Pankaj Bhankar v. Haryana Public Service Commission And Another



  
  



 


 

 !

"# $!%&'&"(

) )

*

* )))! & &"(!+ ,--    .
-,

//-- 



)))!'0"($!( '

/ 1 . /) -
 - - 
 







 



  

 "



#  

 $

%%%% 

- - 

) 3+45 "





  $$(

) 

*   

 



+   $$ ,-
"$0  2
)   #

# $"

""

$,"( $3 ,4 $,"-

1 

 1  '

# 

  .*      #

 # 

  .* 

 

 ) ) 1 #    '1

' 

$

'



  



  .*  0   21
'  )## $"

,5 $,"- 
"

&   

  .*  0

  #

6 ) 1   #

) ) 1

   #    $"

", $,$"

$0  

'#

   /

 ,4 ""

$,$"





 ) ) 1 ,"

""

$,$"

30  

   +    

#

7 ,5 "$ $,$"


8 #  

 #

& 

  ,9 "$ $,$"

", "$ $,$"



   "$ ,"


-    

    ,5 ,$ 

 

  ,8 ,5 
",  '  1  '  ' 

  '

  

 +   

 ' ):
"(($4$,$$   

,"

,- 
""

) 

  "2
)   



-0

   

&  #   $$ ,-
"$0 2
)

   

;  '

 

#   +   # + 

 #

:  +   + 

 +  



  .*  " )

< = & ) <   '1   +   ## # ( 1  +   #= #

*  *  

 1   /  

2 

   +  

   ' 

<

) < 

2      ## # 

( 1  +   /  

& '   #

   #

   

# #  ( 1

+    #
"0  

 $



  




 



    





 
  

!



  

 
 "
 

  
 


  #

 # 
  $  
   % 



   "
    &

 
 
    ' & (

 
& 

 '

          



               !     ) '

  #   *+ *, -    .





  #  $/0 + 1 ,22222222 $ 3'$ # 4

$, 1, ,222222222 052222222 # 



 & 222222222222 &0 222222222     222222222222222222222222222  

 (  0  
 


  #



# 
  



6   
  2222222222222222222  2222222222222     22222222222222222222  222222  22222  "
   



"
 

 



   (

 

 



  '   

 

   222222222   # 

 


  




 

   

 




 


   

  
 


  #



# 
  05

,  .

&    #

   

   
               

 

       " #" ! $  % $ 

  &  ' !   "      (( 

 () $

  #



 

 7  3(



68
 "
 *  +  ,

 9 ::; %  ! ::; < * 4= =%;0+ 

"
  



: 3(




 = 

 )  :  :; !

 :%;<:; > * 4=!=:0+ 

"
   % 3(



68
 = 

 ,

  :?;<:; >  :;?:; @ * ;= @0+ 

"
   ? 3(





  = 

 '

 A( 

1  )   ::;?:; @  %  ;:;:

*:4=!=@0+ 

"
  B

;  '

      ) ) 1 

  1  '  +  +   ' #    1  '    

    

) 

,"

,- 
""

 

 7)

&
  

  

 

   

 

    &  *#+ 





 
           



    

 : ;9:; > *"

 6= +   





 





 

  "
  ( 

 

   




 ( 



 



 



   

      

"

 6=>    



 

   &

    

  &

   

  

      

 




       ' 

 

   

   



:; :;::

*"

 6=>+  



    



 

    







  

       

 #

 
      

   (  

-   C- 0D- '- 




          ' 



  

  

  


     , 
  


        *"

 6=>+  

 
 

 





(    

 



 

  
 


  

 B (

:  ) 

   '

 

 # 1  # #    

"4 1

2

   #   $$ ,-
"$0  1

2

       !

"   ' 

       

2

 

           2  >

1 ;

'

  #    1  #  

2

1 # 

    ! "

2

 # 

  $  

 )

6

< ) <;

# $"

""

$,"( $3 ,4 $,"- /   

1 

"

1 ( # $ 1 / 

#  

/ 

 

+  

( 1 # 1 # $- 1    '

;  '

  $   ) < ) <;

# $"

""

$,"( $3 ,4 $,"- /    '?  2
)   1 '

#     #= #

*  *   =#=#1=

   /  



   
-  

 '

 

 !
)*$'
'
) $+$',
7




   6,CE ',C1- = %:> 

(

 

$/

  

:  :; !

 :%;<:; > 




   #= , & 0  '


  

 



 :9-;;;= *1   & 



$ +   ' 

  

 



 :%;<:; >B

@7

2 & <;<)& 7!*) ;* *&<

&

!6<

.2 2 & <;<)& 7!*) ;&

2 & !6  62A*

>



-

;  '

      < ;# 6#

* <   < ;#

2

   2
)    < ;# 

# '   1      
5    +   #   #   # 
-  "$ ,"

$,$$   

'  #

:  #   8(

 #

#  <  

 < ;#  ##   



    #   #  "$ ,"

          

:  #  "$ ,"

  8(

 '  #   #   +   #

2

1 

# # #   

   #  



#  "$ ,"

  #   8(  

'   1   #   

     

 1 ' 

  1 

 

# 

2

  1 '?



#  1

 #   

   # 2
)   < ;# # '  

 '1

   < ;#

2

1 

#  #

  '   

        

;  '

 '  

  /

 #'

#    '



   #

   ) 

 


""

       1

 2
)    

 



 '  '

2  

# 
"$0  1   

       



'

1   $



2

# 

 $  '

  '   

 7#
  
 








  'F  '

  



; ;>:;::-   



:; :;::

*"

 6=>+ 

 =
  



 

  



 5=

  

"

"


 



 ) .

'A1)    

 



:; :;::

*"

 6=>+ 
   

 -  

  

5=   "


   

 :  :; !

 :%;<:; > *; 4=;!=;:0+   ) 

  
 

       

 



;@ .

; ::;:  '


  

    ( 
   

 

 

 

  

     

 0    


  #

 # 
  







     :  "


   

 ::;?:; @  %  ;:;:

*;:4=;!=;@0+  'A1) 





 ;9; :;::

  


   8


 &


 

      B



",

;  '

 

  1 1   

# $"

""

$,"( $3 ,4 $,"-  

 '  

#     

    '

  

   1  1   



2

    1        1    #  

 # 

2



?'

 

 @ #

  

  $"

) 

*       1

          +  

# '    
- '



   1 '

1  

#  < ;# 



  1 ## #

'

  1 

 

  $"

) 

*

 

2

1  

' 

?'=#       # 
"$0 '   + 

""

7     

 "

'

   
""    /
"$   

    2  >

1 ;# 





1    

#     #   #  
"$0

2   

#      

# #

 # 

     

#= #

*  *   =#=#1= '

      # 

#

2

1     /1 # 

#   

' '    1  1    



   

  #    ' #

"$

*     



"3

7 '

  # 1      



 < ;#



# $"

""

$,"( $3 ,4 $,"-   


-

         1

'

1    

#  

2   '?  2
)   # 1

 #  #  < ;#

 "$ ,"

$,$$ 1   '

   < ;#



 

# 

   

 "2
)    +   '

    1

     #  "$ ,"

   

       1 ' 



#  #

"8

&

      

#

 

   '    ? 



           1

 2
)    1       

1     1      1

  ' 

  

# 
"$   1 

   #  '    < ;#  $   '

  

#    



2  >

1 ;#  

2 

 < ;#  

  #1 

  / ( 1     '  '



 < ;# '

#  / 

 

+ 

( 1

&  1       '

#

     '

  

#       #     


""       '



-0 '







< ;#

# $"

""

$,"( $3 ,4 $,"-   1  #   1 

# 

: # #   1     



&

    '

  '  
""

# 

 

   )#1 



*  1

       

"4

  

 #   '

  

  .*      ) ) 1 '

'1         

  '

"(

* 

1  #

  

#   $$ ,-
"$0 '1   + 

  '

 < ;#     #   8(  

   ' 1  

 

#

;  / #  

 #

# 1



"5

   

 

  

# 
"$0   

1 #  1   '

  '  

 < ;#    #   1       

#   2
) '

   #

 # 



  

$4,,,=

   

 #

3- - 5 ) )

 
7! ( 789+ :  =  B=! : '  B=!