Indian Hardware Industries Ltd v. State Of Haryana & ORS
!""#$%$&'( #!)"*+ !,- &.$ & *./ *"&.0%!*$"%1!.
2! !" *3 & *%
'( 41
222
! " # $ !
%%% 22- & !'
! ()*)++,)-.
(/&
""
+-))+,)- .
(5/ " ! +*0 ! &
"
! )1),+,)-.
(/ " !!1-+2 !
3 . /4
&& 5 !
! ! & !
"
667
#& !
&."
"
-)6 /
"
8 !-9 & !
"
12+ )6*2+ & ( 5 $&5
:".!! /
"!5! !! " "!
" 6 ++5 .
(/ " ! 5
! "
!& "; 8 ! "& "3"
! &
!" "!5 < !!& 8 ++),)76,
"!5 ! "
-)6 3 & !! 3 <
."
/)7*-$& !!! ! "
8& ""
! ! "
8"
12+ "= "
! 6 5 )7>) " ! " "!5 !
!
;534 " !
& & !)6*2+ " &"
'
" !")76)67< " = "
!!
!
?
!"" = " !&"& & "
"
!!! # !3
"
"! !!
8 "3 " "
! ( & =
! "&
!
!
!
5 5
! "
&& 12+ ""
"
3& 4 3 . / 4 ; 3 4 &
! 8 3""
)+,7)772# 1,,7)772
& )1 # & &
& !
& !
"
!
""
1,,7)772"
!
"! 3
" !""
5""
&
"!3$ @ . "<
/ +,,>.!! A+,,>A/ & !"3$ @ . "<
/
+,)).!! B+,))
C/3+,,>& "
"!2-+,),&
+- & &" 4 "
&
. /
07"
!," 07"% ./
!
" #
$ %
&
'
'
) "
! !"! ! !
& " 2"#!$&5( /"*!!* &%"*8 #0"" *9"*!3
(
)
#
*
+
, $% $ % ""
$ $%
*
, $ %
$ 2"#!$& 5 !
!D
& % $%
+
- $ " " ! =
! ! !
=
2"#!$& : &
!& 2"#!$& :
.
. & /
&
$%
-
- $%
$%
- $%
- $ %
!
- $ %
&
$%
" #
-
$%
&
;97 & !$&0 $%
- $
# &'() !
&'() ! !
"&& " !3
$ %
2
&
2 $% '
3
3
+
)
&
*
5
3
6
+ , , + )(! ,) ((, , ) )), ()
, - )). --,-, ,!,) / ) , ) ,
"', --( ) --,"!01 )), ()# + )(! , ) (( ))' , ,",1
21 "-, (-,2 ) ((0- !
2 , ,- (.2
--( ) ((0,3!01 + )(! , + ,
$"
%
)
"<9, %$%%0997$".
.
4+/56+74
+8&)!' ,12,) 9", =4+/58
" #
!
4 + " #
"
4 +
)
$ 3
! "& " !" "
( ! ( "
>
" (
)>,6+,)).
(/
'
,6))+,)).
(/4""
"!$ ! "! +,))
& & # !
?;6211!+,)1&
! !" ! ! )>,6+,)).
(/ "
! ,7,-+,)1.
(?/&!!
)>6+,)) ? 5"
!7-+,)1.
(?/&
& &
!; 3 .
/
# )76+,)1&& ! "
&
!-*>2 "!
)6*2+ ; 3 .
/
5 !'
"
-*>2 !'
" 3! & ! ! ! !
"!
>6)1-,,,(
),!+,))
5&
+,0!"
)6-+2>,,( +-,6+,)1 + 5""
""
. /4 ),,7+,)1
!
;
3 . /3 . /"#!! ! ! ! ++2)1 ' " ! 3
""
. / % '
,
6
7 8,
9:!'
(
$;
%
'
(
$;
% 8 < :'
'
$"
% 6 , 9:! $ 3
! ! ""
< 8 & !
!""
>!3$ @
. " <
/ +,,> 3 ""
< )>))+,)1.
( / ),,7+,)1.
(+/
""
. / )7,6+,)1
3 . /8 ), 5
3 . / 4
-)++,)1 +*0!
+)>6>2*6( '
! ! -*>2 ' & 8 ! !
$& ! ! !; 3 )76+,)1 & ),,7+,)1
! !
& ! "
! >!+,,> !!""
3 & &8 &
! & '
"& " #; 3 . / 4 -6+,)-.
(/
"
3 . /4
)1),+,)- "
!1-+2 ,),)+,,) ! !! &
!! ! ; "! ! & !! "
!1-+2 & "
!" 3
"
1-+2
& !"! "
! !
2*,7-,,,(& "
!
" & D &
+,0! "
)1,)>>,,(3
! )1),+,)- 8 ( '
" " ,1))+,)-.
(6/ 6 3! +-))+,)-.
(5/
"
!
)+)1!+,))
&
& " !
+)1-17>,(
+*0! &
!
-,*217,( & !
))))*+(&
!2,
3 " 8
( 3 3 . / !! ))))+,)-()>))+,)- #& !
)1,)>>,,( ,1-*6>,,-))))+,)- ""
. /& !&
6 ,
=2=>1 6
5!!""
. /
3 . /
"& 3 . /!
3
)+)1!+,))
"! 5 $& "
)*)++,)-.
(/
"
"""
4
&&+-))+,)-.
(5/&
.
(5/ "
& &
" "!1-+2' ! '
"
+3 . /4
! &
1
+
"+-))+,)-.
(5/ "
! "
! 7 E )) "
1-+2 $&&!! &
"& !& '
!"& ""
!&
" && 5& !
"
+ "! '
5&
!
""
!
! ! 4 ""
"!$ < "< " .
9/ & "
"
!
& & " "
3!
" !)1),+,)-.
(/
! !" 7! +,,> "+,), F !!
! ""
. /4
),,7+,)1.
(+/ "!"! ""
& !
"
!8 & !
! !
$& D&
#"# & " !"
"!" !
& " #3 ! !"
"3 " )1),+,)- .
(/
" : & " ! !
! !&
"
!'
! !& ! # !"
.
(/ )6 F !
)>,6+,)).
(/!" !!)6*2+ &
3 . / )7,6+,)1 ! !-*>2
& !&" !& " " & !& !"! " 5 ! &
)>))+,)1. ( /
!F+
+ &
"
!,-,6+,)-'
"
! & !
"
! &! ! &
! "
"
!,-,6+,)- & "
0 &
"
,-,2+,)1 .
(5/ & !! ,),>+,)* "
"!-*>2'
!)7,6+,)1
3
)>))+,)1.
( /
& "
!
'
!" !
"'
" 5 !" ! ! 8 (+ "
'
" ! -*>2 3 # & !
#
!"!" "
!
!&
!&!!
D
! 4
!8 !
"8 !"" "! 8 )& ""
!
& 4! "
!
!1-+2 !"
"& ! # !"
: & <
""
4 """
. /
! !! &
'
&& )*)++,)- .
(/ " !
! "
!
! "
!
&& "
"# ! ! ? ! !
#&
! & &
$ ! "
!
!!
& ! )7,6+,)1
3 . /&" !
& " & !&
" !
" & "5
!" !
& ! & ""
.
/ & !
"
"
!
""
. /
"& !3 . /! 5! # =!"
'
" !
" !
& !
"
""
"# ! & ! D 3
!" !
! & '
D 3
# 3
! ! & &&!
! &&
#
!D '
D
5
D& #
! !! " D
& # ! 5&! ! ! D " ! ! !
"
!
3 D !
! !F+
+
!
! !
#! "
"!
& & D!F+
+ !" 3
! "
!
D!
$$ 3 "! ! !-*>2 ! " ! "! " 5
! "!"
!
* ! &8 !"
-*>2
'
)1),+,)-.
(/!
1-+2 & !! ! "
!"
D !-!+,,> " +,), &
)+)1!
+,))3 . /
& !@ "
$& & &
D
""
. / "
)1
)1"#
""
. / D""!3 . /!"!!
! $&!
D
3 . /& +*0! " & !"5
""
.
/
)7))+,)-&
!
" #3 .
/ !! & 3
!! ""
. /
"!
"!F !" &! "
3" !& ! !
" !! " ! ! 3
"!
! ! " ; 3 4 *! !! *>+,)* " 7**, '
8" !
!
,7
& !!3
"
!! ! &
! "
'
"!
&! & !
!" ! ! +.#/!+,,>
& "
! &
D "( !=!"
$$$ ! " "
!
& ! #!
& !" "
!
& =
3 " !
& " &
"3 !
" & !" " &
" !" ! !
"
! "
&
" !
! $ !
! "
& ! =
(
!
"&
"& )77* 3!( "
" "
"
!
&
5 " " =
!
3
!+,)) & !+,,> " &
!
& !"!
'
&&
! !!B =
C +.#/!+,,> "+,),! !!
&! '
3
"&
& ! "
! ! !!& &!4 " "!: ! "
& "!
& ""
& !"
! + 3
!! "
!
"
(&& " !"
1-+2 "
&
3 !
! "! "!
$ !
"
"!& !" ( & &
&!
7!+,,> "+,), "
!&& & ! " !
"
& '
& !
"
"& =
& "
!
!"" "
!!
& !& !
! +,,> . " +,),/
" 5 "&
!! "5
!" !
!
< " & =
&
! (< " & " ; !
!
! " "
1-+2 '
" #!!
! !
! 1-+2 '
""
. / ! " "
"
1 2 3
!"
"
! "
& !"! (
! +,))
11! G " "
" !
+,))
!
& ! ! "
"
"# !"!
" "
-*>2 & " !
!!!
1)1-! "
"
&
!" &"!!
1-+2 ! "! ! "
& "
8 & 73 & '
)11)!G "&#
"&& ! ! &!
)+E)1!+,))
!D "&3 .
/ " ! !
!
!8 D " "
1-+2 !# # !""
! " '
" &
'
""
. / & 8
&
)1!+,))
3
)1 !
&
!""
. / !&
!
D!
$&
)1!
""
. /
D "
3 . /
& !"!!
!""
. / & +*0!
&"
?
# &! !
& !"
" ! !
(8 & 7 ! ! ("!1-+2
3
.
1-
!/ &3 . /""
. / !&
! & " ;
!
! 3!
"
! " ! ! "
& "
"& '
$ !
"
!
!
& !"!1-+2
! 2 5&! ! "
!
#
< "
! " ! " "
& !D
! 3"!
7!+,,> & "
&!
"
("!" 1-+2 " ! ! & !+" !" !!
! &
"
&"!"
3 . /33 . / " "
"! "&
$&3 . /
!!" ! "!! "
!& !+,,> "+,), &+,))
& "
22 #!)"*+!,-