29- #2 , ;
*> + 0 % <
= 7 &
3A
;
4
,0
> 4 7 6 4 7 ' 4
74
7
+
4 7 4 4 %$+
: 7 4
+
4
-(
5
7
6
' 7
7
7 4
'
=
%#
7
7
'
5 7 4
74 %$#)=#/ 4
L 1)M 7 4 6
:
'
-30- %% 5 7 A .
> < -=
6
7
, ' 4 ' A 4
7 4
4 A
=:
+ :
4 5
7
. ;
+ + N 7 + 7 !
0 O + 54 ' 7 %$#% %%#
4 '
4 '
0 7
4 7 4 7 '
6 4 ' + ' 4
7
%* :
0
' 4
.7 4 :
4
+
A
-31- %-
/#
-(
%),
-(
74
+ 7 7
8
,. ) #,, . 7 # 7, '& + ,
6.
* ) , # #&# , & +
&,* .& F''+ .## , .#, '
#06 * # #60, )
*,3.#7& +, .
# F ,'# 6F , ,# & +,
6.
* , 7.'
?A #F , 7.'
?@# *
:;
+ , '*
* 0 *( <<5 * 3
'0 &"
F ,
6.
* ) F , * .&"
" + , * .& +
#H.*0 + , *.
0 #"
# , + ) , *.
0 #"
+
"
F * .&"
, + , .& F'' "
*# 60 * &" 7 , * .& 60 F # + ,
,* +,"
,,* &".
+ ,#&# **
#*F ,, 7.'
H.'0(, & +,& .#&## & .# ".# .''0, "
"
# & ##, # # "
# + "
#
-32- , "
#8
6.
* ,'# '#
,#&# ++ ) F 7, & **
#*F , ,
)
+ , '*
* 0 *( <<5 # F , 7.'
25:2<1A##11<;<1A ."
# 7& *""'
*
( +0( ,'''
## "
#
+**
# 7'0 ", * "0 + ,
# 6 "'*# , + ' + *, * *#*
"1,- ,23* (VINOD S. BHARDWAJ) ? 4"!4",'5" 6&(78," '#("9 )"'8# 4"!4",,"5#,! 1:" )"'8#