High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4647/2009disposed of

Sutinder Parkash Jain & ORS v. Sulekh Chand Jain & ORS

2019-03-25Mrs. Justice Anita Chaudhry21 pages

"# $%$&"' "

(( )) * $# ) "+"' "

(

,-'+

# $%$&"' "

(( )) * $# ) "+"' "

(

)%$' (( )) * $# "# $%$&"' "

(

$# ".#(/0 / $"

(( )) 1

$$ ( 1

$%&2' /0 / $$ ( 1

$#"

$33$4)/0 $$ ( 5 1

(( ))1

$2 "$$/0 / $$ ( ! 1

$* &-")/$0 /4 " $ &"

)6"$4)/0 / * &."

/0 /

$$ ( !

$7 ' /0 /

$$ ( / /!/

-9"

2#37 /

+$62

")) ( %)

4 ))

(( ):

$62

4 +#$/;# )44"

;# $ $ <"

$ )) 4 4 6

7 3

= # <7 > 3"%$( $9 / "

$6 $

$$ >"

= ##

/! "

$ $

$$ >"

! >4 ) "

$"#6$?

$ 7 < ))

694 4"

4 "0 3 ) )

$ "0 3 6

7 6)#

4 $ 7 3

! /4#) )

$96

7 4 $ $9($

#)$)94"

;# 4 "$ (

4 $"

( $96 ;# "

$67 $ 3" ) 3

# )"

)$3#7 "6 (

/ 3$

3 $7903# ?

3 A $(( )) +#$""

2 "

# 7 )9 ($

$9($( $9 7 )9 $ #)

3(($

($( $( $(

B # $ $ $ ) "

( 6 4

/ 4#)6 (($($ $4( 3$

! "

#$ % &'' ()

*+ ,-

-. /

/ / / 0 '

* / ! 1! ! 2! ) / 3 ' #$ - %

4 . & 5'* , , ! , ! , , '' !

1! -$! !

* , ! , ! !!

/ / / 3 * , 7 ! * / !

! "

8 / / , 5* , * ! "

! "

2 ! "

( ! "

1 (($ "+"

$2 C) #$)

9 $ = )

6 7"(4")

9 $ %)

$ (( )) D"E )'

# ) 3""

( +"

$2 C)/)"#3""

#$) (+"= ) ""

$9/)3) 3

() 2 "

# 7 )9($( $9/"

/()

4 "

@ ") "$ = )($9 $($ $9 697 6#

4$ 3"

# 14() 69"

$ 2 "

7 )9 ($

$9($( $

) 7 D"E )' "

4( /4 (# 4 #$"

$() " D"E )' ")#

"( "

6 7 < )) -""

+#$(($

# $ $ )+#$"

)""

()

($0 ""

$ 2 "

# 7 )9 ($

$9($( $

+#$ #$"

)" "

$ )) < ))

69 "( 4#) $ #) ;# "

0#$ ()

14 #$"

)" ()

" ($0 ( 7 )9 +"

$2 C)B"#/"

$ )+#$

# 9 =4 $/ ) $ A $ (( )) +#$ " 7

2#37 ( 69"

) $ $ )+#$4"

#(") 3"

! "

$ )+#$""

4( ()

) 7 "(4 7(

< ))=4 $/

$(( ))

#$""

D"E )' #$) ( +"/"

37 $ 2 "

# 7 )9 ) :5"

"$ 3$

#)#$))

(3$

#)#$))7 ($

- () %$ $9

$($ "6

( "

@ :5""$ 4 "$ (

# ($( $

7 #6 ($ %

( #6 ($ D 1 " #$"

$ " )

#$ 3 "

( 9 "

# 4 )) 6 #62

2#7 "

)($ /&

( 3 0

0)#

($( $9 B"

+#$""

$) $ # ) $"

) 3"

4 ""

$6)

3 "$#3""

2#37 ( 696"

+#$6 )4"

0)#7 #$

$ )34 ""

(( )/(()

$ )

" )6

$ 3"

$3#7 /"

+#$ 0

4"4 6

# $ ;# $7 <"

$D"E )' 4( 69+"

$2 C)"

"($?

6 <"

$"(4 7( 6 ;# ""

$9"

)69"

" "

$"#6+"

$2 C)/ 0#$ D"E

)' $?

$ 3$

$ # / 6" "

+#$ "0 $

$ " D"E )' " ($0 "

( $ @7

#7 /"

+#$ ) 7 0

4A $ #7 4"

) 6 7 ) 7"(69"

()

)

) 69"

F@1"

#7 /()

D"E ) $

$$ 3$ D"E )' "6

$$ ( #6/

$ #7 "D"E )4#)6 4 $ 7$

"$ 7($ "

$ "

4#) #$"

$ 6 )

# $

"# 4"

7"(# $

/"4 $/ $

$D"E )' (

#7 4"

" 4$ $

3 69D"E )

$)9($0 "D"E )"$

$$ "

C) (+"-""

+#$"0 #" 3#$ D"E

)$ ($0 "

4$ $

)) #$"

$/ "

" (+" 9 $ !/D"E )" "

"$ $9 "

#$) "

$B"

) #7 4"

"$ ;#

+#$ $ < )))) )9

69) 7 "( 9 $!!1"

< )))/D"E )

$$ ( )"#3" $

$ ""

"# )34 ""(

4 ""

))94" $ ) "

$( 10

4 0 $4"

)7 3

3 +#$6 )4$ ;# 9

(

4) #

# 61 # 6/"

$ "$

#7 4"

"$ ;# $($ A $ #7 1 ) 69"

)

D"E )()

) 7" < )) 7

69)

7"(B"

$ ) #7 G$#/$) (9 =

)3#3 0 )6) $

$ C $ # ) (( $ 3 $ "

(

"" 0 $$) (9 #7 /

3 (# 69 ) $ # ) $ "

(( )))"#3"/"

$) "(( )94$ /"4 $/"

+#$")3"

$ )G$# #7 $ 0 $"

" 6

3 0 $) "

$B"

7()

$) (9 @$ # $

! "

# " #%

" &

# #" "

'$ # #

$ " %( ) *$ ) +

! # " #' $ ' % &

' #

' ' #

# #

# # "

+ #

' $##

" "$#

# $ ' ( )$ #

# #&

#,&- $ !' % *$ ) $ .

# #

" &

# # $ ' %( )*$ ) $ $# $ ' " # #

# # # #

# /"

$ & ' '

# #"#$ # #

$ ' #

$ $

# " # $ '

# # " # $ ' ( )

" ' $

# $ ' # .

"0 1$ ' "

' 3 4 4

' !

43 4

- 3 $ ,56- * *,,3

,55, # #$#

/ "

+ 17' $ ' "

$ ,8 )% "

3 &

$ ' #

"3 $ $#

$ ,9:;"

$ 1<

!3 + (4 ! 3 + / 3 ) 4 )4

# ) 4 " 4 ) # 4 24 #

! 24

%+ 3&7 2 2

3&72 3

> 1 (($ "6""

+#$"0 7 "

#7 4"

)# 3""

) "

"# "

4$ F@

#$:B $$ ( )9"

") ""

4#)$ 7 4 $#$ 3"

#7 4#) 7 ( $ $"

$ ""

") ""

4#)

7 -""

+#$4 7($

69"

" 3 69 )$3 #76 $ ( $"

"34$ "1")) ))$ 7$33 $9=4 $/# "

4#) 0 $< )) B 7

) -""

+#$ $$ "

#7 3$

69B )&+"/D"E ) C)( $"3$

< ))69"($ ($#

60 "6

&4) 3 ($( $9 )) 3"

"$ " "6

=4 $/"

3 697"(/"

/# " #7 7"( 7 "( "

#6 ;# $ < )) B 7 )"

)) "

$ $)

$< ))

9 $ F@(

))9B"

$ 4 #7 /

)) < ))

9 $0

))

!!/4"

3 $ "

7 9/"

$< ))

0#$ D"E )6 ;# "

$ ($( $

/ 4"

"0 6

3 < ))-""

+#$"0 3$ "

9 $!!"

3$#""(4)

4 "$ 3"/ ) $ $

)

46)# 4 $ $9 9 $!! 6

7 3

! / "

/ "

#) 6 ;# "

($( $9 0#$ D"E ) 1 "

( "

+#$/ 6" "

$ 69"

) $ +#$6 )4$ $$ #B"

) 1 4 )) ) " "

)< )) F@

#$"($ 0 )7"("

)) "

7 69$ $#7 9 $!! =

/ #7 "

)("

3 4 $"

( $9F@%/"

< ))

!!/ $ < ))($0 69 @7 3 34 7 )9#$ 3"1

(# " $"

" 7"(/($( $9)

6 69"

$4 7# 0#$ D"E )"

$ ")) 3 "

("$#3""

# 4) # @7 $ 4"

""0 6

3 69"

+#$ 3$ < ))

0#$ D"E ) $$ 3 69"

+#$ ") 7"("

) 4"

"")$ 96

# # 6 $$

$ 3 69"

+#$ ) ;#))9 $$ # "

+#$"0 "

)" 9 $!!/"(4)9"0 3 )

4 7(

7 6 ;# ""

$($( $91 4 )) ) " #

( "

" ( $B"

7 < ))4#) ) 7 ( $ :

)9"

" F@

< ))1 # (# "7"(

9 $ /

7 3

! /"

/ 9 /

4 "0 3) $)

$$ 3"4#) )$3 "

4#)

7 6)# 4 $/"

< ))4"

69"

4#)( $ 19 /"

") 7"(4 "0 3)9)

)

$ $+# )(( $ 3 $7

"#67 "4 4"$ 3""

$96

7 3

= #$"

$$ "

($0

$""

"$ $(

(()

6 9=

#67 " 7 "( 4 "

4 $ "

($( $9 / "

2#37 ( 69"

+#$6 )4$ $$

+#$")9E "

$3#7

C $ $+# ) $$

$ 3")

4 4 7 6 $

3 $"

$ )9 $

#) @7 7#6&= #C469 "4A$#2 #)) F / (($ " 0)#

($( $9 "

7) +"( $,1 -& ($ 5 4"

" @$ # $

?,@

* 3

# # 1?,@ A?:@

A?6@

A?-@ B

A?C@ B B

?D,@"

?:@* ! ?

,5:5 #

' $7?,@"*#

# B

?6@ )3

# '

$ $ CD" B

,5:5" # $

"? -6 ,6 ,6*,6D, @"

?-@

* * ))

' # $

B B

# % # # $# # $

? *

,98@"

# ! ?

,5:5 %

# $#

"> 1 79 6 " "

($ " 6

@$ 4 "#

))#$ 3 6& )$)9/

@7 B$

= # C4G3 699 >/ )$

($!

@$ # $

' # $#' $#

" )%1 $ % $ '

7 $ .

# '

>" #

' % $# )% '

$ # )% "<' ' $ 7 .

' # $# ''

$# 3' "

)% ? , 65@

$ ' 1

$ $

$B '

# "* #$ # $B .

7 ' # # ' $ "

$% + ' # $# ! /

B4 0 #

,569 )% #$ % )%

# $ $ # # # $ #$

0 ,569 !

' $# )%3

# # $&

",569 ! /

B4 0 #

$ $

# # .

' $

# # "

)% '

! '

# E'%#B B

B"* '

F $# )% '

" B B $ B

$ B "+ #

$ ' "

# $ # $

$ #'

$ %?)"'"D@"

$#'

$B # # #'

$ .

' $ ' "!

$ !

B4 0 #

$ $ ' $

B $

' '

"=#

% $# " * * )

#&'

# (

$ $ $

"3 #

B # $

0 $$# $B #$# $B $ " ' 0 #3

? # ,5-:@ $ 7 %

"> $

#) @7 / (($ " ) $

# ) $"

7 3

/4 4"$ 3" $9 "

$"#6-9= #C4

7 7 / /"$

7) 4 #

$/6#4 44)$ 9 "

$ "

$"#61"

/4 $ ) 34 " )) 4 4+"

))

4 9 4#)6 ) "

$9 < ))

!! ) 7"("6

($0 69 @7 3"#$ 3"/ 34 10

# /;# $

4 0#$ (( ))1

)$ "6

7 3

/4 44 ) #

$9)

69"

$"#6/796 ) :)

79"0

3")

6#"

$$ 3"4#) )$3

# ) #( "

! 1 #$"

)$ "+#$ $$

") 3"4 4"$ 3"

< ))4 "$ (

($( $9$

$7"

$"#66

7 3

< ))4#) 7 ( $ $"

" 4 4 4"

"&()

9 $ /"

< ))4#)( $ 0#$

$9 (()

$ )

" 6

69 "

(( )) ($#

$ )$3 #76 $ #7 %)

"$#3""

#7 4 "($#

)) 7

0$ #) 3 7 3()

6 (

$2 C)"( 1"

4 +#$/

< ))"6

#("

)D"E )"#

$9 "

$#$)

$ (+"/"

)) 7

4#)

()

D"2 )4 "# ( +"

C)"(B"

)) 7

4#)6

)( #) 6) 3"+"

$2 C)"("( D"E

)="

9( /+"

$2 C)4#)"0 "

) "

( 7 )9"

46$/"

4#)"0

$9=

/(()

$ )

< ))

!! "

)6 0) ( $ D"E )4#)#

$9( $"

< ))($ $7 :5" "$ 4"

" "

( $ "

2#37 "

A $ (( )) +#$6

37 $ ' = #A7 )9%$( $9B"

")) ($ $9

)4 "$ 3$"

$97

5 < ))

69 7 "( '# / !! 1 79 6

" # )(( $ 3 $"

$ ( "0

6$#3""

+#$""

()

"3 #("

) "$ (

($( $94"

""6

):)

# $ $69"

+#$4"

3 3#)$

(( )

($ #$#/" 4#)6 6 3"

()

4) # )4 ";# $ # ) (( $ 3 $ "

$ ( " $4 +#$($ 5 2#37 $ )+#$ 4"

()

"($

# "

@ "7"(4 7(

< ))F@F@% 1"6

()

4 ) 79"

3# $"

< ))B 7 1796 " ($ 5 2#37 /

# )(( $ 3 $"

()

"6 "

) 7# $"

< ))F@% )9 7(

< ))4

=4 $/# "

$ 6 $ 6)# $

$ 3" "

()

$ 4 9(

:67 /

)43 69"

3 69"

# )$"

($9 $

) 3) # / )49( $7

6) $"

($9($0

"# "

44$3# "

6 3"

7 =4 $/4"

7 6 3 %$ 5 2#37 ( 69"

$ )+#$ @$ # $ :;" 3 + "D

3 "

/< ",< "0: #

# #$ # /< ",

$ < "0,"

/< "0: # $# '

+ ":-: '

' * + 4 ',5;;

D88+ ! 4,5CC ,D3 3 ,5D8 ,"> 1 (($ ""

467 $ 3"# $"

< )))9 # )"

""(4 7(

< ))1#6 ;# ($3$("/$ )+#$

# "

< ))"

) 6

($0 6# 3$ "

3$#"7"(4 7( B"

A $(( )) +#$") $ "

$7 "

3 ) $ $ )+#$=

/ 6 ""

) 77 69"

()

# $"

< ))F@F@% "

$ 3)9;# 4 0#$ ()

-@ / =

# #

# # #

7 ' ' G 4) # @7

3 ) $ A $(( ))

+#$ 4 " $ (

($( $9 6

3 2 "

# 7 )9 ($

($( $9/"

/()

D"E )4 ) :5""$ 1796 "

) $ A $(( )) +#$ " # "$+""$ $7"

2 6# 1") 7

$ " G) 4 (( $6 $$ $ "

(#$(

)0 3"

$7:$)=$ 0" = 4"0 3:""$

$7:$)=$ 0" $ )

/(+" +"$ "0 7$33 "#3 $9 )

# 6)

(97 !/

:(96) $+" # )(97 ## $+" /

: )) #$"

$/ C)

"7 ""

$ 4

$7:

(+" +"4 $7 $ ($ $+" 7"((4"0 3:""$

$7 )) #$"

) $ $7F@/"

< ))

697"(4 4 +"

C)""

4 ) 34 ""

$9 #))9B"

< )) 4 3 69(+" +"($ $7"

$A#$"

$/ F@<: ($0 " "

#) ($( $

4 4 69 7 "("

($( $943$

6 ($ : 4

0$ #7 $ 7 )9-""

#7 F@ F@<:4

9 $ )) #$"

$/7"(

)) 3 ($ # 7 < ))

69"

#$"

< ))

F@% 6 ;# "

3 "

$ ($( $9 0#$ D"E ) $ A $(( )) +#$" 77 $$$69 # 3"

2 $ 3

$7 ($

4 "2 "

# 7 )9 ($

$9($( $91

6) "

" $ $ +" ($ / $9 4 "0 3(

"$ $ 3

$7 )) #$"

$/ 60 /

"7 $ 7 )94 ) 34 ""

$9 #)) ) 10

3 ) $ A $(( ))

+#$4 "$ 3$($( $96

32 "

# 7 )9 ($

$9($( $9 $ 4"

4 3;# 0#$

#))9/

)$ "()

) #

$9)

6 697"(

4 ""

$ < ))

!!#62

4" $$ 3"4 3 #(

$ 3)9/6""

(( )4 )) $62

( ))"

( 37

)) #(()

9/$ ( / 0

4 60 2#37

0 #$%&$%'()%*+,-./'%*(0-%12 %(/0 #$%&$%''%)0'&*34%2 %(/0