Liz Batra v. Commissioner Of Income Tax
!"# $ %!&' ("$ #$ "# $ )*%%
'+' %%,!&%-'.+/.'.%0% % ,% .
'1 '
' ( 2'
%,.3%4+54 ,&%6. 2'
%7 %+5,&%5!.1 2'
%'.+//%5,&%5!.'1 '
8888 9 %: 2 ; !"# $ 6,'+<7&%7+'-&1
!"
# . 1 .%' '+/. % 6 ! &% =+%'. % '.6>&%+' & ,%, #?
#"
"# $ + , '& ' "@ 9 :A"@@ ! . &0 %- &5 ?
9! '. B. &C: ! % / 1'&+ 1&, /' '1&!.%''''0 D%"# > "
.1 & ,'.%'1 ">00'' ! &0%->5.% ,/%.'.%+.D&01 ,&,6..
%+ &.1'&+ &+, /!& &%0 ! &0+ "@ %,6.'& "@?!.& '1.'%05%&&, /. 1 5 % %, ! & %-' .%' < ''+ / ,& ' &01 /.00'' ! &0%-%+ &.1'&+
4& "@?!.&%,'%'+ ,(>
! "
# ## $
!
% & '
( # ))
# ))
*+ # # ))
)* $
,
)*
) &
)*
)
-
.
*/ ( ) )
"0 1!
#
)
) *
' * )
)
)
'( *
3 *
#
)*
) * # # ))
$
,
! 2 4
*
5 *
* ) )
)
*
* ) &
" )
(
)
*
) ' )
) '
*)
'(
'
' 5 '
)
-
) (
*
) '* (
(
(
) &
)
!/ 1' 5 .!5 &%
< 1&,, %/% ' ! . !! &' 0 , . -&1 6. . 1+' '% & ! . 00'' 00'' 911%': . %111% %+.D 6. . .! 00'' & % ''+ ' ,& ',' . %%,!&%-'9:' . %111%%+.D''+'+&.,& ' &''%D,%6.
2'
4+C'& ,% .'/%,%'2'
+//%,, & , .6' $ 2'
4+C'%11. ' '.% 6!.&'1 & .% '+,<6 .% ,.& & ,%+.'5.%% !6. 1 <+%+ &.1'&+
'% &5'.,+1 % ,%, # "# .'%,%,,'',<D.20<55 41&%4&%D. 0 ! ,%5.00<9):5 ,' ,&%%0% ,%D,,& %+ &.1'&+
. D'+//''1'&+ 1&, /'+ '"@ % ,"@@ .'%0'1 , /!& ',% !>5.% ,/%. '1 .& &+,'<D'% /.%.20<9):0%D 3''+'+%< '.% ,& & ,& ', % , ,&, .' ''+ -1,+'D ' .% %111% 1'&+ 1&, /'% %,,+ /.'! % &%D% !+.'%'.%!. %'''''6 /&01+ ,.!! &5.'%00%D<& ',,%' 1.-' / , %,.5.!5%'% , ,& /'1 "%+ &.1'&+
0D'+//''.. 00<''+ ',&,.''+-1,+'D
2'
4+ %' , +1 % . ,%,
#?
"# E %,,'',<D.1+D00'' ! &0%- !0 /.
, 4&%D 9 F: .% . .%, < =+', / % %''''0 % , 1 %D 1&, /' &01, -1,+'D % , %' 1&''.&%'!%+ &. /1'&+ A&01+ , /!.%''''0 D%'"# > "% ,"# "> @ .' %' ' % , ,& '+& / '1 ",&,.0% %1%&+%0%
'0D% ,& ,&, . '%0 -1,+'D %' %' 1&'' . &%' !
%+ &. / 1'&+
,' / '1 " ,&, . 0% -1,+'D% ,1&''.0%' .'%0%',& /.0 ,&,.0% %1%&+%0%
../.'&% <'%,.%. ! . ' '+&. .% '1 " 0%D & ', %' % ,A ,& /.0,&,.''+ %1%&+%0%
;
% 0 ! ,+<5 6 ,& .% '1 " '.%,&,6.. %3%& + "@?!.& .' 6 %&&,% &6.%6% ,6.+< / !+ &,<D.,& ' !0% D.'+& &+, /!0. &+, / .<%''! . &00+ &% ' , +1 <D . 1 .6' D + 7+,/0 ,%, "
#$ "# $
! 6 .% ., .% %+ &. /%1'&+ ' 0% ,%D D&%'!!%+1,, '& "@ .'%06+,%11D%' '1&!!%++ ' "@ % ,"@@6.&..1 '%&&+',! .'&%' ?
+.5 . !'1 ",&, /%+ &.. 1'&+ 5.'.%,' D<D%%' ,, %.''+'%', <D . 1 . ! . ,&' ! '1 " < / %,'.1 % D- 5.'%0'.% <010 ,! %1,!!+63'%!'&!.'%0+1 .1 .61 '% ,','1',!6..%!'%,0'
94 FG : 4 9 4): !#"#!"
# B% ,C