← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/693/2019allowed

Chakwuma Anthony v. State Of Punjab

2024-03-06Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Lalit Batra29 pages





    

  



 !!  

   ""##

$%    "

    

 

     & 

 "

'(%) * 

 +% ,( ) 

""##  % '%"

'* &%+ -  .% !

#* # '

/

 

  & "

& .

( ( * , '* /

  , % -( 2* '* / 

 



!

"" !

!

!

5

* %" ,!   6 6&,



*

#  7%2* ," !

&

1( (%2( ( !

""##

2 1



  "%!( -# % ,

  %2

 &0 ( "!

,%-

 

(!



9 *

(%2(

"

  !2  1* : 5

* ( " 

!)" %"

!

   !2% !)"!)

!2 %"

"!

:

0 * -! !)"    !  *:

<* -! %#

0)

!

)% (   

!

%2 !2% !)"!)

!2 %"

"!  0 



% ""##

)

22! )

- 1 !

!

!*

*

#

=%

(1!

   

%" *

) %"

""## %#

#0*

22! !

( !

!

"" !2 6



 

  2!

" %





* >" / -! ,!2(*

#21!

,> ,!2(* / ?

,!2(

 "#!  ! !

#* 2)

(! # !2  &?

4  

##!2

   ( -  #) * "

!## 2 @""

#(!* ""!

( / #* '4   # !2 )  +"%

,!(!

-%



")*  1(!

#% ,1!

A!

* !2  B

C * "

)!2 )  +"%

!* 1(! ( -!2 !  /!% 2 #)



/!% 62

0" 2 #) !

!2



 !2

"#!  0*

!

!



""

- ! %"! !  -!2 =%!

-%

)

 

2 )

 %"

*

! ! # (! )

!# D%) *  %# .(  +* !

+ (* #(!  % =%!0*

! "  #

- 

(! 1 ,%( D%) *  ?

-% #* !

( '

* 61 #(!

6!2!

2

2 !

.1 2% 2 4(*

" !

!2



! # (! )

( .1%)

 (0*  21* !

@)%0 41 + .

& !* ,

 )?

6!2!

1 !

@

  61 #(! > !2

!2 !   # (! 1 !

% "



""!

% (! %"! !

%

"! )   %-

 

(!

  % 1

#

""!

(! #2 !2(

2!   (

"  '

A

! 



2!

 /1*

% "

> !2

!2 ! 

 

))* E;&

!# D%)

 & ( .1%)

(!  1 %  1!

!2    (

* )

- "#

(!2( ( .1%) 1(!

#% "1   )



(#"

%2 .!

 %

/!* 1(! ( 1!2()

) %

.2* 1(! (   # -%#.

 #  #  !2 !)"! 8',9 ,  E;& ""

 "

#0 %*

  

,> ,!2( > !2

!2 !  "  0 )) -  E;&  0 ))

*

#2 

 "

% ( .1%)

E;& < "   ( )) E;&

% !# D%)

 E;&

% ( .1%)

  %)! !)

))

% E;&*

 "



%=

E;&:



"#! 

!*

- ! 1(! ( ) F>* E;&* 2! 

 %2( !

"# "#  0 E;&5 ""

 > !2

!2 !  % "

( ! ,> ?

# ,!2(

""(

% ,%!# D%) ) #(!

 

% !# D%) / ?

,!2(

,> ?

# ,!2( "#!  0*  ,> ?

# ,!2( 1

#(!

""(

% ,%( D%) * 1

  %

"#! 

!*

> !2

!2 !  "!

 ""

/

&#!  ,



% ( .1%)



-(! -  



* 1(

% ,%( D%)

#

 *

> !2

!2 !  "% 

-%#.

 #



##

(

% -

#  7%! !

2!

*

#21!

""#!

E;&

 E;&  #  2!

-. "

-%#.

 #

 (1

1 )"#

2 /!

 

()  # "

 #

 -%#.

 # 1  #

#  2!

 !2 !)"! 8?9 ,  E;&

# ""





# 



2!

  E;& : /1*

 "" %#

"!

+%! !

%

(#!



"!

/ > !2

!2 !  % "





* / ?

#+! ,!2( "%   #* !2 !)"! ?

- (!)

 "%

)

 #

  #

) (!  !2 !)"! 8/,9

 !%  

 6

<



  

)

/  ( "!

!2

) F,B

2

!2  

 !% ) &* &



# !

/

2

"!

) !!2

 "" +%! !



 !"

"

) ()!

E;

)! E;& 

 )"#   ) #!

!* ## ""

 ,> ?

# ,!2( "

"% 

!

E;< -

E;< * "

% ( .1%)

E;<* 

E;< 

 !

"

#$$% &'(

 )"# ! !2

!* ## !#

!

!

% 

(!

""   -

# 

!

##

% 1 2 (

))!!   "%!( -# % , !

:



! ! 2 1  

 ;"# !

##

% !)"# /!!<E2#!(*

1(! (

(0 "# 

2%!#

 !)

!

# ,%-=% #0

 !2 "!

! *

#  "%-#!

" % #

" % !  -%

!2

"

F,B*

1(! ( E;& 

!2

!)* (( &( +$

&$%# !&($+ ",$# &- #"

: #  %#

""##

!2%

 -

(!

(%2(

F,B )!

! %"

!!

 #*

) 

)!

!*



-!

"!!

)!

!!2

"(!-!

  %2<   %-

  F% ()*

# %-)!

(%2(*

)! )  #

 #*

*

(

 !)"!

F,B ) )- /1*

)

"

F,B

" %

 ! 

 #*  -!%#0

)!  # ) !

"% 

%  !  / %-)!

- "%   0*

- 

(! "% !*

2

!

!

1%#

- ) 2 #0 

-#!( * % %-)!

"% !*

 #

"!! -!2

(*

F,B -%

!)"

" !

##0 1(

(0



!

!*

F,B 

(0

%*

"#!  

(0



#

!

(* -%

%

"%  -

# 

!

/ %-)!

"%

)!

!!  #* "!) ! 

#0 %"" !2

"

F,B -%

# %"" !2

2 !)* (( &( +$

&$%"

"$# !&($  #  ,

%# (1 %-)!

1(!# "# !2 #!

  %" , : 

*

# 1(!# "# !2 #!

 * %"

!!

!%

!! F!  * "

)

%*

1



:*

!

!! "

!A%

)"1 2!

# =%!

"% * -!

%! !

#! (

2*

%-,

, : 

"!! 1(



(!

*  # 

!!

"!) !  "

  %





               



 





    



"   # "   #$ $ 

$    



 

$ #    $  $"    

"   

  "

#  %##

 

$ #     $  $ "    

"      

       #          # $  $  "       #   

 "     

  &

 

"

#    !

"

$ #"

##     

  

#  

  # #

& $  



 # $ # ' ()

   $  $"    

"   

 ' "

 !

 # &



## **

 #    

  $            ##

$&

  +,  ##

"*  

$ $



 #   $  $ "    

"   

 ' 

  

        $ 



 

   # $    "

   # $  #

   $  $"    

"   

 '  $ &

$ 

 #     $    ##

"*  



   #   

$  $"    

"   

 '

$ 

      $$   

   #  $ $ #   #    # 

 $ $

-  "   $   #  

$ $# +  "   

 '   #  $ $   -  

& & $   

 $

#  "    $   #     #     # # $

 &

 

,  )

  $$      

   "*   (  

   

 

"

& $$   ./&      0  1  

23(#43(   # 

5  

43,(# 43.

   ##    









   $ $  #       $  $ "    

"   

 '   #  $

  &    "*   (     #  "

 

  

$ 

  $ ###  ' 5 / % 

!!

1



:* 1(-0

)

%-

"!! , : 

%2 !" ))!

 -  *

* 1(! (

  %

)!  # %#

#0* %-)!

1(

)!  #*

) 

F,B

)  #!#0  0 4(* 

"% !* 

)!  #

=%!* -!

# %-)!

!! E;& *   "!) !  "!2

2 #

2 "(

!!

%" *

(!

 6!"#"$%&'

() )"# #*+ , -  &./

#(%")"* %"(#

/ &7

  89 

(:+ $ &

1,+/ *0 ;

 # $& #

"

 +(#  / 7   5  $<"   42+ 8# 42+ 

 #

      $  # # "

<=,,41  :

(::3 ; $ 

$     "

  "

# $  

  



  



   



"   # "   #$ $ 

$ 

 $ #    $  $"  

 

"   

  

$ #   

1

  $  $  "     

 "    

 &

 

"

#    !

"

$ #  ## &

 $  #    

#   $

( "-      * 

      $  $ "     

 "      

   

 "

$ #  +(#    ,(   

      * ## * 

# $     ## $&

   +,#   

  #  $

#  

$  $  "     

 "      

    +(#  .!   *)

   $  $ " 

 

"   

  "

 !

# &

 ## **

# 

$      ## $&

  +,#    #  !

"

 ## 

 

$ $



 #    $  $"    

"    

  $  ; #    $$



    "* (# +(#   

$  ; (# & 

# 

 #  $# 

 $ # !

  

$  $"    

"   (#    

& $$   "* , #     +( #           ##       "* $

$

$ 

  # 



$ $

  $

 & $   #    $ 

 #     "  #  !

 

   # 7 7$



#  "





  $

  #   ## 

  

$ #  

&   !

 ## ** 

#  & + 

 *-- * >

# 7 $  #

  

 <    & #   

 

 

  7 7$



$ 

 "





3

&  

 "

 

 "

  ##    "

&     # <$    #  5 

 9    #     

 1;

 9  7   #  7    #  =





  ## #



   





"

  

$"

 >

# 7 $   

!&#"

&(  % !

%2 !" ))!

 ( ##



 )

=% #0

"!-#

   0G

- %

!# !1 !A ) "!2 !" #G

  !" !A )G





!

" ! !2

!  %"!0 ! 

"

!!

;"!

!% !" # 5

#$%!

$  "  )$  +  .$%  )/  ",$   !'   (0 (

 ** ""$$.

", $'

%" % (0 (  +($ 1$% "$*(

 ! ! ( 2 21 ( ## ""

#!

##

!A )

 - !! %  : 

!

 %-)!

( !)

  %2 !" ))!



 )!!2

#!



%-"

2 "(





!0!2

=%!)  : 

!

 - %##0 )"#! (*

))-

  %2 !" ))!

 ( ##    !!



(! 

(

))!

 ( ## "(0!

##0 )!

 !0

1!2(



!#

!A )  

!A% " "

()!

#0!



0  %) *

   !!2

 

.$  +   !'   (0 (    ** ""$$  +  % (0 (   + ($ 1$%  "$*(4( %2 !" ))!



 !" !A ) %"

=%  #% !!

-# -#1* )#0  ,# 6 6 ) ) H% " !2)

/! :

D2

4

 / (!(

( 

D2  / (!( !#

D2 '

+

D2 :

 !

D2   ;



D2 &""0 @"

4    %2* "0 ( "!

%-

 * ## %-

  0   @"

 #% 

.(  5   #  

    # 

       

 7 7$



 

             >

 #  

$  &

    $

"



7  7$



$ 

 # $ $  4 !      *%$  $

    

"

 $ #"

 #  

  %$   

 )    # 

#?

   (0  #    $  $"           "*$

$       #   

 # ?

  

"

  "

 #  

# 

  #  !

  

#  $

,  # 

#?

  

   &##

#  #  $#  

"* $

$(    #    $  $ "   #

 

 "

$$

 $

   

83@# / 7   5  $<"   =

 42+ .  <      #         $  $ "   #



 "

  # 

# ?

   "*$

$,

"

 #



          #       $  $"  

"

 $ #  

& $  #"*$

$+ 8  3 +/   $  $"     



"  



   

   





 

"

 $ # #

&      $  $"     

"  &

 # ##    

   & $  # 7      4.:(,#4.:   





 

"



"

&

#         

"

  "

 7 7$



#

#  $  #  #   

 #    

 $ # #



  # 7     4.:(,# 4.:   / 7   5  $<"     42+  8  #  42+      

       





$    #8:A# 

# #

#  !

#       #

- "      $  $  "     

"   !

 # ##    & $ $



"

 

-    $  $"     

"   !

" # 

"

 "

&

#

       

"

  "

  7   7$

 

    $   # #

  

  # 7     4.:(,# 4.:   / 7   5  $<"     42+  8  #  42+     

       





# #     # #

 !

"  #  

$ $ #  $$ $  

    7     4.:(,# 4.:    







  

"  



    

 



"

&

#       



"

  "

 7 7$





$ # #



  # / 7  5  $<"   42+8#42+    



  







  !



 

"

 ##"

&

# 

    "

 7 7$



8 /     $  $  "       

"  &



   

   

     # !

 &# ##    "

 

"

 

3   

   "*$

$  "  

 "

 "





 # & $$ $    $

  

  &$

&     





"

  $   $$ 

"

 < 

5

  @  &

  #       

  ;     

       

  

   "

 

      $



 # <  5

  @  5

  

       

 "

 

 "

 " 

  

 

"

  $   #  "

#  7 7$



:" -   5 

-   * 7  7$





   >

# 7 $  

 $   #   

##





     

#  

 

  $     $ ## #    $      #

 $

  7  7$





" >

# 7 $  

$    #    *    *  #   #     $    



    & 

"

    & #   !

 

"

$ $

  "

       "

# 7  7$



$ #    ; ,    

$  

 "

 $        &   #     

   ##    $   "

  

 !   #

   $   $ 

"

 $"

 7  7$



(      

2 

  &



   !

      $  $  " 

  

"   

  "

&

#    

     "

 7 7$



$$ $        #



"



   &  , *--    #  * 6 *7   # $

#   $  $"    

"    

 

"

$   /    @

 

  = $ B &-$&"

/  1 "%%  

"!! , : 

)"! E;& * 

"%  (!

 ! %-)!

#  ,

%#

 !  / % %-)!

!2 ! *

#! (

2* 2!

-!2 "!) !  "

( 6;;;

?0=/(+  (,:,(:8  < (C8C2+#/75<  5  <  <

= D$

75 

".

& 78  9$ 

<

0"    (,,8 0<0C<>%

&$  $ 



#"

 &

$  

#

E$$

 $$  9    7       <&#  7 !    "

 /7FG7(,22  #  "

     &  

= $   H*  $ #  $ $  >  (I  #  $ $  % J> $&

,0 # #  $ $  H # 0 

.< $



>< +  #$ H >  

&  

&    & 

"





$ ><  @ 

  &  & &   EC+(/75< "

    $ $   J$ 

";$  &     $ 

";$ &  J  



&  

 $   ><  #       $ $     

   "

$ ## # 

 < C*> " < 5<<

= D$

 (.,8B & /( ( +",$#$ + $% &-$&"

/  !2

- 1 "

!A% /!

0!2

1!2(

D2 ! #

1 "

 # )

-%#.*  # !2 8/,9 - )!2 )- ,%-=% #0*



"!!

%" *

#  7,* &

 

 E;&

(% !0!2

 

1

,/

"#! 

*

1(! ( E;&

!2

 #

0!2

(

-  !)"! ) 

 



(%2( /  (

<&

()!

 #0

1.!2

F,B  !!2

-  #* ( 

#0 %

 #

!

( 1

-!

# %

%)-  #*

*

#

E2#!(

#"(

 !

E;& *

(%2( .!2

##0!2 E;& * 1(

" 

.

#0!

( @# !)

#0*

!)

"!! "

!

(! *

.!2 )!



!!

 #*

()!

 #0

!

 #

)! !!

 #  )-

 #

F,B

!  #



6?%=1/<0<01/1F@%=%=G5E/9@<</=  "

EC(4, 5   432 = $ /H 88,C(:8C;C?<FC5"

 388 (? &   H <  <$  #5 

5 

=

 /H E   /::.27$C5  (2:,(:8 %$  $ 



& 

#=< &  #    $ 

"

   ::.C(:8 

& 

#><%$  $ 

"

  

::8C(:8& #  H ,  =

 H ?0=/(+  (,:,(:8EC<(C8C2+/7K5<  .7  #=  $H(4:,(:8 + #=  $H% $ 



& 

#L@M

    <

 $ 

& #    

&

$  

$  3I  # $

: #" &$& & $ & $ 

 25 $ #

 H 

  = $  40 # K H 7  

 $ H? $    # $ 

I  #   

 $ H(8.4A &+9(&%      #  $ 

 

     "

 

 "

 

% "

#

,8.4A   

 $

  "

# $   #$ 

 < C*= D=

= D=

< #%##

= 

 ?<F FE7>0/B



-

*

- )!  # 1  %

 1 "% *

* "!) ! 

%



2*

%" *

(0

""

- )  0

F,B  

>

.

-*

##1!2 =% !

! )!

!

 I(

 %

)!  # (!

)-!

"!! , : 

-! "%%  

!!

%" 

(%2(

)"1)

 %

"!!

! , : 

J -

I(

(

!)"

 !

"%

)!  #* (  %

!!2

2 1

!

!

 I(  (%

"%

)!  #*

"

F,B 1( %""

!! E;& *

(% 1 (!

)-!

%-,

, : 

- )

"!) ! *

%

2 1

!

!

-!  %

"%

)!  #* >)"

#0 2! E;& * )"!!2

!#0 

"!) ! 

& /( ( +("

"!"

/0 - &(

 "

!2 , : 

. )2 *

#

) 

" !#!2 %"

!#0  %2 !" ))!

*

-#0 !2

!" !A%* (  - )!2 )"! !

 



%

%* %# -!#!

%-

(G - 

"" 2 "

0 #

!

!G

/1*  % %#

%

-%#.

) !

! ( 2

#.(

"#! 

) !!

%" * #0 (! -!2 :

.2 =%!

 0* -%

(! 1!2(!2 #

:

.2 1(! (

=% %) (!

!



=%!

 0*

% (*

! %)- %"

! !2

!2 ! 

* 

F,B

)!* )  0

()!

E;

)!

)

-%#.

""

 #

"!!

( -!2

()!

 #0

  /1*

!

- 

(-0 )!!

%" * . ! 

!

" %



: * %-,

, : 

!2 # 2

(!A ! 

""

"

!A%*

* #

!2

##  !"

!* =% #!

0* =% 0* ) .!2* .* %)- % ( ! !0!2 ! %# 

(*

<*

.!2 1(! (

(0

.* % 2!*

* ! %# *

!  ! #

! !0

!A%

 /1*

- 1

)"1 ! * .

! %)-

%" (!)*

0

)

""#!

-

+%!!

##0 )"1 2!

"%" 

 !0!2

 

 ""

G

1

-

.!2*

"  % ( 2!

* "( 2 "( K% ( %2* %-

  0  L

 !0!2 % ( "( 2 "(

%G



##1!2

"

)"# % ( %2 %-

 *

"  % ( 2!

 !0!2

 

0 #!

)"#  1

5 #0 1(

-

!#0 

!!

!* ( 

+%!!

##0 )"1 2!

*

""



(!A "#!  ! *

( #0

!

#

# 2 >

!

!*

(%2( %-,

, : 

!2

!!

(!2( "

 !2 "!) !  "

  %

*

-

!2!2

(!2( "

"!) ! *

 #! !! 1 % , : 

#0 "

-%

# "

"( 2 "(* ## %-

  0  * -! "

0 #!

"

)"# 1 % %-,

, : 

&+$ $&#$(+ *",$ ) -$0 - &( &% &(.$ (" ",$ ) -$+ *!

"$% 2!$("

&( + .

 ?

0*

""

!! 0*

*

1(! (

"

"!) ! 

!2 "

  %



(1 0

!2

0 )"1)

%2 !" ))!

  %

!!

%" *

0

 0* 

)!  #*  

 %

""!

-%#.*

%



!#0  %2 !" ))!

*

0

;)"

" % ) %!2

3

"%

)!  # -

# 

!

7%2    .!2

-  #%! - )  %"

%)*

%

 %-,

, :

!2 +%!!

2!

##1

(!A ! *

"

)"# % ( %2 %-

 * -%

(! "  ,%-=% #0

#0

0* -%

#

#!

1 "

!

! "

)"# )

-%#.

% ( %2* %-

 *

# =%!

!! (!)*

 #0 1

 > *  %-,

, : 

(

" .!2

0 !! #!

)"#*

1 % %

 %- ,

, : 

(  - ) "!) !  "

% (   /1* 0



 #%*

!

$ *

#! -!

# $  

"

()!

 #0

)"!!2

"!) ! 

#! (

2* " !

##0 (%

)!  #   - )!2 "%   1!2

- !  - ) 

%)*

#!

"

)"#*

(%2(  #  %-,

, : 

 "!) !  "

! #%  %!2

(! /1*

- #0

()!

 #0

1(  !

()

-

(% - )!2  -#

.

""!

(!2 "

%)-  !)"!*

E2#!(

#"(

!

( -! (! - )!2

#  -#

%



 #*

 #*

(%2( (! !2

 !"

!

!

""!

  !!

 6  !#0

-

!2!2

"

"!) ! *

!! #!

1 "

"

)"#* -%

#0

-

4

#!)!

 0 "!!

1%# %#

" % -!2  #

"

2

(%2( "%

)!  # -%

(%2(

!2 #0

"

()!

 #0

%"

!!

 #*

*

* #0 %

!! #!

1 "

 # $# " .!2

-%

0

-

%   # !!

"

)"#*

!!2



"(!-!

"0 ( "!

%-

 *

<*

  %2 > $ 

!2

!! -

# 

!

7%2

#2

"

F,B  %

"!) !  "

2 %

1%# -!2

(

!## =%  

> I

 (%

 !2

!!

"

 #*

-!2 #

 #%

#

!!2



"(!-!

%-

 

  %2 >>

"!

; #%!2

-

 !2

#

!!

"

 #* 0

! !2 -!2

!2

!! #! 4( (%

-

 !2

!!

"

 #* 

*

!! #!

$ *

- ) "!) !  >  (%

""!

"

()!

 #0

2 1

!

% "

 



" 

" % - ) ;)"

)

# "% !2

)!  # -

# 

!

7%2 %#

#0*

#!

$ *

!

#0*

"!) ! 

"!!

()!

 #0

* "

!!

"

 #*



- )

"!) ! * -%

%-+

)!



 #

#

#2

"

()!

 #0

- )!2 "%  >>> 4(% (%

""!

-

 !2 -!2 

2 ""

!! 0 %#

#0*

(-0

"!! ,

:

>!

E!  -! ,  &*

) !!2



-

;"

! 

"

(%2( "%

)!  # * ! 

-%

-# "%)"

%

!2

"

()!

 #0

"!! ,  & 4(%

%

2!

"" %!

-%

"%)"

% (

E)"( !A!2#0

- !

"% !

%" * -

# 

!

7%2* - )

"!) ! 

%""

2 %

 -!2

; "

!2

-

 !2

!!

 #*

F,B 1(! ( -%

#

!

 ! !!

! 

"

2 1

!

% "

6&,  *

( -

 ! !!

! 

" 4(* #0

"( 

1!2

!!

#  2!

*

!!

"

 #* - ) %-+

-

 !2*

( #0 1%#

!!

! !2 4(

#*

!! #!

$  



-!%#0 - ) "!) !   ;)"

) "% !*

"

F,B 

# ;)"

"%

)!  # =% #0*

!2!2

"

"!) ! *

!! #!

1 "

"

)"#* -%

- "( * %#

(

""!

-

 !2

*

#!)!

( ! !

.!2  #

(*



-! %!2



 #M

(*

!)

1!2 "

 #

" 

2!

* -!

# #0 ; #%!2

"!-!#!

)"!2 -!2 

"

 #* %"

(!

##!2

()!

 #0

  /1*

-

!2!2

(!2( "

"!) ! *

!! #!

!

#0*

-

 ;)"

"%

)!  # 

%" * -%

!)"#

2 1!2

"

 #

2!

)

-%#.*

* 1(! ( #  (!)

.

!!

*

( -

 !2 

!!

"

 # >

-

 !2 

- "( *

( #0

!!

1%# - )

"!) ! *

%

2 %

(1! /1

!



!) 1!2

"

 # -

#  2!

( -

 !2 

!!

"

 #*

(%*

(



 !

"%

)!  # ( 

#2

"

F,B  -!2

- "!! ,

:

>!

E!  -!

"!! ,  &*

( ) !

% =% 

(*

E;" M "

)!  #

"

(%2(

"%

!  # 

"" %!

%

-%

"%)"

% (*

(

()!

 #0

#

2

(!)

",$ $ ( &(+ %

.

&'",$ ) -$ &+$ $&#$(

E (1!*

"

()!

 #0

 !!2!!

1(! (

1%# - )*

 (%

0 -



)!

 -!2

!!

 #* 0

!! #!

- )!2 "!) ! * 1(%"

##

-

! 1%# - ) 0% # *

(%

!! #!

"

 #*  (%

-

)!

! -!2

!!

()* "! %%#0*

!)

(! ""

-

2!

* 1%# 0

- ) %-!

!2#0  % -#

!!2



-  "0 ( "!

%-

 

-    %2

- !

)"#

 4(*  %-,

, : 

"

" 

%* (  % !2

"!! ,  &* -! %

"!! ,

:

>!

E!  * 

(%2(

- %  #!* -! 1.

-#* -%

%-+

!) 1!2 -

2!

#!

""

!!2

!

! "

 # )

-%#.*

0

  !#0

(

""!

-

 !2 -!2  -0<!

" 

2!



""!

-

 !2

- "( 

 !

(%2(

2!

(1!

##!2

"

 #

-

(! "% !2

"!-# ! 

0

"

)"#

-

  #0

- -

 !2 *

*



!) !

! "

)"# )

-%#.* -%

-!%#0 -

2!

*

( #0

-  " 

%

%" *  %!2 %-,

, : 

1%# - ) #!* 1%#

- ) % (1! /1*

!



( !  %22 !*

!) 1!2 "

)"#* )

-%#.

( 

" 

#  2!

(! %!2

!



"

 #* )



-

+!!2

")! 4(* 1( #0

- 

#

""!

-

 !2 -!2 *



%-,

, : 

1%# 

%##

"# 0* (1! /1* (%

""!

-

 !2 -!2 * ) ! %# #0

2 ""

!! !

""

!! #!

"

 #*

(*

) ""

!! ! !! #!

"

 #*



 %

$ 

%# !2

 #%!*

%;

)! !!

"

 #

!

 -  "0 ( "!

%-

 *

* -    %2 > =%#*

(

!)"

 !

"%

)!  #

#2

"

F,B 4(*

!

 .

- ! %!*

) "%

!!

) "%

"

F,B

$ 

%! !

#! (

2 1

!

%

,$$++$#"( +0!

0 ( -$ &"$ $"

&" ",$* &% "$ +(!)3$#"

&4 + $#"

&563 +",$#"

 

- "%"! "

-!2



%-,

, : 

# =%!

2!

%##



#0 -!2 2!

%##

 ( 

#2!#



! "

, : 

1%# - ) %##0

(! 

-

"

 " 

%*

* ; #%

"

 ,

:

>!

E!  -! ; #%

"

,  & ,

:

>!

E! 

#



;"

!  -!2 ## *

*

#

;"

!  -!2

 -! " - 1 * ,  &* #





"

F,B

*

1(! (

-%

-# "%)"

%

!2 " 

% %-,

, : 

1%# 0

) #!* -%

#0 1( -

 !2

!#!



 %

#  2!

 "! #0

"( 

(! !!2 "

)"# )

-%#.

-! 1(

(0

(

.

 !0!2

 

( >



#  2!



!) !0!2

 

""!

0*

*

1(! (

(!2( "

"!) ! 

!#0

!2* " 

#

( " ##0 (1!

#

#2

"

)"#*

-

#

 !2 -!2

(* "%

"!-# A

! 

- "%"*

(

!2!2

(!2( "

"!) ! 

0* 1%#  - )  %

1%# )  #! *

-

# %-+

-

 !2

!!

"

 #*

# -* )

- )!2 ) !

!! 0* )  %)

""

(1!

( >

!!

"( 

#  2!

!0!2

 

!#0 0*

- ) !!2

*

!! #!

(%2( (!

""!2

!!

"

F,B   =% #0*

-

( *

(%

!! 1%# +0

)"# 

0 *

1%#

# %#

#2!#



(  ; #%!2

"!! ,

:

>!

E!  -! ; #%!2

"!! ,  &*

- )!2 )"# #0 #! 

(

( 1%#  !

0*

(

 =%

""!

-

 !2 -!2   1%#

(

0  !

)!  #

#2

"

F,B -!2 "% 

"!) ! *

%

2* (1!



,! 

!



!) (! !0!2

 

 !

""!

0*

#  2!

!

( %

""!

-

 !2 -!2   ) !

()

( (! !!  %

""!2

(1!

""!

"!!

F,B   4(%* $ 

!! 

- ) "!) !  =% #0*

(

!  !

" %

"% * -

)! )"#*

*

#

"

F,B /1*

-

-  : > =% *

2%)

#  ,

%#

$



!! #!

"

 #* "!) !  - ) + *

*

!2#0

1 )

"!2

- )%#

=% 1

 ,! 

-

(! #0 

%" *  #%

( 

! !

!! #!

"

)"#* "!) ! 

"

2 4(*

" %

;)"

) "!2

"

F,B  ;)"

) "% !2*

#2

"

F,B

""!

)!  # E)"( !A!2#0*

-  !

! #0 %

!) "

-

#  2!

)"1 "#!  ! *

(! )!

!2

* - (! !0!2

 

0* !))!

#0

(

(  %!2

(*

""!

-

 !2 -!2 

-  - %

(%2( (! !

" ##0 (1!

%!2

""!

-

 !2*

(%2( (! "% !2 ) "!-# A

! 

*

#2

)"1 "#!  ! *

#

-

#

 !2 -!2

!!

"

 #

 

,%-=% #0* 

!! (!)* (  

!!

"

 # (  -!2 "%

-

 !2 

""

!!

"

F,B   %#

#0*

(

" 

% ; #%!2



,

:

>!

E!  -!



, 

&* 1%# - ) %##0  -#



#!* -! 1%# 2!

%##



#2!#

1!)* -!2 2

, : 

/1*

!

!

!*

##

-  0

"!! ,

:

>!

E!  -!

"!! ,  &* ) %##0

!**

& +0

&# 0$( 5

> -

 !2

!!

"

 # 

!! 1 % , : 

-%

!)"

!*

* #0 -

 !2 -!2 

!!

"

 #*

(

 #%

2 1 "

  %

"

>> ) "%

!!

- ) "!) ! * -%

1%# - )  #0 1(

!) 1!2

"

 # -

#  2!

""!

-

 !2

( * !

(%2(

#  2!

" ##0

##!2

#2

"

 #*

-

(! "% !2

A

! 

#2

)"1 "#!  ! 

#

-

#

 !2 -!2

(

1

>>> >

-

 !2

# 

!!

"

F,B

""

(1!

 

"

F,B

0  %)

""

!! 0*

(

) "%

!! - ) "!) ! *

* $ 

"%

2 %

- ) "

>$ /1*

!) 1!2

"

 #

!) .!2

!!

=%

 

0*

2!



%

""!

-

 !2 -!2 *

(

-

 !2

!!

"

 #* 0



-

  > *

#0

"

F,B -%

#

)! #

 #

"% 

- )"! "!) ! * "!2

2 %

>)"

#0* 1(

- #

!

!*

"!! - ,

:

>!

E! 

* ,  &* )

 2! !

! %#

"0

(! !

, 

/)* ')

&%+ -*

*

, 

/)* ')

/  -!2

2

!

"#!  



- ,

 -!2 %

!   (! !;

) ( (

*

*

!)

(! 

> =% *

( )!

!

"" #*

*

)

##1 !)"%2 !

* 1* %" =%

!

# 

3

!

,! 7%2 =% (*

* 

!*

*

""##

=%!

2 1

!

(!) " #*

* % -

!

!

(1!

 ##*

* ! ( 2 !

% 0*

*

=%!

0

* !

(1!

#  ) "! #  

!2#0 ""

 F!

)%

0* "!

% (1!

%

(!)* -%

   1  

-#1* 

1 (1!

(   "" 0*

0*

=%!*

(*

*  0

;"!0

"! #!)!

!  7

 

   9:;6:64  7 8 ",$(,     ,$",$ (0$ < &'= $ ( &$%3 $(= :

  ;

'8#