High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/6267/2015disposed of

Dhir Singh v. Union Of India & ORS

2015-04-06Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh4 pages

!"!#$% &!'(!#)&

!#' *'"+"

#!##,!

#, &'"

"-#,# "

($ .'

/!#,'(& '0 1,2

' !#'

! ! 0 !# # & "3!#) & +'

1 .' (+#!4 5+0 ' (& '0 # '

42'#0# (

#,!#)+#"4 - "# ! #6& 4 #!# #,!

7'"-#,# 1 .' !"&! 5 +"& 41 ,2

7'"-#,# #, ." .+#!"& #,&!1 ,,4 ,2

41 +#/ 6''"-#,# 8 8 '#, +#"4' !#'& "& #,,2' : -!" & - !# & & 4 '#, +#"4" ' '"-#,# " % #2!: &#

+'',':&! &:-'-" - ""1# '-4;< !, 2!

!"'=+!', 6!4,6; &'"-#,# "

&- !#'" ''"!,# "2!44 )5 ( !, #1!"

0'!

'!"4 #,1 "+44;," '!6,!#- '

&:'!

!#1

, 6# =+!', 6; '"-#,# " #, +#,' &

!)&:

;" 1> & :

', :

" - "", !# & ;

' > 6; & 9 #, =+!"!

!#44 '70- # + ; &- !#'?"0 !#)'!2 # !"

:&!4 """"!#) 0-#"

!#1 &6#!

" ( !#" 81 @ #, 8% & 9 #, =+!"!

!# 1@>%1# 04;1"4

!+0 #,!# :'# )'

# ,

&0,"-!

&!"+'

!# "#$%&'( )(*(& +''% ,)-.(-#/')#0#(.( (&.**(&+1')#!

2342./.%45 !

)'!

44;&4,

2#!# & " =+!"!

!#+#,'

4 !)&:

;" 1 > 1 & 62 0# !#, : "

+ ';

6#!

" ' =+ 44; ,0!""!64 & , 4 #,<:#'" & - !#'" 4" '4; +-# : , !"!#" &!" +'

1 6 & ,

, >- "",!# 3

21*- .(-1*(&*(+1') /')#0# 66.##.(')! *%*(&1*) 7./.#.( *(& +1')#4 #, 33

2)'6 *0)/')#0#(.( (&.**(&+1')#4 :&'6; &6#!

""4

!+0 #,!# !# '0" & 62< !

, , !"!# &!"+'

1& 26#A #,, &"!0!4 '4;"!

,4 #,< :#'" 4!

# :

"-4 ,+-# &','1##A+' <8- "",6;

&!"+'

!#"!0!4 ' !' +0"

# " @ # &')'!2 # !#'!"

6"!,"!""+!#) 4) 4# ! ,

, %B##A+' <C &'"-#,# "1&!"

'+##!#) '0 -!44 ' -"

6' & ! '" '"-#,# <

;"+ ;' &'4 " 620# !#,6#!

6+ &"

0 ':!

&&4,#4;# &-4

#,!'

!#"& 26# )!2#6; &!"+'

!#&!" "& ))'!2,- !#'& 2#:

--' &, &!"+'

5 > & 2& ',4 '#, +#"4' '

"0 4#) & #,)# &'+)& &' ', &-'!# !-4"4 !,,:#6; &!"+'

!#4,#'# #, ( 4 ')!#)"?" "B"+-'

C1 '# !#,!"-+ +'

&'1 &

&6#!

""4

!+0 #,!# & 26#A #,,6; &!"+'

&"!0!4 '4;"!

,4 #,<:#'"2!,',',

,>!#& ) (!#)&?" " B"+-'

C1 # 4" 6 & ',4; ,!"-+ , # &"

!' +0"

# "1: ' &2!:

!"!0-'

!2+-#'"-#,#

" #, #"!,' !#'?" 4 !0' &)'

# "4

!+0

#,!# !# ', # :!

& &, !"!# &!"+'

!#4,#'#

#,( 4 ')!#)"?" "B"+-'

C &:'!

!#!" ',!#)4;,!"-",!# &44:!#)

'0"$< B!C & - !#' "& 44 02 --4!

!# 6' # !!, 0- # + ;< +0<9 #, =+!"!

44 ':!

&!# -'!,#0# &' &)'

!,6#!

"D B!!C &"

!,0- # + ;:!44!""+# ! #,

44' &' ',"7'-4;'0 &

;

+ ;#,!

D B!!!C &0- # + ;"& 44 &'

', '0!# :& &' ' # & - !#' !" # 4,

!,6#!

"1"- !

44;!#2!: &, !"!#"

&!"+'

#, &#E64(+-'0+'

'4!, +-#6; & 4 !0 # "D B!2C !#'!"+#,# 4, 1 "4"- 3!#) "+--40#

';:

', &!" "& 446- "",

3 :!

&!# -'!,+'0# &"'0 &,

!4!#)

& --4!

!#B"CD B2C &

;"+ ;#,!

"& 44,-"!

& 0+# 1! #;1- ;

64!# '0""+--40#

',1!#!# <6 '!#)!A,,-"!

+# B"C!#

#;#

4!F,6 #3 #,,!"6+'"0# &'"& 6 "+6/ & !# 4 , !"!# & #E64 (+-'0+'

!#(- !

4 9 2 -- 4B!2!4C % % 4,$ '/ !'

!)&:

;1*2"

/"&:

'(!#)& #, '" '!

!#"

#,",!"-", ',!#)4; 2

4 7$ 8).%!

4 )6"