High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/2477/2018dismissed

Sanjay Singh And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2022-02-03The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Arun Palli14 pages

-1-

!"#"

$%&'' ($)*("$+,$

/ -#0# (

-*$$

-# .

#1 2% 342 ' ( /(5 6 ( 342 ' (

% 2-' $)"

("$"6 7 !

-#' 2-'$80-2"

96 9' 7 !

-96-*$:"

, 2-'(0-;,2+ 6##"# 7 !

-9-*$' <, #" 1- "# ;

"$+ - ,- 0+, 7"

$!"$+ #"$!

"$+#- "$+!

$ 0!

"$7"- 09 =' '

, -#*"$7 >

- ,$ - #- 0$ 119"!;"9"

* ( $ <= "+,

"- $ $ -$#1- $!*"$4$ !?0"#"

,;"9"

&< -#, @ &A=

:, "$ :- 0$ - # $ 4$ !?0"#"

$ !

6 B :# $$ 0$!

$ &'&'B6 "'

' > ,$ "7 * -# 1-"

>> & $''6$ #!

0$# 9 -1

-#$ -1 9$ "$?0 $,#

$ ;* (

$ - !

$ > 0$ ,# ;

1" C

' ,

6 "

,# ;

$ !9"> ;

-2- "$+ $!"

# > "$ ( $ <= & - 09"99 $1-

"$+## $ 91# ' '

, -#*!- 01- 0$ "$

-1-

$<=

& :# 10 - ;* $# $ $!, (01- $ ""$

;* 9*"$+ :$ 1-"$!"19 !9-"$+

$91# 0$ ( $<= &', 1 D ,# "#!0##

"9 99 #1 #$ ##-*$ - 7$ -"$

-1-

"$+( $<=

& $ "$ ,"# - +- -

"# ;

"$+ >

$!90 "$+ 1-+-1, )0 +> :,"!, "# - 1- 0!

, "$ :% E.'

$#$" %

! "

" ! "

! &' !

)

! & " %) % %% !! *"

( " ) ! " ' "(

" "

$#)$! "

! & "

! +

! ) & ,%-."

#$) %

)-. -. , ! "/ "( "

#$ ! "

! & 0

"% "

! !! "

" ! "

' ! ) 0"

) %'" ) 0'"

) ' ! "

) ' ) 0

, * 1 1 ! "

#$! "

! & "

" ,"/"!2 "

#$ " ) % "

3 ! (

)!" # %$ !

-3- !" ! "/ "

! "

! +

) "

""" % ! "

! &" ) ( "

& ! 4"/ "

! +

)! !

' "

& ! "

" ) ( 52 ! "

# " $

! "/ "( " ! 2 % "

3 ! (!! '"

! & ) 6 %6 ! !" ! "/ "

! "

! +

7 " ) "

& $! "

' "

#$ 2 2 !"

" ,) ( "

) ( "

& $ 4 % % ! ""

% ( !" ! ( "

' " "/ "( "

#$! "

! & , "

#$! "

! & ) !"

#$ !"

$#)$ 8 , ! 0( "

! +

#$ ) %(!/ 9 :"% ) 0( "

! "

! +

' (

#$ ! "

! &' "

) 0 "

#$ + , !"

#$ (! ! "(

") " ! "

! ! )! "

! &" !"' "(!

"/ ( % ""

, !) "! )" )*"

#$! "

! & ( % " ! "

/ ( ! ""

"( ! "/ "

"( ( !!" ! "

! &''

2) "

% % / ( !

! 0( "( ! !"

!" "/ .

-4- &'

, D1 9: > ;* 1 D !$ ;

#0>>-"F :"$+>$$ -> !9-"

* 1-"$!"19 9" :$;* $# $ $!,% <= $ 99 !# # :, "$ !?0"#"

$ 1- ## , ;

"$"

;0 :- ,#$

$$$ 0$!

0$ -# B6

>> !

&"'

'''6 "#$ 91# 1-

"$+# $ #> :"99!

"$0 6, :

-6:"

$ ,#

;

->"$ 0$ 17"#"

&' 99 !# # :, "$ :- 0$ $ B ,# ;

$ $$ 0$!

1-"

>> &6 17"#"

& :

09 ,7 $ ;

-"$+ - 119"! $ $ 1-

"$+#:"99!

"$0 "$- #1 #6#"6 !

B,#$

$- 9 ' <;= , :

- E -A 0# "$ ;

$ ;

"$+ $!"

( $<= &"#

#-. -# -. :,"!, > $#

8 91#"$+ !?0"#"

"$+# ;

"$+ $!"

# >0# ;

09"99 ' $"$+ ;*6 " $, ;

$;0 $ :# $

- "7 :

09 ;

$ 91# ' (">"9-9*6 " !

$ ,# ;

$ !!

;0 $ ,# $

;

$6 :

09 ;

$ 91#"$+' #!"

&&#$! 3( <!= #-# #1 9$ !?0"- "# -$ (01- ,#!

+ -"!99* ;# -7

-5-

D1- $1" "$ >"$1- $<= !

# $

"$!90 $ "$ ', "#- ?0"-

1- "# > 0$ :#

:,"!,,#;

D19"$ &

-"$+ > 0$ :

09 > $ > 0$ "# > 7"9;9

9$ - $ :

09 ;

"#!,-+ ;9"+

>8 1*> $ "$

#0!, 1 -# $ !$$

;

1 $9"# 09 "$ >8"$+ 1*> ',"9

--"$+

$&<=6&<=6 & B $ !

>1-"$+ > :"

1- >

-"17"#"

$#"'

'( $$ &6

1 D ,# !9-""

$9* !

$# ?0 $1*> $ "#

>8 1*> "$

# 1 - ( $ & B' 7 (01- ,#0- -!9-""

1*> $,#;

0$ -( $&<=6

!?0"-"$+0 -"

*!$$

$9"# -$ $1*> # > 0$ ,#- >"$0$1" 0

0#9

9$ -' !9-"* "

0- -6 (01- ,# ;# -7 "9$ -,#"9

,"+, -!

$, !$$

!9"> , :#$

1" > 0$ ' < = ,"9 "$+ 17"#

$ &

1- ( $ <= &6 (01- ,#!9-""

"$!#

-1*> ,#;

> ;0 $

6 9";"9"

1* > 0$ 9 $+ :"

#0;#"# #$ "$

->) -"

* , 9 "$+#

-6-

-"7 * -# -> 6!

$0$ & ,#

9$ -##

""!

- 9$ !?0"#"

$ 0$ - # $ B'

+- "$+ 6"

,#;

$!9-""

)0 +> ,"+, - !

:6 * #, 09 $

,7 ;

4$ !?0"#"

-"$ #0-* -"$ :"

>) -"

* 9$ , 9 "$+#6> $"$+ ;*""

"$$* ,-

#:"

,- #1

>) -"

, 9 "$+#6 ,"+, - !

$ :"99 $

:6 ;0 "$

0$ - ( $ & B :

09 ;

$# ?0 ' < = #- +- # >

8"$+1 $6 (01- , !9-""

-:"$+ "$?0 - C> -$ 0> :

09 > $ 1,*#"!91 $,#;

$', 9: :"

,- +-

7 "$+ 9$ ,# +"$;

, 9 $,#;

$0$ -( G B6 9$ 7 #"$

!$$

$* "7 "$+ -91#"$+' <= ,"9 >10 "$+ +1 1 -"

"7 * -# ;

:- $ !

>> &6 $* "$

-"> -#0;#"# "$+"#

D!90 :,"!,> $#

D!90 "$+ "$

-"> -6 1- - ?0"#"

+11 -"

H* -#"#$

17"#"

$# $<=!$$

"$7 ' <+= , $A;9 ,#0- -!9-""

9$ , -9"

$!,99 $+ $ !?0"#"

$ :#

-701, 9 6 :,"!, > $# 1-

"$+ #

$!90 0>;- 99 1-

( $ <= & !$$

"$7 #"

7"7 # 9 "> ;-- !9">#' <,= $ 1- &&6 $A;9 ,# > "

!9 - 17"#"

$<= &"#>

"$7 ;* ;

"!"-"

# "'

' 9$ -# :, :

# "> "##0$!

""! $ 0$ ( $ B'$*#0;# ?0 10-!,# -6

-:"# 6!$$

"$7 17"#"

$# <= &' '

#1 10 ,;*

-#6 *- 9$ > #0-"$+ & "+, !

>1-"# "$ 5,#- #' &C <G=6 &C <B=6&BC<H=#"

,"$ $0

/"99+ 5,$10-6 ,#"9+ ,-"6"# -"!

>0$+-', #" 9$ 9 $+:"

-9$ #"

/"99+ 5,$10-6298>)-6 5,$-"8,0- 6 09"6-" #"$$ (08, #10-:#!?0"- ;* (

-*$ ,- 0+, 0;9"! -8# 1- 7"

""! $#

'&'B$ &'&'B"##0 0$ -( $IG 4$ !?0"#"

6B6 :

;* :-

&'&'B 10;9"!10-1 $> 9*6 -$9"F"$+,0 $+99- >

"$/"99+ #2982)-65,-"5,0- 6 ,09"6-," #"$6 5,$10- $ (08, #10- "$ ,#"9 + ,-"6 "# -"!

>;9' "# !#

#1"

,7"$+!?0"- 9$ "$?0 $6

,#"9

9$ # >0!,#

0+, >0 9$ "$ "#10

$ #$!

7 0- (

-$> ;* 7"- >0 $ ' B

-8- ''6*

9$ "$ "#10

"#!

"$0"$+:"

-#' "# 0- - !

#1"

$$ 0$!

:- $&'&'B6 $> 0$ ,#$ -;

$1" $

9$ "$?0 $"## "999*"$+ 0$0 "9"F # $99 - :,"!, 9$ :# !?0"- ,# $

;

$# -0!

"99

'$7"

: #" !

#6"

"#!

$1-

"$+#,7 91# 0$ -( <= &' H'

$ "

#" 6

-#,7 19!

9"$!

)0 +> 1## ;*"7"9 :"$!# 9$ :, "9 #0"

!9-

, 9 $+:"

,,"#;-

"#"$1 9$ > #0-"$+;"+,&;"#::,"!, ->1-

""! $#0$ -( $$ G B', #0"

:# !-

)0 +> $ !-

B'' :,"!, :# 01, 9 ;* "

$9"# -"!

0 + 7"

)0 +> !-

'&'& $ ,"# 7"

)0 +>

B'B'& 1## "$

( '&G &', 9"$!

#" !

#"#19!

7 *- "$1,*#"!91 9$ "$ ?0 $$ "99

$ -$*!

9$ "$ "#10

$+"7

-#$ ,0 $+$99 -:,"!, 9$ :#!?0"- ,#;

$# -0!

$ !$9"F "99

'$7"

: #" !

-#,7 # 0+, 91#"$+ $1-

"$+# 0$ -( $<= &' G'

"$+ 7 -> #> ;*

-#62-'$80-2"

96 -$ "

$9 7 !

-96-*$611 -"$+

-*$ #0;>"

;

"$+ "$

-9- 9$ "$?0 $"#> -"

### 9$ :# $ "> $$ 0$!

:- :,"!, # $ # #0;# "

- > !

>0 $ ' B 9$ "$ ?0 9 $+:"

-9$ ,#;

$#$!

"$7 0- 1- ''' -6 ,

$ # - 9$ "$ ?0 $:# 09*

6"'

':#> 7"9;9

-#$

- 9$ -#6 $ #> "# 7"

- > !

>) -"

* $> 0$ 6"'

'> ,$HJ

9:- > 0$ 6,#

$ "#;0-# $ - > 0$ "$!90 "$+ > 0$ 0

-#"#7"9;9 :,"!,

-#- 9";

"7 ' ,#0- -#0;>"

$"#$

>"$ "$;9 "$# $!

-#;

!0# 9$ "$?0

$!90 :* ;!8 "$ * - B6 *

-#$ -!,99 $+ $1-

"$+$ !!

' $*"$+

9$ ,#$

"9"F 6 , #0;>"

$99 "# -0$$"$+ 9$ #"$!

"> ">> -"9$ !$9"F"$+ ,0 0$+$99"#!

>19

$ # #0!, 9$ # $ # 0 "9"F ' ,

6 "$ 7"

: 1-"$!"19 # 9"

:$ "$ !#

; 4 # $ , ,# 1-* - "#>"##9 "$# :-"

$' '

#- +- # 9"$!

19!

)0 +> !-

1## ;* "7"9 # "# !

-$ 6 2-' 2"

9 ,# !

#0!, 9"$!

"#;#

9*>"#19!

!0#

"7"9 ::# 9$ 19"$ "# "$:#$ -!?0"- ;*

C -$>

:# !-

7 0- 19"$ "# "$' :

-6#-# "$,$ "#!

-$ 6"

-10-

# $

9$ "$?0 $:# 09* !?0"- ;*

#" !

"## 7"

!0# ,

$ $ !?0"#"

$6 :# $ !!#"

"9 "$#

8"$+91#"$+ $1-

"$+#0$ -( <= &' ,0#6 , 7 9* !

-#!$$

-:;

- > )0 +> !-

1## ;*

"7"9 :"$7 0-

-9$ -#' '

-,7"$+1 -0# 19 "$+#

"$+1- $ - - "$+ "-!

$#6:

,7 $ ,

$!90

- ,$ "##?0- 9*!

;* 1-"$!"19 #9" :$;* (01-

# $$

1-*

-#!9">"$+91#"$+ $1-

"$+#

-7 #- ) -> ,$ # $6 $0> -

, "$;

:% = , 0+, 1

-# ,7

* - "$ !

091,*#"!91 9$ "$?0 $6, :

-6

#" 7 ->

# $

"$ #0;# $!

"$ 7"

: "$

-1-

E1,*#"!9 1 $A +"7 $ ;* 1 D "$

# $ :, "$

$A;9 ,# !

+ -"!99* , 9 :

- E0# B,##> > $"$+#

0# "$( $<= !

&',

-$> !?0"- 9$ $ -:#> -$ 0> 8"$+1 > 0$

8"$+ 1,*#"!91 9$ $ $"# $6 "#;#

7 "$+ 9$ "$

(

' ,

$ " 9$ - -

"$#

-11- 9$ 6 , "# #1## -6 $ #0!, #1## $0- -,"#;

-"'

'$ "$# #"$!

"# * - B6 $ -

,# ;

$ > "$ :-"

$ #

# - +- # -:"$+ 1$!,$>6 :

-6 #$!

>0 $ "$ 7 0- (

"# 9$ "$?0 $$ !0# "

"# #1 !""! # $ (

9$ "$ ?0 $# $ #0 "9"F 6:,"!,,#$

$- ;0

-# # 0+, :-"

$ #

:# "9 :* ;!8 $''B6 , :

-6$ - 19"! $ :# "9 ;*

"99

' ,0#6 :

,7 $ ,

$!90 9$ :# 09* $$

9$ "#7

- >99 $!0>;-$!

#' !!

- "$+9*6 19 1

> ;

"$+ "$ 1,*#"!91 9$ "#, ;*- )

' ;= 7

-:"# (01- "$ 1-+-1,

# $ ,# !

+ -"!99* 9 & 119"

$9*

1 $ "$+ 1-

"$+#:, "$6 -1 $,#$

$,#$

$1" ' "#$

7"7

"$+#:,"!,# $ #!

$!90 "$BG#6B#6 B#;* 8"$+1 9$ ', 9$ -#"$ #0!,!?0"#"

$#!$$

?0 1-

"$+# 8"$+ ->

"$+ $:"

#0-*0$ +-; $<= & :, $"$!

*"9

-"# #0!,!9"># - 7$

-12- "$ "> ' $ ,"# - +- 6 - 7$ 1-+-1,6 "'

' 1-+-1,6

# $"# 1- 0!

, "$;

!"#

%& %' %(

)

) *

)

) *

+ +

%(!

)

$ 7"

: #" 6 #"$!

!?0"#"

"$+#:

$!90 :*;!8"$ * -B$ >"

9* -99 * -#"

:#$

!,99 $+ -;*

- "$"$

- 1

># #6

"$# :-"

$ #

8"$+ 91#"$+ $1-

"$+#"#$

>"$ "$;9

"$# $!

-#' != # - # #1 $ "# !

-$ 6 "

"# ">1

,"+,9"+, , $A;9 1 D !

:,"9 "$

-1-

"$+ :

- E1" A !!0--"$+"$( $

-13- <=$ :

- E

A0# "$17"#

!<=

& ,# 7 -* !

+ -"!99* ;# -7 $"$+$

,;*, 9 "$+ :

- E1" A

"$!90 $ "$!# > 0$ ,#;

;9"+

1* "# 09"99 ' , :

09 $# -0

> $K

> 0$ L,#;

D19"$ "$1-+-1, &

> $ > 0$ "#C:# > 7"9;9

9$ -$ :

09 ;

"#!,-+

;9"+

>8 1*> ' "# #1 !""!# $

$> 0$ :# 09*

9$ -# $ - #0;# " "$+ #> 6

,"# ,# ;

$ -:$

:- # !

$> ,$HJ> 0$ ,# 9- * ;

$ "#;0-# ' $!

"# #

# $

>"$ $$"

$> 0$ :# 09*

-#6 , :

* , !, $$

#> ,0#6$ "$!

$!$;

-";0

,"#- +- ' ("$!

6 0 9$ # $ # $$ $ # 09*

"$+ $!"

# 1- #!-";

"$ ( $ <= &- 09"99 ,0#6 "#$ 91#"$+ 1-

"$+#"$ ,$ ' B'

- "$!

>19

#0;>"##"

$# 2-'2"

9 -# 9"$!

19!

!"7"9!

"#!

-$ 6#

#" >

-- 9

"- 9* "

#$ "##0 ' -6"

-14- 9# $

!# 1

9$ "$ ?0 $ :# $

!?0"- ;*79" 1-

"$+#6 "

"## 9"$!

19!

)0 +> !-

1## ;*"7"9 "#$

119"!;9 ,$ ' '

# # ?0 9 ;

"#!0##"

$ $ "$ 7"

: 9: #0>>-"F "$1-+-1,&G&

# $6 #1 !""!99*

-,7"$+- "$,$ 6 1,*#"!9 9$ "$?0 $,7"$+;

$6 ;9"+ 1*> $# $ # "#!,-+ $ 9# $#"

-"$+ 9$ "$?0 $"#7 -*>0!, "9

!,"

10;9"!10-1 6:

,7 $ ,

, 9 "$ "$# !# (

,# 099* "#!,-+ "

;9"+ $?0;

"$+ $!"

!!0--"$+"$( <= & $ "

;

"$+ # 1- 1

$ > -"

"#>"##9$ , "$#

$"# "#>"## ' '

7"$+ "#>"## >"$ :-"

$6 1 $ "$+ 119"! $6 " $*6 9# >

' ( 0# ?0 " $* # $ # 7!

' < /(5 = ( <

44=

;-0-*&6 $ ) ,

-#1 8"$+C- # #C ,

-- ;9 #C